Key takeaways
- Review marketing monthly, channel by channel, from cost to booked jobs to gross profit, not from clicks or impressions.
- Judge each channel on cost per booked job and gross profit per dollar spent, using the same definitions every month.
- Use written decision rules for cutting, holding and scaling, so the meeting ends with changes instead of opinions.
- Reviews behave like a channel: 82% of US adults at least sometimes read ratings or reviews before a first purchase[1].
Why a monthly review
Marketing spend in a plumbing company tends to grow by accretion. A paid search campaign gets set up, a lead service gets added in a busy season, a mailer goes out every spring, and nobody ever turns anything off. A monthly review forces each channel to justify its place with numbers the owner trusts: what it cost, what it produced and what that work earned.
Monthly is the right cadence for most shops. Weekly data per channel is too noisy, especially for smaller channels, and quarterly lets a bad campaign burn through three months of budget before anyone notices. Weak demand is a common worry: in the Federal Reserve Banks' survey of small employer firms, 48% named weak sales as a financial challenge, up from 44% a year earlier[2]. When sales are soft, the temptation is to spend more everywhere; the review is how you spend more only where it works.
What to gather before the meeting
- Spend by channel for the month, from invoices and ad accounts, not from the budget.
- Calls, forms and texts by channel, from call tracking numbers, form tags and campaign links.
- Booked jobs by channel, matched by phone number or customer record.
- Completed jobs, revenue and gross profit by channel, from the job list and job costing.
- Unbooked reasons for each channel's leads: price shopper, out of area, wrong trade, no slot.
- Review count and rating changes on the main review platforms.
- Notes on anything unusual: weather events, a technician shortage, a campaign launched mid-month.
If you cannot yet match jobs to channels, fix that before anything else. A review built on guesses about where jobs came from will cut the channels that work and keep the ones that are easy to see.
The one-hour agenda
Totals first, ten minutes
Total spend, total booked jobs, total gross profit from marketed jobs, and the same three numbers for last month and the same month last year.
Channel by channel, twenty-five minutes
For each channel, read the metrics in the table below and apply the decision rules. Stop debating once a rule applies.
Lead quality, ten minutes
Listen to three or four unbooked calls from the channel with the worst booking rate. Decide whether the problem is the leads or how they were handled.
Reputation, five minutes
New reviews, rating trend, any unanswered negative review, and how many review requests went out.
Decisions, ten minutes
Write down each change: what, who, by when, and what number will show whether it worked next month.
Metrics for each channel
| Metric | Formula | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Cost per lead | Spend divided by calls and forms | Shows the price of attention, not of work |
| Booking rate | Booked jobs divided by leads | Separates bad leads from bad handling |
| Cost per booked job | Spend divided by booked jobs | The core comparison across channels |
| Average ticket | Revenue divided by completed jobs | Some channels bring bigger jobs |
| Gross profit per dollar spent | Gross profit from channel jobs divided by spend | The final test of a channel |
| Share of new customers | New customers divided by completed jobs | Growth versus serving existing customers |
Cost per lead is the number ad platforms and lead sellers like to show, and it is the least useful one. The guide to the call-to-revenue funnel explains why the stages below the lead matter more.
Decision rules: cut, hold or scale
- Scale: gross profit per dollar spent is well above your target for two months running and the schedule has room. Raise the budget in steps and watch the next month.
- Hold: results are near target, or the channel is new and has fewer than about twenty booked jobs of data. Keep spend steady and improve handling.
- Fix before cutting: lead volume is fine but the booking rate is low. Review calls and scripts first; the channel may be fine and the handling weak.
- Cut: gross profit per dollar spent is below target for three months, with good handling, or the leads are mostly out of area or the wrong trade.
- Pause in peaks: if the board is booked out for days, reduce spend on channels that bring only routine work, and keep emergency and brand channels running.
Set the target before the meeting, from your own numbers: the gross profit you need per marketing dollar to cover overhead and leave a profit. Without a target, every channel looks acceptable.
Reviews and reputation as a channel
Reviews are not a line on the ad invoice, but they change the results of every paid channel. Pew found that 82% of US adults at least sometimes read online ratings or reviews before buying something for the first time, 46% say reviews help a lot in feeling confident about a purchase and 40% nearly always rely on them[1].
Track review requests sent, reviews received and response time to negative reviews in the same meeting. Stay inside the rules: the FTC's final rule on consumer reviews and testimonials bans creating or selling fake reviews, including AI-generated ones[3]. Ask every customer, not only happy ones, and never pay or reward for a positive review.
Example: one month's review
Example: a fictional shop reviews four channels for April. Its target is three dollars of gross profit per marketing dollar.
| Channel | Spend | Booked jobs | Cost per booked job | GP per dollar |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Paid search | $6,200 | 58 | $107 | 3.4 |
| Local services ads | $3,900 | 41 | $95 | 3.6 |
| Shared lead service | $2,800 | 14 | $200 | 1.3 |
| Spring mailer | $2,100 | 9 | $233 | 2.1 |
Example, continued: paid search and local services ads clear the target, so both hold, with a small increase for local services ads because the schedule has room on Thursdays and Fridays. The lead service has been below target for three months and its unbooked calls are mostly price shoppers from outside the area, so it is cut. The mailer is below target but brought two water heater replacements late in the month, so it is held for one more cycle with a tracking number on every piece.
Attribution traps
- Unknown-number callbacks. If the office calls leads back from a different number, many will not pick up; Pew found 80% of Americans generally do not answer calls from unknown numbers[4]. Call back from the number customers know.
- Brand searches credited to ads. Someone who saw your truck and searched your name may click an ad on the way; that job did not come from the ad.
- Repeat customers in paid channels. Existing customers who click an ad to find your number inflate the channel's results. Tag new versus returning customers.
- Phone versus text. 91% of US adults own a smartphone[5], and many leads text rather than call. Make sure texts and forms are tracked by channel too.
- Lag. Mailers and brand campaigns can produce calls weeks later. Look at two- and three-month windows for slow channels.
Seasons and the marketing calendar
Compare each month with the same month last year as well as with last month. Plumbing demand swings with the weather: freezes, spring rains and summer water heater failures all move call volume regardless of what you spend. A channel that looks weaker in May than in January may simply be running into a quieter season, while a channel that holds steady through a slow month may be the one worth scaling.
Plan spend against capacity, not just against demand. Push routine-work campaigns into the months when the board has gaps, and protect emergency visibility all year. Book seasonal campaigns, such as spring drain checks or pre-winter inspections, at least a month ahead so the review can judge them on a full cycle instead of a rushed launch.
After the meeting
- Make the budget changes within two working days, so next month's numbers test the decision.
- Update call tracking and campaign tags for any new or changed channel.
- Share the booking-rate findings with the office and the call samples with the CSR lead.
- Add one line to the decision log: what changed and why.
The review works best inside a wider routine. Start from the funnel report so you know where leads are lost, watch first-time fix and callback rates so marketed jobs turn into repeat customers, and check competitor activity a few times a year so channel changes are not a surprise.
Frequently asked questions
How much should a plumbing company spend on marketing?
Start from the jobs you need and your cost per booked job by channel, rather than a fixed share of revenue. The monthly review then tells you where the next dollar should go.
How long should I test a new marketing channel?
Give it long enough to produce about twenty booked jobs, or two to three months for slower channels such as mail, before judging it, and track it with its own number or link.
What is the most important marketing metric for plumbers?
Gross profit per marketing dollar, because it reflects cost, booking rate, ticket and margin together. Cost per lead on its own is misleading.
References
Pew Research Center (2016). Online Reviews (Online Shopping and E-Commerce) (opens in a new tab) โ
Federal Reserve Banks (2025). 2025 Report on Employer Firms: Findings from the 2024 Small Business Credit Survey (opens in a new tab) โ
Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) โ
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) โ
Pew Research Center (2026). Mobile Fact Sheet (opens in a new tab) โ