Key takeaways
- Match on the model list and, where the notice sets one, the serial or manufacture-date range. A brand name alone is not a match[2][3].
- Ask about CO alarms and symptoms before anything else; 59% of consumer-product CO deaths fall in November through February[4].
- Read the notice's consumer instructions to the caller word for word and point them to the recalling firm's free remedy[2].
- Pull matching units from vans and shelves the day a recall is announced: selling a recalled product is a prohibited act[5].
- Log every recall call with the model, serial, recall number and exactly what the customer was told.
Where recall calls come from
Recall calls rarely start with the manufacturer's letter. A customer sees a news story about a water heater recall, cannot remember which brand is in the garage, and rings the company whose sticker is on the tank. Others call because a neighbor mentioned it, or because a supply house notice reached the homeowner before it reached you. The person on the phone wants three answers in this order: is my unit affected, is it safe to use tonight, and who fixes it. A CSR can answer all three, as long as they get the details off the rating plate and read the actual notice instead of the headline.
Water heaters are a small part of the carbon monoxide picture, which is exactly why recall calls get handled loosely. CPSC staff estimate an average of 238 non-fire CO deaths a year linked to consumer products in 2020 to 2022, about 5 of them with water heaters, and the yearly count swings: 3 in 2020, 9 in 2022, 18 in 2019[4]. Across all causes, CDC counts more than 400 deaths, more than 100,000 emergency department visits and more than 14,000 hospital stays a year from unintentional CO poisoning not linked to fires[6].
Source: U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, 2026[4]
Show the data
| Year | Estimated deaths |
|---|---|
| 2012 | 5 |
| 2013 | 2 |
| 2014 | 5 |
| 2015 | 9 |
| 2016 | 6 |
| 2017 | 4 |
| 2018 | 5 |
| 2019 | 18 |
| 2020 | 3 |
| 2021 | 4 |
| 2022 | 9 |
Timing matters too. In 2020 to 2022, 59% of consumer-product CO deaths happened in November through February[4], the same stretch of the year covered in why water heater failures rise in winter. A recall question about a gas water heater in January deserves a same-evening answer, not a callback next week.
Read the notice, not the headline
A CPSC recall notice uses the same layout every time, and each field answers a question the caller is about to ask. Take recall 26-026, announced in October 2025 for a line of gas-fired tankless water heaters: about 36,700 units sold through plumbing supply stores nationwide from May 2017 to July 2025, after 33 reports of cracked exhaust ducts, with a free repair as the remedy[2]. Units sold through supply houses are the ones contractors buy, so the install records sit with plumbing companies rather than with a big-box retailer.
| Notice field | What it answers | In recall 26-026 |
|---|---|---|
| Description and model numbers | Which units are in the recall, and where the label is | Twelve model numbers across three series; the model number is bolded near the top of the white label on the side[2] |
| Serial or date range | Whether every unit of a listed model is included | Check every notice: some narrow a model by serial range or build date[3] |
| Hazard | Why it matters tonight | The exhaust duct can crack and let gases escape inside the home[2] |
| Remedy | What the customer gets, and from whom | A free repair installed by a certified technician[2] |
| Consumer instructions | What to tell the caller to do now | Stop using it; if it must stay in use until the repair, have working smoke and CO alarms[2] |
| Sold at and dates | Whether your customers could own one | Plumbing supply stores, May 2017 to July 2025[2] |
Two mistakes cause most wrong answers. The first is matching on brand. The notice lists model numbers, and in 26-026 it lists twelve across three series[2]; a different model from the same brand is not covered by that recall. The second is stopping at the model. Some notices narrow the recall by serial range or build date. The February 2024 recall of about 42,000 portable tankless heaters set a separate manufacture-date cutoff for each of its five models, so two units with the same model number could fall on different sides of the line[3].
The call, step by step
Safety questions first
Ask whether a CO alarm is sounding and whether anyone at home has a headache, dizziness, an upset stomach, vomiting or confusion, which CDC lists among the common CO symptoms[6]. If the answer to either is yes: everyone out, call 911 from outside, and nobody goes back in to read a label.
Get the rating plate
Ask for brand, model number, serial number and fuel type exactly as printed on the label. A photo sent to the office email removes the guesswork between characters like 0 and O, or 1 and I.
Match against the notice
Check the model list first, then any serial range or manufacture date. If the label is missing or unreadable, say so plainly. Do not guess.
Say what the notice says
Read the consumer instructions from the notice word for word. For 26-026 that means stop using the heater and contact the firm for the free repair, with working smoke and CO alarms if it must stay in use until then[2].
Give the remedy route
Pass on the recalling firm's contact details from the notice, and say whether your company can do the repair under the firm's program.
Log it before you hang up
Write the call up while the details are in front of you, using the fields further down this page.
Script: βBefore we look at the model, is a carbon monoxide alarm going off, or is anyone in the house feeling dizzy or sick? β¦ Good. Can you go to the water heater and read me the model number and the serial number from the label on the side? If it's easier, send a photo to the email address I'll give you. I'll check them against the recall notice while you're on the line.β
Four results, four answers
| Result | What to say | Next step |
|---|---|---|
| Model and serial both inside the recall | βYour unit is included in recall [number]. The notice says to stop using it and contact the manufacturer for the free repair.β Then read the safety line. | Give the firm's contact, offer to help arrange the repair, log as matched. |
| Model listed, serial or date outside the range | βYour model is named in the recall, but your serial number is outside the range the notice lists, so this recall does not cover your unit.β | Log the serial checked and the notice date; offer a service visit if they still have concerns. |
| Model not listed | βThat model is not in this recall. Recalls are listed by model, so a different model from the same brand isn't covered by this one.β | Log as checked, not matched. |
| Label unreadable or missing | βI can't confirm it from here. We can send someone to read the plate and look at the venting.β | Book a visit; treat it as urgent if the unit is gas and the caller reports symptoms or an alarm. |
That caption is the whole policy in one line. A recall check tells you whether a defect notice covers a unit. It says nothing about whether the unit is installed correctly, vented properly or in good condition. Keep the two separate in what you say and in what you write down, and train every CSR to use the notice's wording rather than their own reassurance.
Who does the repair, and who pays
The remedy belongs to the recalling firm. In 26-026 the firm arranges a certified technician to install a free repair[2]; in the 2024 portable recall the remedy was a free repair kit[3]. Your company may be asked to do recall repairs as an authorized service provider, may be paid a set labor rate, or may not be involved at all. Find out which before anyone promises the customer anything, and get the labor arrangement in writing before the first truck rolls. The paperwork runs much like a warranty job, covered in handling manufacturer warranty claims.
Some customers would rather replace the heater than wait for a repair. That is a normal sale and you can quote it, but tell them the free remedy exists and let them choose. A customer who finds out later that the fix was free will remember who left that out. If the unit is near the end of its life anyway, say so with the age off the label, and put both options in writing.
Check your own shelves and install history
Recalls apply to the stock on your vans as much as the units in customers' homes. Federal law makes it unlawful to sell, offer for sale or distribute a consumer product that is subject to a voluntary recall CPSC has announced, or one the seller knew or should have known was recalled[5]. When a water heater recall is announced, someone checks the warehouse and every van that day, tags matching units and calls the supply house about returns.
Then search your own records. If your software stores model numbers for installed units, filter by the listed models and by install dates inside the notice's sales window. If it does not, this is the push to start capturing them; planning replacements by water heater age uses the same fields. Recalls do not reach everyone on their own: across 865 closed recall cases from FY 2014 to FY 2016, CPSC found an overall correction rate of 65 percent[1]. The plumber who installed a unit may be the only party who knows where it is.
One more duty to know about. Manufacturers, distributors and retailers that learn a product may have a defect creating a substantial hazard must inform CPSC immediately[7]. If your company sells the water heaters it installs and you start seeing the same failure on one model, raise it with the manufacturer and ask your attorney whether that reporting duty reaches you.
When the call comes after hours
Recall news does not wait for office hours, and worried callers do not either. Decide in advance what happens to a recall call at 9 p.m.: who takes it, which questions get asked and what counts as urgent. A caller with a sounding CO alarm or symptoms is a 911 call first. A caller asking whether the heater is on the list can usually wait for a morning callback, as long as they hear tonight what the notice tells owners to do.
- Caller
- SI Employee
- System
- Your team
01Caller
Caller asks about a recall
They saw a news story and want to know if their water heater is included.
02SI Employee
Safety questions first
CO alarm sounding or symptoms? If yes: leave the house and call 911 from outside.
03SI Employee
Rating plate details taken
Brand, model, serial, fuel type, address and best callback number, read back.
04System
Summary to the office
Summary emailed; recording and transcript in the account; urgent calls marked urgent.
05Your team
CSR checks the notice
Model list, then serial or date range, then a callback in the notice's own words.
Example sequence. The SI Employee collects the details; a CSR does the matching against the notice.
If an SI Employee answers your overflow or after-hours calls, add the recall questions to its approved script: the safety questions in your wording, then the label details. It does not look anything up in a recall database. It takes the details down, reads them back and sends the call summary to the inbox you choose, and calls that meet your urgent rules follow your on-call path (see what it does). The one-van plumber example shows the same pattern for a shop with nobody in the office.
Log it like a warranty job
- Date, time and who took the call.
- Customer name, service address and callback number.
- Brand, model, serial and fuel type, plus how you got them: read out, photo or on site.
- Recall number and the date of the notice you checked against.
- Result: matched, outside the range, not listed, or could not confirm.
- What the customer was told, in the notice's words, and what they chose: repair through the firm, a replacement quote or nothing yet.
- Follow-up date and who owns it.
File the note with the customer record, not in someone's inbox. If a customer later says nobody warned them, a dated note with the notice number and the instruction you read is the answer. How long to keep job files is set out in what records a plumbing business must keep.
Example: a customer calls on a Tuesday evening in January after seeing a recall story. The CSR asks the safety questions (no alarm, nobody unwell), gets a photo of the label and finds the model on the notice's list and the serial inside the stated range. She reads the instruction to stop using the heater, gives the manufacturer's recall line and explains that the shop is not an authorized repairer for this program. The customer asks about a replacement, so she books an estimate visit for Thursday and logs both: recall matched, customer informed, estimate booked.
Frequently asked questions
Are we required to do recall repairs for free?
The free remedy is the recalling firm's obligation, and the firm decides who performs it. In recall 26-026 a certified technician installs the free repair[2]. If the firm asks your company to do the work, agree the labor payment in writing first.
Can we install a recalled water heater we already have in stock?
No. Selling or distributing a product under a voluntary recall that CPSC has announced is a prohibited act[5]. Tag it, set it aside and contact your supplier about a return.
The serial number is outside the recall range. Can we tell the customer the heater is safe?
Tell them the unit is not covered by that recall, which is all a recall check shows. If they are worried about venting, a smell or an alarm, book a service visit.
Should we contact past customers who have a recalled model?
If your records show who has the model, a short informational call or letter is a service most customers will welcome: what the recall covers, how to read the label and the firm's contact. Keep sales offers out of that first message.
What should a CSR do if the caller has CO symptoms?
Stop the recall conversation. Tell everyone to leave the home and call 911 from outside. CDC lists headache, dizziness, weakness, upset stomach, vomiting, chest pain and confusion as common symptoms[6].
References
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (2018). Recall Effectiveness Workshop Report (opens in a new tab) β
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (2025). Recall 26-026: gas-fired tankless water heaters, carbon monoxide poisoning hazard (opens in a new tab) β
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (2024). Recall 24-137: portable tankless water heaters, fire hazard (opens in a new tab) β
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (2026). Non-Fire Carbon Monoxide Deaths Associated with the Use of Consumer Products: 2022 Annual Estimates (opens in a new tab) β
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (U.S. Code) (2026). 15 U.S. Code 2068: Prohibited acts (opens in a new tab) β
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2026). Carbon Monoxide Poisoning Basics (opens in a new tab) β
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (U.S. Code) (2026). 15 U.S. Code 2064: Substantial product hazards (opens in a new tab) β