Sales memberships

Improving membership renewal and retention

How plumbing companies measure membership renewal, spot members about to lapse, time value reminders and win back customers whose plans expired.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Measure renewal the same way every month
  2. Why members lapse
  3. A renewal calendar that starts at the first visit
  4. Show value before you ask for money
  5. Raising the renewal price without losing members
  6. Reaching members who don't pick up
  7. Failed payments are churn you can fix
  8. Win-backs after a lapse
  9. Give retention an owner
  10. Example: reading a renewal report
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References
Sales memberships: Improving membership renewal and retentionArticle coverSALES MEMBERSHIPSImproving membershiprenewal and retentionAva for PlumbersInsightsSales memberships: Improving membership renewal and retentionArticle coverSALES MEMBERSHIPSImproving membershiprenewal and retentionAva for Plumbers

Key takeaways

  • Measure renewal on the members who were due in the month, and track failed payments separately from people who chose to leave.
  • Retention is decided at the visits, not at the renewal notice: members who never got their visit rarely renew.
  • Send a value summary before the renewal notice so the price arrives after the reminder of what the plan delivered.
  • Most people let unknown numbers ring out but check voicemail[1], so leave a short message and make calling back easy.

Measure renewal the same way every month

Many shops quote a renewal rate that mixes three different things: members who chose to leave, members whose card failed, and members who were never due that month. Before you try to improve the number, fix the definition. The cleanest version looks only at the agreements that reached their renewal date in the period.

Five retention measures for a plumbing membership program
MetricHow to calculate itWhat it tells you
Renewal rateAgreements renewed ÷ agreements that reached their renewal date this monthWhether members see enough value to stay
Voluntary churnMembers who cancelled or declined renewal ÷ agreements dueProblems with the plan, the visits or the price
Payment churnAgreements lost to failed charges not recovered within 30 days ÷ agreements dueBilling process gaps, not member opinion
Visit completionMember visits completed ÷ visits owed in the agreement yearThe best early warning of next year's churn
Win-back rateLapsed members who rejoin within 6 months ÷ members lapsedWhether your lapse follow-up works

Visit completion is the one to watch weekly. A member who paid for a yearly inspection and never got it has a clear reason to leave, and no renewal email will change that. If your completion rate is low, the fix is scheduling, not marketing.

Why members lapse

  • The visit never happened, or it was rescheduled so many times that the member gave up.
  • The visit happened but felt like a sales call, with little time spent on the house itself.
  • The member forgot what the plan included and saw the charge as a surprise.
  • The card on file expired or was replaced, and nobody followed up.
  • The price went up with no explanation of why.
  • The member moved, which no amount of follow-up will fix, though the new owner of the house is a prospect.

Tag each lapse with one of these reasons when it happens. After a quarter you will know which two cause most of your churn, and those are the only ones worth a project.

A renewal calendar that starts at the first visit

  1. Welcome, day 0

    Confirm what the plan includes, when the first visit will be, how billing works and how to cancel. Book the first visit before the welcome message goes out.

  2. After every visit

    Send a short findings report with photos: what was checked, what was fine and what to watch. This report is your strongest renewal asset.

  3. About 60 days before renewal

    Send a value summary: visits completed, issues caught, member discounts used. No price yet.

  4. The renewal notice

    State the renewal date, the amount, what changes and how to cancel, in the window your state's automatic renewal law requires.

  5. About 7 days before

    A brief reminder by the channel the member uses most, with a link or number to update the card.

  6. Renewal day and after

    Send a receipt and book the next visit. If the charge fails, start payment recovery the same day.

Compliance belongs in the calendar, not in a separate binder. State rules on renewal notices and cancellation differ, and some set specific timing; auto-renewal laws for plumbing memberships explains what to check before you automate any step.

Show value before you ask for money

A value summary works when it is about the member's house, not about the program. Three or four lines are enough, and they should read like a report from the technician.

  • Visits completed this year, with dates and the technician's name.
  • What was found and fixed early, such as a weeping supply line or a worn flapper.
  • Member discounts or priority dispatches used, with the amounts saved where you track them.
  • One thing to watch next year, so the member has a reason to keep the visit.

If a member's summary has nothing in it, do not send a generic one. Call instead and book the missed visit. An empty summary is a cancellation request waiting to happen.

Raising the renewal price without losing members

Labor costs keep rising, so most plans need occasional price changes. Average hourly earnings at plumbing, heating and AC contractors rose from $39.30 in January 2025 to $42.65 in August 2026, and were about 4.4% higher in September 2026 than a year earlier[2]. Members accept increases better when they are small, regular and explained.

Average hourly earnings at plumbing, heating and AC contractorsAll employees, not seasonally adjusted; recent months preliminary.
Average hourly earnings at plumbing, heating and AC contractorsLine chart. Jan 2025: $39.3; Sep 2025: $40.59; Aug 2026: $42.65; Sep 2026: $42.38.$38$39$40$41$42$43Jan 2025Sep 2025Aug 2026Sep 2026Jan 2025: $39.3Sep 2025: $40.59Aug 2026: $42.65Sep 2026: $42.38$42.38$39.3Average hourly earnings at plumbing, heating and AC contractorsLine chart. Jan 2025: $39.3; Sep 2025: $40.59; Aug 2026: $42.65; Sep 2026: $42.38.$38$39$40$41$42$43Jan 2025Sep 2026Jan 2025: $39.3Sep 2025: $40.59Aug 2026: $42.65Sep 2026: $42.38$42.38$39.3

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2026[2]

Show the data
PeriodValue
Jan 2025$39.3
Sep 2025$40.59
Aug 2026$42.65
Sep 2026$42.38

Put the increase in the renewal notice, never on the receipt. Say why in one sentence, restate what the plan includes and offer a clear way to cancel. Grandfathering long-time members for one cycle is a cheap way to show loyalty matters. For the broader approach, see raising prices for existing customers.

Reaching members who don't pick up

Renewal calls from the office often go unanswered. In Pew Research Center's survey, 80% of Americans said they generally do not answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers, and 67% said they let the call ring but check voicemail if one is left[1]. So every renewal call should leave a voicemail of under 20 seconds with the member's name, the reason and a direct number.

Text and email reach most members: 91% of US adults own a smartphone, including 79% of adults aged 65 and older[3]. Get consent for automated messages at signup. The FCC requires prior express written consent before telemarketing robocalls and treats AI-generated voices as artificial under the TCPA[4], and consumers can recover $500 or their actual losses per violation[5]. Keep renewal notices informational and keep consent records with the agreement.

When members call back, someone has to answer. An SI Employee such as Ava can pick up those return calls at any hour, answer what the plan includes and book the member visit, so a callback does not turn into another missed call.

Failed payments are churn you can fix

  • Use your processor's card updater service if it offers one, so replaced cards update automatically.
  • Retry a failed charge on a set schedule, for example on day 1, 3 and 7, before contacting the member.
  • Send a plain message on the first failure: the plan stays active while they update the card.
  • Give the office a daily list of failed charges with phone numbers, oldest first.
  • Mark the agreement as payment churn, not voluntary churn, if it lapses, so the numbers stay honest.

Win-backs after a lapse

A member who lapsed for payment reasons is often happy to rejoin. One who left because the visit never happened needs an apology first. Use the lapse tag to pick the message, and stop after two attempts.

Script for a missed-visit lapse: “Hi, this is the office at the plumbing company. Your plan ended last month, and we noticed we never got your inspection done. That's on us. If you'd like, we can do the visit this month at no charge and you can decide afterwards whether to rejoin.”

When a house changes owners, send the new owner a welcome letter with the home's service history. Buyers often have no idea when the water heater was last flushed, and you are the one company that knows.

Give retention an owner

In many shops, sales belongs to the technicians and billing belongs to the office, so nobody owns whether members stay. Name one person, often the service manager or a senior CSR, and give them three numbers to report every Monday: visits owed versus completed, failed charges still open, and renewals due in the next 60 days. Those three lines predict next month's renewal rate better than any marketing report.

Book next year's first visit during the current visit or the renewal call, while the member is engaged. A visit already on the calendar is the simplest retention tool you have, and it spreads member work across the year instead of piling it into one season.

Example: reading a renewal report

Example (fictional): in March, 120 agreements reach their renewal date. 96 renew, 14 cancel and 10 fail on payment, of which 6 are recovered within 30 days. The renewal rate is 102 of 120, or 85%. Voluntary churn is 14 of 120 and payment churn 4 of 120. Of the 14 who cancelled, 9 had no completed visit in the year. The fix is in the schedule: book next year's visits at the renewal call and report completion weekly.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good membership renewal rate for a plumbing company?

Compare yourself with your own history using a consistent definition rather than with numbers quoted without method. Track voluntary and payment churn separately; payment churn is usually the faster fix.

Should membership plans auto-renew?

Auto-renewal reduces lapses from forgetfulness, but it brings disclosure, consent and cancellation duties under federal and state law. Build those into signup and the renewal notice before switching it on.

How early should we contact members before renewal?

Send a value summary about two months out, the renewal notice in the window your state requires, and a short reminder about a week before the charge.

Can we call members with an automated voice about renewal?

Only with the right consent. The FCC treats AI-generated voices as artificial under the TCPA and requires prior express written consent for telemarketing robocalls[4].

References

  1. Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Average hourly earnings of all employees, plumbing, heating, and air-conditioning contractors (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Pew Research Center (2026). Mobile Fact Sheet (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Federal Communications Commission (2024). FCC Makes AI-Generated Voices in Robocalls Illegal (news release) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 47 U.S. Code § 227 - Restrictions on use of telephone equipment (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo