Key takeaways
- A single company P&L averages good and bad work together; a department P&L shows which line actually pays for the trucks.
- Tag every invoice, labor hour and material purchase to one department at the source, not at month end.
- Burden labor before you assign it: benefits are about 30% of private-industry compensation cost[1].
- Allocate overhead with a stated rule you keep for at least a year, and judge departments on contribution first.
- Read the report monthly with a short list of decisions, not as a scorecard to argue about.
Why one P&L hides the problem
Most plumbing companies start with one profit and loss statement because the accountant sets it up that way. That works with two trucks doing similar work. Once you run service calls, water heater installs, drain cleaning and a few commercial accounts, the single P&L blends very different businesses. A drain department with cheap equipment payments and short jobs can carry an install crew that loses money on every bid, and the total still looks fine.
Labor is the biggest line where this hides. Across plumbing, heating and air-conditioning contractors, payroll was about 27% of receipts in the latest Census data[2], but that figure is an industry average across very different mixes of work. Inside your company, the share will differ sharply between a service tech who bills by the task and a two-person crew roughing in a building for weeks.
27%
Payroll as a share of receipts at plumbing, heating and AC contractors, 2022[2]
A department P&L answers three questions the company total cannot: which work earns the most per labor hour, which work ties up cash, and where a price change or a hire will move profit the most. It is also what a lender or buyer will ask for later, so building it now is cheaper than rebuilding history.
Choose departments that match how you sell and staff
A department should be a line of work with its own techs or crews, its own pricing method and its own equipment. If two kinds of work share all three, keep them together. Four or five departments is plenty for most shops under 20 trucks; more than that and the tagging gets sloppy.
| Department | What belongs in it | How it is priced | Main direct costs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Residential service | Repair calls, fixtures, leaks, diagnostics | Task or flat-rate menu | Tech wages, parts, truck stock |
| Install and replacement | Water heaters, repipes, fixture packages | Quoted per job | Crew wages, equipment, permits, disposal |
| Drain and sewer | Snaking, hydro jetting, camera, excavation | Task pricing plus quotes for digs | Jetter and camera payments, tech wages |
| Commercial | Restaurants, property managers, small facilities | Contract rates or time and material | Wages, after-hours premiums, longer terms |
| New construction (if any) | Builder rough-in and trim | Bid per house or per fixture | Crew wages, materials, retainage |
Decide where edge cases go before they happen. A water heater found on a service call usually belongs to install if a different crew does the work, and to service if the same tech sells and installs it. Write the rule down in one sentence per department and give it to whoever closes invoices.
Set up the books in five steps
Turn on class or department tracking
Most accounting software supports classes, locations or departments. Use one field consistently. Make it required on invoices, bills and payroll entries so nothing lands untagged.
Map job types in your field software
Every job type in your scheduling or field service system should map to exactly one department. When a job type maps to two, split the job type.
Capture labor hours by job, not by day
Department labor cost comes from timesheets tied to jobs. If techs clock in and out only for the day, you will be guessing. Include drive time and shop time in a separate unbillable code per department.
Burden the labor rate
Add payroll taxes, workers' compensation, health cover and paid time off to the wage before assigning it. Nationally, benefits averaged about 30% of private-industry compensation cost in mid-2026[1], so wages alone understate labor cost badly.
Tag material and equipment at purchase
Supply-house accounts can often carry a job number or PO. Equipment loans and leases go to the department that uses the machine; shared vans go to overhead or are split by hours.
- Wages and salaries 70%
- Benefits 30%
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2026[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Wages and salaries | 70% |
| Benefits | 30% |
The split matters most for departments with different pay structures. A commercial crew on premium after-hours rates and an apprentice-heavy install crew can carry very different burden percentages, so calculate a burdened rate per department rather than one company figure. Total private-industry compensation averaged $46.89 per hour worked in June 2026[3], a reminder of how far the true hourly cost sits above the wage on a pay stub.
Allocating overhead without starting a fight
Overhead is rent, the office team, software, insurance, marketing that is not department-specific, and the owner's management time. How you spread it changes which department looks profitable, so pick a method, state it at the top of the report, and keep it for at least a year.
| Method | How it works | Good for | Watch out |
|---|---|---|---|
| Share of revenue | Each department carries overhead in proportion to its sales | Simple, quick to explain | Punishes high-ticket, low-effort work like water heaters |
| Share of labor hours | Overhead follows billable plus unbillable hours | Shops where office effort follows tech time | Needs clean timesheets |
| Share of jobs or calls | Overhead follows the count of jobs booked and dispatched | Call-heavy service and drain lines | Undercharges long commercial jobs |
| Activity-based | Each cost pool has its own driver, such as calls for the office and trucks for fleet | Shops over about 15 trucks | Takes time to maintain |
Labor hours are a sound default for most plumbing shops because dispatch, purchasing and billing effort tends to follow the hours techs work. Hourly earnings at plumbing, heating and AC contractors rose about 4.4% in the year to September 2026[4], so refresh your burdened rates at least every year or the allocation drifts.
Judge each department on contribution margin first: revenue minus its own labor, materials, equipment and direct marketing. Allocated overhead tells you whether the whole company covers its fixed costs; it should not decide on its own whether to close a department.
Example: a four-department month
Example (fictional): a 9-truck shop splits a month into four departments. Numbers are rounded and invented to show the mechanics, not benchmarks.
| Example line | Service | Install | Drain | Commercial |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | $92,000 | $71,000 | $38,000 | $29,000 |
| Burdened labor | $27,600 | $24,900 | $9,900 | $11,600 |
| Materials and equipment | $15,600 | $29,800 | $6,100 | $6,400 |
| Contribution margin | $48,800 | $16,300 | $22,000 | $11,000 |
| Contribution margin % | 53% | 23% | 58% | 38% |
| Labor hours | 620 | 510 | 230 | 260 |
| Overhead at $30 per labor hour | $18,600 | $15,300 | $6,900 | $7,800 |
| Department profit | $30,200 | $1,000 | $15,100 | $3,200 |
In this Example the install department brings in the second-largest revenue but almost no profit after overhead. The fix is not obvious from the total P&L, which shows a healthy month. The department view points to three checks: whether install quotes include the full burdened crew time, whether material markup covers supply-house price changes, and whether long installs are blocking techs who could run higher-margin service calls.
The Example drain department shows a different lesson. Its margin is high, but its equipment payments sit inside the materials and equipment line, so a new jetter would cut that margin for a year. Department P&Ls make that trade-off visible before you sign the loan.
A monthly review that leads to decisions
Hold a 30-minute review in the second week of each month, after invoices and payroll have closed. Keep it to the same short agenda so the numbers become familiar.
- Check tagging quality first: how much revenue and labor landed untagged or in overhead by mistake. Fix that before reading anything else.
- Compare each department's contribution margin with its own last three months, not with the other departments.
- Look at revenue per labor hour by department; it shows where an extra tech hour earns the most.
- Pick one action per weak department: a price update, a crew change, a marketing shift or a scope rule.
- Note anything that will distort next month, such as a big commercial job or a slow season.
Revenue per employee across the industry was about $260,000 in 2022[5], but that blends HVAC, plumbing and very different business models. Use your own department trend as the main benchmark, and treat national figures as a rough sense check. Our guide to using benchmarks without fooling yourself covers how to compare fairly.
When a department keeps losing money
Three months of negative contribution margin is a signal, not an automatic shutdown. Work through these questions in order:
- Is it a tagging problem? Labor from another department charged here can sink a small line.
- Is it pricing? Run the sample-job test in our guide to checking whether your prices cover your costs.
- Is it capacity? A department that waits on parts, permits or customers burns paid hours.
- Does it feed another department? Drain calls that lead to sewer replacements may be worth keeping at a thin margin, but only if you track the referrals.
- Would closing it free a tech for better work? If not, fix it rather than drop it.
Once departments are stable, link the report to owner decisions: hiring, truck purchases and pay. The same structure makes it easier to set a fair owner salary because you can see which work the owner's time actually supports.
Frequently asked questions
How many departments should a small plumbing company track?
Usually three to five. Each should have its own techs or crews, pricing method and equipment. If two lines share all three, merge them; too many departments makes tagging unreliable.
Should overhead be allocated by revenue or by labor hours?
Labor hours suit most plumbing shops because office, dispatch and purchasing effort tends to follow tech time. Revenue is simpler but makes high-ticket, low-effort work look worse than it is. Pick one method and keep it for at least a year.
Where does a water heater sold on a service call go?
Decide in advance. A common rule is: if a separate install crew does the work, it goes to install; if the same service tech sells and installs it, it stays in service. Write the rule down so invoices are tagged the same way every time.
Do I need special software for department P&Ls?
No. Class or department tracking in mainstream accounting software is enough, as long as job types in your field software map to one department each and timesheets are tied to jobs.
References
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employer Costs for Employee Compensation - June 2026 (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Census Bureau (2022). Statistics of U.S. Businesses 2022: U.S. and states, 6-digit NAICS (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employer Costs for Employee Compensation - June 2026 (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics (2026). Average hourly earnings of all employees, plumbing, heating, and air-conditioning contractors, not seasonally adjusted (CEU2023822003) (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Census Bureau (2022). Statistics of U.S. Businesses 2022: U.S. and states, 6-digit NAICS (opens in a new tab) โ