Key takeaways
- Section 1 is due by the first day of work and Section 2 within 3 business days; a Monday start is due Thursday[2][3].
- Let the new hire choose the documents from the lists. Asking for specific ones is a common and avoidable error[3].
- Keep each form until 3 years after hire or 1 year after the person leaves, whichever is later[4].
- Arizona and South Carolina require E-Verify of private employers, and Florida and North Carolina from 25 employees[5][6][7][8].
Hiring in bursts is where I-9s go wrong
Plumbing companies rarely hire one person at a time on a quiet Tuesday. They hire two helpers the week before the busy season, a licensed tech who can start Monday, an apprentice class in the fall. The paperwork lands on an office manager who is also running payroll and answering the phones, and the Form I-9 is the one document with a hard federal clock and a fine attached to every mistake.
Every new employee needs a completed Form I-9, citizen or not. It is not filed with USCIS or ICE; you keep it and produce it if asked[9]. The current edition is dated 01/20/25, and employers who complete the form electronically had to update their systems to the version expiring 05/31/2027 by 07/31/2026[9]. If your onboarding software or the PDF in your shared drive is older, replace it before the next hire.
The form sits alongside the rest of your hiring steps: the federal payroll basics in hiring your first employee, the driving and criminal checks in background checks for in-home technicians, and the first weeks of training in a 90-day onboarding plan.
The clock, day by day
The new hire completes and signs Section 1 no later than the first day of employment, and may do it any time after accepting the offer[2]. You complete Section 2, examining the documents, within 3 business days of the first day; if someone starts on a Monday, the form is due by Thursday[3]. A job that lasts less than 3 days, such as a two-day helper on a sewer replacement, needs Section 2 done no later than the first day of work for pay[3].
| Day | What must be done | Who |
|---|---|---|
| Before Monday | Offer accepted; Section 1 can be completed any time from here | New hire |
| Monday (day 1) | Section 1 signed, at the latest. Any preparer or translator completes Supplement A | New hire |
| Monday to Thursday | Documents examined in person; Section 2 completed and signed | Office manager |
| By Thursday | E-Verify case created, if you use E-Verify | Office manager |
| Same week | Form filed in the I-9 binder or system; retention date calculated | Office manager |
- Your team
- System
01Your team
Offer accepted
Start date set; the new hire gets the Section 1 link or paper form.
02Your team
Section 1 by day one
Completed and signed by the employee, with Supplement A if anyone helped.
03Your team
Documents examined
The employee picks List A, or List B plus List C; you check the originals.
04Your team
Section 2 by day three
Completed, signed and dated within 3 business days of the start.
05System
E-Verify case
Created from the finished I-9 by the third business day, where used.
06Your team
Filed and dated
Stored apart from the personnel file, with the date it can be destroyed.
Example sequence based on USCIS and E-Verify guidance.
Documents: the employee chooses
The new hire decides which acceptable documents to present: one from List A, or one from List B together with one from List C. If they present an acceptable List A document, you do not ask for anything from Lists B or C[3]. You must physically examine the originals. The exception is an employer enrolled in E-Verify that uses the DHS alternative procedure to examine documents remotely[3].
Plumbing shops trip over this because they have a legitimate reason to see a driver's license: the tech will drive a company truck. Keep the two conversations apart. The vehicle policy, the motor vehicle record and the insurer's driver list are their own file. The I-9 conversation is βplease bring documents from the list on the form, your choice.β Saying βbring your driver's license and Social Security card for the I-9β turns a reasonable driving check into a request for specific I-9 documents.
Example wording for the offer email: βWelcome aboard. Before your first day, please complete Section 1 of Form I-9 using the link below. On Monday, bring original documents to show you can work in the US: either one document from List A, or one from List B and one from List C. The lists are on the last page of the form, and the choice is yours. Separately, for the company truck, please bring your driver's license so we can add you to our vehicle policy.β
- Do give every new hire the same written instruction: the list of acceptable documents and the date they need them by.
- Do check that each document reasonably appears genuine and relates to the person in front of you.
- Do record the document title, issuing authority, number and expiration date exactly as shown.
- Do not ask for more documents than the form requires, or for particular ones.
- Do not complete Section 2 from photocopies unless you are using the remote procedure as an E-Verify employer.
The same wording works for every hire, from a first-year apprentice to a master plumber joining as a service manager. Using one script is the simplest protection against the inconsistent requests that cause most document problems, and it saves the office from rewriting the instructions each time.
State E-Verify mandates
E-Verify checks the information on a completed I-9 against government records. Participants create the case from the employee's form no later than the third business day after the employee starts work for pay[10]. Some states make it mandatory for private employers, and the thresholds differ.
| State | Who must use E-Verify | Timing, records and penalties |
|---|---|---|
| Arizona | Every employer, after hiring an employee[5] | Keep the verification record for the length of employment or 3 years, whichever is longer[5] |
| South Carolina | Private employers required to complete federal I-9s[6] | Verify within three business days of employing a new employee; a first violation brings probation, a repeat can suspend licenses for 10 to 30 days[6] |
| Florida | Private employers with 25 or more employees, since July 1, 2023[7] | Within three business days after the first paid workday; keep documentation at least 3 years; after three failures in 24 months, $1,000 a day until cured[7] |
| North Carolina | Employers with 25 or more employees in the state[8] | Employees employed less than nine months in a calendar year are excluded from the definition[8] |
Two details matter for plumbing shops. Florida employers that must use E-Verify also certify compliance on their first unemployment tax return each calendar year[7]. North Carolina's exclusion for short-term employees can cover summer helpers, but a helper who stays on into the fall may no longer fit it[8], so decide case by case, and see seasonal helpers for the staffing side.
Contractors are among the heaviest users of the system. At the end of 2025, specialty trade contractors, the industry group plumbing contractors belong to, ranked third of all industries by E-Verify hiring sites[11].
Keeping and storing the forms
Keep each Form I-9 until three years after the date of hire or one year after employment ends, whichever is later[4]. In practice: someone who worked for you less than two years keeps a form for three years from their first day; someone who worked more than two years keeps a form for one year after they leave[4].
- Example: a helper starts March 3, 2025 and leaves August 15, 2025. Three years after hire is March 3, 2028; one year after leaving is August 15, 2026. Keep the form until March 3, 2028.
- Example: a service tech starts in June 2019 and leaves on June 30, 2026. One year after leaving, June 30, 2027, is later than three years after hire, so keep it until then.
USCIS recommends storing I-9s separately from personnel files, and if you copy the documents an employee presents, the copies go with that employee's form[12]. Paper, scanned or electronic storage all work, but whatever the format, you must be able to hand the forms to government officials within 3 business days of a request[12]. One binder or folder for current employees and one for former employees, sorted by destruction date, makes that easy. Broader retention schedules are in what records a plumbing business must keep.
Paperwork errors that draw fines
For violations after November 2, 2015, the civil penalty for failing the verification requirements runs from $288 to $2,861 for each person[1]. Knowingly hiring or continuing to employ an unauthorized worker carries $716 to $5,724 per worker for a first offense, rising for repeat offenses[1]. The amount depends on the size of the business, good faith, how serious the violation is, whether the person was unauthorized, and your history[1]. Twenty helpers' forms with the same mistake is twenty violations.
- Section 2 completed late, often because the office manager was out on the start day.
- Blank fields: the employer's title, business name and address, the first day of employment, a signature or a date.
- An outdated form edition from an old onboarding packet[9].
- Requesting specific documents, or more documents than the form calls for[3].
- A preparer or translator helped with Section 1 and no Supplement A was completed[2].
- An E-Verify case created before the I-9 was finished; the process starts from a completed form[10].
- Forms mixed into personnel files, so producing them within 3 business days becomes a scramble[12].
Run a self-audit once a year. Pull every current employee's form, check each field against this list, and correct errors the way USCIS instructions describe: fix the wrong entry, initial and date the change, and never backdate. If you find a systemic problem, talk to an employment attorney about how to correct past forms.
Make first days easier on the office
Send Section 1 with the offer
The new hire can complete it any time after accepting[2], so it is done before day one.
Book the document check
Put 15 minutes on the calendar for day one, with a named backup if the office manager is out.
Use one onboarding sheet
Same instructions for every hire: the document lists, the date, and what to bring for the truck policy separately.
Calculate the destruction date
Write it on the form or in the system the day it is filed.
Diary the annual audit
Same week every year, before the spring hiring push.
Hiring days are also when the office line gets neglected: the person who would answer is across the desk from a new tech with a passport and a stack of forms. Forwarding overflow calls to an SI Employee for those hours means callers still get your business name, the job is taken down and read back, and the summary is in the inbox when the paperwork is done (try it). The commercial contractor example models a 14-technician shop where the desk handles about 85 calls a weekday, which is the volume an onboarding morning interrupts. For the hiring side itself, see how to hire plumbers in a tight labor market.
Frequently asked questions
Can a new hire fill out Section 1 before their first day?
Yes, any time after accepting the job offer, and no later than the first day of employment[2].
Can we check documents over video?
Only if you are enrolled in E-Verify and use the DHS alternative procedure. Otherwise documents must be examined in person[3].
How long do we keep the I-9 for someone who quit after six months?
Three years from the date of hire, because that is later than one year after they left[4].
Do we have to use E-Verify?
It depends on the state and your size. Arizona requires it of every employer[5], South Carolina of private employers[6], and Florida and North Carolina from 25 employees[7][8]. Check your own state's rules as well.
What does a paperwork mistake cost?
For violations after November 2, 2015, $288 to $2,861 per person, depending on business size, good faith, seriousness and history[1].
References
Electronic Code of Federal Regulations (eCFR) (2025). 8 CFR 274a.10: Penalties (opens in a new tab) β
U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (2026). Completing Section 1, Employee Information and Attestation (opens in a new tab) β
U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (2026). Completing Section 2, Employer Review and Attestation (opens in a new tab) β
U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (2026). Handbook for Employers M-274: 10.0 Retaining Form I-9 (opens in a new tab) β
Arizona State Legislature (2026). Arizona Revised Statutes 23-214: Verification of employment eligibility; e-verify program (opens in a new tab) β
South Carolina Legislature (2026). South Carolina Code of Laws, Title 41, Chapter 8: Unauthorized Aliens and Public Employment (opens in a new tab) β
The Florida Senate (2025). Florida Statutes section 448.095: Employment eligibility (opens in a new tab) β
North Carolina General Assembly (2026). North Carolina General Statutes 64-25: Definitions (Article 2, Verification of Work Authorization) (opens in a new tab) β
U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (2026). I-9, Employment Eligibility Verification (opens in a new tab) β
E-Verify (U.S. Department of Homeland Security) (2026). Verification Process (opens in a new tab) β
E-Verify (U.S. Department of Homeland Security) (2025). E-Verify Usage Statistics (opens in a new tab) β
U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (2026). Retain and Store Form I-9 (opens in a new tab) β