Hiring training

Tool allowances and who buys the tools

Who buys the tools in a plumbing company: five tool policy models, how allowances are taxed, wage deduction limits, California rules and a checklist.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Why tool policy causes friction
  2. Five ways to handle tools
  3. Choosing the right model for your shop
  4. Tracking company tools
  5. Federal limits on making techs pay
  6. California and other state rules
  7. Allowances, reimbursement and tax
  8. Tools as a recruiting and retention tool
  9. Writing the policy
  10. Example: moving from a messy mix to a clear split
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References
Hiring training: Tool allowances and who buys the toolsArticle coverHIRING TRAININGTool allowances and whobuys the toolsAva for PlumbersInsightsHiring training: Tool allowances and who buys the toolsArticle coverHIRING TRAININGTool allowances andwho buys the toolsAva for Plumbers

Key takeaways

  • Most shops split tools: techs supply basic hand tools, the company supplies power, specialty and diagnostic equipment.
  • Under federal law, tool costs you require techs to cover cannot cut their pay below minimum wage or reduce overtime owed in any workweek[1].
  • California's construction wage order requires employers to provide required tools, except that employees earning at least twice the minimum wage may supply hand tools customary in the trade[2].
  • Business expense reimbursements are excluded from the overtime regular rate[3]; a flat allowance with no receipts is usually treated as taxable wages.
  • Put ownership, loss, theft and return rules in writing before the first tool is handed out.

Why tool policy causes friction

Tools are personal for plumbers. Many techs have spent thousands building a kit they trust, and they notice when a new hire gets a free company set or when a stolen drill is deducted from a paycheck. BLS describes plumbing as physical work that involves lifting heavy materials, climbing ladders and working in tight spaces[4], so the right tools also affect safety and speed. A clear policy prevents most disputes.

There is also a pay angle. Plumber pay ranges from about $21.22 an hour at the 10th percentile to $52.13 at the 90th[5]. A tool requirement that a senior tech barely notices can be a real burden for a helper near the bottom of that range, which is where the wage rules below bite.

Hourly pay of US plumbers, pipefitters and steamfitters, 2025
Hourly pay of US plumbers, pipefitters and steamfitters, 2025Bar chart. 10th percentile: $21.22; Median: $30.67; 90th percentile: $52.13.10th percentile10th percentile: $21.22$21.22MedianMedian: $30.67$30.6790th percentile90th percentile: $52.13$52.13Hourly pay of US plumbers, pipefitters and steamfitters, 2025Bar chart. 10th percentile: $21.22; Median: $30.67; 90th percentile: $52.13.10th percentile10th percentile: $21.22$21.22MedianMedian: $30.67$30.6790th percentile90th percentile: $52.13$52.13

Source: O*NET OnLine (U.S. Department of Labor), BLS 2025 wage data, 2025[5]

Show the data
ItemValue
10th percentile$21.22
Median$30.67
90th percentile$52.13

Five ways to handle tools

Tool policy models for plumbing companies
ModelHow it worksGood forWatch out for
Tech-supplied hand toolsTechs bring a defined list of hand tools; the company supplies everything elseExperienced teams, traditional shopsWage deduction rules, uneven kits
Company-supplied everythingCompany buys and owns all toolsApprentice-heavy teams, recruitingCost, loss and care of tools
Flat tool allowanceFixed amount per pay period or year, no receiptsSimplicityUsually taxable wages; no control over what is bought
Reimbursement with receiptsCompany repays approved tool purchases against receiptsFair and controlledAdmin work; needs written rules
Tool purchase programCompany buys tools at trade pricing; tech repays through payrollHelping new techs build a kitDeduction limits and written consent

The most common split is a defined hand-tool list supplied by the tech, with the company owning power tools, press tools, drain machines, cameras, jetters, locators and test equipment. That keeps expensive equipment insured and maintained by the company while respecting techs' personal kits.

Choosing the right model for your shop

No single model is right for every company. Use these questions to pick one, then write it down so every tech is treated the same way.

  • How many apprentices and helpers do you hire? Shops that grow their own techs usually need to supply more, because new hires cannot afford a full kit and some states do not allow you to require one.
  • How much specialty equipment do you use? Cameras, jetters, locators and press tools are expensive and need maintenance; company ownership keeps them working.
  • How often are tools lost or stolen? High theft areas favor company-owned, tagged and insured tools.
  • How much admin can the office handle? Reimbursement with receipts is fair but needs someone to approve and file claims.
  • What do competitors offer? If every shop nearby supplies tools, asking techs to buy their own is a recruiting handicap.

Tracking company tools

Company-owned tools disappear without a system. Tag every item worth tracking with an asset number, record which truck or tech it is assigned to, and check it during routine truck inspections. Shared equipment such as jetters and sewer cameras works best with a simple check-out log or a booking calendar in your field software, so dispatch knows where it is before promising a camera inspection. Review the asset list quarterly and decide what to repair, replace or retire, and photograph high-value tools so insurance claims after a theft move faster.

Federal limits on making techs pay

The federal minimum wage and overtime rules require wages to be paid free and clear. If an employer requires an employee to provide tools of the trade used in the employer's work, there is a violation in any workweek where the cost of those tools cuts the employee's pay below the required minimum wage or overtime[1]. The same logic applies to deductions for tools the company buys on the tech's behalf.

  • Check the effect in the week the cost falls, not averaged over a year.
  • Be careful with overtime weeks; a deduction can reduce the overtime owed.
  • Get written consent for any payroll deduction, and follow state rules, which are often stricter than federal law.
  • Avoid deducting the cost of lost or damaged tools from a final paycheck without advice; many states restrict this.

California and other state rules

State law can go further. California's wage order for on-site construction occupations says that when tools or equipment are required by the employer or necessary to do the job, the employer must provide and maintain them, except that an employee whose wages are at least two times the minimum wage may provide and maintain hand tools and equipment customarily required by the trade or craft[2]. In practice, a California helper earning below that level cannot be required to buy their own hand tools.

Other states have their own rules on deductions, reimbursement of business expenses and final pay. If you operate in more than one state, write the policy to the strictest one or create state-specific addenda.

Allowances, reimbursement and tax

How you pay for tools changes the tax treatment and the overtime math. The Labor Department's regular rate guidance lists reimbursement of business expenses among the payments excluded from the regular rate[3]. A real reimbursement, tied to receipts for approved tools, therefore does not raise overtime.

A flat allowance paid regardless of what the tech buys is different. It is usually treated as taxable wages, and if it works like extra pay rather than a reimbursement it may also need to be included in the regular rate. Ask your payroll provider to set up tool payments under an accountable plan if you want them treated as non-taxable reimbursements: that generally means a business purpose, receipts within a reasonable time and returning any excess.

Decide what you want the payment to do. If the goal is to help techs build a kit, reimbursement with receipts is cleaner. If the goal is simply higher take-home pay, raise the wage rather than calling it a tool allowance.

Tools as a recruiting and retention tool

Tool policy shows up in job interviews more often than owners expect. Candidates ask whether they must bring a full kit, who owns the press tool and what happens when a drill is stolen from a van. A clear answer, such as a starter kit for apprentices, company-owned power and diagnostic tools and a yearly reimbursement for hand tools, is easy to put in a job post and compares well with shops that leave it vague. It also helps retention: techs who feel the company invests in their equipment are less likely to leave for a shop that does. Ask about tools in stay interviews and fix the complaints that come up repeatedly.

Writing the policy

  1. Define the hand-tool list

    List exactly which tools each level is expected to carry, from helper to senior tech. Vague lists cause disputes.

  2. List company-owned equipment

    Name the equipment the company provides, who it is assigned to and how it is tracked, such as asset tags or a check-out log.

  3. Set the payment model

    Choose supplied, reimbursed, allowance or purchase program, with amounts, approval steps and timing.

  4. Cover loss, theft and damage

    Say who pays when a company tool is stolen from a locked van, damaged through normal use or lost through carelessness, and how claims are reviewed.

  5. Set replacement rules

    Normal wear on company tools is replaced by the company. Decide whether you help replace a tech's own tools if they break on the job.

  6. Cover return on departure

    List company tools on a signed receipt, check them in on the last day and follow state rules on any deductions.

  7. Sign and review yearly

    Have each tech sign the policy and review it when you change equipment or pay plans.

Example: moving from a messy mix to a clear split

Example (fictional): a 10-tech shop has no written policy. Some techs use their own press tools, others borrow the company's, and two techs argue over who owns a drain camera. The owner writes a policy: techs supply a defined hand-tool list, the company owns and tags all power, press and diagnostic tools, and new apprentices get a starter hand-tool kit after 90 days.

Example (fictional) money: the company reimburses approved hand-tool purchases up to a yearly cap against receipts, through an accountable plan set up by its payroll provider. Techs who bring their own press tools are offered a fair price for them or a reimbursement for wear. Disputes stop because the asset list shows who owns what. For related policies, see take-home truck policies and continuing education budgets.

Frequently asked questions

Do plumbers have to buy their own tools?

It depends on the employer and the state. Many shops ask techs to supply basic hand tools and provide power and specialty equipment. Federal law bars tool costs from cutting pay below minimum wage or overtime in any workweek, and California requires employers to provide tools unless the employee earns at least twice the minimum wage, and even then only customary hand tools can be required.

Is a tool allowance taxable?

A flat allowance paid without receipts is usually taxable wages. Reimbursements for approved tools made under an accountable plan, with receipts and return of any excess, are generally not. Confirm the setup with your payroll provider.

Can I deduct a lost tool from a tech's paycheck?

Be careful. Federal law prohibits deductions that cut pay below minimum wage or overtime, and many states restrict deductions for loss or damage. Get written consent and check your state's rules first.

References

  1. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 29 CFR 531.35 โ€” Free and clear payment; kickbacks (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. California Department of Industrial Relations (2025). IWC Wage Order 16-2001: Certain On-Site Occupations in the Construction, Drilling, Logging and Mining Industries (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. U.S. Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division (2019). Fact Sheet #56A: Overview of the Regular Rate of Pay Under the FLSA (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  5. O*NET OnLine (U.S. Department of Labor), BLS 2025 wage data (2025). National Wages 47-2152.00 - Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo