Key takeaways
- A free estimate visit typically involves a booking call, a drive, time on site, writing the quote and follow-ups; add them up before deciding it is free.
- In small shops the estimator is often the owner: about 58% of plumbing, heating and AC contractor establishments had fewer than five employees in 2023[1].
- Divide estimating time by your close rate to see the real time cost behind each sold job.
- Ask qualifying questions before booking: decision-maker, timeline, scope, budget expectations and photos.
- Use alternatives where they fit: photo or video quotes, phone ranges and estimate windows grouped by area.
Free to the customer, not to the shop
Free estimates are a fixture of plumbing marketing, especially for water heaters, repipes, sewer lines and remodels. They make it easy for a homeowner to say yes to a visit. But every estimate uses a person, a vehicle and part of the day that could have gone to paid work. Preparing cost estimates is a core part of a plumber’s job[2]; the question is how much of it you do for nothing, and for whom.
For most shops the answer is not to stop offering free estimates. It is to know what they cost, decide which work deserves them and protect the schedule from visits that were never likely to turn into jobs.
The time math of one estimate
Break a typical estimate into its parts and time each one for a few weeks. The steps below are usually all there, even if nobody has counted them.
| Step (Example) | Typical minutes (Example) |
|---|---|
| Booking call and scheduling | 10 |
| Drive to the address | 25 |
| On site: inspection, measurements, photos, conversation | 45 |
| Drive to the next job | 20 |
| Writing and sending the quote | 20 |
| Follow-up calls and messages | 15 |
| Total | 135 |
Example (fictional): at 135 minutes per estimate and a fully loaded cost of $140 an hour for the estimator, truck and overhead, each estimate costs the shop about $315. If one in three estimates turns into a job, every sold job carries roughly $945 of estimating cost, before any work is done.
The close rate is the multiplier that matters most. A shop that closes half its estimates carries two estimates per sold job; a shop that closes one in five carries five. Improving qualification before the visit is usually cheaper than trying to close more at the door.
Why it matters more in small shops
In large companies, estimates are done by dedicated salespeople whose time is planned for it. In most plumbing businesses the estimator is the owner or the senior tech. Of 111,207 plumbing, heating and AC contractor establishments in 2023, about 58% had fewer than five employees and about 77% had fewer than ten[1].
That makes estimating time the scarcest time in the business. Hours spent on unqualified estimates are hours the owner is not spending on paid work, on managing the team or on the jobs that are already sold. Labor costs keep rising too: average hourly earnings for all employees at plumbing, heating and AC contractors reached $42.38 in September 2026[3], and the industry generated about $260,000 in receipts per employee in 2022[4]. Unproductive hours are expensive hours.
Qualifying questions that protect the schedule
Ask these before booking a free estimate. Most serious customers are glad to answer; people collecting quotes for comparison often reveal it.
- What is happening, and how long has it been going on? This confirms the work is estimate work rather than a repair needing diagnosis.
- Who will make the decision, and can they be there for the visit? Estimates with the decision-maker present are more likely to end with a decision.
- When would you like the work done? A customer planning for next year is a lower priority than one with a failing water heater.
- Is this related to an insurance claim, a home sale or a renovation? Each changes the scope and paperwork.
- Have you had other quotes? Not a reason to refuse, but useful context.
- Could you send a few photos? Photos of the water heater label, the area or the problem often let you prepare or quote remotely.
- Do you have a rough budget in mind, or would options at different levels help? This opens the door to presenting choices rather than a single price.
- Is the property owner-occupied or rented? For rentals, confirm who approves the work.
Ask the same questions on every call. When the office is busy, an SI Employee such as Ava can take down each caller’s details and the job, read them back and book estimate visits into the windows you set, so qualified visits keep landing on the calendar during a busy morning.
Signs an estimate is unlikely to close
- The caller only wants a number by phone and declines to share photos or details.
- The decision-maker will not be present and cannot be reached during the visit.
- The timeline is vague, such as “sometime next year, maybe.”
- The caller says they are collecting several quotes and will pick the lowest.
- The job is outside your normal service area or outside the work you do well.
None of these means the caller should be refused. They are signals to offer a different route: a phone range, a remote quote from photos, or a later estimate date grouped with other visits in the area.
Alternatives to a full visit
Phone ranges
For common replacements, give a range from the price book with the assumptions stated. Many callers only need to know whether the job is in their budget.
Photo and video quotes
Ask for photos of the equipment label, the area and access points. A short video call can replace a visit for many water heater and fixture quotes.
Estimate windows
Group estimates by area into set windows on certain days, so drive time is shared across several visits.
Paid estimates with credit
For complex or remote jobs, charge a fee credited toward the work if approved. Customers who are serious rarely object.
Diagnostic first
Where the cause is unknown, book a diagnostic visit instead of a free estimate. See diagnostic fee vs free estimates.
A qualification call, start to finish
Example script (fictional): “Thanks for calling about a water heater replacement. I can set up a free estimate. So we bring the right information, can I ask a few quick questions? How old is the current heater, and is it gas or electric? Is it leaking now? Will you be the one deciding, or should anyone else be there? If you can text us a photo of the label on the side, the estimator can often give you options before arriving. We have estimate times in your area on Tuesday morning or Thursday afternoon. Which suits you?”
The call is friendly, quick and useful to the customer. It also gives the estimator what they need to prepare, which shortens the visit and improves the quote.
When to decline or redirect
Some requests are better redirected than booked. Decide in advance which ones, so the office can say so kindly and consistently.
- Work outside your service area or outside the jobs your team does well: refer it on and keep the goodwill.
- Requests for a written bid to compare against a single preferred contractor, where the customer says the decision is already made.
- Estimates for insurance or legal disputes, which often need a different, paid type of report.
- Repeat requests from the same address for the same work every few months without a decision: offer a remote update instead of another visit.
Declining politely, with a reason and an alternative, rarely costs a customer you would have kept. It protects the time that serious customers are waiting for.
Measure it
Track four numbers for a month: estimates booked, average total time per estimate, close rate and revenue from sold estimates. Then divide revenue by total estimating hours to get revenue per estimating hour. Compare it with the revenue per hour of normal service work. Break the numbers down by lead source and job type. It is common to find that some sources produce many estimates and few jobs, while referrals and repeat customers close at much higher rates.
Use the results to decide where free estimates stay, where they move to remote quotes and where a paid estimate makes sense. Then tighten the paperwork, because a clear quote closes better: see writing plumbing estimates customers approve and following up on unsold estimates.
Frequently asked questions
Are free estimates worth it for plumbers?
For larger replacements and projects they often are, provided callers are qualified first. For repairs with an unknown cause, a diagnostic fee is usually fairer to both sides.
How do I stop wasting time on estimates that never close?
Ask qualifying questions before booking, ask for photos, make sure the decision-maker will be there, group visits by area, and offer phone ranges or remote quotes where a visit adds little.
Should I charge for estimates?
Many shops charge for complex or distant estimates and credit the fee toward the work if it is approved. Simple replacements are often quoted free or remotely.
References
U.S. Census Bureau (2023). County Business Patterns 2023, U.S. national file (cbp23us) (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics (2026). Average hourly earnings of all employees, plumbing, heating, and air-conditioning contractors, not seasonally adjusted (CEU2023822003) (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Census Bureau (2022). Statistics of U.S. Businesses 2022: U.S. and states, 6-digit NAICS (opens in a new tab) ↑