Hiring training

Overtime rules for commissioned and piece-rate techs

How to calculate overtime for commissioned, flat-rate and piece-rate plumbing techs under the FLSA, with regular rate examples and a payroll checklist.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. The rule in one paragraph
  2. What goes into the regular rate and what stays out
  3. Flat-rate and piece-rate techs
  4. Commissioned techs
  5. Counting hours worked
  6. Exemptions and state rules
  7. Mistakes that show up in wage claims
  8. Payroll setup checklist
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References
Hiring training: Overtime rules for commissioned and piece-rate techsArticle coverHIRING TRAININGOvertime rules forcommissioned andpiece-rate techsAva for PlumbersInsightsHiring training: Overtime rules for commissioned and piece-rate techsArticle coverHIRING TRAININGOvertime rules forcommissioned andpiece-rate techsAva for Plumbers

Key takeaways

  • Overtime is due at one and one-half times the regular rate for hours over 40 in a workweek, and the regular rate includes commissions and piece earnings[1].
  • Regular rate = total compensation for the week (minus the few allowed exclusions) divided by total hours worked[1].
  • For piece-rate and flat-rate techs, the overtime owed is an extra half of the regular rate for each overtime hour, because the straight time is already in the piece pay[2].
  • Commissions are payments for hours worked whatever the formula, so they must go into the regular rate[3].
  • Count every hour worked, including shop time, drive time between jobs and required meetings, not just billed book hours.

The rule in one paragraph

Under the Fair Labor Standards Act, non-exempt employees must get overtime pay of at least one and one-half times their regular rate for every hour worked over 40 in a workweek[1]. The regular rate is not the base hourly rate on the offer letter. It is the total compensation for the workweek, minus a short list of statutory exclusions, divided by the total hours actually worked[1]. Earnings may be by the hour, the piece, salary or commission; they all go into the same calculation[1].

This matters more in plumbing than in most industries. BLS notes plumbers are often on call for emergencies, so evening and weekend work is common[4]. A pay plan that works on paper for a 40-hour week can underpay overtime in exactly the weeks when techs are working hardest.

What goes into the regular rate and what stays out

The Labor Department's guidance says all compensation for hours worked, services rendered or performance must be included[1]. For a plumbing tech, that typically means:

  • Hourly wages, including any higher rate for on-call or after-hours work.
  • Commissions on tickets, replacements or maintenance plans.
  • Flat-rate or piece-rate earnings per task or book hour.
  • Production, booking or quality bonuses promised in advance or paid by formula.
  • Spiffs for selling leads or plans.

The exclusions are narrow. They include gifts not tied to hours or production, pay for vacation, holidays or sick leave, reimbursement of business expenses, infrequent call-back pay, certain perks, truly discretionary bonuses where both the decision and the amount are at the employer's sole discretion with no prior promise, and contributions to qualifying benefit plans[1]. A bonus you announced at the start of the quarter is not discretionary, however it is described.

Flat-rate and piece-rate techs

Many plumbing shops pay service techs per book hour or per task. The federal method for pieceworkers is to add up all earnings for the week, including any pay for waiting or other hours, divide by all hours worked to get the regular rate, then pay an extra half of that rate for each hour over 40[2]. The straight-time portion of the overtime hours is already covered by the piece earnings, which is why only the half-time premium is added.

The regulation's own example: a worker earns $491 in piece pay and $32 for 4 waiting hours in a 50-hour week, for $523 in total. The regular rate is $523 divided by 50, or $10.46, and the overtime premium is 10 hours times $5.23, or $52.30, for total pay of $575.30[2]. Plumbing pay is higher, but the method is identical.

Pieceworker overtime example from 29 CFR 778.11150-hour week; total pay $575.30
Pieceworker overtime example from 29 CFR 778.111Stacked bar chart. Piece-rate earnings: $491; Waiting-time pay: $32; Overtime premium (half-time on 10 hours): $52.3.Piece-rate earnings: $491 (85%)Waiting-time pay: $32 (6%)Overtime premium (half-time on 10 hours): $52.3 (9%)Pieceworker overtime example from 29 CFR 778.111Stacked bar chart. Piece-rate earnings: $491; Waiting-time pay: $32; Overtime premium (half-time on 10 hours): $52.3.Piece-rate earnings: $491 (85%)Waiting-time pay: $32 (6%)Overtime premium (half-time on 10 hours): $52.3 (9%)
  • Piece-rate earnings $491 85%
  • Waiting-time pay $32 6%
  • Overtime premium (half-time on 10 hours) $52.3 9%

Source: Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School, 2026[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
Piece-rate earnings$491
Waiting-time pay$32
Overtime premium (half-time on 10 hours)$52.3

Example (fictional), plumbing version: a flat-rate tech is paid $30 per book hour and completes 42 book hours of work in a week where he is on the clock for 48 hours, including shop time, a training meeting and drive time between calls. Flat-rate pay is $1,260. The regular rate is $1,260 divided by 48, or $26.25. The overtime premium is half of $26.25 times 8 overtime hours, or $105. Total pay: $1,365. Note that the regular rate uses all 48 hours on the clock, not the 42 book hours.

Commissioned techs

Federal rules say commissions are payments for hours worked and must be included in the regular rate, whether the commission is the employee's only pay or is added to a salary or hourly wage, and whatever the formula or how often it is computed[3]. A tech paid an hourly base plus a percentage of ticket sales therefore has a regular rate higher than the base rate in any week with commission.

Example (fictional): a tech earns $25 an hour and works 45 hours, plus $450 in commission for the week. Straight-time pay is $1,125; with commission, total straight earnings are $1,575. The regular rate is $1,575 divided by 45, or $35.00. Overtime premium: half of $35.00 times 5 hours, or $87.50. Total pay: $1,662.50. Paying overtime only on the $25 base would have paid $62.50 for the premium and underpaid the tech by $25 that week.

When commissions are calculated monthly or after the job is paid, overtime for the weeks covered has to be recalculated once the commission is known. Payroll providers do this by spreading the commission across those workweeks; make sure yours is set up to do it, and that the adjustment is paid promptly.

Counting hours worked

Overtime errors in flat-rate shops usually come from hours, not rates. If the tech is only paid for book hours, the time sheet often shows book hours too, and the real hours disappear. Federal law looks at hours actually worked. Time that is generally counted includes:

  • Required morning meetings and training sessions.
  • Loading, cleaning and restocking the truck at the shop.
  • Driving from the first call to later calls and back to the shop or supply house.
  • Waiting at a job site for a customer, inspector or part when the tech cannot use the time for themselves.
  • On-call time if the restrictions are so tight the tech cannot use the time for their own purposes; looser on-call rules are treated differently, so get advice on your specific policy.

Ordinary commuting from home to the first job is usually not work time, but take-home truck arrangements, required stops and work done before the first call can change that. Have techs clock in and out in the field software and pay from those times.

Exemptions and state rules

There is a narrow federal overtime exemption for certain commissioned employees of retail or service establishments, with strict conditions on the share of pay from commission and the regular rate. Do not assume it applies to a plumbing contractor without specific legal advice. Some states also add daily overtime, separate pay requirements for rest periods or non-productive time for piece-rate workers, or higher minimum wages that change the calculation. Your state labor department publishes these rules; follow whichever standard is more generous to the employee.

The cost of getting it wrong grows with wages. Average hourly earnings at plumbing, heating and AC contractors were $42.38 in September 2026 (preliminary)[5], so even a small error on the overtime premium, repeated across a team for a year, adds up to a meaningful back-pay exposure.

Mistakes that show up in wage claims

  • Paying overtime at one and one-half times the base hourly rate and ignoring commission, spiffs or production bonuses earned the same week.
  • Recording book hours as hours worked for flat-rate techs, so the overtime hours never appear.
  • Averaging hours across two weeks. Overtime is calculated for each workweek separately, so a 50-hour week followed by a 30-hour week still has 10 overtime hours.
  • Calling a formula bonus discretionary to keep it out of the regular rate.
  • Deducting tools, uniforms or damaged parts in a way that pushes pay below the minimum wage or reduces overtime owed.
  • Treating a lead tech as salaried and exempt because of the title, without checking the duties and salary tests.

Each of these is easy to fix going forward and expensive to fix after a former employee files a claim covering several years. If you find a problem in an audit, ask your adviser how to correct past pay as well as future pay.

Payroll setup checklist

  1. Code every pay type

    Set up separate earning codes for hourly, flat-rate, commission, spiffs, bonuses and expense reimbursements so payroll knows what goes into the regular rate.

  2. Capture real hours

    Use clock-in and clock-out times from the field app, not book hours, as the hours for overtime.

  3. Check the calculation

    Run the worked examples above through your payroll system with test data and compare the results by hand.

  4. Handle delayed commissions

    Agree with your provider how monthly or quarterly commissions will be allocated back to workweeks and when the true-up is paid.

  5. Write the pay plan down

    A signed plan that explains rates, overtime and what counts as hours worked prevents most disputes.

  6. Audit twice a year

    Pick a few overtime weeks per tech and recalculate them by hand.

Choosing the plan itself is covered in commission, hourly or hybrid pay for plumbing techs; keeping labor in line with revenue is covered in labor cost percentage.

Frequently asked questions

Do flat-rate plumbers get overtime?

Yes, if they are non-exempt. Total earnings for the week are divided by all hours worked to get the regular rate, and an extra half of that rate is owed for each hour over 40.

Are commissions included in overtime calculations?

Yes. Federal rules treat commissions as payments for hours worked, so they go into the regular rate whatever the formula or payment schedule.

Is drive time between jobs paid for plumbers?

Driving between job sites during the workday is generally hours worked. Ordinary commuting from home to the first job is usually not, but take-home vehicle rules and required stops can change that.

References

  1. U.S. Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division (2019). Fact Sheet #56A: Overview of the Regular Rate of Pay Under the FLSA (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 29 CFR 778.111 โ€” Pieceworker (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 29 CFR 778.117 โ€” Commission payments, general (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  5. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics (2026). Average hourly earnings of all employees, plumbing, heating, and air-conditioning contractors, not seasonally adjusted (CEU2023822003) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo