Key takeaways
- Every option must fix the problem properly; the differences are longevity, convenience, efficiency and warranty, never safety.
- Build options from the price book so every tech presents the same choices at the same prices.
- Use real, checkable benefits: replacing old toilets with WaterSense models can save a family more than $170 a year in water costs[1].
- Present all three with equal care, explain the differences in plain words and let the customer choose.
- Honest options protect reviews, which 82% of US adults read at least sometimes before a first purchase[2].
What good-better-best means in plumbing
Good-better-best is a way of presenting a repair as a short menu instead of a single take-it-or-leave-it price. The customer sees three ways to solve the same problem, each priced and explained, and chooses the one that fits their budget and plans. Done well, it gives customers control and gives the shop a fair chance at more complete work. Done badly, it becomes a pressure tactic with a decoy option nobody should pick.
The difference lies in how the options are built. The rules below keep them honest, and the examples show what that looks like on common jobs.
Rules for honest options
- Every option solves the customer’s problem and meets code. The good option is not a patch that will fail next month.
- Differences are real and explainable: expected life, convenience, efficiency, warranty length, or preventing a related problem.
- Safety is never an upgrade. If an expansion tank or a new shutoff is needed for the job to be safe or compliant, it is in every option.
- Prices come from the price book, so two techs show the same customer the same choices.
- The tech can recommend an option and say why, but the customer decides.
- No invented savings or benefits. Anything you claim about water or energy use should be something you can show.
If an option fails any rule, rebuild it. A menu with a weak first option and an inflated third one teaches customers to distrust all three.
Building the three options
Start with the good option
Define the proper repair: the fix a careful plumber would do if the customer said “just fix it.” This is the base of the menu.
Build better around longevity
Add the items that make the repair last or prevent the next call: replacing the related worn parts, a new shutoff valve, a longer warranty.
Build best around upgrade or replacement
Offer the version that solves the problem most completely: a replacement fixture, a higher-efficiency model, a full system fix rather than a component.
Write each in one line
Each option gets a short plain-language description and two or three bullet benefits the customer can understand.
Check the price steps
The jumps between options should make sense for what is added. A best option many times the price of better needs a very clear reason.
Load them in the price book
Save the menu as a template for the job type so it appears ready to present on the tablet.
Examples by job type
| Job | Good | Better | Best |
|---|---|---|---|
| Running toilet | Replace flapper and fill valve | Rebuild tank internals, new supply line and quarter-turn shutoff | Replace with a WaterSense labeled toilet |
| Dripping kitchen faucet | Replace cartridge | Replace cartridge, supply lines and stop valves | New faucet with supply lines and stop valves |
| Slow main drain | Clear the line | Clear the line and camera inspect | Clear, camera inspect and hydro-jet with a maintenance plan |
| Failed tank water heater | Like-for-like tank replacement to code | Upgraded tank with longer warranty and expansion tank service | High-efficiency or tankless option with extended warranty |
| Low water pressure | Clean aerators and test pressure | Replace failing PRV | Replace PRV and the worn shutoff valves on the main |
Where a legal or safety requirement applies, such as an expansion tank on a closed system or a code-required valve, include it in every column rather than reserving it for the upper options.
Use real, checkable benefits
Efficiency is one of the most useful differences between options, and one of the easiest to exaggerate. Stick to published figures and explain that results vary by household. EPA WaterSense says replacing old, inefficient toilets with WaterSense models can save a family nearly 13,000 gallons and more than $170 a year in water costs[1], and that a family can save more than $380 a year by retrofitting with WaterSense labeled fixtures[3].
Be careful with tax incentives. The federal energy efficient home improvement credit, which covered certain water heaters and heat pumps, applied to improvements made through December 31, 2025[4]. Do not present it as available on current jobs unless you have checked that a replacement program exists, and never give tax advice; suggest the customer confirm with their tax preparer.
Presenting without pressure
How the menu is presented matters as much as how it is built. A simple sequence works for most repairs.
- Explain the problem first, with a photo: what failed, why, and what happens if it is left.
- Show all three options at once on the tablet or printed sheet, not one at a time.
- Describe each in the same calm tone. Start with the good option so the customer knows a proper fix is available at the lowest price.
- If you recommend one, say which and why in a sentence, based on what the customer told you about their plans.
- Stop talking and let them read. Answer questions; do not fill the silence with more selling.
- Accept the choice without comment, including the good option.
Example script (fictional): “Your toilet is running because the flapper and fill valve are worn. Here are three ways to fix it. The first replaces those two parts and stops the running today. The second rebuilds everything in the tank and replaces the old shutoff, so you are unlikely to see me for this toilet again for years. The third replaces the toilet with a WaterSense model that uses less water per flush. If you are planning to stay in the house a long time, I’d lean toward the second or third, but all three fix the problem. Take a minute and let me know.”
For a broader look at presenting on a tablet and keeping the conversation honest, see presenting options on a tablet and plumbing sales ethics.
Why honesty pays
Customers check. In Pew Research Center’s survey, 82% of US adults said they at least sometimes read online ratings or reviews before buying something for the first time, 40% nearly always rely on them and 46% said reviews help a lot in feeling confident about a purchase[2]. A menu that felt like a trick shows up in those reviews; a menu that felt fair does too.
Only around one in ten Americans nearly always post reviews of services they use[2], which means each review carries weight. The goal of good-better-best is a customer who felt informed and in control, whichever option they chose.
Mistakes to avoid
- Decoy options: a good option designed to look bad so the better one seems reasonable.
- Too many add-ons: a menu with nine checkboxes overwhelms customers. Three clear options beat a long list.
- Commission structures that reward only the best option, which push techs toward pressure. Reward accurate diagnosis and customer satisfaction too.
- Options made up on the spot, so prices differ between techs.
- Leaving out the reason for each upgrade. If the tech cannot explain it in a sentence, it should not be on the menu.
Training techs to present options
Techs who are comfortable fixing pipes are not always comfortable talking about price. Short, regular practice closes that gap faster than a single sales course.
Learn the menus
Each tech should be able to explain every option for the ten most common job types without reading the tablet.
Role-play the objections
Practice the three most common responses: that is too expensive, I need to think about it, and the other company quoted less.
Ride along
Newer techs watch an experienced tech present options on real calls, then present themselves with the senior tech present.
Review real outcomes
Once a month, look at which options customers chose and any callbacks, and discuss what worked.
Keep the emphasis on clarity rather than closing. A tech who explains options well will see a natural mix of choices and very few complaints.
Track the results
Watch three numbers for each job type: the share of customers choosing each option, callbacks by option, and review sentiment. A healthy menu shows a real mix of choices and few callbacks on any of them. If nearly everyone picks the good option, the better and best options may not be explained well or may be priced out of reach. If callbacks cluster on the good option, it may not be a proper fix and needs rebuilding.
Revisit menus when material costs change, because option price steps can drift. The quote validity guide covers how long the prices on a menu should hold, and diagnostic fee vs free estimates covers what to charge for the visit where the menu is presented.
Frequently asked questions
Is good-better-best pricing a sales trick?
Not when every option genuinely fixes the problem and the differences are real and explained. It becomes a trick when the first option is designed to fail or the top option is inflated.
Should plumbers present the most expensive option first?
There are different schools of thought. Starting with the good option reassures customers that a proper fix is available at the lowest price, and showing all three together lets them compare without feeling led.
How many options should a plumbing repair menu have?
Three is usually enough. More choices tend to slow decisions and confuse customers, especially when the differences are small.
References
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, WaterSense (2026). Residential Toilets (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2016). Online Reviews (Online Shopping and E-Commerce) (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, WaterSense (2026). WaterSense Statistics and Facts (opens in a new tab) ↑
Internal Revenue Service (2025). Energy Efficient Home Improvement Credit (opens in a new tab) ↑