Metrics finance

Checking whether your plumbing prices cover your costs

A sample-job test for plumbing prices: pull recent invoices, rebuild true job cost with burdened labor and current materials, then fix losing jobs.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Why a sample test beats a gut check
  2. Pick the sample
  3. Rebuild the true job cost
  4. Example: six jobs from the sample
  5. Decide what to change
  6. Rolling out the new prices
  7. Make it a routine
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. References
Metrics finance: Checking whether your plumbing prices cover your costsArticle coverMETRICS FINANCEChecking whether yourplumbing prices coveryour costsAva for PlumbersInsightsMetrics finance: Checking whether your plumbing prices cover your costsArticle coverMETRICS FINANCEChecking whether yourplumbing prices coveryour costsAva for Plumbers

Key takeaways

  • Test prices on a sample of real invoices, not on the price book's assumptions.
  • Rebuild each job's cost with burdened labor, drive time and today's replacement cost for materials.
  • Labor costs have climbed: average hourly earnings at plumbing, heating and AC contractors rose from $39.30 to $42.65 between January 2025 and August 2026[1].
  • Copper and brass prices move fast; the producer price index for mill shapes rose about 3% between May and September 2026[2].
  • Fix the pattern, not the single job: update the task, the minimum charge or the markup rule that caused the loss.

Why a sample test beats a gut check

Most price books are built once and then nudged. A task price set two years ago assumed a labor rate, a drive time, a material cost and a callback rate that may no longer be true. The company P&L will tell you profit fell, but not which prices caused it. Testing a sample of actual jobs does.

Two costs have moved the most. Average hourly earnings for all employees at plumbing, heating and air-conditioning contractors rose from $39.30 in January 2025 to $42.65 in August 2026[1]. And benefits make up about 30% of private-industry employer compensation costs[3], so every wage increase carries extra payroll tax, insurance and paid leave with it.

$42.65

Average hourly earnings, plumbing, heating and AC contractors, August 2026[1]

Materials add a second moving target. If your price book was built when copper fittings cost less, the same flat-rate task now earns less on every ticket, and nobody on the truck will notice because the customer still pays the listed price.

A sample test is also faster than rebuilding the whole price book. You are not trying to recalculate every task; you are checking whether the assumptions behind the book still hold on real work. If most sample jobs hit their targets, the book is sound and only a handful of tasks need attention. If most miss, the base labor rate or the overhead figure is wrong, and every task built on it needs a reprice.

Pick the sample

Pull 25 to 40 invoices from the last 60 days. That is enough to see patterns and small enough to finish in an afternoon. Choose them deliberately rather than at random, so every major type of work is represented.

A balanced sample covers common work, high-material work and the jobs that went wrong.
IncludeWhyHow many
Your five most common tasksSmall losses here add up fastest3 to 4 of each
Water heater replacementsHigh material share, sensitive to supplier prices4 to 6
Drain and sewer callsEquipment time is often not priced4 to 6
Jobs that ran longShow where task times are wrong3 to 5
After-hours and weekend callsOvertime and premium pay change the math3 to 5
Callbacks and warranty visitsThe hidden cost of the original jobAll from the period

For each invoice, collect the price charged, the tech or crew, clock-in and clock-out times on the job, drive time, parts used with quantities, and any return visit. Field service software usually has all of this; if it does not, the gap itself is a finding.

Rebuild the true job cost

  1. Labor hours

    Count time on site plus drive time from the previous job and any supply-house run. Unpaid drive time is still a cost if techs are paid for the whole day.

  2. Burdened labor rate

    Take each tech's wage and add payroll taxes, workers' compensation, health cover, retirement and paid time off. Private-industry employers paid an average $46.89 per hour worked in total compensation in June 2026[4], well above the typical wage on a pay stub.

  3. Materials at replacement cost

    Price the parts used at what it costs to restock them this week, not what you paid months ago. The copper and brass mill shapes index went from 809.8 in May 2026 to 835.3 in September 2026[2].

  4. Truck and equipment cost per hour

    Divide annual vehicle and equipment costs, including payments, fuel, insurance and maintenance, by billable hours. Add it per job hour.

  5. Overhead per hour

    Divide office, rent, software, marketing and insurance by total billable hours across the company. This is the cost every hour must cover before profit.

  6. Callback cost

    If the job needed a return visit, add the full cost of that visit to the original job.

Producer price index, copper and brass mill shapes, 2026Index 1982 = 100, not seasonally adjusted
Producer price index, copper and brass mill shapes, 2026Line chart. May: 809.78; Jun: 809.09; Jul: 802.06; Aug: 823.44; Sep: 835.34.790800810820830840MayJunJulAugSepMay: 809.78Jun: 809.09Jul: 802.06Aug: 823.44Sep: 835.34835.34809.78Producer price index, copper and brass mill shapes, 2026Line chart. May: 809.78; Jun: 809.09; Jul: 802.06; Aug: 823.44; Sep: 835.34.790800810820830840MayJunJulAugSepMay: 809.78Jun: 809.09Jul: 802.06Aug: 823.44Sep: 835.34835.34809.78

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics via Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis (FRED), 2026[2]

Show the data
PeriodValue
May809.78
Jun809.09
Jul802.06
Aug823.44
Sep835.34

The chart shows why replacement cost matters. The index dipped in July 2026 and then climbed in August and September[2], so a part restocked in the autumn cost more than the same part bought in early summer. For high-material jobs such as water heaters, repipes and fixture packages, a few points of movement in supplier prices can wipe out the margin on a flat price that was set from older invoices.

Use the same overhead-per-hour figure for every job in the sample. The aim is to compare jobs fairly with each other, not to debate the allocation.

Example: six jobs from the sample

Example (fictional): a 7-truck shop used a burdened labor rate of $58 an hour, truck cost of $14 an hour and overhead of $41 an hour, for a total of $113 per job hour before materials. These figures are invented to show the method.

Example only: fictional jobs priced against a fictional cost of $113 per job hour.
Example jobPriceHours incl. driveLabor, truck, overheadMaterialsProfitMargin
Faucet cartridge replacement$3851.4$158$62$16543%
Toilet rebuild$3101.5$170$48$9230%
Main line clear with camera$4952.6$294$15$18638%
50-gallon gas water heater$2,3505.5$622$1,310$41818%
Slab leak locate$6504.2$475$10$16525%
Shut-off valve swap, 2 hours over$4203.8$429$55-$64-15%

Three patterns stand out in this Example. The water heater earns a thin margin because materials are more than half the price and the markup was set when units cost less. The slab leak locate is priced as a fixed fee but routinely runs over four hours. The valve swap lost money because the task assumed a modern shut-off and the house had seized gate valves, which happens often enough to deserve its own task.

Decide what to change

Group the sample by cause, then fix the rule that produced the result. A single bad job is noise; the same cause on four jobs is a price-book problem.

Fix the rule that produced the loss, not just the one invoice.
What you seeLikely causeWhat to change
Common task below target marginTask time or labor rate out of dateRetime the task and reprice with the current burdened rate
High-material jobs below targetMarkup tied to old supplier pricesPrice materials at replacement cost and review markup tiers
Short jobs losing moneyDrive time and setup not coveredRaise the minimum charge or add a dispatch fee
Same job type runs long oftenHidden conditions not pricedAdd a separate task or a condition-based add-on
After-hours jobs barely profitablePremium pay not passed onSet a clear after-hours rate and explain it when booking
Callbacks concentrated on one taskWorkmanship or part qualityTraining, a better part, or both, before any price change

Set target margins by department rather than one company figure. Service tasks usually carry a higher margin than installs because the material share is lower. Our guide to department P&Ls shows how to see each line's results month to month.

Resist the urge to raise everything by the same percentage. Across-the-board increases overcharge tasks that were already healthy and still leave the worst ones underwater. They also make it harder for techs to explain prices, because the change has no link to the work. A targeted update, with the reason written next to each changed task, holds up better with both customers and the team.

Rolling out the new prices

  1. Update the price book in one release, with a date, so techs and the office see the same numbers.
  2. Brief the team on why: show the cost changes, not just the new prices. Techs sell more confidently when they know the job still has to pay for the truck.
  3. Give the office a short script for the first weeks, such as: โ€œOur prices changed this month because labor and material costs went up; here is what this repair includes.โ€
  4. Honor written quotes already given, and set an expiry date on new quotes so you are not locked in when material prices jump.
  5. Watch close rates for a month. A small drop is normal; a sharp one on a single task means the new price or the presentation needs work.

Payroll was about 27% of receipts across plumbing, heating and AC contractors in 2022[5]. If your own labor share has risen well above where it was when prices were last set, that is another signal the price book has fallen behind. Our guide to labor cost as a percentage of revenue explains how to calculate it consistently.

Make it a routine

Run the sample test twice a year and after any of these triggers: a wage increase for the team, a supplier price notice, a new benefit, a change in service area that adds drive time, or a month where profit fell and revenue did not. Keep each test's worksheet so you can compare the same tasks over time.

The owner's time belongs in the test too. If you still run calls, cost your hours at a market wage so prices hold when someone else takes those jobs; see how plumbing business owners pay themselves for setting that rate.

Assign one person to own the test. In a small shop that is usually the owner or office manager; in a larger one, a service manager working with the bookkeeper. Give them a date on the calendar, the invoice export and an hour with the lead tech to sanity-check task times. A test that depends on someone finding spare time rarely happens twice.

Frequently asked questions

How many jobs do I need to test my prices?

Twenty-five to forty recent invoices across your main job types is usually enough to see patterns. Include common tasks, high-material jobs, after-hours calls, jobs that ran long and any callbacks.

Should I use what I paid for parts or what they cost now?

What they cost to replace now. Pricing from old purchase costs makes margins look better than they are and leaves you short when you restock.

What is a burdened labor rate?

The wage plus everything the employer pays because of it: payroll taxes, workers' compensation, health cover, retirement contributions and paid time off. It is the real hourly cost of a tech.

How often should a plumbing company review prices?

At least twice a year, and whenever wages, supplier prices or benefits change. Keep the worksheets so you can compare the same tasks over time.

References

  1. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics (2026). Average hourly earnings of all employees, plumbing, heating, and air-conditioning contractors, not seasonally adjusted (CEU2023822003) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics via Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis (FRED) (2026). Producer Price Index by Commodity: Metals and Metal Products: Copper and Brass Mill Shapes (WPU102502) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employer Costs for Employee Compensation - June 2026 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employer Costs for Employee Compensation - June 2026 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  5. U.S. Census Bureau (2022). Statistics of U.S. Businesses 2022: U.S. and states, 6-digit NAICS (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo