Key takeaways
- A 10% discount on a job with a 40% gross margin needs about a third more jobs just to earn the same gross profit.
- Labor costs keep rising: average hourly earnings in the industry were up about 4.4% in a year[1].
- Use promotions for slow weeks, memberships and planned work, not for emergencies people will book anyway.
- Never tie a discount to a positive review; the FTC bans incentives conditioned on sentiment[2].
Why discounts cost more than they look
Coupons feel like cheap marketing. The discount only applies when someone books, so it seems like you only pay for results. The problem is that a discount comes straight out of gross profit, not revenue. After labor, materials and truck costs, a plumbing job keeps only part of the invoice. Take ten percent off the price and you have taken a much bigger share of what the job actually earns.
There is a second cost. Many people who use a coupon would have called anyway. A homeowner with a backed-up sewer line is going to book someone today; offering them money off does not create the job, it just gives away margin on a job you would have won. Promotions pay only when they create work that would not otherwise have happened.
The margin math
The question to ask about any discount is how many extra jobs it must bring in to leave you with the same gross profit. The formula is simple: extra jobs needed equals the discount divided by the gross margin minus the discount. The table shows how fast it climbs.
| Gross margin before discount | Discount | Extra jobs needed to break even |
|---|---|---|
| 50% | 10% | 25% more jobs |
| 40% | 10% | 33% more jobs |
| 30% | 10% | 50% more jobs |
| 50% | 20% | 67% more jobs |
| 40% | 15% | 60% more jobs |
If your techs were already busy, those extra jobs may not even fit on the schedule. That is why a discount in your peak season is almost always a loss, while the same offer in a quiet week may be worth it.
Rising labor costs squeeze discounts further
Labor is the biggest cost in most plumbing jobs, and it keeps rising. Across plumbing, heating and air-conditioning contractors, payroll equalled about 27% of receipts in 2022[3], before benefits, trucks and materials. Average hourly earnings in the industry rose from $39.30 in January 2025 to $42.65 in August 2026, and the September 2026 figure of $42.38 was about 4.4% higher than a year earlier[1].
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics, 2026[1]
Show the data
| Period | Value |
|---|---|
| Jan 2025 | $39.3 |
| Sep 2025 | $40.59 |
| Aug 2026 | $42.65 |
| Sep 2026 | $42.38 |
If your prices have not kept up with wages, your margin is already thinner than last year, and the same coupon costs you a larger share of profit than it used to. Review the price book before deciding on any promotion.
What a coupon says about your brand
Price signals quality. A company that always has a coupon running teaches customers that the regular price is not the real price, and that they should wait or ask for a deal. It also attracts customers who choose on price alone and leave for the next cheaper offer. For a company that wants to be known for reliable work, clear written prices and techs who show up on time, constant discounting sends a mixed message. Keep promotions occasional and specific, so they feel like a reason to act now rather than a permanent markdown.
When a promotion does make sense
- Slow weeks: filling empty slots when techs would otherwise be paid to wait.
- Planned work: water heater checks, camera inspections or fixture upgrades that people put off without a nudge.
- Memberships: a first-visit offer that turns a one-time customer into a recurring one.
- New services: getting the first customers for a service you just launched, such as water treatment.
- New neighborhoods: an introduction offer where you have trucks nearby but few customers.
In each case the promotion creates a booking that probably would not have happened that week. That is the test to apply before printing anything.
Better alternatives to discounting
- Add value instead of cutting price: include a water pressure check or a camera look at the line with a drain cleaning, at no extra charge.
- Offer priority scheduling and waived trip fees for members rather than general coupons.
- Bundle related work, such as a water heater replacement with an expansion tank and shut-off valve upgrade, at a clear package price.
- Show the savings a product brings. EPA estimates a family can save more than $380 a year by retrofitting with WaterSense labeled fixtures[4], and replacing old toilets with WaterSense models can save nearly 13,000 gallons and more than $170 a year[5].
- Offer financing on large replacements if you have a provider, so price is spread out rather than cut.
- Extend warranty or guarantee terms that cost little if your work is good.
These options give customers a reason to act without training them to wait for the next coupon.
Design a promotion that protects margin
Pick the slow window
Use your schedule history to choose weeks with open capacity.
Pick planned work
Choose a service people can schedule, not an emergency.
Run the math first
Check the extra jobs needed against how many open slots you really have.
Cap and date it
Set a clear end date and a limit on how many jobs it applies to.
Track every redemption
Use a code or dedicated number, and record booked jobs, revenue and gross profit.
Compare with no promotion
Look at the same weeks last year to see whether the offer created work or just discounted it.
Where promotions fit by channel
- Search ads: usually skip discounts; people searching have a problem now and respond to availability and trust.
- Direct mail and door hangers: a dated, planned-work offer gives the card a reason to stay on the fridge.
- Email to past customers: memberships and seasonal checks work better than percentage discounts.
- Social media: introductory offers in new neighborhoods, clearly limited.
- On-site leave-behinds: a return-visit offer for a related service the tech noticed, such as a water heater flush.
Brief the team before launch
Promotions fail at the front line when nobody knows the rules. Before launch, tell everyone who answers phones and every tech what the offer includes, what it excludes, when it ends and how to record it on the job. Give the office a short script for callers who ask for the discount on an emergency job outside the offer, so they can explain politely. Make sure techs know they must apply the discount as printed and must never use the promotion as an opening for pressure selling.
Rules to stay out of trouble
Promotions bring legal and reputation risks. The FTC's rule on reviews bans offering compensation or incentives conditioned on reviews expressing a particular sentiment[2], so never offer a discount for a five-star review. Only advertise a sale price against a price you have really charged, state any limits clearly, and honor every coupon you print until its stated end date. If a technician finds a larger problem during a promotional visit, explain it honestly and give a written price; nothing damages trust faster than a cheap offer followed by a hard sell.
Example: a drain promotion, measured
Example (fictional): a shop considers 15% off drain cleaning in July, its busiest month. Its average drain invoice is $340 with a 45% gross margin, so gross profit is $153 per job. With the discount, the invoice drops to $289 and gross profit to $102, so the shop needs 50% more drain jobs to break even, in a month with no open slots. Instead, it runs the same offer in the first two weeks of February, when two techs usually have open afternoons. The offer brings 31 bookings in those weeks, compared with 19 drain jobs in the same weeks last year, and fills time that would otherwise have been paid but idle.
Measure promotions honestly
For every promotion, record the number of redemptions, the gross profit earned and how many of those customers were new. Compare the period with the same weeks last year. If most redemptions came from existing customers who would have booked anyway, the promotion cost money. If it filled empty slots with new customers, many of whom came back, it worked. Keep the results in one file so future decisions rest on your numbers, not on how busy the phones felt.
Frequently asked questions
Do coupons work for plumbing companies?
They can fill slow weeks or launch planned services, but discounts on work customers would book anyway simply give away margin.
How much extra business does a discount need?
Divide the discount by your gross margin minus the discount. A 10% discount at a 40% margin needs about 33% more jobs to break even.
What are alternatives to plumbing coupons?
Value-added services, memberships with priority scheduling, bundles, financing on large jobs and extended guarantees.
Can I offer a discount for a good review?
No. The FTC bans incentives conditioned on reviews expressing a particular sentiment.
References
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics (2026). Average hourly earnings of all employees, plumbing, heating, and air-conditioning contractors, not seasonally adjusted (CEU2023822003) (opens in a new tab) โ
Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Census Bureau (2022). Statistics of U.S. Businesses 2022: U.S. and states, 6-digit NAICS (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, WaterSense (2026). WaterSense Statistics and Facts (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, WaterSense (2026). Residential Toilets (opens in a new tab) โ