Key takeaways
- A stay interview asks current techs why they stay and what would make them leave, while you can still act on the answer.
- Construction quits rose from 127,000 in September 2025 to 198,000 in September 2026 (preliminary), so waiting for the exit interview is too late[1].
- Keep it to 20 minutes, one on one, with the tech's direct manager, away from the pay review.
- Use the same core questions for everyone, write down one action per concern and report back within 30 days.
- Adapt the conversation for long-tenure techs; about 115,000 employed plumbers were 55 or older in 2025[2].
What a stay interview is, and why it beats an exit interview
An exit interview tells you why someone left. By then the truck is parked, the customers are calling for the tech who is gone and the information is useful only for the next person. A stay interview asks the same questions of people who are still working for you: what keeps them here, what frustrates them and what would tempt them to leave.
The timing has never mattered more. In construction, quits rose from 127,000 in September 2025 to 198,000 in September 2026 (preliminary)[1], while job openings reached 298,000[3]. When techs have options, small frustrations become resignations quickly.
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2026[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| September 2025 | 127 thousand |
| September 2026 (preliminary) | 198 thousand |
When, who and how long
- When: once a year for every tech, plus at six months for new hires. Avoid busy season and keep it separate from the annual pay review, so the conversation is about the job, not the raise.
- Who: the tech's direct manager, because that is the person who can act on most answers. If the manager is part of the problem, have the owner do it instead.
- Where: somewhere private and neutral, such as a quiet office, a coffee shop or the cab of the truck at the end of the day. Not in front of the crew.
- How long: 20 minutes. Longer feels like a performance review.
- How to book it: tell the tech in advance what it is for and that there is no hidden agenda. A surprise meeting invites suspicion.
Opening the conversation
Script: "I'm having short conversations with everyone on the team about what keeps them here and what we could do better. This isn't a review and nothing you say will be held against you. I'll take a few notes so I remember to follow up. Is that okay?"
Then ask the first question and stop talking. The most common mistake in stay interviews is a manager who explains, defends or promises in the first five minutes. Your job is to listen and take notes.
Fifteen questions that get honest answers
Pick eight to ten for each conversation. Always include the first three and the last one.
- What do you look forward to most when you come to work?
- What frustrates you most about the job right now?
- If you could change one thing about how we operate, what would it be?
- When was the last time you thought about leaving, and what prompted it?
- What would make you take a call from a recruiter or a competitor?
- Do you have the tools, truck and parts to do your best work?
- How do you feel about your schedule and on-call rotation?
- Do you know what you need to do to move up, and do you want to?
- What skills would you like to learn in the next year?
- Do you get enough feedback from me, and is it useful?
- How well does the office support you when you are in the field?
- Who on the team do you most like working with, and why?
- Is there anything about your pay plan you do not understand or think is unfair?
- What did you like at a previous job that we do not do?
- What is one thing I could do differently as your manager?
How to listen
- Ask follow-ups instead of answering: "Tell me more about that" or "What would good look like?"
- Write down the tech's words, not your interpretation.
- Do not promise on the spot. Say: "Thanks, I'll look into that and get back to you by the end of the month."
- Do not argue with the facts even if you think they are wrong. Find out why the tech sees it that way.
- Notice what they do not mention. A tech who praises everything but cannot name what they look forward to may already be looking.
- End by thanking them and confirming when you will follow up.
Turning answers into action
A stay interview that produces no change is worse than none, because it proves to the team that speaking up is pointless. Log every concern and close the loop.
| Concern raised | Action | Owner | Due | Reported back |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| On-call schedule changes at short notice | Publish rotation two months ahead | Service manager | End of month | Team meeting |
| Van has had a broken shelf for weeks | Fix or replace shelving | Fleet lead | Two weeks | Directly to tech |
| Unclear how to reach the next pay level | Write and share the pay ladder | Owner | Next quarter | One-on-one |
| Wants to learn hydro jetting | Schedule two ride-alongs with the jetting tech | Service manager | Next month | Directly to tech |
Group the answers
After all interviews, sort concerns into pay, schedule, growth, tools, management and office support. Count how many techs raised each.
Pick the top two
Fix what most people raised first. Small, visible fixes build trust for harder ones.
Say no clearly when you must
If a request cannot be met, explain why. A clear no is better than silence.
Report back within 30 days
Tell the team what you heard, what you are changing and what you are not. Then tell each tech what happened with their specific points.
Track the effect
Compare quits and regretted departures over the next year with the year before.
In a small shop, the owner does it
In a shop with four or five techs, the owner is usually the manager, and techs may be reluctant to criticize the person who signs their paychecks. Make it easier: do the interviews in the truck or over lunch rather than in the office, start by naming one thing you already know needs fixing and ask for written answers to two or three questions beforehand for anyone who prefers that.
Mistakes that make stay interviews backfire
- Holding them once and never again. A single round looks like a gimmick; a yearly rhythm looks like a habit.
- Asking and doing nothing. If nothing changes after the first round, nobody will be honest in the second.
- Turning it into a pay negotiation. If pay comes up, note it, explain when pay reviews happen and keep the conversation on the job.
- Sharing what one tech said with others in a way that identifies them. Report themes, not names.
- Getting defensive about the office or a manager. The point is to hear the problem, not to win the argument.
- Interviewing only the people you think might leave. Everyone gets a turn, or the meeting itself becomes a warning sign.
Adapting it for long-tenure techs
About 115,000 of the 624,000 employed plumbers, pipefitters and steamfitters were 55 or older in 2025[2], and BLS expects many future openings to come from workers who retire or leave the occupation[4]. Your most experienced techs need a slightly different conversation.
- Ask about their plans for the next three to five years, respectfully and without assuming anything.
- Ask what would make the work easier physically, such as fewer crawl spaces, more install supervision or a helper.
- Ask whether they would like to teach, mentor or move into estimating, inspection or training.
- Ask what knowledge only they have: which commercial buildings, which old systems, which customers. Start capturing it.
- Discuss reduced or phased schedules if they are interested. Keeping a senior tech three days a week can be worth more than replacing them.
Example: what one round of stay interviews found
Example (fictional): a service manager holds 20-minute stay interviews with all nine techs over two weeks. Six mention the on-call week, five mention trucks not being restocked overnight and three senior techs say they would like to train apprentices but have never been asked. Two techs admit they have spoken to a competitor in the past month.
Example (fictional) follow-up: within 30 days the shop publishes the on-call rotation two months ahead, moves restocking to the warehouse lead at the end of each day and assigns each senior tech an apprentice with a mentoring bonus. Both techs who were talking to the competitor stay. The manager repeats the interviews six months later and finds pay plans are now the main concern, which leads to a review against local market rates; industry average hourly earnings had risen about 4.4% over the year[5]. For the levers behind the answers, see our retention guide and what losing a plumber really costs.
Frequently asked questions
What is a stay interview?
A short one-on-one conversation with a current employee about what keeps them, what frustrates them and what might make them leave, held while you can still act on the answers.
How often should I do stay interviews?
Once a year for every tech and at about six months for new hires, separate from the annual pay review.
What is the difference between a stay interview and an exit interview?
An exit interview happens after someone has decided to leave. A stay interview asks current staff the same kinds of questions so you can fix problems before they cost you a good tech.
References
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey, Table 4: Quits levels and rates by industry and region, seasonally adjusted (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Labor Force Statistics from the CPS, Table 11b: Employed persons by detailed occupation and age, 2025 (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey, Table 1: Job openings levels and rates by industry (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025-2035). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics (2026). Average hourly earnings of all employees, plumbing, heating, and air-conditioning contractors, not seasonally adjusted (CEU2023822003) (opens in a new tab) โ