Key takeaways
- Payroll was about 27% of receipts at plumbing, heating and AC contractors in 2022, so the pay model is the biggest lever on margin you control[1].
- Hourly pay is simple and safe for training and installs, but it rewards time on the clock rather than output.
- Commission and flat-rate pay reward production, and they also reward overselling unless callbacks and quality are part of the formula.
- A hybrid, hourly base plus commission above a threshold or the greater of the two, suits most service departments.
- Commissioned and flat-rate techs are still owed overtime on a regular rate that includes the commission[2][3].
Why the pay model matters so much
Technician pay is the largest controllable cost in most plumbing companies. Census data show payroll equalled about 26.9% of receipts at plumbing, heating and air-conditioning contractors in 2022, with about $260,000 in receipts per employee[1]. Average hourly earnings in the industry reached $42.38 in September 2026 (preliminary), up about 4.4% from a year earlier[4]. A pay model that drifts a few points out of line with production shows up directly in profit.
Pay also drives behavior more than any memo. Techs paid by the hour, by the job or by a share of the ticket will make different choices on the same call. The right model is the one that rewards the behavior your customers and your reviews need.
- Payroll 26.9%
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2022[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Payroll | 26.9% |
The four main models
Most shops use one of four structures, or a mix by department.
- Hourly: a fixed rate for every hour worked, often with a raise ladder tied to skills. Common for apprentices, new construction and install crews.
- Straight commission: a percentage of the labor or the whole ticket, sometimes with different rates for repairs, replacements and maintenance plans. Common in residential service.
- Flat-rate or piece-rate: pay per task based on book hours or a set amount per job type, regardless of how long it takes. Common where a mature flat-rate price book exists.
- Hybrid: an hourly base plus commission on sales above a threshold, or pay at whichever is higher, hourly or commission, each week. Increasingly common for service departments.
| Factor | Hourly | Straight commission | Flat-rate per task | Hybrid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fairness to slow weeks | High | Low | Low | High |
| Reward for productivity | Low | High | High | Medium to high |
| Cost predictability for the owner | Low in slow weeks | High (moves with revenue) | High | Medium |
| Risk of overselling | Low | High | Medium | Medium |
| Admin and payroll complexity | Low | Medium | High | High |
| Best fit | Training, installs, new construction | Experienced service techs | Shops with a mature price book | Most service departments |
What each model does to behavior
Hourly pay rewards being on the clock. It is fair when calls are slow, it lets you assign the unpleasant work without arguments and it suits training. The downside is that an hourly tech has no direct reason to finish fast or to mention a water heater that is near the end of its life. Shops on hourly pay usually add a separate spiff for sold leads or maintenance plans.
Straight commission rewards ticket size. Strong techs earn well and often prefer it. But it hurts in slow weeks, tempts techs to cherry-pick calls and can push recommendations past what the customer needs. Without a callback rule, the company pays commission on work it later redoes for free.
Flat-rate per task rewards speed and consistency. It works when book hours are realistic and the price book is maintained. It causes friction when book times are wrong, when techs skip steps to beat the clock or when a job turns out to be twice as hard as the book says.
Hybrids try to keep the security of hourly pay and the motivation of commission. The common forms are a base rate plus a smaller commission on sales above a weekly threshold, or a weekly comparison where the tech is paid whichever is higher. They take more payroll work, but they reduce both slow-week turnover and the temptation to oversell.
Worked example: one tech, four pay plans
Example (fictional): a service tech works 40 hours in a week and completes jobs totaling $6,000 in revenue, of which $4,000 is labor. The shop compares four plans that all target similar pay for an average week.
- Example hourly: $32 an hour for 40 hours pays $1,280 regardless of revenue.
- Example straight commission: 22% of the $6,000 ticket total pays $1,320; in a slow $3,500 week the same tech earns $770.
- Example flat-rate: book hours on the completed jobs total 46 at $28 per book hour, paying $1,288; a tech who beats the book by more earns more, one who struggles earns less.
- Example hybrid: $24 an hour base ($960) plus 15% of revenue above a $4,000 weekly threshold ($300) pays $1,260; in the slow week the tech still earns the $960 base.
Example takeaway: in a strong week the plans pay similar amounts. The difference shows up in slow weeks and in what the tech is encouraged to do on each call. Model your own last six months of tickets under each plan before choosing; the results are often surprising.
Overtime still applies
Commission and piece-rate pay do not remove overtime. The Labor Department's regular rate guidance says all compensation for hours worked, services or performance goes into the regular rate, whether it is earned by the hour, the piece or on commission[2]. Federal rules state that commissions are payments for hours worked and must be included in the regular rate, whether they are the only pay or are added to a salary or hourly wage[3]. BLS notes that most plumbers work full time and that nights and weekends are common[5], so overtime weeks are normal, not rare.
Before you launch any commission or flat-rate plan, have your payroll provider or employment adviser confirm how overtime will be calculated each week. The detailed math is in our guide to overtime for commissioned and piece-rate techs.
Choosing the right model for your shop
Use these questions to narrow the choice. Answer them for each department, not the company as a whole; many shops pay installers hourly and service techs on a hybrid.
- Is your price book current and trusted by the techs? If not, flat-rate pay will cause arguments.
- Do you track callbacks per tech? If not, do not start commission until you do.
- How seasonal is your call volume? Strong seasonality favors a base rate or a weekly guarantee.
- How experienced is the team? New techs need hourly security while they learn.
- Can your payroll system handle weekly comparisons and overtime on commission? If not, keep it simple.
Whatever you choose, add three protections: a callback rule (commission is reversed or not paid on work redone within a set period), a quality or customer feedback gate, and a clear rule on who is paid for leads that someone else closes.
Callback and chargeback rules techs accept
Any production-based plan needs a rule for work that has to be redone. Without one, the company pays twice for the same job. With a harsh one, techs feel punished for problems they did not cause, such as a failed part or a customer who refused the recommended repair. Rules that tend to hold up share four features.
- A defined window, such as 30 days, after which a return visit is a new job rather than a callback.
- A clear test of cause: workmanship or a missed diagnosis counts; a defective part, a declined recommendation or a new, unrelated problem does not.
- Review by someone other than the tech's direct competitor, usually the service manager, with the tech able to explain their side.
- The original tech gets the chance to fix their own callback, on the clock at their base rate, which keeps the learning with the person who needs it.
Write the rule into the signed pay plan, apply it the same way to every tech and report callback rates by tech every month. When techs see the numbers and the reasons, disputes drop quickly.
Switching models without losing your team
Model six months of real tickets
Show each tech what they would have earned under the new plan, week by week, including slow weeks.
Offer a guarantee period
For the first two or three months, pay the higher of the old and new plan so nobody loses money while learning it.
Put it in writing
A signed pay plan that explains rates, thresholds, callbacks and overtime prevents most disputes.
Review after one quarter
Compare revenue per tech, callbacks, customer complaints and turnover with the period before the change, and adjust.
Pay design affects retention as much as cost. For the bigger picture, see our guide to keeping good plumbers and CSR pay and incentives. O*NET's national data show plumber pay ranging from about $21.22 to $52.13 an hour between the 10th and 90th percentiles[6], so test any plan against what your best and newest techs could earn elsewhere.
Frequently asked questions
Is commission or hourly pay better for plumbers?
Hourly is better for training, installs and new construction. Commission rewards experienced service techs but needs callback rules and quality checks. Many shops use a hybrid: an hourly base plus commission above a threshold, or the higher of the two.
Do commissioned plumbers get overtime?
Yes, unless a specific exemption applies. Commissions are included in the regular rate, and overtime is due at one and one-half times that rate for hours over 40 in a workweek.
What percentage commission do plumbing techs get?
It varies widely by market, ticket type and whether commission is on labor or the whole ticket. Model your own tickets so the plan pays a competitive weekly amount and keeps payroll in line with revenue.
References
U.S. Census Bureau (2022). Statistics of U.S. Businesses 2022: U.S. and states, 6-digit NAICS (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division (2019). Fact Sheet #56A: Overview of the Regular Rate of Pay Under the FLSA (opens in a new tab) โ
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 29 CFR 778.117 โ Commission payments, general (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics (2026). Average hourly earnings of all employees, plumbing, heating, and air-conditioning contractors, not seasonally adjusted (CEU2023822003) (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) โ
O*NET OnLine (U.S. Department of Labor), BLS 2025 wage data (2025). National Wages 47-2152.00 - Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) โ