Hiring training

What losing a plumber really costs

What it really costs when a plumbing tech quits: a worked example covering the vacancy, overtime, recruiting, ramp-up and hidden costs, plus a calculator.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Why owners underestimate the cost
  2. Where the money goes
  3. Worked example: one service tech leaves
  4. Run the numbers for your shop
  5. First-year and long-tenure departures cost differently
  6. Shrinking each bucket
  7. Track ramp-up on your next hire
  8. Presenting the number to your team
  9. What the number justifies
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References
Hiring training: What losing a plumber really costsArticle coverHIRING TRAININGWhat losing a plumberreally costsAva for PlumbersInsightsHiring training: What losing a plumber really costsArticle coverHIRING TRAININGWhat losing a plumberreally costsAva for Plumbers

Key takeaways

  • Plumbing, heating and AC contractors took in about $260,000 per employee in 2022, roughly $5,000 a week, and an empty truck loses much of that[1].
  • The biggest costs of turnover are lost gross profit during the vacancy and the new hire's ramp-up, not the job ad.
  • In our worked example, replacing one experienced service tech costs about $26,000, around 40% of a median plumber's annual wage[2].
  • Use your own revenue per tech, gross margin and time to fill; the method matters more than the example figures.
  • Knowing the number tells you how much a retention fix is worth before you spend on it.

Why owners underestimate the cost

When a tech quits, the visible costs are small: a job ad, a few interviews, a uniform order. The real costs hide in revenue that never happens, overtime paid to cover the gap and months of reduced output while the replacement learns your systems. Those costs do not appear on any single line of the profit and loss statement, so they are easy to ignore.

They are also becoming more frequent. The quits rate in construction rose to 2.4% in September 2026 (preliminary), from 1.5% a year earlier[3]. If you have not put a number on turnover, you cannot judge whether a retention change, such as a pay adjustment or an on-call stipend, pays for itself.

Where the money goes

Turnover costs fall into five buckets. Count all five, or the result will be too low to drive any decision.

  1. Vacancy: gross profit lost on calls you cannot run, delay or turn away while the position is open.
  2. Coverage: overtime premiums and burnout for the techs who pick up the extra work.
  3. Recruiting: ads, referral bonuses, recruiter fees and staff time for screening, interviews and skills tests.
  4. Ramp-up: reduced output during the new hire's first months while you pay full wages, plus the mentor's lost production.
  5. Separation and hidden costs: unreturned tools, truck downtime, callbacks on the departed tech's work and customers who follow a well-liked tech to a competitor.

The vacancy and ramp-up buckets are usually the largest because they are tied to revenue. Census figures show plumbing, heating and air-conditioning contractors generated about $260,000 in receipts per employee in 2022[1]. That average includes office staff; a productive service tech's ticket total is usually higher.

Receipts and payroll, plumbing, heating and AC contractors, 2022Payroll was about 26.9% of receipts
Receipts and payroll, plumbing, heating and AC contractors, 2022Comparison. Receipts: 306.3 billion dollars; Payroll: 82.2 billion dollars.306.3 billion dollarsReceiptsReceipts: 306.3 billion dollars82.2 billion dollarsPayrollPayroll: 82.2 billion dollarsReceipts and payroll, plumbing, heating and AC contractors, 2022Comparison. Receipts: 306.3 billion dollars; Payroll: 82.2 billion dollars.306.3 billion dollarsReceiptsReceipts: 306.3 billion dollars82.2 billion dollarsPayrollPayroll: 82.2 billion dollars

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2022[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Receipts306.3 billion dollars
Payroll82.2 billion dollars

Worked example: one service tech leaves

Example (fictional): a residential shop loses an experienced service tech who averaged $5,000 a week in revenue, in line with the industry's receipts per employee[1]. The shop's gross margin on service work is 50%. It takes eight weeks to hire a replacement and three months to bring them to full speed.

Example cost of replacing one experienced service tech
Cost bucketExample assumptionExample cost
Vacancy8 weeks; other techs cover 60% of the work, 40% is lost: $16,000 revenue at 50% margin$8,000
Coverage80 overtime hours; half-time premium on a $40 regular rate$1,600
RecruitingAds $1,000, referral bonus $1,000, 15 staff hours at $46.89 total compensation$2,703
Ramp-upOutput at 50%, 75% and 90% over months 1 to 3: about $18,400 revenue lost at 50% margin$9,200
Mentor timeMentor's reduced production during the first month$2,000
OnboardingBackground check, uniforms, tools, licensing paperwork$1,500
SeparationCallbacks on the departed tech's jobs, unreturned tools$1,000
TotalAll buckets aboveAbout $26,000

Example: the staff time line uses $46.89 an hour, the average total compensation private employers paid per hour worked in June 2026[4]; use your own office manager's and service manager's loaded rates instead. About $26,000 is roughly 40% of the $63,800 median annual wage for plumbers in May 2025[2], or about a third of the $73,700 average annual payroll per employee at plumbing, heating and AC contractors in 2023[5].

The example leaves out customers lost when a popular tech moves to a competitor and takes relationships with him. In some shops that is the largest cost of all. If you can identify which customers followed a departed tech, add their typical annual spend at your gross margin.

Run the numbers for your shop

  1. Find weekly revenue per tech

    Take the last 12 months of revenue for the departed tech, or the average for techs at the same level, and divide by 52.

  2. Estimate the vacancy loss

    Multiply weekly revenue by weeks to fill and by the share of work you could not cover, then by your gross margin. Look at how long your last three hires took.

  3. Add coverage costs

    Pull overtime hours for the covering techs during the vacancy and multiply by the half-time premium on their regular rate.

  4. Add recruiting

    Ads, fees, referral bonuses and staff hours at loaded hourly cost.

  5. Estimate ramp-up

    Assume a ramp curve, for example 50%, 75% and 90% for the first three months, and calculate lost gross profit against full output. Track actual ramp on your next hire and update the assumption.

  6. Add the rest

    Onboarding items, mentor time, callbacks, unreturned equipment and, if you can, lost customers.

Keep the calculation in a simple spreadsheet and update it each time someone leaves. After two or three departures you will have your own average, which is far more persuasive to a management team than any industry rule of thumb.

First-year and long-tenure departures cost differently

Not every departure costs the same. A helper who leaves in month four costs mostly recruiting and training, because they were not yet producing much revenue. A senior tech who leaves after six years costs much more: their revenue was higher, they trained others and they carried customer relationships. Calculate both, and you will usually find that losing one senior tech costs as much as several early departures.

That changes where you focus. High first-year turnover points to hiring and onboarding problems; fix them with a skills test and a structured 90-day plan. Losing senior techs points to pay, schedule, growth or leadership; start with stay interviews to find out which.

Shrinking each bucket

Preventing departures is the best fix, but you can also make each departure cheaper. Shops that replace techs quickly and bring them up to speed fast lose far less than shops that start from zero every time.

  • Vacancy: keep a short list of candidates all year, from past applicants, referrals and school partners, so a search starts with names rather than an ad.
  • Coverage: plan overflow before you need it, with an on-call rotation that spreads the load and an answering setup that only pages techs for real emergencies.
  • Recruiting: pay referral bonuses to your own techs after a new hire stays 90 days; referred hires usually arrive with realistic expectations.
  • Ramp-up: use a written 90-day onboarding plan with sign-offs, so new hires reach solo calls on a schedule rather than by chance.
  • Separation: use a checklist for returning tools, tablets, keys and fuel cards, and review the departing tech's open jobs before their last day.
  • Hidden costs: keep customer records in your system rather than in a tech's phone, so relationships stay with the company.

Track ramp-up on your next hire

The ramp-up assumption is the softest part of the calculation, and it is easy to measure properly. For the next new tech, record weekly revenue, billable hours, callbacks and the number of calls that needed help from another tech, for the first 16 weeks. Compare each week with the average for experienced techs at the same level. After two or three hires you will know your real ramp curve, how much a good mentor shortens it and which call types take longest to learn. That data also tells you whether changes to onboarding, such as more bench time or earlier solo calls on simple jobs, actually make new techs productive sooner.

Presenting the number to your team

Share the turnover cost with your managers, not just your accountant. When a service manager sees that losing one senior tech costs roughly what the whole team's on-call stipends cost for a year, decisions about schedules, recognition and day-to-day treatment change. Keep the calculation simple, show the assumptions and update it after every departure. Managers trust a number they helped build more than one handed to them.

What the number justifies

Once you know what a departure costs, you can judge retention spending like any other investment. Example: if replacing a senior tech costs about $26,000 and your shop loses two a year, a change that prevents even one departure is worth up to that amount. Compare that with the cost of the fixes your techs ask for.

  • Example: an on-call stipend for a 12-tech rotation, compared with one prevented departure.
  • Example: a pay adjustment for the five techs most at risk, compared with the cost of replacing two of them.
  • Example: replacing two unreliable vans, compared with the lost days and frustration they cause.
  • Example: a mentor bonus that cuts the ramp-up period for new hires by a month.

The math is not perfect, but it turns retention from a feeling into a decision. For the full set of levers, see our guide to keeping good plumbers, and review benefits options in benefits a small plumbing company can afford.

Frequently asked questions

How much does it cost to replace a plumbing technician?

It depends on revenue per tech, time to fill and ramp-up. In our worked example, replacing an experienced service tech costs about $26,000, mostly in lost gross profit during the vacancy and the new hire's first months. Use your own numbers with the steps in this article.

What is included in employee turnover cost?

Lost gross profit during the vacancy, overtime for covering staff, recruiting, onboarding, the new hire's ramp-up and mentor time, plus separation costs such as callbacks and unreturned tools.

Is it cheaper to keep a tech or hire a new one?

Usually cheaper to keep a good one. Compare the full replacement cost with the cost of what would keep them, such as a pay adjustment, schedule change or better equipment.

References

  1. U.S. Census Bureau (2022). Statistics of U.S. Businesses 2022: U.S. and states, 6-digit NAICS (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey, Table 4: Quits levels and rates by industry and region, seasonally adjusted (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employer Costs for Employee Compensation - June 2026 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  5. U.S. Census Bureau (2023). County Business Patterns 2023, U.S. national file (cbp23us) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo