Key takeaways
- Ask about what the job needs, such as the schedule, required licenses and physical tasks, never about family, health, origin, religion or age[2].
- Disability was named in 41.1% of EEOC charges in fiscal 2025[1]; health questions wait until after an offer[3].
- New York and Washington, among other places, bar questions about salary history; ask what the applicant is looking for instead[4][5].
- The same questions, in the same order, on the same scoring sheet for every office applicant is the simplest protection.
Why office interviews drift into trouble
Interviews for the office go wrong in a way tech interviews rarely do. A technician interview is anchored by a license and a hands-on test. A CSR or dispatcher interview is mostly conversation, often run by an owner fitting it in between jobs, and conversation drifts toward exactly the topics that get employers in trouble: kids, health, where someone is from, what they earned last time. Most of those questions come from a real need. The fix is to ask about the need, not about the person.
Front-desk hiring also comes around often. BLS projects about 105,100 receptionist openings a year, mostly to replace people who leave[6], so a small office may run these interviews every year or two, each time with whoever happens to be free that afternoon. A short list of what not to ask, and what to ask instead, keeps the next interview consistent with the last one.
General information, not legal advice. State and city laws often go further than federal law; check yours or ask an employment lawyer before you change your hiring process.
Which laws reach a small plumbing shop
Federal coverage depends on headcount. EEOC-enforced laws on race, color, religion, sex including pregnancy, national origin, disability and genetic information cover private employers with 15 or more employees who worked at least 20 calendar weeks this year or last. Age discrimination coverage starts at 20 employees, and the Equal Pay Act covers virtually all employers[7]. Most plumbing shops sit below those lines: in 2023, 58% of plumbing, heating and air-conditioning establishments had fewer than five employees[8].
Do not read that as a free pass. State laws often reach much smaller employers, and the risky questions are poor practice at any size, because the answers tell you nothing about who will handle a flooded-basement call well. California's Fair Chance Act, for one, applies to employers with five or more employees[9]. Write one interview standard and use it whether you employ four people or forty.
What discrimination charges are about
The EEOC received 88,201 discrimination charges in fiscal 2025[1]. A charge can name more than one basis, and the mix is a fair guide to where interviews create risk. Disability appeared in 41.1% of charges, race in 33.3%, sex in 30.5% and age in 18.5%[1]. Retaliation, alleged in 61.6%, is mostly about what happens after someone complains rather than about hiring[1].
Disability sits near the top for a reason the interview can control. The EEOC says employers are explicitly prohibited from making pre-offer inquiries about disability[2], and the usual way a small employer breaks that rule is a friendly question at the end of a good conversation: “Any health issues I should know about?” or “How's your back holding up?”
Topics to keep out of the interview
The EEOC's general rule is to limit pre-employment questions to what is essential to decide whether someone is qualified, and to avoid questions that could reveal an applicant's race, sex, national origin, disability status, age, religion, color or ancestry[2]. In a plumbing office, these are the ones that actually come up:
| Topic | Do not ask | Ask instead |
|---|---|---|
| Family | Married? Kids? Who watches them? Planning a family?[10] | “The desk is staffed 7 to 4, plus one Saturday morning in three. Can you work that schedule?” |
| Health and injuries | Any health problems? Old injuries? What medications do you take?[3] | “The job is a full day on the phone and computer. Can you do that, with or without a reasonable accommodation?” |
| Citizenship and origin | Are you a citizen? Where are you from? Where is that accent from?[11] | “Everyone we hire verifies identity and eligibility to work in the US after the offer.” |
| Religion | Where do you worship? Which holidays do you observe?[12] | Describe the full schedule, weekends included, and ask whether they can meet it. |
| Age | How old are you? What year did you finish school?[2] | Ask about experience that matters to the job, not dates. |
| Pay history | What did you make at your last job?[4][5] | “What pay range are you looking for?” |
| Criminal record | Have you ever been convicted? (before an offer, where a fair chance law applies)[9] | Wait for the conditional offer where the law requires it, then follow the state's process. |
Spanish is a legitimate exception that needs careful handling. If you need a bilingual CSR, put it in the job description and test the skill directly by running part of the role-play in Spanish. Ask about the language the job uses, never about where the applicant or their family comes from.
Asking about availability, driving and lifting
Most illegal questions are clumsy attempts to learn something you are allowed to know. Three come up in nearly every office interview.
Availability. You need to know whether someone can cover the 7 a.m. phones, a Saturday rotation or a storm week. Questions about marital status, children and child care arrangements may be treated as evidence of intent to discriminate[10], and days of worship and religious holidays are on the EEOC's list to avoid[12]. So describe the real schedule, weekends and holidays included, and ask every candidate the same question: can you work it? If the answer is yes, the reasons behind it are not the interview's business.
Driving. Some office roles run parts, drop paperwork at job sites or move a van between yards. You may ask whether an applicant has the certifications or licenses the job's duties require[3], so “This job drives a company van between our two yards. Do you have a valid driver's license?” is fine. If you then pull a driving record or background report through a screening company, the federal consumer-report rules apply: a stand-alone written disclosure and the applicant's written permission first, and before rejecting anyone because of the report, a pre-adverse action notice with a copy of the report and a summary of rights[13]. The details are in background checks for technicians.
Physical tasks. A dispatcher who also unloads parts deliveries may need to lift boxes. Ask whether the applicant can do that specific task, with or without a reasonable accommodation[3]. Do not ask about injuries, conditions or medications before an offer.
Work authorization gets similar treatment. Most employers should not ask whether an applicant is a US citizen before an offer, but you can tell every applicant that all persons hired will be required to verify identity and eligibility to work in the United States. Form I-9 comes after the offer is accepted, not before[11].
The questions start in the job ad
The same rules apply before anyone walks in. The EEOC says it is illegal to publish a job advertisement that shows a preference for, or discourages people from applying because of, a protected characteristic, and gives the example of an ad seeking “recent college graduates”, which may discourage people over 40 from applying[2]. Office ads drift this way far more than tech ads do: “young, energetic front desk,” “perfect for a college student,” “native English speaker.” Describe the work instead: answering a busy phone line, booking jobs onto a dispatch board, working one Saturday in three.
Recruiting channels count as well. The EEOC notes that relying on word-of-mouth recruitment by a workforce made up mostly of one group may violate the law[2]. Referrals are fine; referrals as the only channel are the risk. Post the job where anyone can see it, even when you expect to hire a current CSR's friend, and run that friend through the same five questions as everyone else.
Salary history bans and what to ask instead
Several states and cities stop employers from asking what an applicant earned before. New York bars employers from relying on salary history to decide whether to hire someone or what to pay them, and from seeking, requesting or requiring it, orally or in writing[4]. An applicant may volunteer it, and an employer may confirm it only if the applicant uses prior pay to argue for more than the offer[4]. Washington bars employers from seeking an applicant's wage history from the applicant or from a current or former employer, and allows confirmation only if the applicant volunteered it or after an offer with pay has been made[5].
The alternative that works everywhere is to ask what the applicant is looking for and anchor the conversation in your own range. If the range is already in the ad, which several states now require, most of the pay conversation is over before the interview starts; see pay transparency laws for plumbing job posts.
Example script: “The range for this role is $19 to $23 an hour, depending on dispatch experience and Spanish. Where in that range are you hoping to land, and what would put you at the top of it?”
One interview for every office applicant
- Caller
- Your team
01Caller
Applicant calls about the ad
Whoever answers takes a name and callback number; no screening on that call.
02Your team
Five-question phone screen
Schedule, location, pay range, licenses the job needs, start date. Same order for all.
03Your team
Role-play interview
Two scripted calls scored on one sheet: an emergency and a price shopper.
04Your team
Conditional offer
Offer in writing, conditional on any checks the law allows after an offer.
05Your team
Post-offer paperwork
Form I-9 after acceptance; any background check with written disclosure and consent.
Example sequence for an office hire. Which checks are allowed, and when, depends on your state.
Structure is the protection. When every applicant gets the same questions in the same order, scored on the same sheet, nobody drifts into small talk about kids or church, and your notes show a job-related reason for the choice. The role-play and scoring sheet are in hiring and training plumbing CSRs, and the tech version is interview questions for plumbing technicians.
The first contact counts too. Applicants often ring the main line about an ad, and whoever picks up, an office manager between calls or an SI Employee covering overflow, should take a name, a callback number and the job they are asking about, and leave every screening question to the hiring manager (what it does).
A one-van owner hiring a first office helper, like the solo plumber example, is the person most likely to ask a bad question, simply because nobody ever handed them a list. Print the table above, keep it with the interview sheet and use it for every candidate. If the hire is your first employee, start with hiring your first employee as a solo plumber.
Notes need the same discipline. Write down answers to job questions, not impressions of the person. If an applicant volunteers something you could not have asked, such as a pregnancy, a disability or a religious holiday, do not follow up and do not write it down. Thank them and go back to the schedule question.
Frequently asked questions
We have eight employees. Do federal discrimination laws apply to us?
Most EEOC-enforced laws start at 15 employees and age discrimination at 20, while the Equal Pay Act covers virtually all employers[7]. State laws often reach smaller shops, such as California's Fair Chance Act at five employees[9].
Can we ask whether an applicant has a driver's license?
Yes, if the job's duties require one; the EEOC's guidance allows questions about licenses the job needs[3]. A driving-record check through a screening company follows the federal consumer-report steps[13].
Can we ask what they made at their last job?
Not in New York or Washington, among other places[4][5]. Ask what pay they are looking for, and share your range.
An applicant mentioned her kids. What now?
Do not follow up and do not note it. Go back to the schedule: describe the hours and ask whether she can work them. Questions about children and child care can be treated as evidence of intent to discriminate[10].
Can we ask if someone is a US citizen?
Most employers should not ask before an offer. Tell every applicant that anyone hired must verify identity and eligibility to work in the US, and complete Form I-9 after the offer is accepted[11].
References
U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (2026). Table E1a: Charge receipts by basis or statute (all statutes), FY 1997 to FY 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (2026). Prohibited employment policies/practices (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (2026). Enforcement guidance: preemployment disability-related questions and medical examinations (opens in a new tab) ↑
New York State Senate (2026). New York Labor Law section 194-A: Prohibition on reliance on salary history (opens in a new tab) ↑
Washington State Legislature (2026). RCW 49.58.100: Wage or salary history (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Receptionists (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (2026). Coverage: businesses and private employers (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Census Bureau (2023). County Business Patterns 2023, U.S. file (cbp23us) (opens in a new tab) ↑
California Civil Rights Department (2026). Fair Chance Act (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (2026). Pre-employment inquiries and marital status or number of children (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (2026). Pre-employment inquiries and citizenship (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (2026). Pre-employment inquiries and religious affiliation or beliefs (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2026). Using consumer reports: what employers need to know (opens in a new tab) ↑