Key takeaways
- Pay-as-you-go changes when premium is calculated, not the rates: each payroll run reports actual wages by class and the premium follows[2].
- It shrinks the audit bill that comes from hiring and raises after the estimate, which is the normal pattern in a growing plumbing shop[3][1].
- It automates whatever class mapping you give it, so wrong classes and lumped overtime get billed wrong every pay period[4].
- You are still audited; keep time records for split roles and overtime shown separately by employee[4][5].
Why the annual estimate goes wrong
The classic workers' comp bill is built on a guess. At the start of the policy year you tell the carrier what payroll you expect in each class, pay a deposit and installments on that estimate, and a premium audit after the year ends compares the guess with what you really paid. When audited payroll is larger than the up-front estimate, NCCI notes, additional premium is due at audit; when it is smaller, money comes back[3].
For a plumbing company the guess is almost always low, because pay rarely stands still. BLS payroll survey data for plumbing, heating and air-conditioning contractors show average hourly earnings of $37.86 in January 2024 and $42.38 by September 2026, the second number still preliminary[1]. Shops hire in spring, run overtime through a freeze and move apprentices up mid-year. Every added technician brings a sizeable payroll line with them: the Census Bureau's 2023 County Business Patterns work out to about $73,700 of annual payroll per employee in this industry[6]. None of that was in the estimate, and the bill for it arrives in one lump months after the policy ends.
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics, 2024-2026[1]
Show the data
| Month | Average hourly earnings |
|---|---|
| Jan 2024 | $37.86 |
| Jul 2024 | $38.75 |
| Jan 2025 | $39.3 |
| Jul 2025 | $40.44 |
| Jan 2026 | $41.08 |
| Jul 2026 | $42.63 |
| Sep 2026 | $42.38 |
Example: a shop estimates $600,000 of field payroll for the year. It hires two technicians in April and gives raises in July, and actual field payroll comes in at $690,000. At an example rate of $5.00 per $100 of payroll, the audit asks for $4,500 more, long after the money was spent. Rates vary widely by state and class, so run it with your own.
How pay-as-you-go billing works
Pay-as-you-go changes when premium is calculated, not how. Each time you run payroll, the payroll system reports gross wages by class code to the carrier, and the premium for that period is worked out from actual payroll and collected on the same cycle. Pinnacol, for example, describes premiums that are automatically calculated and paid each pay period, which removes large upfront deposits[2].
- Your team
- System
01Your team
Payroll is run
The office runs the biweekly payroll as usual: nine field techs and two office staff.
02System
Wages reported by class
The payroll system sends gross wages, split by class code, to the carrier.
03System
Premium calculated
Each class's payroll times its rate, adjusted by the experience mod, for this period only.
04System
Premium collected
The amount is drawn on the payroll cycle, so the cost lands in the same week as the wages.
05Your team
Year-end audit
The auditor reconciles the year's reports; the gap is small if the classes were right.
Example: a fictional 11-person shop. Reporting and payment schedules vary by carrier and state.
Two things stay the same. You still have a policy, rates, class codes and an experience mod, and you are still audited. Pinnacol says plainly that pay-as-you-go does not prevent an audit, though year-end audits tend to go faster because premium tracked payroll all year[2].
Washington shows the same principle from a different angle. Most classes there are rated on hours worked rather than payroll, and premiums are reported and paid each quarter after the quarter ends[7]. If you work in that state, premium already follows actual work quarter by quarter, and the setup advice below applies to hours instead of wages.
Annual estimate or pay-as-you-go
| Annual estimate and audit | Pay-as-you-go | |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront cash | Deposit plus installments on estimated payroll | Smaller deposit; premium follows each payroll |
| Mid-year hiring | Shows up as a bill at audit | Paid in the period the wages are paid |
| Slow season | Installments stay the same | Premium falls with payroll |
| Year-end audit | Can bring a large balance due | Still happens; the gap is usually small |
| Class code mistakes | Found once a year, at audit | Repeated every pay run until fixed |
Typical behavior only. Deposit rules, reporting schedules and availability vary by carrier and state.
The last row is the one owners skip. Pay-as-you-go is only as accurate as the class mapping in your payroll system. Set it up right and it is the cleanest way to pay for workers' comp. Set it up wrong and it bills the mistake twenty-six times a year.
Class codes: it only automates what you set up
The payroll system reports what it is told. If every employee is mapped to the plumbing class, including the office manager and the CSR, the carrier bills every dollar at the plumbing rate every pay period. That mapping is where the real money in this decision sits.
Rating manuals let you split payroll across classes only with records. North Carolina's Basic Manual, for example, allows an employee's payroll to be divided between classifications only when payroll records show actual payroll by classification for each employee; without them, the whole payroll goes to the highest-rated class[4]. SAIF in Oregon applies the same idea: without verifiable time records, payroll is allocated to the class that charges the most premium, and the clerical class needs a work area physically separated from operating hazards[5].
| Who | Usual treatment | What the records need to show |
|---|---|---|
| Field technicians and apprentices | Plumbing class | Nothing special; this is the default |
| CSR, dispatcher, bookkeeper in a separate office | Clerical office class | A physically separated office and duties that keep them off job sites |
| Owner who runs calls and does the books | Split, or all plumbing | Time by class, recorded every pay period |
| Service manager who rides along | Often plumbing | Office time and field time recorded separately |
| Overtime hours | Straight-time pay counts | Overtime premium shown separately by employee |
Overtime is the quiet one. In the North Carolina manual, extra pay for overtime is excluded from premium payroll, provided the books show overtime separately by employee[4]. In a February freeze, with every tech on time-and-a-half, a payroll setup that lumps overtime into one wage line pays premium on money that could have been left out. Map it right once and pay-as-you-go applies it every period. The guides to controlling overtime costs and on-call pay for technicians cover the pay side.
Field hours spent on the phone
Class codes follow the person and the records, not the task. A technician who spends twenty minutes between jobs returning calls and quoting by phone is still on plumbing payroll for that time, at a loaded cost well above an office wage. For June 2026, BLS put wages plus benefits in the construction industry at $51.96 for every hour worked[8]. Phone time on the truck is some of the most expensive office work a shop pays for, and it is rated in your highest class.
| Input | Example |
|---|---|
| Field calls per day (techs and owner) | 14 |
| Minutes per call | 4 |
| Share that could move off the truck | 70% |
| Loaded field labor cost per hour | $52 |
| Calls a month | 304 |
| Staff hours on these calls | 20 |
| Hours handed off | 14 |
| Monthly value of that staff time | $737 |
How it is worked out: Calls a day ร 21.7 working days ร minutes per call รท 60 ร share handled = hours; hours ร hourly cost.
Assumptions
- Loaded labor cost of $52 an hour, rounded from the $51.96 average total compensation per hour worked in construction in June 2026.[8]
- Call counts, minutes per call and the share that could move off the truck are invented for this example; count a week of your own calls.
Example only. Adjust the inputs to your own shop.
In this example about 14 field hours a month go to the phone, all of it rated as plumbing payroll. Hand those calls to an office CSR and the work moves to the clerical class, provided your time records support the split. Route them to an SI Employee and the calls it answers and books never reach the truck, so those minutes go back to billable work (what an SI Employee handles). For an owner-operator with no office at all, the one-van plumber example puts the same choice in terms of calls missed from under a sink. To see how workers' comp fits into total labor spend, read labor cost as a percentage of revenue.
Who gains most
- Growing shops that hire through the year. The audit gap is largest when headcount rises after the estimate was set.
- Seasonal shops. Premium drops with payroll in slow months instead of staying flat.
- Shops short on cash in spring. A smaller deposit keeps money in the business while you hire and stock up[2].
- Owners who dread the audit letter. The year-end reconciliation is usually a small adjustment rather than a surprise.
It matters less if payroll is flat, classes are clean and the deposit is easy to carry; then the difference is mostly convenience. Either way the bill is not optional. Nearly every state makes employers buy the cover[9], and the exposure behind it is real: the BLS 2024 survey counted 2.3 recordable cases per 100 full-time workers across specialty trade contractors[10]. If you are about to hire your first employee, set the billing up from the first payroll rather than switching later. For how the premium itself is built, the experience mod and safety steps, see workers' comp for plumbing companies, and for the rest of the insurance program, business owner's policy vs general liability.
What changes in the office
The day-to-day difference is small but real. Whoever runs payroll now owns a workers' comp task every pay period, not once a year, and three habits keep it clean.
- New hires get a class code on day one, in the payroll system, before their first paycheck. A tech left on a default office code, or with no code at all, sends a wrong report from the first paycheck onward.
- Role changes are updated the same week. When a CSR starts riding along on estimates, or a tech moves into the office after an injury, the mapping and the time records change with them.
- Payroll corrections flow through. If you void a check or fix an hours error, confirm the correction reached the carrier too, or the premium for that period stays wrong until audit.
None of this is new work, strictly. It is the same information the auditor asks for at year end, kept up as you go. If payroll already runs through software on a fixed cycle, most of the switch is setup: the carrier links to the payroll system, and someone checks the class mapping before the first report goes out.
Setting it up without new audit problems
Ask your carrier or agent
Confirm the carrier offers pay-as-you-go in your state, which payroll systems it accepts, what deposit it still requires and whether it needs a payroll run every month.
Map every employee to a class
Field staff, office staff, owners and mixed roles. Agree the mapping with your agent in writing before the first report goes out.
Separate overtime premium
Make sure payroll shows overtime premium as its own line by employee, so it can be excluded where your state allows.
Check the first three reports
Compare what the payroll system sent with your payroll register. A mistake in the mapping repeats every period until someone fixes it.
Collect subcontractor certificates
Get a current certificate of insurance from every sub before they start, so their payroll is not added to yours at audit.
Keep an audit folder anyway
Payroll registers, time records by class, overtime reports and certificates in one place. The audit still comes; make it a short one.
Frequently asked questions
Does pay-as-you-go change my workers' comp rates?
No. It is a billing method. Your rates, class codes and experience mod stay the same; what changes is that premium is calculated from actual payroll each pay period instead of from an annual estimate[2].
Will I still be audited?
Yes. Pay-as-you-go does not prevent a premium audit, but because premium tracked payroll all year, the year-end adjustment is usually small and the audit quicker[2].
Does pay-as-you-go lower the total premium?
Not by itself; the same rates apply to the same payroll. Real savings come from correct class mapping and from showing overtime premium separately where it can be excluded[4].
Can a small shop with two or three employees use it?
Usually, if you run regular payroll through a system the carrier accepts. Ask whether the program needs a payroll run every month and whether owners are included or excluded under your entity type and state rules.
How does this work in Washington?
Washington rates most classes on hours worked, not payroll, and employers report and pay premiums quarterly after each quarter ends[7]. Keep hours by class as carefully as other states keep payroll by class.
References
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics (2024-2026). Average hourly earnings of all employees, plumbing, heating, and air-conditioning contractors, not seasonally adjusted (CEU2023822003) (opens in a new tab) โ
Pinnacol Assurance (2026). Pay-as-you-go (opens in a new tab) โ
National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI) (2020). COVID-19, Premium Audits, and EBNR: Lessons Learned from the Past (opens in a new tab) โ
North Carolina Rate Bureau (2026). Basic Manual Rule 2: Premium and Payroll (opens in a new tab) โ
SAIF Corporation (2026). Specific classification rules (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Census Bureau (2023). County Business Patterns 2023, U.S. national file (cbp23us) (opens in a new tab) โ
Washington State Department of Labor & Industries (2026). Unique premium rating features in Washington (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employer Costs for Employee Compensation, Table 4: Private industry workers by occupational and industry group (June 2026) (opens in a new tab) โ
National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) (2026). Small Business Insurance (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2024). Industries at a Glance: Specialty Trade Contractors (NAICS 238) (opens in a new tab) โ