Key takeaways
- Voicemail is a last resort, not an answering plan. Emergency callers with water on the floor rarely wait for a callback; they ring the next plumber.
- A good plumbing voicemail greeting says who you are, when you will call back, what to do in an emergency and what to leave in the message, in under twenty seconds.
- Your own outbound voicemails matter too: 67% of Americans do not answer unknown numbers but do check a voicemail if one is left[1].
- Measure the gap: compare calls that reached voicemail with messages left and messages returned, every week.
What voicemail can and cannot do
Voicemail is useful for callers who are not in a hurry: a customer asking about an invoice, a homeowner who wants an estimate next week, a supplier. For those calls, a clear greeting and a quick callback work well.
For urgent plumbing calls, voicemail is a weak safety net. A caller facing water damage, where the average homeowners claim for water damage and freezing was about $15,400 over 2019 to 2023[2], has every reason to keep dialing until a person answers. Many of them will hang up at the beep and call someone else. You can check this in your own data: count how many calls reached voicemail and how many left a message. The difference is the share who gave up.
The five parts of a good greeting
- Company name, so the caller knows they reached the right business.
- Why nobody answered, briefly and honestly: on another call, closed for the day, or the weekend.
- When you will call back, with a real time frame.
- What to do in an emergency, with a number or option that reaches a person.
- What to say in the message: name, address, the problem and the best number.
Keep the whole greeting under about twenty seconds. Record it in a quiet room, speak slowly and say the phone numbers twice.
Greetings by situation
Business hours, all lines busy:
"You've reached Granite Plumbing. We're helping other customers right now. Please leave your name, address, the problem and your best number, and we'll call you back within the hour. If water is leaking right now, press 1 to reach our emergency team."
After hours, with an emergency line:
"Thanks for calling Granite Plumbing. Our office is closed, and we'll return messages from 7:30 tomorrow morning. For an emergency like an active leak or sewage backup, call our emergency line at 555-0142, that's 555-0142. Otherwise, leave your name, address, the problem and your number."
Weekend:
"You've reached Granite Plumbing's weekend line. Leave your details and we'll call back today if it's urgent, or Monday morning for routine work. If water is leaking right now, turn off the main valve and press 1 for our on-call technician."
Holiday:
"Thanks for calling Granite Plumbing. We're closed for the holiday and back on Friday at 7:30. For emergencies, press 1. For everything else, leave a message and we'll call you first thing Friday."
Technician's business mobile:
"This is Luis from Granite Plumbing. I'm probably on a job. For a booking or a question, please call the office at 555-0100. If you're my customer today, leave a message and I'll call you right back."
Why emergencies need a live route
Plumbers are often on call for emergencies, so evening and weekend work is common in the trade[3]. Most people are not working then: only 30.3% of employed people work on an average weekend day or holiday, compared with 80.5% on a weekday[4]. If your after-hours plan is a voicemail box, it relies on the urgent caller trusting that someone will listen to it soon.
Give emergency callers a way to reach a person from the greeting itself: a "press 1" option that rings the on-call path, a separate emergency number, or live answering for nights and weekends. An SI Employee such as Ava, for example, answers in your business name at night and sends urgent jobs to the on-call technician, so the voicemail box only catches routine messages.
Greetings to avoid
- "Your call is very important to us." Callers hear it as "nobody is coming."
- No callback time at all, or "as soon as possible."
- A personal voicemail greeting on a business line: "Hey, it's Mike, leave a message."
- Reading out your full list of services and service areas.
- A full mailbox. It tells callers you are not listening. Clear messages daily.
- Greetings that still mention last season's holiday hours or a promotion that ended.
When you leave the voicemail
When your team calls customers back and reaches voicemail, the message you leave is often your only chance. In a Pew Research Center survey, 67% of Americans said their general practice is to not answer calls from unknown numbers but to check a voicemail if one is left[1].
- Do not answer, but check voicemail 67%
Source: Pew Research Center, 2020[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Do not answer, but check voicemail | 67% |
So leave one, every time:
"Hi, this is Sam from Granite Plumbing, returning your call about the leak under your kitchen sink. You can reach us at 555-0100, that's 555-0100. I've also sent you a text with the number. We have openings this afternoon."
Name the company first, mention their problem so they know it is genuine, give the number twice and offer a reason to call back. Then send a text with the same information. Most adults own a smartphone[5], and many people answer a text faster than they return a call.
Handling messages fast
Send every message to a named person
Voicemail-to-email and a text alert to whoever is on duty, not to a shared inbox nobody owns.
Set a callback target
For example within an hour in business hours and first thing in the morning for overnight routine messages.
Return urgent messages immediately
Anything mentioning water, sewage, gas or no water goes to the on-call path at once.
Log each message
Time received, time returned, outcome. Unreturned messages are missed calls.
Clear the mailbox daily
Delete processed messages so the box never fills.
Review weekly
Check messages that were not returned on time and why.
Bilingual greetings
If many of your customers speak Spanish, record the greeting in both languages, English first and then Spanish, or set up a separate Spanish-language line with its own greeting. Keep both versions short; a bilingual greeting that runs to forty seconds loses callers in both languages. Make sure someone who reads Spanish handles the Spanish messages, and return them in Spanish. A message left in Spanish and returned in English, by someone who cannot understand the reply, is a lost job and a poor first impression.
Transcripts and message summaries
Many phone systems now transcribe voicemails and email the text with the recording. Transcripts are a real help: the person on duty can scan a dozen messages in a minute and spot the urgent ones. They are not perfect, though. Addresses, street names and phone numbers are often transcribed wrongly, so always play the recording before calling back or dispatching. Set up a simple rule for the person checking messages: anything that mentions water, flooding, sewage, gas or no water is listened to first, whatever the transcript seems to say.
Measure what voicemail costs you
Add three numbers to your weekly report:
- Calls that reached voicemail.
- Messages left. The gap between the first two is callers who gave up.
- Messages returned within your target time, and how many of those booked.
If many calls reach voicemail but few leave messages, the greeting is not the main problem; coverage is. Use the missed call cost calculator to put a dollar figure on the gap.
Example: rewriting an after-hours greeting
Example: the fictional Granite Plumbing's old after-hours greeting said, "You've reached Granite Plumbing. Please leave a message after the tone." In a two-week check, 58 calls reached the after-hours mailbox and only 21 left messages.
They recorded the new after-hours greeting above, with a press-1 option to the on-call technician and a callback time for routine messages. Example: over the next two weeks, 24 callers pressed 1 and reached the on-call technician, and 19 more left detailed messages that were returned before 8:30 the next morning.
Record and test
- Record each greeting in a quiet room on the same phone system it will play from.
- Call in from a mobile and listen to every greeting: business hours, busy, after hours, weekend, holiday.
- Check that press-1 options actually ring the on-call phone at night.
- Put a calendar reminder to update holiday greetings a week before each holiday and to switch them back afterwards.
Frequently asked questions
What should a plumber's voicemail greeting say?
Your company name, why nobody answered, when you will call back, what to do in an emergency and what to include in the message. Keep it under about twenty seconds.
Should plumbers rely on voicemail after hours?
Not for emergencies. Urgent callers often hang up and call another company. Give them a live route, such as a press-1 option to the on-call technician or an answering service, and use voicemail for routine messages.
How fast should voicemails be returned?
Set a target, such as within an hour during business hours, and return anything urgent immediately. Overnight routine messages should be returned first thing in the morning.
Should we leave a voicemail when calling a customer back?
Yes. Many people do not answer unknown numbers but do check voicemail. Leave your company name, the reason for the call and your number twice, then follow up with a text.
References
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) โ
Insurance Information Institute (2019-2023). Facts + Statistics: Homeowners and renters insurance (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). American Time Use Survey, Table 4: Employed persons working and time spent working on days worked, 2025 (opens in a new tab) โ
Pew Research Center (2026). Mobile Fact Sheet (opens in a new tab) โ