Metrics finance

Using plumbing industry benchmarks without fooling yourself

How to use plumbing benchmarks safely: check definitions, means vs medians and work mix, segment before comparing, and make your own trend the benchmark.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Why benchmarks so often mislead
  2. Five questions to ask before using any benchmark
  3. Means, medians and a skewed industry
  4. Definitions that look alike but are not
  5. Segment before you compare
  6. Make your own trend the main benchmark
  7. Example: a benchmark that nearly caused a bad decision
  8. Where external benchmarks do help
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References
Metrics finance: Using plumbing industry benchmarks without fooling yourselfArticle coverMETRICS FINANCEUsing plumbing industrybenchmarks withoutfooling yourselfAva for PlumbersInsightsMetrics finance: Using plumbing industry benchmarks without fooling yourselfArticle coverMETRICS FINANCEUsing plumbingindustry benchmarkswithout foolingyourselfAva for Plumbers

Key takeaways

  • Before using any benchmark, check what it includes, who it covers, whether it is a mean or median, and what year it describes.
  • Averages mislead in a skewed industry: the average firm took in about $2.9 million in 2022[1], yet about 63% of firms had receipts under $1 million[2].
  • Similar-sounding measures differ: Census payroll per employee is not the same as a plumber's median wage.
  • Segment first by size, work mix and region; a residential service shop should not compare itself with a mechanical contractor.
  • Your own trend over four to eight quarters is the most reliable benchmark you have.

Why benchmarks so often mislead

Benchmarks are appealing because they promise a quick answer to the question every owner asks: are we doing well? A number from a trade survey, a consultant's slide or a government table seems to settle it. In practice, most bad decisions made with benchmarks come from comparing two numbers that only look alike.

The usual problems are the same every time. The benchmark uses a different definition from yours. It describes a different kind of business, such as a mix of HVAC and plumbing, or new construction and service. It reports an average pulled up by a few large companies. It covers only firms that chose to answer a survey, which tend to be the better-run ones. Or it describes a year when conditions were different. Any one of these can turn a sensible comparison into a misleading one.

None of this means benchmarks are useless. They are good at telling you where to look. They are bad at telling you what to do. Use them to raise questions about your own numbers, then answer those questions with your own data.

Five questions to ask before using any benchmark

  1. What exactly is in the number? Payroll or total labor cost, revenue or gross profit, all staff or only field techs.
  2. Who does it cover? Plumbing only or plumbing with HVAC, residential or commercial, firms of what size, in which region.
  3. Is it a mean or a median? Means are pulled toward the largest firms; medians describe the middle.
  4. Where did it come from? A government census, a sample survey, a vendor's customer base or a consultant's clients.
  5. When was it measured? Wages and prices have moved quickly, so a benchmark from a few years ago may describe a different market.

If you cannot answer at least three of these, treat the number as a rough indication only. If someone quoting a benchmark cannot answer them either, be wary of the advice that comes with it.

Means, medians and a skewed industry

Plumbing, heating and AC contracting is an industry of many small firms and a few very large ones. That shape makes averages unreliable. Census data puts average receipts per firm at about $2.9 million in 2022[1]. But about 63% of firms had annual receipts under $1 million that year[2]. The average is real; it just does not describe a typical firm.

The same thing happens with pay. For plumbers, pipefitters and steamfitters working for specialty trade contractors, the median wage in 2025 was $63,150, while the mean was $71,840[3]. The higher-paid end of the distribution pulls the mean up. If you set pay against the mean, you may overpay relative to most of your local market; set it against the median and you may underpay your best people. Use both, and ideally use local data.

Plumbers at specialty trade contractors: median vs mean annual wage, 2025The mean sits above the median because high earners pull it up
Plumbers at specialty trade contractors: median vs mean annual wage, 2025Comparison. Median wage: $63,150; Mean wage: $71,840.$63,150Median wageMedian wage: $63,150$71,840Mean wageMean wage: $71,840Plumbers at specialty trade contractors: median vs mean annual wage, 2025Comparison. Median wage: $63,150; Mean wage: $71,840.$63,150Median wageMedian wage: $63,150$71,840Mean wageMean wage: $71,840

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2025[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Median wage$63,150
Mean wage$71,840

When a source gives only an average, ask for the median or the distribution. If neither is available, assume the typical firm sits below the average in a skewed industry like this one.

Definitions that look alike but are not

Match the definition before comparing; otherwise the gap is just a definitional difference.
BenchmarkWhat it includesWhat it leaves outCompare it with
Census payroll as a share of receiptsWages for all employees, including office and managersBenefits, owner draws in non-corporate firms, subcontractorsYour total payroll divided by revenue
Census payroll per employeeTotal payroll divided by all employees, field and officeBenefits; part-time and full-time are mixedYour total payroll divided by headcount
BLS median plumber wageWages of plumbers as an occupation, wherever employedOffice staff, benefits, overtime differencesWhat you pay your field plumbers
Receipts per employeeAll revenue divided by all employeesDifferences in subcontracting and material shareYour revenue divided by headcount, same basis

A concrete case: average annual payroll per employee at plumbing, heating and AC contractors was about $73,700 in 2023[4], while the median wage for plumbers employed by those contractors was $63,010 in May 2025[5]. These are different measures from different surveys. The first divides all payroll, including managers and office staff, by all employees and is an average; the second is the middle wage of one occupation. Neither tells you whether your tech pay is right.

Labor cost is another trap. Census payroll leaves out benefits, which averaged about 30% of private-industry employer compensation cost in June 2026[6]. Comparing your fully burdened labor cost with a payroll-only benchmark will make your business look worse than it is.

Segment before you compare

Even with matching definitions, businesses differ in ways that move every ratio. Before comparing, put your company in the right group and look for benchmarks from that group.

  • Size band. A three-truck shop where the owner runs calls has very different overhead from a 30-truck company with a management team.
  • Work mix. Water heater and repipe work carries a high material share; drain and repair work carries a high labor share. Mix alone can move labor percentage by many points.
  • Customer type. Residential service, commercial contracts and builder work have different margins, payment terms and seasonality.
  • Plumbing or plumbing plus HVAC. Most government business data combines them.
  • Region. Wages, prices and demand vary widely between metro areas and states.

Our guide to department P&Ls lets you compare each line of work with the right peers instead of comparing a blended company total with someone else's blend.

Make your own trend the main benchmark

Your own numbers, measured the same way every quarter, are the most reliable comparison available. The definitions match by construction, the business mix is yours and the market is the one you serve.

  1. Fix your definitions

    Write one sentence defining each measure you track: what goes in the numerator, the denominator and the period. Do not change it without noting the date.

  2. Build a baseline

    Collect four to eight quarters of history. If your old data uses different definitions, restate it or start the baseline from now.

  3. Set a normal range

    For each measure, note the range it usually falls in. A move outside that range for two periods running is a signal worth investigating.

  4. Use external data as a sense check

    Once a year, compare a few measures with matching external benchmarks to check you are not far off in either direction.

  5. Review in the quarterly meeting

    Look at trends at your quarterly business review, not at single months.

Example: a benchmark that nearly caused a bad decision

Example (fictional): an owner of an 8-truck shop reads that a typical plumbing company should keep labor at a certain share of revenue. His own burdened field labor is several points higher, and he considers cutting a tech.

In this Example, a closer look shows three differences. The benchmark used wages only, while his figure included benefits. The benchmark mixed HVAC companies with high equipment sales, while his shop is mostly repair and drain work. And his labor share had been steady for six quarters while revenue per tech rose. On a like-for-like basis there was no problem to fix. Cutting a tech would have reduced capacity in his busiest department.

The useful lesson from the benchmark was different: it prompted him to split labor by department, which showed his install crew was underpriced. That was worth fixing, and it came from asking why his number differed rather than assuming the benchmark was right.

Where external benchmarks do help

Government data is strongest for market-level questions: how many competitors operate in your county, how fast wages are rising, how many openings the trade expects. Our guide to plumbing industry statistics collects the main figures. For pricing and staffing decisions inside your company, use benchmarks to prompt questions, then decide with your own data and with measures shown live on a KPI dashboard.

Vendor benchmarks deserve extra care. Software and marketing companies often publish figures drawn from their own customers, who are not a random sample of the trade. The numbers may be accurate for that group and still say little about yours. Look for the sample size, the date range and how the figure was calculated; if those details are missing, treat it as marketing rather than data.

Customer measures such as review scores and net promoter scores are especially hard to compare across companies, because survey timing and wording change the result. Our guide to NPS for plumbing companies covers how to track your own score consistently.

Frequently asked questions

Should I use the mean or the median when comparing my business?

Prefer the median in a skewed industry like plumbing and HVAC contracting, where a few very large firms pull averages up. If only an average is available, assume a typical firm sits below it.

Why doesn't my labor cost match industry benchmarks?

Often because definitions differ. Census payroll excludes benefits and includes office staff, and the industry data mixes plumbing with HVAC. Match the definition and your work mix before drawing conclusions.

What is the best benchmark for a plumbing company?

Your own trend, measured the same way every quarter. Use external benchmarks once a year as a sense check.

Where can I find reliable plumbing industry data?

Government sources such as Census County Business Patterns, Statistics of U.S. Businesses and BLS wage and employment data are the most transparent about definitions and coverage.

References

  1. U.S. Census Bureau (2022). Statistics of U.S. Businesses 2022: U.S. and states, 6-digit NAICS (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. U.S. Census Bureau (2022). Statistics of U.S. Businesses 2022: Firms by industry and enterprise receipts size (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Industries at a Glance: Specialty Trade Contractors (NAICS 238) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. U.S. Census Bureau (2023). County Business Patterns 2023, U.S. national file (cbp23us) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  5. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  6. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employer Costs for Employee Compensation - June 2026 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo