Key takeaways
- DOT drug and alcohol testing applies to drivers who need a CDL, such as those in vehicles of 26,001 pounds or more; most service vans fall below that line[1].
- State cannabis laws now limit some THC testing. California, for example, protects applicants' off-duty use from January 1, 2024, with exceptions[2].
- Construction job openings rose to 298,000 in September 2026, so a blunt testing policy can cost you good applicants[3].
- Write the policy around safety-sensitive work, reasonable suspicion and post-accident testing, and train supervisors to document what they see.
Why plumbing shops test at all
Plumbing is safety-sensitive work. BLS lists cuts from sharp tools, burns from hot pipes and soldering equipment, and falls from ladders among common plumber injuries[4], and many plumbers drive to job sites every day[5]. Specialty trade contractors recorded 2.3 injury and illness cases per 100 full-time workers in 2024[6]. Add torches, trenches, gas lines and customers' homes, and impairment on the job becomes a real risk to the worker, the customer and your insurance.
That does not mean every shop needs the same policy. The right policy depends on whether you have drivers who need a commercial driver's license, which states you work in, and what you want testing to achieve: screening applicants, responding to warning signs, or investigating accidents.
When federal DOT rules apply
Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration testing rules in 49 CFR Part 382 cover drivers of commercial motor vehicles who need a CDL. For these rules, a commercial motor vehicle includes one with a gross vehicle or combination weight rating of 26,001 pounds or more, one designed to carry 16 or more passengers including the driver, or a vehicle of any size carrying hazardous materials that require placards[1].
A typical cargo van or service truck is well under that weight. The rules start to matter when a shop runs a dump truck with an equipment trailer for excavation, a large box truck for new-construction material, or hauls placarded quantities of hazardous materials. If even one driver needs a CDL for your work, that driver must be in a DOT-compliant testing program, separate from your company policy.
| Vehicle | Typical DOT testing status | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Cargo van or pickup service truck | Not covered by Part 382 in most cases | Company policy only |
| Box truck under the weight threshold | Usually not covered | Company policy only; confirm the rating plate |
| Dump truck or truck with heavy equipment trailer | Often covered if the combination rating reaches the threshold | Enroll CDL drivers in a DOT program |
| Any vehicle hauling placarded hazmat | Covered regardless of size | DOT program and hazmat training |
State cannabis law has changed the THC question
Cannabis is the area where state law has moved fastest. California is a useful example of how detailed the rules can be. Beginning January 1, 2024, California employers generally cannot deny someone a job because they use cannabis off the job and away from the workplace, or because a test shows non-psychoactive cannabis metabolites[2]. A scientifically valid test showing psychoactive THC can still justify action[2]. The protections do not apply to employers with four or fewer employees or to positions needing a federal background investigation or security clearance[2].
There is a twist for the trades. For current employees, California's protections for off-duty use do not apply to people in the building or construction trades[2]. Applicants are treated differently from employees, so a plumbing company in California has to handle pre-employment screening and on-the-job testing as two separate questions. Other states have their own versions, from full protection of off-duty use to narrower limits on pre-employment tests, and the details change often.
Before testing for THC in any state, confirm with an employment lawyer what the state allows for applicants, what it allows for current employees, and whether construction trades are treated differently.
Testing policy and the hiring market
The labor market matters too. Construction had 298,000 job openings in September 2026, a 3.4% openings rate, up from 206,000 a year earlier[3]. Shops that screen out every applicant with any trace of cannabis, where the law allows it, are drawing from a smaller pool in a tight market. Many owners now focus testing on impairment and safety events rather than on off-duty use.
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2026[3]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| September 2025 | 206,000 |
| September 2026 | 298,000 |
What the written policy should include
- Purpose and scope: who is covered, which positions are safety-sensitive, and which drivers fall under DOT rules.
- Prohibited conduct: being impaired at work, using or possessing drugs or alcohol on the job, in company vehicles or on customer property.
- Test types: pre-employment (where lawful), reasonable suspicion, post-accident and return-to-duty; random testing only where required or clearly lawful.
- Substances tested and cut-off levels, and the lab and collection standards you use.
- Prescription medications: how employees report medication that may affect safe work, and how that information is kept confidential.
- Consequences: what happens after a refusal or confirmed positive, including any second-chance or treatment option.
- Confidentiality: who sees results and where records are stored, separate from the general personnel file.
- State supplement: any state-specific rules, especially for cannabis and notice requirements.
Reasonable suspicion: train supervisors to document
Reasonable suspicion testing is the most useful tool for a service company and the easiest to get wrong. A supervisor must be able to describe specific, observable signs, not a hunch. Train every field supervisor and dispatcher who may make the call, and give them a one-page checklist.
Observe and write it down
Note the time, place and specific signs: slurred speech, smell of alcohol, unsteady walking, red eyes with other signs, unusual behavior or a near miss.
Get a second observer
Where possible, have a second trained person confirm what they see before acting.
Remove from duty
Take the employee off the job and out of the vehicle. Never let them drive to the collection site.
Arrange transport and testing
Use a ride service or a supervisor to take them to an approved collection site promptly.
Follow the policy
Keep the employee off safety-sensitive work until results arrive, then apply the written consequences consistently.
Post-accident testing and return to duty
Post-accident testing is where many policies are vague. Define what counts as an accident for testing purposes, for example a vehicle crash that needs a tow or a police report, an injury that needs treatment beyond first aid, or property damage above a set level in a customer's home. Testing every minor incident can discourage people from reporting injuries, so tie the trigger to events where impairment could plausibly have played a part.
Spell out timing. Alcohol tests lose value quickly, so the policy should say how soon after an incident testing must happen and who arranges it, including after hours. Your after-hours line or on-call manager needs a written procedure, because the crash that matters most often happens on a night emergency call.
For return to duty, decide in advance whether you offer a second chance after a first positive result, what an employee must complete before coming back, and whether follow-up testing applies. Consistency is the main legal protection: apply the same rules to the star technician and the new helper. Tell employees about any employee assistance program or treatment resources, and make sure an employee who asks for help before a test is treated according to the policy rather than case by case.
Finally, keep the policy and the practice aligned. If the policy says reasonable suspicion testing is required and supervisors routinely send people home without testing, the written policy is undermined. Review every test and every removal from duty once a quarter.
Example: an eight-van shop with one heavy truck
Example: a fictional company, Lakeline Plumbing, runs eight service vans and one dump truck with an equipment trailer that it uses for sewer replacements. Its owner checks the rating plates and finds that the truck and trailer combination meets the federal commercial vehicle definition. The two employees who drive that rig hold CDLs, so Lakeline enrolls them in a DOT consortium that handles random selection and recordkeeping.
For everyone else, Lakeline's company policy covers reasonable suspicion and post-accident testing, plus pre-employment testing where state law allows it. The policy states plainly that being impaired at work is prohibited, explains how employees report medications, and tells techs that they will be sent home in a ride service, not in the van, if a supervisor removes them from duty. Supervisors take a two-hour course on recognizing impairment and documenting it.
Frequently asked questions
Do plumbing van drivers need DOT drug testing?
Usually not. Part 382 testing applies to drivers who need a CDL to operate a commercial motor vehicle, such as one rated at 26,001 pounds or more. Check each vehicle's rating plate, including any trailer.
Can a plumbing company still test for marijuana?
It depends on the state and on whether the person is an applicant or an employee. Some states restrict pre-employment THC tests or protect off-duty use. Impairment at work can almost always be addressed.
Should we do random drug testing?
Random testing is required for DOT-covered drivers. For other employees, some states restrict it, so many shops limit random testing to roles where it is required and rely on reasonable suspicion and post-accident testing for everyone else.
Where should drug test results be stored?
Keep them confidential and separate from the general personnel file, with access limited to the people who need them to make employment decisions.
References
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 49 CFR 382.107: Definitions (controlled substances and alcohol use and testing) (opens in a new tab) โ
California Civil Rights Department (2024). Discrimination in Employment: Use of Cannabis (FAQ) (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey, Table 1: Job openings levels and rates by industry (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2024). Industries at a Glance: Specialty Trade Contractors (NAICS 238) (opens in a new tab) โ