Key takeaways
- There were 107,004 plumbing, heating and AC contractor firms with employees in 2022, so most local markets are crowded[1].
- About 77% of these establishments have fewer than 10 employees: your real rivals are mostly small shops like yours[2].
- Free public tools show competitors’ map presence, ads, reviews and hours. You do not need paid software to start.
- Look for gaps you can serve, such as hours, towns, services or responsiveness, not slogans to copy.
- Keep it honest: no fake enquiries, no clicking rivals’ ads and no claims you cannot keep.
What competitor research is for
The point is not to imitate the biggest shop in town. It is to answer a few practical questions that shape your marketing budget and your schedule: who shows up when local homeowners search, what those businesses promise, where customers complain about them, and which jobs, hours or towns nobody is covering well.
- Who appears in the map results and ads for your top five services?
- What hours, response times and service areas do they claim?
- What do their recent reviews praise, and what do they complain about?
- Which channels are they paying for: search ads, Local Services Ads, social ads, mailers?
- Where are they thin: a service, a town, weekends, a language?
How crowded is your market?
Start with the size of the field. The Census Bureau counted 107,004 plumbing, heating and air-conditioning contractor firms with paid employees in 2022[1]. They are spread unevenly: California had 11,135 firms, Florida 8,889 and Texas 8,508[3].
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2022[3]
Show the data
| Item | Firms with employees |
|---|---|
| California | 11,135 firms |
| Florida | 8,889 firms |
| Texas | 8,508 firms |
| New York | 7,019 firms |
| Illinois | 4,113 firms |
Most of those businesses are small. About 77% of plumbing, heating and AC contractor establishments had fewer than 10 employees in 2023[2]. In practice your competition is a few well-known names plus a long tail of one- to five-truck shops, many of which do little marketing. That tail is why a steady, well-run profile can stand out even in a busy metro.
For your own county, the Census Bureau’s County Business Patterns data on data.census.gov lets you look up industry code 238220 (plumbing, heating and air-conditioning contractors) by county and see how many establishments operate there, broken down by employee size. Note it once a year; it changes slowly.
77%
of plumbing, heating and AC contractor establishments had fewer than 10 employees in 2023[2]
The free toolkit
| Tool | What it shows | What to write down |
|---|---|---|
| Google Search and Maps on a phone | Who appears for real local searches | Names in the top results for each service and town |
| Competitors’ Business Profiles | Categories, hours, services, photos, reviews | Primary category, stated hours, newest review date |
| Google Ads Transparency Center | Ads an advertiser has run on Google | Services and offers they advertise |
| Meta Ad Library | Active ads on Facebook and Instagram | Offers, seasons and whether ads run all year |
| Local Services Ads results | Who pays for the top “Google screened” slots | Names, review counts, hours shown |
| Competitor websites | Service pages, towns, guarantees, financing | Towns listed, services they emphasize |
| State license lookup | License status and type | Whether the business is licensed for the work it advertises |
| Job boards | Who is hiring and for what roles | Growth signals, new service lines, pay offered |
Search on a phone, signed out or in a private window, and from different parts of your area. Map results shift with the searcher’s location, so a single search from your office tells you very little about what a customer across town sees.
Reading review profiles for weak spots
Reviews are the most honest public data about a competitor’s operations. Customers rarely write about marketing; they write about arrival times, communication, mess and surprise bills. Since 82% of US adults at least sometimes read reviews before a first purchase, the same patterns you spot are the ones your shared customers are reading[4].
Read the last 20 reviews for each of your top three rivals and tally the themes. Pay most attention to the one- and two-star reviews, because readers do: 54% of US review readers pay more attention to extremely negative reviews[5].
- Repeated “never called back” or “no one answered” complaints suggest a phone gap you can fill.
- “Showed up hours late” suggests weak dispatch or too few techs at peak times.
- “Price changed when they arrived” suggests a quoting habit you can contrast with clear service-call fee wording.
- Praise for one named technician suggests a shop that depends on a few people.
- Owner replies that argue with customers show a reputation weakness, not a strength.
Reading their ads and offers
Ad libraries show what competitors are willing to pay to say. Note the services they push, the seasons when their ads appear and the offers they lead with. Then ask whether each offer is something you could deliver every day. A “60-minute arrival” promise is only useful to copy if your dispatch board can keep it; a guarantee you cannot honor is a liability, not a marketing message.
Treat what you find as information about the market, not as copy to reuse. Use your own wording, your own photos and your own claims. If you consider bidding on a competitor’s business name as a search term, read the ad platform’s trademark policy first and never use their name in your ad text in a way that suggests you are them.
Finding the gaps
A useful audit ends with a short list of openings. Google ranks local results on relevance, distance and prominence, so the best gaps are usually about relevance (services and towns you could cover better) and prominence (reviews and replies), since distance is fixed[6].
| Gap type | What it looks like | Possible move |
|---|---|---|
| Hours | Rivals list 8–5 and miss evening calls | Cover evenings properly, then advertise it |
| Towns | Few profiles mention an outlying town | Build a real service page for that town and serve it |
| Services | Nobody highlights tankless or backflow testing | Add the service to your profile and site if you do it |
| Language | No Spanish-speaking option visible | Offer it if your team can, and say so plainly |
| Responsiveness | Reviews mention unanswered phones | Answer every call and track it |
A half-day audit
Pick the searches
List your five most profitable services and three most important towns. That gives up to 15 searches.
Run them on a phone
Record the top three map results and any ads for each search. Use a simple sheet.
Profile the top five rivals
For each, note rating, review count, newest review, hours, primary category and services listed.
Check their ads
Look each rival up in the Google and Meta ad libraries and note offers and services.
Tally review themes
Read their last 20 reviews and count complaint and praise themes.
Choose two moves
Pick the two gaps you can act on this quarter and set a date to repeat the audit.
Example: what one audit turned up
Example (fictional): a four-truck shop in a mid-sized county runs the 15 searches. The same three rivals appear in most map results. Two list weekday hours only; the third claims 24/7 service but its recent reviews include several “no one picked up at night” complaints. None of the three mentions the county’s two northern towns on its website, and only one advertises water heater replacement outside winter.
In this example the shop picks two moves: properly staffed evening coverage with honest hours on its profile, and service pages plus a review push for the northern towns where it already has customers. It decides not to copy the rival’s “24/7” badge until it can answer every night call. Three months later it repeats the same searches to see what changed.
Signals of where a rival is heading
Today’s map results show where competitors are now. A few public signals hint at where they are going next, which matters when you are deciding whether to invest in a service line or a town.
- Job postings for a second dispatcher or customer service role usually mean call volume is growing faster than the office can handle.
- Postings for licensed plumbers with specific skills, such as backflow certification or tankless experience, often come before a new service is advertised.
- New service pages or new towns on a competitor’s website tend to be followed by ads for the same services a few weeks later.
- A sudden burst of reviews followed by silence often means a short campaign rather than a lasting habit.
- A change of business name, phone number or logo can signal a sale or merger; watch whether review replies and response times change afterwards.
None of these signals is proof. Treat them as reasons to look again next quarter, and as prompts to check whether your own team could respond if a rival starts competing hard for the jobs you rely on. A shop that already answers every call, replies to every review and keeps honest hours is hard to dislodge, whatever a competitor spends.
Staying on the right side of fair play
- Do not pose as a customer to book fake appointments; it ties up a rival’s dispatcher and tells you little you cannot see publicly.
- Do not click competitors’ ads to drain their budget.
- Do not post or buy reviews about yourself or about competitors. Fake reviews are banned under the FTC rule[7].
- Do not copy text or photos from competitor websites.
- Do keep notes dated, so next quarter’s audit shows real change.
Use the results to set your plan: see plumbing marketing strategy by stage and the monthly marketing spend review for where the findings feed into budget decisions.
Frequently asked questions
How often should a plumbing company research competitors?
A full audit once a quarter is enough for most shops, with a quick monthly look at the map results for your top two services.
Can I see how much a competitor spends on ads?
Not exactly. Ad libraries show which ads run and when, but not budgets. Frequency and how long an ad has run give a rough sense of commitment.
Is it legal to bid on a competitor’s name in search ads?
Rules depend on the ad platform’s trademark policy and on how the name is used. Read the policy first and never use a rival’s name in a way that suggests you are them.
What is the most useful thing to look at?
Recent negative reviews of your top rivals. They show operational gaps, such as unanswered phones or late arrivals, that you can fix in your own shop and fairly highlight.
References
U.S. Census Bureau (2022). Statistics of U.S. Businesses 2022: U.S. and states, 6-digit NAICS (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Census Bureau (2023). County Business Patterns 2023, U.S. national file (cbp23us) (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Census Bureau (2022). Statistics of U.S. Businesses 2022: U.S. and states, 6-digit NAICS (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2016). Online Reviews (Online Shopping and E-Commerce) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2016). Online Reviews (Online Shopping and E-Commerce) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Google Business Profile Help (2026). Tips to improve your local ranking on Google (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) ↑