Key takeaways
- There is no federal non-compete ban: in September 2025 the FTC voted to drop its appeals and accept that its rule was vacated[1].
- State law decides. Minnesota, for example, makes covenants not to compete void and unenforceable[2].
- Narrow tools such as confidentiality and customer non-solicitation clauses are often more useful, and more enforceable, than a broad non-compete.
- With wages up about 4.4% in a year at plumbing, heating and AC contractors, pay and career paths do more to stop poaching than contracts[3].
Why poaching is a live issue
Good plumbers are hard to find, and competitors know who they are. BLS projects about 42,000 openings for plumbers, pipefitters and steamfitters each year from 2025 to 2035[4], many of them created by workers who retire or move to other occupations[5]. Construction overall had 298,000 job openings in September 2026, up from 206,000 a year earlier[6]. When a rival shop offers your best service tech a raise and a newer truck, the question many owners ask is whether a non-compete can stop it.
The honest answer is: sometimes, depending on the state, and less often than owners hope. The more useful question is which protections are enforceable where you operate, and what actually keeps technicians from leaving in the first place.
The federal rule is off the table
In 2024 the Federal Trade Commission issued a rule that would have banned most non-compete clauses nationwide. A federal district court found that the FTC lacked authority to issue the rule and barred its enforcement. On September 5, 2025, the Commission voted 3-1 to dismiss its appeals in the two main cases and to accede to the vacatur of the rule[1].
That leaves non-competes where they were before: governed by state law, with the FTC able to challenge particular agreements case by case as unfair methods of competition. For a plumbing company, the practical effect is that you need to know your own state's rules, and the rules of every state where your employees live and work.
State law: from outright bans to pay thresholds
States fall into rough groups. A few ban non-competes for employees almost entirely. California has long treated most employee non-compete agreements as void. Minnesota's statute says plainly that any covenant not to compete contained in a contract or agreement is void and unenforceable[2]. Several other states allow non-competes only for workers earning above a set pay threshold, require advance notice, or limit their length. The remaining states enforce them when they are reasonable in time, geography and scope and protect a legitimate business interest, which courts judge case by case.
| Agreement | What it does | How it usually fares |
|---|---|---|
| Non-compete | Bars the employee from working for a competitor or starting a competing business for a period in an area | Void in some states, limited in others; courts often narrow or reject broad ones for hourly trades workers |
| Customer non-solicitation | Bars the employee from soliciting customers they served or learned about at your company | More often enforceable when limited to customers the employee actually dealt with, for a reasonable period |
| Employee non-solicitation | Bars the departing employee from recruiting your other staff | Varies by state; some treat it like a non-compete |
| Confidentiality | Protects customer lists, pricing, maintenance agreement data and methods | Widely enforceable when the information is genuinely confidential and protected |
| No-poach between companies | Two businesses agree not to hire each other's workers | Risky: agreements between competitors can violate federal antitrust law |
Never agree with another plumbing company not to hire each other's technicians or to hold down wages. Agreements like that between competitors can create serious antitrust exposure.
What a plumbing shop can realistically protect
For most shops, the assets worth protecting are customer relationships, maintenance agreement lists, pricing, and the trust of commercial accounts such as property managers and restaurants. Those can be protected without a broad ban on where a technician works next.
- Customer data: limit who can export customer lists from your field service software, and log exports.
- Maintenance agreements: keep renewals in your system, not in a tech's phone; send renewal reminders from the company.
- Commercial accounts: make sure each account has a relationship with the office or owner, not only with one technician.
- Pricing and price book: treat it as confidential and mark it as such in your handbook and agreements.
- Equipment and devices: collect tablets, phones and keys on the last day and remove app logins immediately.
A well-drafted confidentiality agreement plus a customer non-solicitation clause, limited to customers the technician actually served and to a reasonable period, is often the most enforceable combination where state law allows it. Have a lawyer licensed in your state draft it, and remember that a clause is only useful if you are willing to enforce it.
Using agreements fairly
If your state allows restrictive agreements, how you use them matters as much as what they say. Present the agreement before the job starts, ideally with the offer letter, rather than springing it on an employee mid-career. Some states require advance notice or extra consideration, such as a raise or bonus, for agreements signed after hiring. Explain in plain words what the employee can and cannot do after leaving, and keep the terms proportionate to the role: a helper who never handles commercial accounts is a poor candidate for any restriction beyond confidentiality.
Review the agreements every year or two. State laws in this area have changed often, and an agreement that was enforceable when signed may not be today. Keep signed copies in the personnel file and make sure the version you rely on matches the one the employee actually signed.
Be careful with training repayment clauses as well. Some shops ask technicians to repay certification or school costs if they leave within a set period. Several states now limit these arrangements, and regulators have scrutinized them as a way to trap workers. If you use one, tie the amount to genuine, documented training costs, reduce it over time, and have it reviewed under your state's current law.
Finally, remember that your own hiring is affected by other shops' agreements. When you recruit an experienced plumber from a competitor, ask whether they signed any restrictive agreement and have a lawyer review it before the start date if they did. A new hire who brings a former employer's customer list is a liability, not an asset.
Retention beats restriction
The strongest protection against poaching is a technician who does not want to leave. Pay is part of that. Average hourly earnings for all employees at plumbing, heating and AC contractors reached $42.38 in September 2026, up about 4.4% from $40.59 a year earlier[3]. If your raises lag the market, a competitor's offer will look good no matter what the employee signed.
Retention also depends on the manager a technician reports to. Techs rarely leave a shop where the service manager backs them up with customers, gives fair notice of schedule changes and explains decisions. Train new leads on those basics before promoting them, and ask about the manager in every stay interview.
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics, 2026[3]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| September 2025 | $40.59 |
| September 2026 | $42.38 |
Benchmark pay twice a year
Compare your rates with local job ads and supply-house gossip; adjust before techs start interviewing.
Publish a career path
Show the steps from helper to apprentice, journeyman, lead and service manager, with the pay band for each.
Pay for licenses
Cover exam fees, continuing education and code books, and add an automatic raise at each license level.
Fix the daily irritants
Reliable vans, stocked parts, fair on-call rotations and a dispatcher who respects techs' time.
Ask before they leave
Hold short stay interviews: what would make you leave, and what would make you stay five more years?
When a technician leaves anyway
- Thank them, confirm the last day and collect all company property, devices and keys.
- Remove access to the field service app, email, phone system and supplier accounts the same day.
- Remind them in writing of any confidentiality or non-solicitation terms they signed, without threats.
- Call key commercial accounts the tech served to introduce the new contact person.
- Hold an exit interview and use what you learn.
Example: a fictional shop, Ironwood Plumbing, loses a senior tech to a competitor. Ironwood's agreements include confidentiality and a 12-month non-solicitation of customers he served, drafted for its state. The owner collects his tablet, cuts his software access that afternoon, and calls the six property management accounts he handled. Two months later one property manager mentions the former tech offered to take over their work; Ironwood's lawyer sends a measured letter citing the non-solicitation clause, and the solicitation stops. The bigger change is internal: Ironwood moves its pay review from yearly to twice a year.
Frequently asked questions
Are non-competes banned nationwide?
No. The FTC's 2024 rule was vacated, and in September 2025 the FTC voted to drop its appeals. State law now governs, and the rules vary widely.
Can I stop a plumber from working for a competitor?
In some states you cannot enforce a non-compete at all. Where they are allowed, courts usually require them to be reasonable in time, area and scope and to protect a legitimate interest.
Is a customer non-solicitation clause better than a non-compete?
Often yes. A narrow clause covering customers the employee actually served, for a limited time, is more likely to be enforced where state law allows restrictive covenants.
Can two plumbing companies agree not to hire each other's techs?
That is risky. No-poach or wage agreements between competitors can violate federal antitrust law.
References
Federal Trade Commission (2025). Federal Trade Commission Files to Accede to Vacatur of Non-Compete Clause Rule (opens in a new tab) โ
Minnesota Office of the Revisor of Statutes (2023). Minnesota Statutes, Section 181.988: Covenants not to compete void (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics (2026). Average hourly earnings of all employees, plumbing, heating, and air-conditioning contractors, not seasonally adjusted (CEU2023822003) (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025-2035). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025-2035). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey, Table 1: Job openings levels and rates by industry (opens in a new tab) โ