Hiring training

1099 subcontractor vs W-2 plumber: the legal test

How the IRS, the Labor Department and states like California decide whether a plumber is a 1099 subcontractor or a W-2 employee, and how to audit yours.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Why this question keeps coming up in plumbing
  2. The IRS test: behavioral, financial and relationship
  3. The Labor Department test is changing
  4. State tests are often stricter
  5. A side-by-side decision table
  6. Example: two arrangements at the same shop
  7. Real independent plumbing businesses do exist
  8. Red flags that draw attention
  9. Audit your 1099 list in an afternoon
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References
Hiring training: 1099 subcontractor vs W-2 plumber: the legal testArticle coverHIRING TRAINING1099 subcontractor vsW-2 plumber: the legaltestAva for PlumbersInsightsHiring training: 1099 subcontractor vs W-2 plumber: the legal testArticle coverHIRING TRAINING1099 subcontractor vsW-2 plumber: thelegal testAva for Plumbers

Key takeaways

  • The label on the paperwork does not decide status; control, money and the relationship do[1].
  • Federal wage-law rules are in flux: the Labor Department proposed in February 2026 to replace its 2024 independent contractor rule[2].
  • California's ABC test makes it very hard to treat a plumber doing your core plumbing work as a contractor[3].
  • Benefits are about 30% of private employer compensation costs, which is why the 1099 shortcut is tempting and why auditors look for it[4].

Why this question keeps coming up in plumbing

Plumbing shops use outside help all the time: a sewer camera specialist for a tricky line, a hydro-excavation crew, a licensed plumber who covers overflow work in spring, or a helper paid by the job. Some of those relationships are genuine subcontracts between two businesses. Others are employees with a 1099 form instead of a W-2, and that difference carries payroll tax, overtime, workers' compensation and unemployment insurance consequences.

The money explains the temptation. Private-industry employers paid an average of $46.89 per hour worked in total compensation in June 2026[5], and benefits made up 30.0% of that cost[4]. A shop that pays a 1099 rate skips employer payroll taxes, workers' comp premiums and benefits. That is also why tax agencies, state labor departments and injured workers' lawyers look closely at trades businesses that rely on 1099 labor.

What private employers pay per hour of workShare of employer compensation costs, June 2026
What private employers pay per hour of workStacked bar chart. Wages and salaries: 70%; Benefits: 30%.Wages and salaries: 70% (70%)Benefits: 30% (30%)What private employers pay per hour of workStacked bar chart. Wages and salaries: 70%; Benefits: 30%.Wages and salaries: 70% (70%)Benefits: 30% (30%)
  • Wages and salaries 70%
  • Benefits 30%

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2026[4]

Show the data
ItemValue
Wages and salaries70%
Benefits30%

The IRS test: behavioral, financial and relationship

For federal employment taxes, the IRS looks at all the evidence of control and independence, grouped in three categories[1]:

  • Behavioral control: does the company control, or have the right to control, what the worker does and how the job is done? Dispatching the worker to your calls, setting the order of jobs and requiring your methods all point to employment.
  • Financial control: who controls the business side of the work? Look at how the worker is paid, whether expenses are reimbursed and who supplies the van, tools and parts.
  • Type of relationship: are there written contracts or employee-type benefits, and is the work ongoing and a key part of the company's regular business?

Either the business or the worker can file Form SS-8 to ask the IRS for a formal determination, though the IRS notes this can take at least six months[1]. If you treat an employee as a contractor without a reasonable basis, the IRS says you may be held liable for employment taxes for that worker. Relief under Section 530 exists, but only when its filing and consistency requirements are met[1].

The Labor Department test is changing

Overtime and minimum wage claims are decided under the Fair Labor Standards Act, which uses an economic reality test rather than the IRS categories. The rules have moved several times. On February 26, 2026 the Labor Department announced a proposal to rescind its 2024 independent contractor rule and replace it with a streamlined test built on two core factors: the control the worker has over the work, and the worker's opportunity for profit or loss through initiative or investment[2]. Skill, permanence of the relationship and whether the work is part of an integrated unit of production would be considered as well, especially when the core factors point in different directions[2].

The comment period closed on April 28, 2026, and the Department's rulemaking page still shows the proposal stage[2]. Check that page before relying on any one version of the test, and remember that courts hearing private lawsuits may apply the regulation in force when the work was done.

Practical reading: under every version of the federal test, a worker who drives your van, takes your dispatches, works only for you and is paid by the hour looks like an employee.

State tests are often stricter

States apply their own tests for unemployment insurance, workers' compensation and state wage law. California is the strictest well-known example. Under the ABC test added to the Labor Code by AB 5, a worker is an employee unless all three conditions are met: the worker is free from the hiring entity's control and direction in practice and in the contract; the worker performs work outside the usual course of the hiring entity's business; and the worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade or business of the same nature[3].

The second prong is the problem for plumbing companies. A plumber who fixes leaks for a plumbing company is doing work inside the usual course of that company's business. Some exemptions exist in California law for certain business-to-business and construction subcontracting arrangements, with their own conditions, so get advice before relying on one. Other states use versions of the ABC test for unemployment insurance even when they use a looser test for wage claims.

A side-by-side decision table

Common factors and which way they usually point
FactorPoints to W-2 employeePoints to genuine 1099 subcontractor
Who sets the scheduleYour dispatcher assigns calls and timesThe sub quotes and schedules its own crew
Vehicle and toolsYour van, your jetter, your partsIts own trucks, equipment and inventory
ClientsWorks only or mainly for youServes several contractors and the public
PayHourly or daily rate, regardless of resultsBid per job, can make or lose money
License and insuranceWorks under your license and policiesHolds its own contractor license, liability and workers' comp
BrandingWears your uniform, introduced as your techUses its own name, invoices you as a business
DurationOngoing, open-endedDefined project or scope

No single row decides the answer, but when most rows fall in the middle column, the relationship should run through payroll.

Example: two arrangements at the same shop

Example: a fictional company, Summit Drain and Sewer, pays a jetter operator by the day on a 1099. He uses Summit's trailer jetter, takes jobs from Summit's dispatch board, wears a Summit shirt and has not worked for anyone else in two years. Under the IRS categories and the federal economic reality factors, this looks like employment, and under an ABC test it almost certainly is. Summit moves him to payroll, adds him to its workers' comp policy and pays overtime for weeks over 40 hours.

The same shop hires a fictional hydro-excavation contractor to expose a sewer lateral under a driveway. That contractor has its own trucks, its own license and insurance, bids the job at a fixed price and works for several general contractors and municipalities. Summit collects a certificate of insurance, a signed subcontract and a W-9, and issues a 1099 at year end. That is a business-to-business subcontract.

Real independent plumbing businesses do exist

Plenty of plumbers run their own businesses. BLS reports that 8% of plumbers, pipefitters and steamfitters are self-employed[6], and Census counts 385,453 nonemployer building equipment contractor businesses, a group that includes plumbing, HVAC and electrical firms with no paid staff[7]. Subcontracting overflow work to one of them is legitimate when the relationship really runs business to business.

The safest way to work with them is to treat them like any other vendor: a written subcontract with a defined scope, their own license number on file, their certificate of insurance with you listed as certificate holder, invoices on their letterhead, and freedom to set their own methods and schedule within the job's deadline.

Red flags that draw attention

Classification problems usually surface in one of four ways: an injured worker files a workers' comp claim, a former worker applies for unemployment, a worker files an overtime complaint, or an insurer's premium audit finds 1099 payments for field labor. Each of these routes can lead to the others. Watch for these patterns in your own books:

  • The same person paid on a 1099 every week, all year, at a day or hourly rate.
  • 1099 workers listed on your dispatch board, wearing your uniform or driving your vans.
  • Subcontractors with no contractor license, no certificate of insurance and no other clients.
  • A worker moved from W-2 to 1099 while doing the same job in the same way.
  • Helpers or apprentices paid as contractors.

Audit your 1099 list in an afternoon

  1. Pull every 1099 payee

    Export last year's 1099 vendors from your accounting system and flag anyone paid for field labor.

  2. Score each one

    Run each through the decision table above. Note who supplies vehicles, tools and dispatch.

  3. Check licenses and insurance

    Confirm each subcontractor's contractor license, general liability and workers' comp are current.

  4. Fix the clear cases

    Move workers who are really employees onto payroll from the start of the next pay period, with legal and tax advice on back taxes.

  5. Document the rest

    Keep signed subcontracts, insurance certificates and invoices for every genuine sub, and re-check them yearly.

Fixing classification also affects your workers' comp audit, your handbook and your insurance. See workers' comp for plumbing companies and our employee handbook outline.

Frequently asked questions

Can I make a plumber a 1099 contractor just by having them sign an agreement?

No. Agencies and courts look at how the work is actually done. A signed independent contractor agreement does not override day-to-day control, your tools and vehicles, or an open-ended relationship.

Is a helper or apprentice ever a 1099 contractor?

Rarely. Helpers and apprentices work under supervision, on your jobs, with your tools, which points strongly to employment under the IRS, federal and state tests.

What happens if we misclassified someone?

You may owe back employment taxes, unpaid overtime, penalties and interest, and you may face workers' comp exposure if they were injured. Talk to a tax adviser and an employment lawyer about correcting it going forward and any relief programs.

Which federal test applies right now?

The IRS uses its common-law categories for taxes. For wage and hour law, check the Labor Department's rulemaking page, because the 2024 rule was proposed for replacement in February 2026.

References

  1. Internal Revenue Service (2026). Independent contractor (self-employed) or employee? (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. U.S. Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division (2026). Notice of Proposed Rule: Employee or Independent Contractor Status Under the FLSA, FMLA and MSPA (RIN 1235-AA46) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. California Department of Industrial Relations, Labor Commissioner's Office (2026). Independent Contractor versus Employee: Frequently Asked Questions (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employer Costs for Employee Compensation - June 2026 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  5. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employer Costs for Employee Compensation - June 2026 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  6. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  7. U.S. Census Bureau (2024). Nonemployer Statistics 2024, U.S. file (nonemp24us) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo