Key takeaways
- Premium is driven by three things you can influence: correct class codes, accurate payroll and your experience modification factor.
- NCCI describes a mod of 1.20 as a prediction of losses 20% worse than the average employer in the same class[1].
- Small, frequent claims hurt the mod more than their size suggests, because losses below the split point carry more weight[1].
- Texas lets private employers go without coverage, but nonsubscribers must report to the state and lose key legal protection[2].
Why workers' comp matters more in plumbing
Plumbing is physical work in awkward places. BLS lists cuts from sharp tools, burns from hot pipes and soldering equipment, and falls from ladders among the common injuries plumbers face[3]. Specialty trade contractors recorded 2.3 injury and illness cases per 100 full-time workers in 2024[4] and 608 fatal work injuries[5]. Add trench work, heavy water heaters and daily driving, and workers' compensation is one of the largest insurance costs in a plumbing business.
Workers' comp also protects the business. In most states it is the exclusive remedy for workplace injuries, which means an injured employee receives medical care and wage replacement through the policy instead of suing the employer. General contractors, property managers and commercial customers routinely ask for a certificate of workers' comp coverage before they let a plumbing crew on site.
2.3
Recordable injury and illness cases per 100 full-time workers, specialty trade contractors, 2024[4]
How the premium is built
In most states the basic formula is the same: payroll in each job classification, multiplied by that classification's rate for each hundred dollars of payroll, multiplied by your experience modification factor, then adjusted by any schedule credits, discounts and fees. Three parts of that formula are within your control.
| Part of the premium | What it is | What you control |
|---|---|---|
| Classification codes | The job categories your employees are rated in | Correct codes for field, clerical and sales staff, with payroll split properly |
| Payroll | Estimated at the start of the policy, audited at the end | Accurate estimates and records that support overtime and job splits |
| Experience mod | A factor comparing your losses with the average for your class | Claim frequency, prompt reporting and return-to-work |
| Schedule credits | Underwriter adjustments for safety programs and management | Written safety program, training records, fleet rules |
Classification is where many shops overpay. In states that use the NCCI system, plumbing field employees are generally rated under a plumbing class, while office staff who never go to job sites can usually be rated under the much cheaper clerical class, and outside salespeople under a sales class. California, New York and several other states use their own rating bureaus and codes, and a handful of states run monopolistic state funds, so confirm the codes with an agent who knows your state.
The experience mod, in plain words
Once a business has enough premium history, its rating bureau calculates an experience modification factor. A mod of 1.00 means your losses look like the average employer's in your classes. NCCI explains that a mod of 1.20 is a prediction that the employer's future loss experience will be 20% worse than the average employer in the same classification[1], and the premium is raised to match. A mod below 1.00 earns a discount.
The formula splits each claim into a primary layer and an excess layer. Losses below the split point are weighted more heavily than losses above it[1]. In practice, that means frequency matters: several small claims can raise your mod more than one larger claim of the same total. Preventing the everyday injuries, such as cuts, strains and eye injuries, is how small shops keep their mods down.
Report every injury to your carrier promptly, even small ones. Late reporting tends to make claims more expensive, and an expensive claim damages the mod for years.
Payroll audits and seasonal swings
Your premium is based on an estimate of payroll at the start of the policy year. At the end, the carrier audits actual payroll and sends a bill or a refund. Plumbing payroll moves with the seasons: employment at plumbing, heating and AC contractors rose from 1,305,900 in January 2026 to 1,357,800 in August[6]. Shops that grow fast or hire for peak season often under-estimate payroll and get a large audit bill.
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics, 2026[6]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| January 2026 | 1,305,900 |
| August 2026 | 1,357,800 |
- Update your carrier mid-year if headcount changes significantly, rather than waiting for the audit.
- Keep payroll records that split time by class where your state allows it, such as a tech who also works in the office.
- Collect certificates of insurance from every subcontractor. Auditors may add uninsured subcontractor payments to your payroll and charge premium on them.
- Check the auditor's worksheet before you sign it. Errors in classification and overtime treatment are common.
Average annual payroll per employee at plumbing, heating and AC contractors was about $73,700 in 2023[7]. Because premium is calculated on each hundred dollars of payroll, a single misclassified employee can cost hundreds or thousands of dollars a year.
Texas: the nonsubscriber option
Texas is the notable exception to mandatory coverage. The Texas Department of Insurance says private employers can choose to carry workers' compensation insurance, but it is not required in most cases[2]. Employers that go without it, known as nonsubscribers, must report to the state that they do not have coverage and must report work-related injuries resulting in more than one day of lost time, along with work-related illnesses and deaths[2]. TDI also notes that coverage limits liability if an employee sues the business for damages[2].
For most plumbing companies, nonsubscription is a poor trade. Many commercial customers and general contractors require proof of coverage, and an injured employee's lawsuit against an uninsured employer can be far costlier than years of premium. If you consider it, get advice from an attorney and an agent who handles Texas nonsubscriber plans.
Safety steps that lower cost
Write a short safety program
Cover PPE, ladders, trenching, hot work, confined spaces, lifting and driving. Underwriters look for it when setting schedule credits.
Train and record
Hold short monthly safety talks and keep sign-in sheets. Documented training supports credits and defends claims.
Stock the vans
Gloves, eye protection, hearing protection, knee pads, first aid kit and a fire extinguisher in every vehicle.
Plan heavy lifts
Use dollies, stair climbers and two-person lifts for water heaters and cast iron; most strains happen on routine jobs.
Build return-to-work
Offer modified duty, such as van stocking, ride-along training or office tasks, so injured employees come back sooner.
Review every claim
Within a week, find the cause and fix it, whether that is a tool, a procedure or training.
Handling a claim well
How a shop handles the first days after an injury shapes the cost of the claim. Make sure every technician knows what to do: get first aid or medical care, tell a supervisor the same day, and fill in the company injury report. The office then reports the claim to the carrier, records the details and stays in touch with the employee. Injured workers who hear nothing from their employer are more likely to hire a lawyer, and represented claims tend to cost more.
Choose an occupational clinic near your service area in advance, where your state allows employers to direct initial care, and keep its address in every van. Ask the clinic about modified duty notes, so the doctor knows you can offer light work. Then offer it. A tech with a hand injury can stock vans, ride along as a trainer, review job photos or help with warranty paperwork. Getting people back to some form of work quickly is one of the most effective ways to control claim costs and protect the mod.
Example: how a few small claims add up
Example: a fictional 15-person shop, Granite Valley Plumbing, has four small claims in a year: two hand cuts, an eye injury from debris and a back strain lifting a water heater. None is serious, but together they push its mod from 0.92 to 1.08 when the next rating is calculated. Because the mod applies to the whole premium, the shop pays noticeably more for three years. The owner responds with cut-resistant gloves and safety glasses in every van, a two-person rule for water heaters, and a monthly safety talk. Two years later the claim count has dropped and the mod is back below 1.00.
Frequently asked questions
Is workers' comp required for a small plumbing company?
In most states, yes, often from the first employee. Texas lets private employers choose, but nonsubscribers must report to the state and lose some legal protections.
What is a good experience mod?
Below 1.00 means your losses are better than average for your classes and earns a discount. Above 1.00 raises your premium.
Why did we get a big bill after the audit?
Usually because actual payroll was higher than estimated, an employee was in a more expensive class, or the auditor added payments to uninsured subcontractors.
Can office staff be rated in a cheaper class?
Usually yes, if they do not go to job sites. Rules vary by state, so confirm with your agent and keep records that show their duties.
References
National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI) (2026). Experience Rating Plan Methodology Update Filing Summary (opens in a new tab) โ
Texas Department of Insurance, Division of Workers' Compensation (2026). Workers' compensation: employer resources (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2024). Industries at a Glance: Specialty Trade Contractors (NAICS 238) (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2024). Industries at a Glance: Specialty Trade Contractors (NAICS 238) (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics (2026). All employees, plumbing, heating, and air-conditioning contractors, not seasonally adjusted (CEU2023822001) (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Census Bureau (2023). County Business Patterns 2023, U.S. national file (cbp23us) (opens in a new tab) โ