Reviews customer experience

Review count vs star rating: what customers weigh

What research says customers weigh in reviews (the first few, ratings of 4.0 to 4.7, negative reviews, recency) and what plumbers should prioritize.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing6 min read

On this page
  1. The three numbers a customer sees
  2. Count: the first five matter most
  3. Rating: why 4.7 can beat 5.0
  4. Negative reviews weigh more than positive ones
  5. Recency: the signal owners forget
  6. Big-ticket jobs need more proof
  7. What the phone screen shows first
  8. Setting a sensible review flow
  9. What to prioritize in your situation
  10. Audit your profile in 20 minutes
  11. Read the research with care
  12. Example: which profile wins the call?
  13. Frequently asked questions
  14. References
Reviews customer experience: Review count vs star rating: what customers weighArticle coverREVIEWS CUSTOMER EXPERIENCEReview count vs starrating: what customersweighAva for PlumbersInsightsReviews customer experience: Review count vs star rating: what customers weighArticle coverREVIEWS CUSTOMER EXPERIENCEReview count vs starrating: whatcustomers weighAva for Plumbers

Key takeaways

  • The first handful of reviews do the most work: in Spiegel Research Center data, a product with five reviews was 270% more likely to be bought than one with none[1].
  • A perfect score is not the goal. Purchase likelihood tended to peak for ratings between 4.0 and 4.7[1].
  • Negative reviews carry extra weight: 54% of US review readers pay more attention to extremely negative ones[2].
  • Reviews mattered more for higher-priced items, which is where water heaters, repipes and sewer lines sit[1].
  • Recency is visible on every profile. A steady flow beats a large but stale total.

The three numbers a customer sees

When a homeowner scrolls the map results, each plumbing company is reduced to a few signals: the star rating, the number of reviews and, a tap later, how recent the newest ones are. They are judged together, quickly, often on a phone screen showing only the first two or three reviews.

What each review signal tells a customer at a glance.
SignalWhat the customer infersCommon mistake
Star ratingQuality and consistencyChasing a perfect 5.0 and treating every four-star review as a failure
Review countSize, track record, how many people trust themAssuming hundreds of reviews are needed before reviews help
RecencyWhether the business is active and still goodCollecting reviews in bursts, then going quiet for months
Owner repliesWhether anyone is paying attentionReplying only to complaints, or not at all

Count: the first five matter most

The best-known study on this comes from Northwestern University’s Spiegel Research Center, which analyzed purchase data from online retailers. It found that the purchase likelihood for a product with five reviews was 270% greater than for one with no reviews, and that returns diminished quickly after those first five[1].

How much reviews raised purchase likelihood in retail dataSpiegel Research Center, Northwestern University, 2017
How much reviews raised purchase likelihood in retail dataColumn chart. Five reviews vs none: 270%; Reviews shown, lower-priced item: 190%; Reviews shown, higher-priced item: 380%.0%100%200%300%400%Five reviews vs none: 270%270%Five reviews vs noneReviews shown, lower-priced item: 190%190%Reviews shown, lower-priceditemReviews shown, higher-priced item: 380%380%Reviews shown, higher-priceditemHow much reviews raised purchase likelihood in retail dataColumn chart. Five reviews vs none: 270%; Reviews shown, lower-priced item: 190%; Reviews shown, higher-priced item: 380%.Five reviews vs noneFive reviews vs none: 270%270%Reviews shown, lower-priced itemReviews shown, lower-priced item: 190%190%Reviews shown, higher-priced itemReviews shown, higher-priced item: 380%380%

Source: Spiegel Research Center, Medill, Northwestern University, 2017[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Five reviews vs none270%
Reviews shown, lower-priced item190%
Reviews shown, higher-priced item380%

The lesson for a small plumbing company is encouraging. You do not need hundreds of reviews before reviews start to help. Getting from zero to a handful of genuine, detailed reviews is the steepest part of the benefit. After that, count still matters, especially against local competitors, but the marginal review is worth less than keeping the flow recent.

Count also feeds where you appear. Google says prominence is based partly on how many reviews you have, and that more reviews and positive ratings can help local ranking[3]. So volume works on both the click and the ranking.

Rating: why 4.7 can beat 5.0

Spiegel found that purchase likelihood typically peaked for ratings in the 4.0 to 4.7 range and then fell as ratings approached a perfect 5.0[1]. Shoppers seem to read a flawless score as too good to be true. A few honest four-star reviews, and a calm reply to the occasional complaint, make the rest more believable.

4.0–4.7

star range where purchase likelihood typically peaked in Spiegel Research Center data[1]

That does not make low ratings acceptable. It means the target is a high, credible rating built from every customer, not a perfect one protected by asking only happy customers, which Google’s policies prohibit. If your rating is below 4.0, the cause is usually operational, and the fix starts in the field, not in the review process.

Negative reviews weigh more than positive ones

Readers do not treat all reviews equally. Pew found that 54% of Americans who read reviews pay more attention to extremely negative ones, compared with 43% for extremely positive ones[2]. One detailed one-star review near the top of your profile can therefore offset several five-star reviews in a reader’s mind, at least until they see how you responded.

Two practical consequences follow. First, a reply to every negative review is part of your rating, in effect. Second, a large count protects you: a single bad review among hundreds is visibly an exception, while among a dozen it looks like a pattern.

Recency: the signal owners forget

A customer who sees that your newest review is ten months old will wonder whether the business has changed hands, lost its good techs or closed. Recency is not a number most studies isolate cleanly, but it is visible on every profile, and it is the signal you control most directly week to week.

Seasonality makes this worse for plumbers. Many shops collect a wave of reviews in the winter emergency season and very few in spring. A shop that asks every customer all year keeps a fresh review at the top even in slow months. Because only around one in ten Americans nearly always post reviews unprompted, recency depends almost entirely on asking[4].

Big-ticket jobs need more proof

Spiegel also found the effect of reviews was larger for higher-priced products: displaying reviews raised the conversion rate by 380% for a higher-priced product, against 190% for a lower-priced one[1]. Customers want more reassurance when more money is at stake.

For plumbers, this points to where detailed reviews are most valuable: water heater replacements, repiping, sewer line work, tankless conversions and remodel rough-ins. Make sure customers for those jobs are always asked, and that the reviews describe the job type. Those are the reviews a future customer facing a large bill will look for. Pew’s finding that 40% of Americans nearly always rely on online reviews when making purchasing decisions suggests that many of those customers will read before they call[5].

What the phone screen shows first

Most homeowners judge you on a phone: 91% of US adults own a smartphone[6]. On that small screen, the rating and count appear beside your name, and only two or three reviews show before the customer has to tap or scroll. Those first reviews carry far more weight than review number 150.

Check what appears first on your own profile from a phone, signed out. If the top reviews are old, short or about a job type you rarely do, the fix is not to hide them but to add new, specific reviews from current work. A reply under each visible review also shows up in that first glance.

Setting a sensible review flow

Rather than a total to hit, set a flow you can sustain. Start from completed jobs: if your team completes 60 jobs a month and asks every customer, even a modest response gives you a new review most weeks. Track reviews per 100 completed jobs and the age of your newest review, and treat a gap of more than a couple of weeks as a sign that asks have slipped.

This also smooths seasonality. A steady ask on every job, all year, keeps recency healthy in quiet months without any special campaign.

What to prioritize in your situation

Match your review effort to where your profile is weakest.
Your profilePriorityWhy
Fewer than about 10 reviewsAsk every customer until you have a solid baseThe early reviews do the most work
Many reviews, newest months oldRestart the habit; aim for weekly reviewsRecency is visible and easy to fix
Perfect 5.0 from few reviewsKeep asking everyone; accept some four-star reviewsA believable rating beats a perfect small sample
Rating below 4.0Fix the operational cause firstMore reviews will repeat the same complaints
High count, few repliesStart replying to new reviewsReplies show an active, attentive business

Audit your profile in 20 minutes

  1. Record your numbers

    Rating, total reviews, date of the newest review, and how many of the last 20 have an owner reply.

  2. Record three competitors

    The same four numbers for the plumbers who appear beside you most often.

  3. Read your last 20 reviews

    Note job types mentioned. Are big-ticket jobs represented?

  4. Check on a phone

    See which reviews appear first in the mobile view; that is what most customers read.

  5. Pick one priority

    Use the table above to choose the one change that would most improve how your profile reads.

Read the research with care

The Spiegel figures come from online retail purchases, published in 2017, not from plumbing calls. The Pew figures come from a 2016 national survey. Neither tells you exactly how many reviews a plumber needs. What they show consistently is the shape of the effect: the first reviews matter most, a credible rating beats a perfect one, negative reviews draw attention, and reviews matter more as the price rises. Use your own data, such as calls from your profile month by month, to judge what works locally.

Example: which profile wins the call?

Example (fictional): Profile A shows 4.9 stars from 18 reviews, newest yesterday, with owner replies on all of them, several mentioning water heater installs. Profile B shows 5.0 from 9 reviews, newest four months ago, no replies. Profile C shows 4.6 from 420 reviews, newest last week, a few recent complaints with calm replies.

In this example a homeowner with a failed water heater is likely to call A or C. A looks active and specific to their job; C looks large, established and responsive. B’s perfect score is undermined by its age and silence. The difference between A and B is not quality of work; it is the habit of asking and replying. See encouraging customers to name techs and the plumbing customer journey for what makes reviews specific.

Frequently asked questions

Is review count or star rating more important?

Both matter and work together. Research suggests the first few reviews do the most work and that ratings between about 4.0 and 4.7 are trusted more than a perfect 5.0. Recency matters too.

Is a perfect 5.0 rating bad?

Not bad, but it can look less believable, especially with few reviews. Keep asking every customer and accept honest four-star reviews.

How recent should my newest review be?

As recent as your normal job flow allows. If you ask every customer, a busy shop should rarely go more than a week or two without a new review.

Do reviews matter more for big jobs?

Research on retail purchases found reviews had a larger effect on higher-priced items, so make sure customers for water heaters, repipes and sewer work are always asked.

References

  1. Spiegel Research Center, Medill, Northwestern University (2017). How Online Reviews Influence Sales (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Pew Research Center (2016). Online Reviews (Online Shopping and E-Commerce) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Google Business Profile Help (2026). Tips to improve your local ranking on Google (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Pew Research Center (2016). Online Reviews (Online Shopping and E-Commerce) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Pew Research Center (2016). Online Reviews (Online Shopping and E-Commerce) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Pew Research Center (2026). Mobile Fact Sheet (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo