Key takeaways
- Under the FCRA you need a stand-alone written disclosure and the applicant’s written permission before ordering a background report[1].
- Before rejecting someone because of a report, send a pre-adverse action notice with a copy of the report and the FCRA summary of rights[1].
- Construction had 298,000 job openings in September 2026, so a slow screening process loses candidates[2].
- Screen for what matters in a customer’s home and on the road; judge records by relevance and time passed, not blanket bans.
Why screening matters more for in-home work
A plumbing technician is often alone in a customer’s home, sometimes with children, older adults or valuables nearby, and often drives a company vehicle between jobs. Customers know this. When they let someone in, they are trusting your hiring process as much as the person at the door. A clear, consistent background check policy protects customers, protects your team and gives your office something concrete to say when a caller asks whether your techs are screened.
Screening is also a legal process with its own rules. Do it casually and you can face claims under the Fair Credit Reporting Act or discrimination law. Do it slowly and you lose good candidates to the shop down the road. The sections below cover both sides: a check that is fair and lawful, and fast enough for a tight market.
Speed matters in this hiring market
Construction employers are competing hard for people. The industry had 298,000 job openings in September 2026, a 3.4% openings rate, up from 206,000 a year earlier[2]. BLS projects about 42,000 openings for plumbers, pipefitters and steamfitters each year on average through 2035[3], many of them to replace workers who change occupations or retire[4].
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2026[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| September 2025 | 206 thousand |
| September 2026 | 298 thousand |
In practice this means a good candidate may have two other offers by the time a slow check comes back. Make a conditional offer early, order the check the same day the candidate signs the authorization, and tell them how long it usually takes. Most of the delay in screening comes from paperwork sitting in someone’s inbox, not from the check itself.
What to check for a plumbing technician
| Check | What it shows | Notes for plumbing shops |
|---|---|---|
| Identity and address history | Confirms who the person is and where to search records | Basis for every other search |
| Criminal records | Convictions in relevant counties and states | Judge relevance and time passed, not just the existence of a record |
| Motor vehicle record | License status, suspensions, serious violations | Essential if the tech drives a company van |
| Trade license verification | Apprentice, journeyman or master status | Check the state or city board directly |
| Employment verification | Past employers and dates | Confirms trade experience claimed on the resume |
| Drug and alcohol testing | Results under your written policy | Follow state rules, which vary widely |
Pick the checks that relate to the job and apply the same package to everyone hired into that role. Checking some applicants more closely than others, based on how they look or sound, is exactly the kind of inconsistency that leads to discrimination claims.
Drug testing deserves its own written policy. State rules differ on when you can test, what you can test for and how to treat lawful off-duty cannabis use, so have the policy reviewed for each state where you hire. Whatever you choose, apply it the same way to every applicant for the role and explain it before the offer, not after.
The FCRA steps, in order
When you use a background screening company, the Fair Credit Reporting Act applies. The FTC and EEOC publish a joint plain-language guide for employers[1]; here is the sequence it describes, in the order your office should follow it.
Give a stand-alone disclosure
Tell the applicant in writing that you may use a background report for employment decisions. The notice must be in a stand-alone format and cannot sit inside the job application[1].
Get written permission
Have the applicant sign an authorization. If you plan to run checks during employment too, such as yearly driving records, say so clearly in the authorization[1].
Order the report and certify
Your screening company will ask you to certify that you followed the FCRA and will not misuse the information. Keep a copy of the signed forms in the hiring file.
Send a pre-adverse action notice
If something in the report may lead you to reject the applicant, first send a notice with a copy of the report and “A Summary of Your Rights Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act”[1].
Pause and listen
Give the applicant a fair chance to explain or correct the record. Reports can contain errors, such as a record that belongs to someone with a similar name.
Send the adverse action notice
If you decide not to hire, tell the applicant that the decision was based on the report, give the screening company’s contact details, state that the company did not make the decision, and explain their right to dispute the report and get a free copy within 60 days[1].
Fair-chance decisions
Federal discrimination law still applies when you use background information. The FTC and EEOC guide warns that a screening policy can be unlawful if it has a disparate impact on a protected group and is not job related and consistent with business necessity[1]. Many states and cities also have fair-chance or ban-the-box laws that limit when you can ask about criminal history, often not until after a conditional offer. Check your state and city rules before you write the policy.
A practical approach for in-home roles is an individual review using three questions:
- What was the offense, and does it relate to the duties of this job, such as being alone in homes, handling payments or driving?
- How long ago did it happen, and what has the person done since, including work history and training?
- What does the person say about it, and is there evidence of rehabilitation?
Write down the reasons for each decision. If a theft conviction from two years ago leads you to decline a role that involves collecting payments in homes, say so. If a minor offense from a decade ago does not, record that too. Consistent written reasons are your best defense.
Mistakes that cause trouble
- Burying the disclosure inside the application or adding a liability waiver to it. The disclosure must stand alone.
- Rejecting someone by phone the day the report arrives, without the pre-adverse action notice and a pause.
- Searching social media or court sites yourself and treating what you find as a screening report.
- Using a different package of checks for different applicants in the same role.
- Keeping reports in an open shared folder or the owner’s email inbox.
- Promising customers that “every tech is screened” while seasonal helpers or subcontractors are not.
Most of these come from rushing. A one-page checklist in the hiring file, ticked off by the person running the process, prevents nearly all of them and leaves a record that the steps were followed.
Telling customers you screen
Screening only builds trust if customers know about it. Add a short line to your website and booking confirmations, such as: “Every technician who enters your home has passed a background check and driving record review.” Make sure it is true for every person you send, including subcontractors and seasonal help. Combine it with a named technician and photo in the confirmation text, so the customer knows exactly who to expect.
When callers ask directly, the office should answer with facts, not adjectives. The same goes for any phone answering you use outside office hours: give it the approved wording so the answer never changes. If Ava answers your calls, load the screening line into the answers she is allowed to give.
Keeping it current
- Run motor vehicle records at least yearly for anyone who drives a company vehicle, with authorization on file.
- Re-verify trade licenses at each renewal date.
- Apply the same rules to subcontractors who enter homes under your name.
- Store reports securely, limit access to the people who make hiring decisions and dispose of them safely.
Example: a conditional offer done right
Example (fictional): A shop offers a journeyman a job on Monday, conditional on screening. He signs the stand-alone disclosure and authorization that afternoon. The report arrives Wednesday and shows a suspended license from six years ago. The office sends a pre-adverse action notice with the report and the summary of rights. He replies with proof the suspension was cleared five years ago, and the current record is clean. The owner records the reasoning, confirms the hire and he starts the following Monday, a week from offer to start.
For the rest of the hiring process, see how to hire plumbers in a tight labor market and writing a plumber job ad that gets applicants. The customer side of trust is covered in why customers fear plumbing scams.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need the applicant’s permission to run a background check?
Yes, when you use a background screening company. You need a stand-alone written disclosure and written authorization before ordering the report[1].
Can I refuse to hire anyone with a criminal record?
Blanket bans are risky. A policy that screens out a protected group and is not job related and consistent with business necessity can be unlawful[1]. Review each case on relevance and time passed.
Should I check driving records for plumbers?
If they drive a company vehicle, yes. Get authorization that covers ongoing checks and review records at least once a year.
Do these rules apply to subcontractors?
If subcontractors enter homes under your name, customers will treat them as your staff. Require equivalent screening in the subcontract and keep proof on file.
References
Federal Trade Commission and Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (2014). Background Checks: What Employers Need to Know (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey, Table 1: Job openings levels and rates by industry (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025-2035). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025-2035). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) ↑