Key takeaways
- Score technicians on a balanced card: about half job results, half behaviors such as communication, safety and paperwork.
- Compare techs only on similar call types; a drain tech and a water heater installer should not share one revenue target.
- Pay at plumbing, heating and AC contractors rose from $39.30 to $42.65 an hour between January 2025 and August 2026, so reviews and raises need a clear link[1].
- Hold short monthly data check-ins so the annual review contains no surprises.
Why most technician reviews fail
Many plumbing shops review technicians once a year, if at all, and the conversation is driven by gut feel: who the owner likes, who complained last, who sold the most last month. Techs see it as arbitrary, and the good ones leave for a shop that explains how pay and promotion work. Other shops swing the other way and review only on revenue, which rewards overselling and punishes the tech who gets sent on all the small, difficult jobs.
A better review uses a scorecard that both sides understand in advance. It mixes numbers the business can measure from its field service software with behaviors a manager can observe and customers can describe. It also accounts for context: call mix, season and how many callbacks were really the tech's fault.
The economics make this worth doing. Plumbing, heating and AC contractors generated about $260,000 in receipts per employee in 2022[2], and payroll equalled about 27% of receipts[3]. Technicians are the engine of that revenue, and labor is the largest controllable cost. A fair, data-backed review is how you decide where raises go.
The balanced scorecard
Use five to eight measures, no more. Weight results and behaviors roughly equally, and publish the scorecard so every tech knows how they are judged.
| Measure | How to measure it | Example weight | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Callback rate | Return visits for the same problem within 30 days, divided by jobs | 15% | Exclude callbacks caused by parts failures or customer changes |
| Revenue per billable hour | Invoiced labor and parts divided by hours on jobs | 15% | Compare within the same job type only |
| Estimate conversion | Estimates accepted divided by estimates given | 10% | Low conversion on big replacements may be fine if options were offered |
| On-time arrival | Arrived within the promised window | 10% | Dispatch delays are not the tech's fault |
| Paperwork and photos | Jobs closed with notes, photos and signatures the same day | 10% | Make the standard clear before scoring it |
| Customer communication | Review mentions, manager ride-alongs, complaint log | 15% | Score behavior, not just star ratings |
| Safety and vehicle care | Incidents, telematics events, van inspections | 15% | Never trade safety for speed |
| Learning and teamwork | Training completed, helping apprentices, covering on-call | 10% | Record specific examples through the year |
Keep revenue to a minority of the score. A card that is mostly sales will push techs to oversell, and customers notice.
Behaviors: make them observable
Behaviors are where reviews become vague. Write each one as something you could see or hear. BLS lists communication as a key quality for plumbers because they talk to customers regularly[4], and preparing cost estimates is a core part of the job[5]. Both can be observed.
- Explains the problem and the options in plain words before starting work, and gets approval for the price.
- Protects the home: shoe covers, drop cloths, cleans up, shows the customer the finished work.
- Presents good, better and best options on replacements without pressure, and records which one the customer chose.
- Calls the office when running late and gives the customer a new window.
- Follows the safety rules every time, including when the manager is not there.
- Helps newer techs and apprentices, and shares fixes that save time.
Customer reviews are useful evidence but handle them carefully. Readers pay extra attention to very negative reviews; Pew found 54% of review readers focus more on extremely negative ones[6]. One angry review should start a conversation about what happened, not set a tech's score for the year.
Normalize for job mix and season
A tech who spends February on frozen pipes and slab leaks will have different numbers from one who runs drain calls and faucet swaps. Before comparing anyone, group jobs by type and compare each tech with the shop's average for that type. Review results over at least a quarter so one big repipe or one bad week does not swing the score.
- Split revenue measures by job category: drains, water heaters, repairs, repipes, sewer.
- Track callbacks by cause: workmanship, parts, misdiagnosis, customer change.
- Note seasonal duties: on-call nights, emergency volume, training time.
- Adjust for helpers: a tech who carries an apprentice may be slower but is building your next tech.
A yearly calendar that avoids surprises
Monthly 15-minute check-in
Review the tech's numbers against shop averages for their job types; agree on one thing to keep and one to improve.
Quarterly ride-along
A manager or lead spends half a day with the tech and records specific examples of the behaviors on the card.
Mid-year development talk
Discuss training goals, licensing steps and interest in lead roles, separate from pay.
Annual review and pay decision
Score the full card, share the evidence, then explain how the result maps to the raise or bonus.
Written follow-up
Send a one-page summary with the score, examples and goals for next year, signed by both.
Linking reviews to pay
Wages have been rising. Average hourly earnings at plumbing, heating and AC contractors rose from $39.30 in January 2025 to $42.65 in August 2026[1], and were up about 4.4% year on year in September 2026[7]. Techs know the market. If your review does not explain how pay is set, they will assume it is arbitrary.
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics, 2026[1]
Show the data
| Period | Value |
|---|---|
| Jan 2025 | $39.3 |
| Sep 2025 | $40.59 |
| Aug 2026 | $42.65 |
| Sep 2026 | $42.38 |
A simple approach: set a market adjustment that everyone in good standing receives, then add a merit band based on the scorecard. Publish the bands. Tie license upgrades, such as journeyman to master, to an automatic step so learning is rewarded on its own track.
Mistakes that undermine the review
- Changing the scorecard at review time. If a measure was not on the card in January, it should not decide pay in December.
- Scoring on memory. Without monthly notes and ride-along records, the last month dominates the whole year.
- Blaming techs for system problems. Late arrivals caused by overbooked dispatch boards or missing parts belong to the office, not the tech.
- Ranking techs against each other publicly. Shared leaderboards can motivate some people, but they also push techs to avoid hard, low-revenue calls.
- Skipping the review for top performers. Your best techs want feedback and a path forward as much as anyone; they are also the ones competitors call.
- Mixing discipline into the annual review. Serious conduct problems need to be handled when they happen, under your discipline policy, not saved for a yearly meeting.
When a technician is struggling
Sometimes the scorecard shows a real problem: callbacks well above the shop average, repeated complaints or safety events. Treat it as a coaching problem first. Look at the evidence together, find the cause and agree on a specific plan with dates. A tech with a high callback rate on water heaters may need a refresher on venting or expansion tanks; a tech with poor conversion may need practice presenting options; a tech who is always late may be stuck with a dispatch pattern that does not work.
Write the plan down: the measure, the target, the support you will give (ride-alongs, training, a mentor) and the review date, usually 30 to 60 days out. If the numbers do not improve after genuine support, the written record makes the next decision fair and defensible. If they do improve, say so clearly and note it in the file. Most technicians who are given a clear target and real help will meet it.
Example: a review conversation script
Example: a fictional tech, Marco, scored well on callbacks and customer communication but poorly on same-day paperwork. His manager opens with the evidence, not the score.
- Open: “Thanks for the year. I want to walk through the card together, starting with what went well.”
- Strengths with evidence: “Your callback rate on water heater installs was the lowest in the shop, and three customers named you in reviews for explaining options clearly.”
- Gap with evidence: “About a third of your jobs were closed without photos or notes until the next day. That slowed billing and made two warranty claims harder.”
- Ask: “What gets in the way of closing jobs in the van?”
- Agree: “Let's set a goal of closing every job before you leave the driveway, and I'll check in monthly.”
- Pay: “Your score puts you in the upper merit band, plus the market adjustment. Here's how that was calculated.”
Frequently asked questions
How often should plumbing technicians be reviewed?
Hold short monthly check-ins on numbers, a quarterly ride-along and one formal annual review tied to pay. The annual review should summarize what was already discussed.
Should technician reviews be based on sales?
Sales can be one measure, but keep it a minority of the score and pair it with callbacks, customer communication and safety. A sales-only review encourages overselling.
How do we compare techs who do different kinds of work?
Group jobs by type and compare each tech with the shop average for that type, over at least a quarter.
What should we do about a tech with great numbers but poor behavior?
Score both parts of the card honestly. Strong revenue does not cancel unsafe driving, rudeness to customers or skipped paperwork.
References
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics (2026). Average hourly earnings of all employees, plumbing, heating, and air-conditioning contractors, not seasonally adjusted (CEU2023822003) (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Census Bureau (2022). Statistics of U.S. Businesses 2022: U.S. and states, 6-digit NAICS (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Census Bureau (2022). Statistics of U.S. Businesses 2022: U.S. and states, 6-digit NAICS (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2016). Online Reviews (Online Shopping and E-Commerce) (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics (2026). Average hourly earnings of all employees, plumbing, heating, and air-conditioning contractors, not seasonally adjusted (CEU2023822003) (opens in a new tab) ↑