Key takeaways
- New York State requires pay ranges in job ads from businesses with four or more employees[1].
- Washington requires a wage scale or salary range plus a general description of benefits and other compensation from employers with 15 or more employees[2].
- New York City’s rule covers ads for any job performed in the city, including internal postings and flyers[3].
- Thresholds are low enough to catch many plumbing shops: about 42% of plumbing, heating and AC establishments had five or more employees in 2023[4].
- The safest policy is one good-faith range and a benefits summary in every ad, everywhere you hire.
What these laws ask for
Pay transparency laws require employers to tell applicants what a job pays, usually by including a pay range in the job posting. The details differ by state and city: which employers are covered, whether benefits must be described, whether internal promotions count and how violations are enforced. The common thread is simple: “competitive pay” is no longer enough in a growing list of places.
For plumbing shops, these rules matter for two reasons. Many apply to small employers, not just large companies. And the trades are exactly where candidates compare hourly rates closely, so a clear range helps recruiting regardless of the law. This article uses three rules we checked directly as examples; always confirm the current rules with your state and city labor departments before posting.
Some laws go beyond the posting itself. Depending on where you hire, rules may also give current employees the right to ask for the pay range of their own position, require you to keep records of ranges and pay history, or limit questions about an applicant’s past pay. Treat the job ad as the visible part of a wider pay policy, and write that policy down once so every posting follows it.
Three examples, side by side
| Where | Who is covered | What the ad must include | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| New York State | Businesses with four or more employees[1] | Compensation range and job description for advertised jobs, promotions and transfers[1] | Range can be annual salary or hourly; state if the job is commission-based[1] |
| New York City | Ads for jobs, promotions or transfers performed in the city[3] | A good-faith pay range[3] | Effective November 1, 2022; covers internal postings, online ads, flyers and newspaper ads[3] |
| Washington | Employers with 15 or more employees[2] | Wage scale or salary range, general description of all benefits and of other compensation[2] | Employers get a chance to fix a noncompliant posting before enforcement[2] |
Other states, including California, Colorado and Illinois, have their own pay-range rules for job postings, and more have followed. Thresholds and details vary, and some cities add rules on top of state law. If you hire in more than one state, follow the strictest rule that applies to each posting, or simply follow the strictest rule everywhere.
Why small shops are often covered
Many plumbing owners assume these laws are aimed at large employers. The thresholds say otherwise. In 2023, about 58% of plumbing, heating and air-conditioning contractor establishments had fewer than five employees, 77% had fewer than ten and 89% had fewer than twenty[4][5][6]. Put the other way round, about four in ten establishments had five or more employees, and a four-employee threshold like New York State’s reaches even further.
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2023[5]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Fewer than 5 employees | 58% |
| Fewer than 10 | 77% |
| Fewer than 20 | 89% |
Count employees the way the law in question does. Some rules count all employees, not just those in the state, and some count part-time staff. A three-truck shop with an office manager, a dispatcher and a part-time bookkeeper may already be over a low threshold.
Writing a range that complies and convinces
Set a good-faith range
Use the minimum and maximum you genuinely expect to pay for the role at the time of posting, not a theoretical ceiling.
Use the right unit
Hourly ranges are normal for technicians; New York’s guidance allows hourly compensation[1]. Annual salary works for managers and office roles.
Summarize benefits
List health insurance, retirement, paid time off and vehicle or tool benefits in a sentence or two.
Cover every posting
Apply the same rules to internal postings for promotions and transfers, recruiter ads and posts on social media.
Keep records
Save a copy of each ad with its date and range, and the basis for the range, such as local wage data.
A good-faith range for a journeyman might start near your metro’s median and rise toward the upper percentiles for experienced techs. Nationally, the median wage for plumbers, pipefitters and steamfitters was $63,800 in May 2025[7]; your local figures will differ.
Ranges that hold up in practice
The hardest part is not the law but the range itself. Owners worry that posting $30 to $40 an hour (example figures) will make every applicant ask for $40, or that current staff will compare their pay with the ad. Both concerns are manageable with preparation.
- Define what moves someone up the range: license level, years in residential service, specific skills such as sewer camera work or tankless installs.
- Write those criteria down and use them in interviews, so offers within the range are explainable.
- Check current staff against the range before posting; if someone is paid below the bottom of a range you are about to advertise, fix it first.
- Avoid ranges so wide they mean nothing; candidates read a huge spread as a sign the top figure is not real.
- Review ranges at least yearly against local wage data and your own recent offers.
Handled this way, a posted range becomes a recruiting tool and a retention tool. Technicians who can see how pay is set, and what it takes to move up, have one less reason to look elsewhere.
Where the job is performed
Rules usually follow the job’s location. New York City’s law covers any advertisement for a job, promotion or transfer that would be performed in the city[3]. For a plumbing company, the work location is where the technician works, which may be a service area that crosses city or state lines. A shop based outside a city that sends technicians into it may still need to follow that city’s rules for those roles. When in doubt, include the range.
Recruiters, job boards and social posts
Rules generally attach to the advertisement, not to who placed it. New York City’s guidance describes an advertisement as a written description of an available job, promotion or transfer, and gives examples ranging from internal bulletin board postings to internet ads, job fair flyers and newspaper ads[3]. A quick post in a local trades group or a flyer at a supply house counter can count. If a staffing agency or recruiter advertises your role, make the range a contract requirement and ask to see the ad before it goes live.
Enforcement and fixing mistakes
Penalties and processes differ. Washington’s Department of Labor & Industries says that if an employer does not correct a noncompliant posting within five business days, it can proceed with enforcement and may assess civil penalties, and that it generally assesses damages only when an applicant shows harm from the posting[2]. Other jurisdictions handle complaints through human rights commissions or labor departments, and some allow private claims.
- If you discover an old ad without a range, update or remove it right away.
- Check job boards for automatic reposts of old ads.
- Tell recruiters and staffing agencies in writing that every ad for your roles must include the range.
- If you receive a complaint, respond promptly and keep a record of the correction.
A one-page compliance checklist
- List every state and city where your technicians and office staff work.
- Note each jurisdiction’s pay-transparency rule and threshold, and check it once a year.
- Count employees the way each rule counts them.
- Build a job ad template with fields for pay range, unit, other compensation and benefits.
- Require a range in every ad, internal or external, as company policy.
- Store copies of ads and the reasoning behind each range.
Example: a growing shop crosses the line
Example (fictional): A Washington plumbing company grows from twelve to sixteen employees after adding two trucks and a dispatcher. Its old ad for a service plumber says “competitive pay, great benefits.” The office manager notices the company is now over the state’s 15-employee threshold, rewrites the ad with an hourly range, a note that on-call shifts are paid at a premium and a two-line benefits summary, and adds the same fields to every future posting. Applications rise, and candidates stop asking “what does it pay?” on the first call.
This article is general information, not legal advice; check the current rules with your state labor department or an employment lawyer. Related reading: writing a plumber job ad, plumber wages by state and metro area, starting a registered apprenticeship and apprentice to journeyman.
Frequently asked questions
Which states require pay ranges in plumbing job ads?
Several, with different thresholds. New York State covers businesses with four or more employees[1] and Washington covers employers with 15 or more[2]; others, including California, Colorado and Illinois, have their own rules. Check your state labor department.
Does a small plumbing company have to post pay ranges?
It depends on the law where the job is performed and how many employees you have. Some thresholds are as low as four employees, so many small shops are covered.
Can I post an hourly range instead of a salary?
Yes in many places; New York’s guidance allows hourly compensation[1]. Hourly ranges are normal for technician roles.
Do internal promotions need a posted range?
Under some rules, yes. New York State’s rule covers promotions and transfers as well as new jobs[1].
References
New York State Department of Labor (2026). Pay Transparency (opens in a new tab) ↑
Washington State Department of Labor & Industries (2026). Equal Pay & Opportunities Act (opens in a new tab) ↑
New York City Commission on Human Rights (2022). Salary Transparency in Job Advertisements (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Census Bureau (2023). County Business Patterns 2023, U.S. national file (cbp23us) (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Census Bureau (2023). County Business Patterns 2023, U.S. national file (cbp23us) (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Census Bureau (2023). County Business Patterns 2023, U.S. national file (cbp23us) (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) ↑