Reviews customer experience

Removing fake or competitor reviews on Google

How plumbers can report fake, competitor or ex-employee Google reviews: what qualifies, the evidence that helps, the appeal and what to do meanwhile.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing6 min read

On this page
  1. Why one bad fake review matters
  2. First, check whether it is really fake
  3. What Google’s policies cover
  4. Build the evidence pack
  5. How to flag a review
  6. What to do while you wait
  7. Former employees and competitors
  8. When the answer is no
  9. Keep an incident log
  10. Prevention through real reviews
  11. Example: a burst of one-star reviews
  12. Frequently asked questions
  13. References
Reviews customer experience: Removing fake or competitor reviews on GoogleArticle coverREVIEWS CUSTOMER EXPERIENCERemoving fake orcompetitor reviews onGoogleAva for PlumbersInsightsReviews customer experience: Removing fake or competitor reviews on GoogleArticle coverREVIEWS CUSTOMER EXPERIENCERemoving fake orcompetitor reviews onGoogleAva for Plumbers

Key takeaways

  • Google removes reviews that break its policies, such as fake engagement and conflicts of interest from competitors or former employees, not reviews you simply disagree with[1][2].
  • Build an evidence pack before you flag: job records, phone logs, timing and any link to a competitor or ex-employee.
  • Review evaluation typically takes several days; if a report fails you get a one-time appeal[1].
  • Reply calmly while you wait. 54% of review readers pay more attention to extremely negative reviews[3].
  • Never answer with threats. The FTC rule bans unfounded legal threats and intimidation used to suppress reviews[4].

Why one bad fake review matters

A single fake one-star review sits at the top of a small shop’s profile for weeks. Readers lean on what they see there: 82% of US adults at least sometimes read reviews before a first purchase, and 40% nearly always rely on reviews[5].

How much US adults lean on online reviewsPew Research Center, 2016
How much US adults lean on online reviewsBar chart. At least sometimes read reviews before a first purchase: 82%; Say reviews help a lot to feel confident: 46%; Nearly always rely on reviews: 40%.At least sometimes read reviews before a first purchaseAt least sometimes read reviews before a first purchase: 82%82%Say reviews help a lot to feel confidentSay reviews help a lot to feel confident: 46%46%Nearly always rely on reviewsNearly always rely on reviews: 40%40%How much US adults lean on online reviewsBar chart. At least sometimes read reviews before a first purchase: 82%; Say reviews help a lot to feel confident: 46%; Nearly always rely on reviews: 40%.At least sometimes read reviews beforea first purchaseAt least sometimes read reviews before a first purchase: 82%82%Say reviews help a lot to feelconfidentSay reviews help a lot to feel confident: 46%46%Nearly always rely on reviewsNearly always rely on reviews: 40%40%

Source: Pew Research Center, 2016[5]

Show the data
ItemValue
At least sometimes read reviews before a first purchase82%
Say reviews help a lot to feel confident46%
Nearly always rely on reviews40%

Fake reviews are also illegal to create or sell under the FTC’s 2024 rule, which explicitly covers AI-generated fake reviews[6]. That does not mean the FTC will remove a review from your profile; removal goes through the platform. But it means you are on firm ground in asking.

First, check whether it is really fake

Most reviews that feel unfair are from real customers who remember the job differently. Treat those as complaints and reply. A review is worth reporting when the evidence suggests it breaks the platform’s rules, not when it hurts.

Separate fake reviews from real complaints before you report.
SignWhat it may meanEvidence to collect
No matching name, phone or address in your recordsNot a customer, or the wrong businessSearch screenshots from your field software
Describes a service you do not offerWrong businessYour service list; the competitor who does offer it
Several one-star reviews within hoursCoordinated attackDates and times of each review
Reviewer’s other reviews praise one competitorConflict of interestScreenshots of the reviewer’s profile
Details only an ex-employee would knowFormer employeeEmployment end date, matching details
Same wording as reviews on other profilesReview farm or templateScreenshots of the matching text

What Google’s policies cover

Google’s user content policy lists several kinds of review it does not allow. Under fake engagement it includes reviews paid for directly or in kind and content posted from multiple accounts by one person. Under conflicts of interest it includes current or former employment and relationships such as industry competitors, and it prohibits posting content on a competitor’s listing to undermine its reputation[2].

Google is equally clear about what it will not do. Its help page says not to report a review just because you disagree with it or dislike it, and that Google does not get involved in conflicts between businesses and customers[1]. Reports that amount to “the customer is wrong” waste your one appeal and your time.

Report the rule the review breaks, not how you feel about it. “Reviewer is a competitor’s employee” is a policy reason; “reviewer is lying about our prices” usually is not.

Build the evidence pack

  • A search of your job records by the reviewer’s name and any phone number or address in the review, with a screenshot showing no match.
  • Call logs for the date the reviewer says they called, if they give one.
  • Screenshots of the reviewer’s profile and other reviews, especially any praise for a single competitor.
  • For an ex-employee: their end date and the details in the review that match their knowledge.
  • Timestamps for a burst of reviews, and any matching wording across them.
  • A short written summary: which review, which policy, what the evidence shows.

Keep everything in one folder per review. If you need to appeal or escalate, you will be asked for it again, and memories fade quickly.

How to flag a review

  1. Open your reviews

    In your Business Profile, choose Read reviews and find the review in question[1].

  2. Select Report

    Next to the review, select Report and choose the reason that matches the policy it breaks.

  3. Use the Reviews Management Tool

    Google’s tool lets you report a review for removal and later check its status[1].

  4. Check the status

    Statuses include decision pending, report reviewed with no policy violation, and escalated, with an email for the final decision[1].

  5. Appeal once if needed

    If a flagged review does not qualify for removal, you can submit a one-time appeal, selecting up to 10 reviews per appeal[1].

Several days

typical time for Google to evaluate a flagged review[1]

What to do while you wait

A review under evaluation stays visible, so do not leave it bare. Post a short, neutral reply that a future customer can read without needing context. Do not accuse the reviewer of being a competitor in public, even if you are sure; if you are wrong, you look worse than the review.

  • Not a customer: “We take every review seriously but can’t find any record of a visit under this name. If we’ve missed something, please call [number] and ask for [name].”
  • Wrong business: “We think this may be about another company; we don’t offer [service]. If it was us, please call [number] so we can look into it.”
  • Coordinated burst: reply once to each with the not-a-customer wording, then stop. Do not engage in back-and-forth.

Keep replies factual, short and free of private details. The structure for replies to real complaints is in responding to negative reviews.

Former employees and competitors

These two cases cause most genuine disputes. A former employee may post as a customer, or a competitor’s staff may post one-star reviews from personal accounts. Both fall under Google’s conflict-of-interest rules[2], but proving the link takes care.

  • Do not contact the suspected person to demand removal. It can look like intimidation.
  • Do not post their name or accuse them publicly.
  • Do give Google specific, checkable facts: matching details, dates, profile links.
  • If a pattern continues, take legal advice before any letter. The FTC rule bans unfounded legal threats used to get reviews removed[4], so any legal step needs a genuine basis.

When the answer is no

Sometimes Google finds no policy violation, even when you are confident the review is fake. After the one-time appeal, accept the decision for that review. Your remaining tools are a calm public reply and a steady flow of genuine reviews, which pushes the fake one down the list and dilutes its effect on the rating.

Other platforms have their own reporting systems and standards. Yelp, Facebook and Nextdoor each handle reports differently, so read their rules before flagging, and keep the same evidence pack.

Keep an incident log

One fake review is an annoyance; a pattern is a problem you may need to prove later. Keep a simple log with one row per suspicious review: date posted, reviewer name as shown, star rating, the policy you reported it under, the date you reported it, the status on each check, and the final outcome. Link each row to its evidence folder.

The log does three jobs. It stops two people in the office from reporting the same review twice. It shows whether attacks cluster around particular events, such as a dispute with a former employee or a competitor’s new ad campaign. And if you ever do need to take advice from an attorney, it gives them a dated record instead of a story pieced together from memory.

  • Review the log monthly with whoever replies to reviews.
  • Note which report reasons succeeded, so future reports use the strongest category.
  • Close each row once the review is removed or the appeal is decided.

Prevention through real reviews

The best protection is volume of honest feedback. A profile with three reviews can be dragged down by one fake; a profile with three hundred recent reviews barely moves. A consistent habit of asking every customer, described in how to get more plumbing reviews, is also the cleanest evidence that your profile is genuine.

Example: a burst of one-star reviews

Example (fictional): a two-truck shop wakes up to four one-star reviews posted overnight, none matching any job record. Two reviewers’ other reviews praise the same competitor across town. The office manager screenshots each profile, searches the field software for each name, and flags all four for conflict of interest with a short note on the evidence.

In this example Google removes three within a week. The fourth stays after the appeal. The owner leaves the brief not-a-customer reply on it, asks every customer as usual, and within a month the remaining review has dropped out of sight below a dozen new genuine ones.

Frequently asked questions

Can Google remove a fake review of my plumbing business?

Yes, if it breaks Google’s policies, for example fake engagement or a conflict of interest such as a competitor or former employee. Report it with evidence.

How long does Google take to review a flagged review?

Google says evaluation typically takes several days. You can check the status in the Reviews Management Tool.

What if Google refuses to remove it?

You can submit a one-time appeal. If that fails, post a calm reply and keep collecting genuine reviews.

Should I reply to a review I have reported?

Yes, briefly and neutrally. The review stays visible while it is evaluated, so future customers need to see your side.

References

  1. Google Business Profile Help (2026). Report inappropriate reviews on your Business Profile (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Google Maps Help (2026). Prohibited & restricted content (Maps user generated content policy) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Pew Research Center (2016). Online Reviews (Online Shopping and E-Commerce) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Pew Research Center (2016). Online Reviews (Online Shopping and E-Commerce) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo