Metrics finance

Controlling overtime costs in a plumbing company

Control overtime costs in a plumbing company: what overtime really costs, where it comes from, reason codes, scheduling controls and a weekly review.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing6 min read

On this page
  1. What an overtime hour really costs
  2. Seasonal pressure on hours
  3. Where overtime actually comes from
  4. Measure it before you cut it
  5. Controls that work
  6. Example: one week of overtime
  7. When overtime is the right choice
  8. Pay plans and benefits
  9. Talking to technicians about overtime
  10. A weekly overtime checklist
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References
Metrics finance: Controlling overtime costs in a plumbing companyArticle coverMETRICS FINANCEControlling overtimecosts in a plumbingcompanyAva for PlumbersInsightsMetrics finance: Controlling overtime costs in a plumbing companyArticle coverMETRICS FINANCEControlling overtimecosts in a plumbingcompanyAva for Plumbers

Key takeaways

  • Under federal law, covered non-exempt employees earn at least time and one-half their regular rate for hours over 40 in a workweek[1].
  • Most plumbing overtime is not emergencies; it comes from late starts, overbooked boards, long drives, parts runs and return visits.
  • Give every overtime hour a reason code, review it weekly by technician and cause, and fix the top two causes first.
  • Some overtime is worth paying for; the goal is planned overtime on profitable work, not zero overtime.

What an overtime hour really costs

The Fair Labor Standards Act requires covered non-exempt employees to be paid at least time and one-half their regular rate for hours worked over 40 in a workweek[1]. Federal law does not require a premium just because work falls on a Saturday, Sunday or holiday, and it sets no limit on weekly hours for employees aged 16 and over[1]. Some states add their own rules, so check your state labor department as well.

The premium is the visible part. Average hourly earnings for all employees at plumbing, heating and AC contractors were $42.38 in September 2026, preliminary[2]. An overtime hour costs half as much again before payroll taxes, and it often comes at the end of a long day, when work is slower and mistakes are more likely. Fatigue also feeds turnover, which is far more expensive than any single week of overtime.

Overtime is not automatically bad. The test is whether the extra hour produced profitable work that could not have been scheduled at straight time, or whether it paid for something the company could have prevented.

Seasonal pressure on hours

Demand in this trade is seasonal, and staffing follows it only loosely. Employment at plumbing, heating and AC contractors rose from 1,293,700 in January 2025 to 1,335,400 in July, eased to 1,317,700 in December, then climbed from 1,305,900 in January 2026 to 1,357,800 in August[3]. When demand jumps faster than hiring, the gap is filled with overtime.

Employment at plumbing, heating and AC contractorsAll employees, not seasonally adjusted
Employment at plumbing, heating and AC contractorsLine chart. Jan 2025: 1,293,700; Jul 2025: 1,335,400; Dec 2025: 1,317,700; Jan 2026: 1,305,900; Aug 2026: 1,357,800.1.3M1.3M1.3M1.3M1.4MJan 2025Jul 2025Dec 2025Jan 2026Aug 2026Jan 2025: 1,293,700Jul 2025: 1,335,400Dec 2025: 1,317,700Jan 2026: 1,305,900Aug 2026: 1,357,8001.4M1.3MEmployment at plumbing, heating and AC contractorsLine chart. Jan 2025: 1,293,700; Jul 2025: 1,335,400; Dec 2025: 1,317,700; Jan 2026: 1,305,900; Aug 2026: 1,357,800.1.3M1.3M1.3M1.3M1.4MJan 2025Aug 2026Jan 2025: 1,293,700Jul 2025: 1,335,400Dec 2025: 1,317,700Jan 2026: 1,305,900Aug 2026: 1,357,8001.4M1.3M

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics, 2026[3]

Show the data
PeriodValue
Jan 20251,293,700
Jul 20251,335,400
Dec 20251,317,700
Jan 20261,305,900
Aug 20261,357,800

The schedule also matters. The Bureau of Labor Statistics notes that most plumbers work full time and that evening and weekend work is common because plumbers are often on call for emergencies[4]. Those hours count toward the weekly 40, so a technician who works a full week and then takes a weekend emergency is often already in overtime before arriving at the door.

Where overtime actually comes from

Common causes of overtime and a control for each
CauseHow you spot itControl
Overbooked boardLast job of the day starts after 4 p.m. most daysCap jobs per tech by expected duration, not count
Late first jobTrucks leave the shop well after start timeLoad trucks the night before; start from home where it makes sense
Long or crossing routesHigh drive time share, techs crossing pathsZone-based scheduling, route review each morning
Parts runsMid-day supply house stops on GPSBetter truck stock and staging for booked jobs
Underestimated job durationsJobs regularly overrun their slotUpdate durations from actual job times
CallbacksReturn visits squeezed in after the dayFix causes; schedule returns in normal hours
On-call emergenciesNight calls after a full weekRotate on-call, adjust next-day schedule
AbsenceOne tech out, others coveringCross-training and a short-notice plan

Measure it before you cut it

  1. Agree what counts

    Track hours over 40 in the workweek, plus any premium hours your own policy pays, such as call-out minimums. Keep the two separate.

  2. Add a reason code to every overtime hour

    Use a short list: emergency, overbooked, late start, drive, parts, callback, absence cover, install overrun. Technicians or dispatch pick one when the overtime happens.

  3. Report weekly by technician and cause

    Show overtime hours and cost by reason, with last month's average beside each.

  4. Tie it to revenue

    Compare overtime hours with gross profit for the same week. Overtime in a high-profit week of emergency work is a different story from overtime in an average week.

  5. Act on the top two causes

    Pick the two largest preventable causes and assign one change for each, with an owner and a date.

Accurate time records matter for more than cost control. Hours worked must be paid correctly, so make sure drive time between jobs, required shop time and on-call work that counts as hours worked are recorded properly. When in doubt about what counts, ask an employment advisor rather than guessing.

Controls that work

  • Schedule by hours, not job count. Use realistic durations by job type and leave a buffer at the end of each technician's day.
  • Hold a reserve slot. Keeping one slot open per truck each afternoon absorbs emergencies without pushing everything later.
  • Start the day on time. Trucks loaded and tickets assigned the night before often save more hours than any software change.
  • Route by zone. Keep technicians in compact areas so the last job of the day is near home, not across the county.
  • Fix the truck stock. Every parts run is an hour of paid time and a slot pushed later; restock to the jobs you actually see.
  • Cut callbacks. Return visits often land at the end of the day or the weekend, at premium rates.
  • Plan the busy season early. Hire or train before peak demand, and agree with technicians on how planned overtime will be shared.
  • Use the next day. A job that will run past the end of the shift can often be finished first thing tomorrow, with the customer's agreement.

Example: one week of overtime

Example: a fictional six-technician shop logs 41 overtime hours in a February week. The reason codes tell the story.

Example overtime reason codes for one week, fictional data
ReasonHoursPreventable?
Emergency (burst pipes after a cold night)14No
Overbooked board11Yes
Parts runs7Mostly
Callbacks5Yes
Late start, truck not loaded4Yes

Example, continued: only about a third of the overtime came from genuine emergencies. The owner sets two changes: dispatch caps booked hours per tech at seven and a half on forecast cold days to leave room for emergencies, and the warehouse adds the three most-run parts to every truck. Two weeks later, overtime is down to 22 hours, almost all of it emergencies that customers were glad to pay for.

When overtime is the right choice

Overtime can be cheaper than the alternatives. A technician working two extra hours to finish a profitable job may cost less than a second trip the next day, and a few weeks of planned overtime in peak season can be better than hiring someone you do not need in winter. The point of control is to choose overtime deliberately, for work that earns more than it costs, rather than to absorb it from preventable problems.

Check the math with gross profit per hour. If a job type earns well above your target per hour, overtime on it may still be worthwhile. If it barely covers overhead at straight time, overtime makes it a loss. Your break-even analysis shows how much rising labor cost moves the daily job target.

Pay plans and benefits

Overtime interacts with how technicians are paid. Commission, flat-rate and bonus plans can change how the regular rate is calculated for non-exempt employees, so have an employment advisor review any plan before you launch it. The guide on commission pay models covers the main structures.

Benefits matter too. Across private industry, benefits were 30.0% of employer compensation costs in June 2026[5]. Some benefit costs, such as health insurance, do not rise with overtime hours, which is why overtime can look cheaper per hour than hiring in the short run. Over a full year, persistent overtime usually signals that the business needs another technician, better scheduling or both.

Talking to technicians about overtime

Technicians often have mixed feelings about overtime. Some count on it as part of their income; others are worn down by late finishes and weekend calls. Cutting overtime without a conversation can feel like a pay cut to the first group, while letting it run unchecked pushes the second group toward the door. Talk about it openly, and explain that the aim is predictable hours and fewer wasted ones, not lower earnings.

  • Share the reason-code report with the team so everyone sees where hours go.
  • Ask technicians which delays cost them the most time; they usually know before the data does.
  • Offer planned overtime fairly, by rotation or sign-up, instead of defaulting to whoever is closest.
  • Protect rest after a night call by starting that technician later the next day where possible.

A weekly overtime checklist

  • Overtime hours and cost this week, against the four-week average.
  • Hours by reason code and by technician.
  • The two largest preventable causes and the action for each.
  • Any technician over a personal threshold for three weeks running, for a fatigue and workload conversation.
  • Next week's forecast: weather, booked installs and on-call rotation.

Frequently asked questions

Do plumbers get overtime for weekend work?

Federal law does not require a premium for weekend or holiday work as such; it requires overtime for hours over 40 in a workweek for covered non-exempt employees[1]. Your state, union contract or company policy may add more.

What is a reasonable level of overtime?

There is no single figure. Track overtime as a share of paid hours by season and by cause. Emergency overtime in a freeze is expected; steady overtime from overbooking is a scheduling problem.

Is it cheaper to pay overtime or hire another technician?

In short peaks, overtime is often cheaper. If overtime stays high for months and the board still overflows, another technician usually pays for itself and reduces burnout.

References

  1. U.S. Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division (2019). Fact Sheet #23: Overtime Pay Requirements of the FLSA (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics (2026). Average hourly earnings of all employees, plumbing, heating, and air-conditioning contractors, not seasonally adjusted (CEU2023822003) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics (2026). All employees, plumbing, heating, and air-conditioning contractors, not seasonally adjusted (CEU2023822001) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  5. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employer Costs for Employee Compensation - June 2026 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo