Key takeaways
- FEMA notes that sump pumps will not work when the electricity is off; a battery or generator is needed for outages[1].
- Sump pumps handle groundwater, not sewer backups; a backwater valve is a different fix for a different problem[1].
- Water damage and freezing caused 22.6% of homeowners insurance losses in 2023[2]; use it as context, not as a scare.
- Time the conversation before the wet season and after storms, and get consent before automated seasonal outreach[3].
An honest sale when it is done right
Few upgrades are as easy to justify as a sump pump in good order. A basement that floods once can cost far more than the pump, and a pump that fails silently during a storm is the most common way it happens. That also makes sump pumps easy to oversell, with talk of flooded basements to homeowners whose pit has never held water.
The honest approach is the same as for any recommendation: inspect, explain what you see, give options and let the customer decide. What follows is a practical guide to the inspection, the options and the conversation, with the timing that makes it useful rather than opportunistic.
When to raise it
- Late winter, before snowmelt and spring storms, when homeowners are thinking about the basement anyway.
- During any service call in a basement with a sump pit, as part of a quick look-around.
- After a storm or a power outage in your area, for customers who have called about water in the basement.
- During member inspections, where the sump pump belongs on the checklist.
- When a customer finishes a basement, because the cost of failure just went up.
The worst time is mid-storm, when a homeowner calls with water rising. Fix the problem first; the upgrade conversation can wait until the basement is dry and the customer can think clearly. Offering a battery backup while someone is bailing water feels like taking advantage, even when it is good advice.
The questions that frame the risk
FEMA's urban flooding guidance for homeowners includes a short set of questions for basements[1]. They make a good opening because they are neutral and the homeowner answers them, not the technician.
- Does your basement have a sump pump?
- Has water ever backed up through the floor drain?
- Does the sump pump have battery backup?
- Is there an alarm to warn you that the water level has risen above the top of the sump?
- Is the sump pump maintained annually?
If the answers are yes, no, yes, yes and yes, the customer probably needs nothing but a routine check. If several are no, you have the beginning of an honest recommendation, and the customer has reached it with you.
What to inspect
Pit and inflow
Look at the pit size, the liner, debris and how much water is coming in. Ask how often the pump runs in wet weather.
Pump age and condition
Find the install date if possible, check for corrosion and listen to it run by lifting the float or filling the pit with a bucket.
Float and switch
Make sure the float moves freely and is not snagging on the pit wall or the discharge pipe.
Check valve and discharge
Confirm a check valve is fitted and working, and follow the discharge line outside. It should carry water away from the foundation and not freeze or clog.
Power
Check the outlet, whether it is on a dedicated circuit and whether the cord is in good condition. Note whether an alarm is present.
Record and photograph
Age, run test result, check valve condition and discharge route, all in the job record.
The discharge line deserves attention in cold climates. The American Red Cross notes that pipes exposed to severe cold or running through unheated spaces are the ones that freeze most often[4]; a frozen discharge line can leave a working pump with nowhere to send the water.
Options to present
| Option | What it does | Limits | Fits when |
|---|---|---|---|
| Service and test | Clean pit, test pump, check valve and float | Does not change capacity or add backup | Pump is young and working |
| Replace primary pump | New pump sized for inflow | Still stops in a power outage | Pump is old, noisy or failing |
| Add battery backup pump | Second pump runs on battery when power fails or primary fails | Battery runtime is limited and batteries need replacing | Finished basement, frequent outages |
| Add high-water alarm | Alerts the household when water rises above the normal level | Warns but does not pump | Any basement with a sump, low-cost first step |
| Generator connection | Keeps the primary pump running in long outages | Needs safe installation and fuel | Long outages are common in the area |
Present the options in order and let the customer choose a level of protection. A high-water alarm on its own is a perfectly reasonable choice for a dry basement; a finished basement with a history of outages may justify a new primary pump, a battery backup and an alarm together.
Battery backup in plain words
FEMA's guidance is direct: sump pumps are not designed to handle large amounts of water, and they will not work when the electricity is off; you would need to add battery storage or a generator if you want the pump to work during an outage[1]. That sentence is often the whole case for a backup. Storms that bring heavy rain also bring outages, which is when the primary pump stops.
Be clear about limits. A battery backup runs for a limited time depending on the battery and how often the pump cycles, and batteries need replacing on a schedule. Put the battery date on a label and in the job record, and add a battery check to the member visit. For generators, point customers to FEMA's guidance on using generators safely[1], and never set up a generator connection that could backfeed the grid.
Sump pumps do not stop sewer backups
Customers often assume a sump pump protects against every kind of basement water. It does not. FEMA explains that during extreme rainfall, stormwater and sewage can back up into basements through the sewer drain lines[1]. The Insurance Information Institute notes that problems arise where systems combine stormwater and raw sewage in the same pipe, and that backed-up sewers have been increasing about 3% a year, according to the Civil Engineering Research Foundation[5].
If the customer's water came up through a floor drain or toilet, the conversation is about a backwater valve, not a bigger pump. Recommending backwater valves after sewer backups covers that. Getting this distinction right is the clearest sign to a customer that you are diagnosing rather than selling.
Insurance without overpromising
Water damage is common and costly. Water damage and freezing caused 22.6% of US homeowners insurance losses in 2023, down from 28.7% in 2019, and the average claim was about $15,400 over 2019 to 2023[2]. Technicians should not interpret a customer's policy. FEMA's advice is simply to review the policy or call the agent to understand what coverage exists for sewer backups and water damage[1]. Suggest that; do not promise that a new pump will lower premiums or guarantee a claim.
Source: Insurance Information Institute, 2019-2023[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| 2019 | 28.7% |
| 2023 | 22.6% |
Seasonal outreach that respects consent
A late-winter reminder to customers with sump pumps on file is useful and welcome when it is informational: the pump's age, the last check date and an offer to test it before spring. If you plan to use automated calls or prerecorded messages, remember that the FCC requires prior express written consent for telemarketing robocalls and treats AI-generated voices as artificial under the TCPA[3]. Letters, emails and personal calls from the office are simpler to get right.
A short script
โYour sump pump ran fine when I tested it, and the check valve is good. It's about nine years old and there's no backup, so if the power goes out in a storm it'll stop. Some customers add a battery backup and an alarm; some just add the alarm. I can give you prices for both, or we can leave it as is and check it again next year.โ
Example: a finished basement
Example (fictional): during a water heater visit, the technician asks FEMA's five questions. The customer has a sump pump, no backup, no alarm, and recently finished the basement. The run test is fine but the pump is about ten years old and the check valve chatters. The technician offers three options: replace the check valve and add an alarm; replace the pump and check valve and add an alarm; or all of that plus a battery backup. The customer chooses the full set, and the battery date goes on the member visit checklist for a reminder.
Frequently asked questions
Does a sump pump work during a power outage?
Not on its own. FEMA notes sump pumps will not work when electricity is off; you need battery storage or a generator for that[1].
Will a sump pump stop sewage backing up into the basement?
No. Sewer backups come through drain lines; FEMA describes backwater valves as the device that lets wastewater out while preventing backups[1].
How often should a sump pump be checked?
FEMA's homeowner checklist asks whether the pump is maintained annually[1]. A yearly test, plus a check before the wet season, is a sensible routine.
Should we tell customers a backup will lower their insurance?
No. Suggest they review their policy or talk to their agent about coverage for water damage and sewer backup. Do not promise premium changes.
References
Federal Emergency Management Agency (2024 (revised 2025)). Urban Flooding: Guidance for Homeowners and Renters (Cook County, IL, Mitigation Assessment Team) (opens in a new tab) โ
Insurance Information Institute (2019-2023). Facts + Statistics: Homeowners and renters insurance (opens in a new tab) โ
Federal Communications Commission (2024). FCC Makes AI-Generated Voices in Robocalls Illegal (news release) (opens in a new tab) โ
American Red Cross (2026). Frozen Pipes (opens in a new tab) โ
Insurance Information Institute (n.d.). Protect your house from sewer backups (opens in a new tab) โ