Metrics finance

Leasing vs buying service vans

Leasing vs buying service vans for a plumbing company: cash flow, tax, mileage, upfit and maintenance trade-offs, with a five-year example.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing6 min read

On this page
  1. The decision in one sentence
  2. Where the money goes in vehicle ownership
  3. Side by side
  4. Cash flow
  5. Tax considerations
  6. Mileage, wear and upfit
  7. Questions to ask before signing a lease
  8. A decision checklist
  9. Example: a five-year comparison
  10. Fleet strategy
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References
Metrics finance: Leasing vs buying service vansArticle coverMETRICS FINANCELeasing vs buyingservice vansAva for PlumbersInsightsMetrics finance: Leasing vs buying service vansArticle coverMETRICS FINANCELeasing vs buyingservice vansAva for Plumbers

Key takeaways

  • Depreciation is the largest cost of owning a vehicle; in AAA's 2025 study it averaged $4,334 a year, more than any other component[1].
  • Leasing protects cash and simplifies replacement; buying usually costs less over a long life and frees you from mileage and upfit limits.
  • Tax rules can favor buying: for tax years beginning in 2025, the maximum section 179 deduction is $2,500,000[2], but vehicle limits and your entity type matter, so ask your tax adviser.
  • Decide on miles per year, years you keep a van, how heavily you upfit it and how tight cash is, not on the monthly payment alone.

The decision in one sentence

Leasing a service van means paying to use it for a fixed term and mileage, then handing it back or buying it; buying means paying for all of it, with cash or a loan, and keeping whatever value is left at the end. For a plumbing company, the right answer depends less on the monthly payment than on how many miles your vans run, how long you keep them, how much you build into them and how much cash you can tie up.

Many shops end up with a mix: owned vans for the core service fleet that runs high miles and carries heavy racking, and leased vans for growth, seasonal capacity or roles that change vehicles often.

Where the money goes in vehicle ownership

AAA's 2025 Your Driving Costs study gives a useful breakdown for new vehicles driven 15,000 miles a year over five years. Depreciation averaged $4,334 a year, insurance $1,694, finance costs $1,131 and license, registration and taxes $813, with fuel at about 13 cents a mile and maintenance, repair and tires at about 11.04 cents a mile[1]. The chart converts the per-mile items to annual figures at 15,000 miles.

Annual cost of owning a new vehicle, by component, 2025AAA Your Driving Costs, 15,000 miles a year; fuel and maintenance converted from cents a mile
Annual cost of owning a new vehicle, by component, 2025Stacked bar chart. Depreciation: $4,334; Fuel: $1,950; Insurance: $1,694; Maintenance, repair and tires: $1,656; Finance: $1,131; License, registration and taxes: $813.Depreciation: $4,334 (37%)Fuel: $1,950 (17%)Insurance: $1,694 (15%)Maintenance, repair and tires: $1,656 (14%)Finance: $1,131 (10%)License, registration and taxes: $813 (7%)Annual cost of owning a new vehicle, by component, 2025Stacked bar chart. Depreciation: $4,334; Fuel: $1,950; Insurance: $1,694; Maintenance, repair and tires: $1,656; Finance: $1,131; License, registration and taxes: $813.Depreciation: $4,334 (37%)Fuel: $1,950 (17%)Insurance: $1,694 (15%)Maintenance, repair and tires: $1,656 (14%)Finance: $1,131 (10%)License, registration and taxes: $813 (7%)
  • Depreciation $4,334 37%
  • Fuel $1,950 17%
  • Insurance $1,694 15%
  • Maintenance, repair and tires $1,656 14%
  • Finance $1,131 10%
  • License, registration and taxes $813 7%

Source: AAA, 2025[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Depreciation$4,334
Fuel$1,950
Insurance$1,694
Maintenance, repair and tires$1,656
Finance$1,131
License, registration and taxes$813

The study covers personal vehicles, not commercial vans, but the shape holds: the biggest cost is the vehicle losing value. Leasing and buying are two ways of paying for that loss. A lease prices it into the payment up front; owning lets you control it by keeping the van longer, maintaining it well and selling it at the right time.

Side by side

Leasing versus buying service vans
FactorLeaseBuy
Upfront cashLow: first payment, fees, sometimes a depositDown payment or full price, plus upfit
Monthly costUsually lower than a loan payment for the same vanLoan payment until paid off, then none
Total cost over a long lifeHigher if you keep leasingUsually lower if kept many years
MileageAnnual limit, excess charged per mileNo limit
Upfit and rackingRestrictions; must often be removableBuild as needed
Wraps and brandingUsually allowed if removable without damageNo restrictions
Wear and damageCharged at lease end beyond normal wearReflected in resale value
ReplacementPlanned at term endYour choice of timing
Tax treatmentLease payments generally deductible as an expenseDepreciation, possibly accelerated
Balance sheetLease obligations still count as commitmentsAsset and loan on the books

Cash flow

Leasing's main advantage is cash. A growing shop that needs three new vans this year may not want to put down payments and upfit costs on all of them at once, especially going into a slow season. Leasing keeps that cash available for payroll, stock and marketing. The trade-off is that the payments never end while you keep leasing, whereas a bought van eventually becomes a low-cost asset.

Leasing is a common choice for small firms. In the Federal Reserve Banks' survey of small employer firms, 10% sought a lease in the prior year, while auto and equipment loans had the highest full-approval rate of any loan product among applicants, at 68%[3]. If your credit is solid, financing a purchase is usually available; the question is whether you want the debt.

Tax considerations

Tax rules can tilt the decision toward buying, but they are detailed and change often, so treat this section as questions for your tax adviser, not advice. For tax years beginning in 2025, the maximum section 179 expense deduction is $2,500,000, reduced dollar for dollar once section 179 property placed in service exceeds $4,000,000[2]. The same instructions say the 100% special depreciation allowance was reinstated for certain qualified property acquired and placed in service after January 19, 2025[2].

Vehicles have their own limits. For example, the maximum section 179 deduction for sport utility vehicles placed in service in tax years beginning in 2025 is $31,300[2], and passenger vehicles face annual depreciation caps. Cargo vans built for work may be treated differently, depending on weight and design. Entity type matters too: many plumbing businesses are S corporations, which ran about 69% of plumbing, heating and AC contractor establishments in 2023[4], and deductions flow through to owners in ways your accountant should model for you.

A large first-year deduction is not free money. It reduces taxable income now, but the van still has to earn its keep, and selling it later can bring some of that deduction back as taxable income.

Mileage, wear and upfit

Service vans in busy territories often run well beyond the mileage built into a standard lease. Excess-mile charges at lease end can wipe out the payment savings, so compare your actual miles per van with the lease allowance before signing. Wear matters as well: ladder racks, bins, heavy stock and job-site parking add dents and interior damage that lessors may charge for.

Upfit is the other sticking point. Shelving, drawers, inverters and jetter mounts are part of what makes a van productive. On a leased van, check what can be installed, whether it must be removed before return and who pays for any holes or damage. A bought van can be built exactly as the work requires and the upfit moved to the next van when it is replaced.

Questions to ask before signing a lease

  • What is the annual mileage allowance, and what is the charge per excess mile?
  • What counts as normal wear, and is there a written inspection standard at return?
  • Can racking, shelving and an inverter be installed, and must they be removed before return?
  • Is maintenance included, and if so, where can the van be serviced and how fast?
  • What happens if the van is totaled or stolen: is gap coverage included?
  • Can the lease end early, and what does that cost?
  • Is there a purchase option at the end, and at what price?

Get the answers in writing and compare at least two lessors. Commercial fleet lessors often handle upfits, maintenance programs and replacement cycles better than consumer dealers, but their terms vary widely, and the details at return time are where the real cost of a lease is decided.

A decision checklist

  1. Measure miles per van

    Use twelve months of odometer or telematics data. High-mileage vans favor buying.

  2. Decide how long you keep vans

    If you typically keep a van well past a lease term, buying usually wins on total cost.

  3. Price the upfit

    Heavy, permanent upfits favor buying; light, removable ones work with leases.

  4. Check your cash position

    If down payments would push your cash below a safe floor, leasing or financing protects payroll.

  5. Ask your tax adviser

    Have them compare first-year and multi-year tax effects for both options with your actual numbers.

  6. Compare total cost, not payments

    Add every payment, fee, expected excess-mile charge and expected resale value for each option over the same period.

Example: a five-year comparison

Example: a fictional shop compares one cargo van over five years at 20,000 miles a year. All figures are illustrative and before tax effects.

Example lease versus buy comparison, fictional data
ItemLease, 36 months, then a second leaseBuy with a loan
Upfront cash$3,000$9,000 down plus upfit
Payments over five years$46,200$44,500 loan payments
Excess-mile and wear charges$4,800$0
Upfit removal and reinstall$2,500$0
Resale value at year five$0minus $14,000
Net five-year cost$56,500$39,500 plus upfit

Example, continued: at high mileage with a heavy upfit, buying comes out well ahead even before tax effects, because the shop keeps the resale value and avoids excess-mile and wear charges. If the same van ran half the miles and the shop needed to protect cash for an expansion, the lease would look much closer, and the extra cash in hand might be worth the higher total cost.

Fleet strategy

Start with the total cost of running each van, covered in cost per service van, then decide vehicle by vehicle. Core service vans that run high miles and carry permanent racking are often best owned. Vans for new hires, seasonal surge or roles that may change are good lease candidates. Review the mix each year with the budget.

Financing options for vans overlap with those for jetters, cameras and other tools; the guide to equipment financing compares them, and SBA loans can fund vehicles as part of a broader expansion. Whatever you choose, keep supplier terms and cash reserves in view, because vehicle payments compete for the same cash, and the right business entity affects how the tax side plays out.

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to lease or buy a plumbing van?

Buying usually costs less for high-mileage vans with heavy upfits kept for many years. Leasing helps when cash is tight, miles are moderate or you replace vans on a fixed cycle.

Can I deduct a service van under section 179?

Possibly. Section 179 and bonus depreciation can apply to business vehicles, but limits depend on the vehicle's type and weight and on your situation[2]. Ask your tax adviser before you buy.

Can I wrap a leased van?

Usually, if the wrap can be removed without damaging the paint. Check the lease terms and budget for removal at the end of the term.

References

  1. AAA (2025). Your Driving Costs 2025 (fact sheet) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. Internal Revenue Service (2025). Instructions for Form 4562 (2025): Depreciation and Amortization (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. Federal Reserve Banks (2025). 2025 Report on Employer Firms: Findings from the 2024 Small Business Credit Survey (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. U.S. Census Bureau (2023). County Business Patterns 2023, U.S. national file (cbp23us) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo