Call handling

A call scorecard template for plumbing CSRs

A 12-point weighted call scorecard for plumbing CSRs with pass and fail examples, critical safety items, calibration tips and fair use of the scores.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Why a scorecard
  2. The 12 items and their weights
  3. Pass and fail examples
  4. Scoring rules
  5. Calibrate the scorers
  6. How many calls to score
  7. Using the scores
  8. After-hours and overflow calls
  9. Sharing scores without fear
  10. Reviews and the scorecard
  11. Example: scoring a call
  12. Keep the scorecard current
  13. Frequently asked questions
  14. References
Call handling: A call scorecard template for plumbing CSRsArticle coverCALL HANDLINGA call scorecardtemplate for plumbingCSRsAva for PlumbersInsightsCall handling: A call scorecard template for plumbing CSRsArticle coverCALL HANDLINGA call scorecardtemplate for plumbingCSRsAva for Plumbers

Key takeaways

  • Twelve items, weighted to 100 points, cover what matters on a plumbing call: greeting, listening, urgency, details, price, booking and recap.
  • Two safety items are critical: missing the gas script or an active-leak shutoff fails the call whatever the total.
  • Score with examples, not adjectives. Each item needs a written pass and fail description so two managers give the same score.
  • Use scores for coaching, not ranking. Negative experiences carry more weight with the public than positive ones[1], so the goal is consistency on every call.

Why a scorecard

Without a scorecard, call reviews become impressions: "that sounded fine" or "she was a bit abrupt". Impressions vary by reviewer and by mood. A scorecard turns the review into a checklist with clear standards, so CSRs know exactly what good looks like and managers measure the same things every week.

The stakes are public. Of Americans who read online reviews, 54% say they pay more attention to extremely negative reviews, against 43% for extremely positive ones[1]. A single badly handled call can become the review that a hundred future callers read.

Bad experiences carry more weight with review readersShare of Americans who read online reviews and say they pay more attention to each type, 2016.
Bad experiences carry more weight with review readersComparison. Extremely negative reviews: 54%; Extremely positive reviews: 43%.54%Extremely negative reviewsExtremely negative reviews: 54%43%Extremely positive reviewsExtremely positive reviews: 43%Bad experiences carry more weight with review readersComparison. Extremely negative reviews: 54%; Extremely positive reviews: 43%.54%Extremely negative reviewsExtremely negative reviews: 54%43%Extremely positive reviewsExtremely positive reviews: 43%

Source: Pew Research Center, 2016[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Extremely negative reviews54%
Extremely positive reviews43%

The 12 items and their weights

  1. 1. Greeting (5 points)

    Company name, the CSR's first name and an open question within the first few seconds. Pass: "Thanks for calling Kingsley Plumbing, this is Ana. How can I help?" Fail: "Hello?" or "Please hold."

  2. 2. Listens before questioning (8 points)

    Lets the caller describe the problem without interrupting for the first part of the call. Fail: jumps straight to name and address while the caller is explaining a leak.

  3. 3. Urgency check (12 points, critical)

    Asks whether water, sewage or gas is involved and follows the right path. A caller who mentions gas must hear the gas script: leave, no switches, call 911 and the gas company from outside. Missing it fails the whole call.

  4. 4. Damage control (8 points, critical when relevant)

    For an active leak, helps the caller find and close the shutoff, within safe boundaries. Missing it on an active leak fails the call. Water damage and freezing claims averaged about $15,400 over 2019 to 2023[2], so minutes matter.

  5. 5. Problem capture (8 points)

    Asks the clarifying questions that decide the job: where, how long, one fixture or several, anything tried already.

  6. 6. Address and access (8 points)

    Service address, ZIP code, gate codes, parking, pets and who will be there.

  7. 7. Contact number confirmed (7 points)

    Reads the mobile number back in groups. Tells the caller which number will call them, because 80% of Americans say they generally do not answer calls from unknown numbers[3].

  8. 8. Decision-maker and billing (6 points)

    Asks whether the caller owns the property or rents it, and who approves the work if it is a rental or commercial site.

  9. 9. Price conversation (10 points)

    States the visit or diagnostic fee clearly, explains what it covers and avoids guessing repair prices.

  10. 10. Offers two specific slots (10 points)

    Gives two windows and asks the caller to choose. Fail: "When are you free?"

  11. 11. Recap and expectations (10 points)

    Repeats the problem, address, window and what happens next, including the on-the-way call.

  12. 12. Tone and courtesy (8 points)

    Calm, warm and confident throughout; uses the caller's name; no talking over them; thanks them at the end.

The weights add up to 100. Adjust them to your business, but keep urgency, price, slots and recap near the top. Those are the items that most often decide whether a call books and whether the customer is happy.

Pass and fail examples

Example pass and fail lines for selected items
ItemPassFail
Urgency check"Is anything leaking or backing up right now?"Books a routine slot without asking
Price conversation"Our visit fee covers finding the cause, and you'll get a firm price before any work.""Probably a couple of hundred, depends."
Two slots"Tomorrow 8 to 10, or today 3 to 5?""What day works for you?"
Contact number"Let me read that back: 4-1-5, 5-5-5, 0-1-9-8."Types the number without confirming
Recap"So that's the slow drain upstairs at 41 Birch Lane, tomorrow 8 to 10, and Luis will call when he's on the way.""OK, we'll see you then."
ToneCalm and steady with an upset callerDefensive: "That's not our fault."

Write the same kind of table for every item in your own scorecard. Specific lines make scoring consistent and give CSRs words to copy.

Scoring rules

  1. Score only items that apply. If a call had no rental question to ask, mark item 8 as not applicable and score out of the remaining points.
  2. Critical items override the total. Missing the gas script or the active-leak shutoff is an automatic fail.
  3. Partial credit is allowed: half points when an item was attempted but incomplete, such as one slot offered instead of two.
  4. Score from the recording, not from the CSR's notes.
  5. Write one sentence of feedback for the lowest-scoring item on every scored call.

Calibrate the scorers

Two managers will score the same call differently until they practice together. Once a month, have everyone who scores calls listen to the same three recordings and score them separately. Compare the results item by item. Where scores differ by more than a couple of points, discuss the call and agree how to score it, then add a note to the pass and fail table. After a few months, scores from different reviewers should be close.

How many calls to score

Score a small, regular sample rather than a big batch now and then. A practical rhythm for a small office is a few calls per CSR per week, chosen from three groups: one booked new-customer call, one lost call and one urgent or after-hours call. That mix shows how the CSR handles the calls that matter most, not just the easy ones.

Using the scores

  • Use scores in weekly coaching. Pick the lowest-scoring item across the week and make it the coaching focus.
  • Share each CSR's scores with them privately. Share the team average openly.
  • Look for patterns across the team. If everyone scores low on recaps, the script or training needs to change.
  • Avoid ranking CSRs on a wall chart. It encourages people to avoid hard calls.
  • If you link pay to quality, use averages over a month or more and a clear written policy.

After-hours and overflow calls

Score a sample of calls answered outside the main office: the on-call line, overflow to the dispatcher or owner, and any outside answering option you use. These calls are often the most urgent, and they are rarely reviewed.

Use the same twelve items, with two adjustments. For item 10, offering the on-call technician now or the first morning window counts as offering two options. For item 11, the recap must include an honest expectation of when someone will call or arrive. If an outside service answers for you, share the scorecard with them and ask for recordings of a few calls each month. Their callers are your customers, and they deserve the same standard.

Sharing scores without fear

CSRs accept scorecards when they see them used to help, not to punish. Introduce the scorecard by scoring a few of the manager's own calls first and sharing the results. Let each CSR pick one call a week to be scored, alongside the ones you choose. Celebrate improvements on specific items in team meetings, such as "every booking this week had a recap", rather than announcing who scored highest. When a score is low, start the conversation with the recording, not the number.

Reviews and the scorecard

Some shops add an item for asking the customer to leave a review. If you do, be careful with incentives. The FTC's rule on consumer reviews bans offering compensation or incentives conditioned on a review expressing a particular sentiment[4]. Asking every customer for honest feedback is fine; offering a discount only for five-star reviews is not. Keep any review request neutral and send it after the job, not during the booking call.

Example: scoring a call

Example: a fictional CSR, Jamal, handles a first-time caller with a leaking water heater. He greets well, lets the caller explain, asks whether water is spreading and helps the caller close the cold-water valve on top of the heater. He takes the address and access notes, reads back the number and asks whether the caller owns the home.

He explains the visit fee clearly but offers only one time window, and his recap leaves out the on-the-way call. Example score: items 1 to 9 earn full points (72 of 72), item 10 earns half (5 of 10), item 11 earns 7 of 10 and item 12 earns 8 of 8, for a total of 92 out of 100. No critical item was missed, so the call passes. Coaching focus for the week: always offer two windows, and finish every recap with the on-the-way call.

Keep the scorecard current

Review the scorecard every six months. Remove items that every CSR now passes every time, and add items for new problems you hear on calls, such as a new service area, a new fee or a new type of caller. A scorecard that never changes stops being read. Pair it with a regular coaching routine using recordings and your new-customer call script.

Frequently asked questions

What should a plumbing CSR call scorecard include?

Greeting, listening, an urgency check, damage control for active leaks, problem details, address and access, a confirmed contact number, decision-maker and billing, the price conversation, two offered slots, a recap and tone.

Should some scorecard items be automatic fails?

Yes. Safety items such as giving the gas script when a caller smells gas, or helping with the shutoff during an active leak, should fail the call if missed, whatever the total score.

How many calls should be scored per CSR?

A few each week, mixing a booked new-customer call, a lost call and an urgent or after-hours call, is enough to see patterns and guide coaching.

Can we reward CSRs for getting good reviews?

Be careful. The FTC bans incentives conditioned on reviews expressing a particular sentiment. Encourage honest reviews from every customer, and reward call quality using your scorecard instead.

References

  1. Pew Research Center (2016). Online Reviews (Online Shopping and E-Commerce) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. Insurance Information Institute (2019-2023). Facts + Statistics: Homeowners and renters insurance (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo