Key takeaways
- An LLC is a legal entity formed under state law; an S corporation is a federal tax election that an LLC or corporation can make.
- S corporations ran about 69% of plumbing, heating and AC contractor establishments in 2023, so the election is common in the trade.
- Self-employment tax is 15.3%; an S corp can reduce it by splitting profit into a reasonable salary and distributions, but adds payroll and filing costs.
- Neither structure replaces insurance: owners generally stay personally responsible for their own negligent work.
Two separate decisions
'Should I be an LLC or an S corp?' mixes two different choices. The first is the legal form of the business under state law: a sole proprietorship, a limited liability company, a partnership or a corporation. The second is how the business is taxed federally. An LLC with one owner is taxed like a sole proprietorship by default, and an LLC with several owners like a partnership, but either can elect to be taxed as an S corporation. A corporation can also elect S status.
Most plumbing companies of any size have made that election. In 2023, S corporations ran 76,190 of the 111,207 plumbing, heating and air-conditioning contractor establishments in the United States, about 69%, while sole proprietorships with employees ran 11,821[1]. At the other end of the scale, about 8% of plumbers, pipefitters and steamfitters are self-employed[2], many of them one-truck businesses deciding which structure fits.
- S corporations 76,190 establishments 69%
- Sole proprietorships with employees 11,821 establishments 11%
- Other legal forms 23,196 establishments 21%
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2023[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| S corporations | 76,190 establishments |
| Sole proprietorships with employees | 11,821 establishments |
| Other legal forms | 23,196 establishments |
Liability: what an LLC does and does not protect
The main legal reason to form an LLC or corporation is to separate business debts and obligations from your personal assets. If the company signs a lease, borrows money or loses a contract dispute, creditors generally look to the company, not to your house, as long as you keep the company genuinely separate.
The protection has limits plumbers need to understand. You are generally still personally responsible for your own negligent work, so if you personally install a fitting that floods a basement, an LLC does not shield you from that claim. Banks and suppliers often ask owners to sign personal guarantees, and sureties usually ask for personal indemnity on bonds. Mixing personal and business money can let a court ignore the company altogether. That is why general liability insurance remains the first line of protection, with the entity as a second layer.
Keep the shield intact: separate bank accounts, contracts signed in the company's name, annual state filings on time, and no paying personal bills from the business account.
Tax: where the S corp saving comes from
Sole proprietors and single-member LLCs pay self-employment tax on their net earnings at 15.3%, made up of 12.4% for Social Security and 2.9% for Medicare, once net earnings reach $400[3]. They can deduct the employer-equivalent half of that tax when figuring adjusted gross income, but it still applies to essentially all the profit, and higher earners may owe an additional 0.9% Medicare tax[3].
In an S corporation, the owner who works in the business is an employee. The company must pay that owner reasonable compensation for their services before making non-wage distributions[4]. Payroll taxes apply to the salary, but profit paid out as distributions is not subject to Social Security and Medicare tax. The saving comes from the gap between total profit and a reasonable salary.
The IRS lists the factors it uses to judge reasonable compensation, including training and experience, duties and responsibilities, time and effort devoted to the business, dividend history, what comparable businesses pay for similar services, and the use of a formula to set pay[4]. For a master plumber who runs jobs, estimates and manages crews, comparable pay is usually substantial. A salary set far below what you would pay someone to do your job invites an audit.
Side-by-side comparison
| Factor | Sole proprietorship | Single-member LLC (default tax) | LLC or corporation taxed as S corp |
|---|---|---|---|
| Liability separation | None | Yes, if kept separate | Yes, if kept separate |
| Self-employment tax | On essentially all net earnings | On essentially all net earnings | Payroll tax on salary only; distributions not subject to it |
| Owner pay | Draws, no payroll | Draws, no payroll | Reasonable salary through payroll, plus distributions |
| Federal return | Schedule C on personal return | Schedule C on personal return | Separate S corporation return plus owner's return |
| Extra costs | Lowest | State formation and annual fees | State fees, payroll service, separate return, state taxes on S corps in some states |
| Ownership rules | One owner | One owner | No more than 100 shareholders, only allowable shareholders, one class of stock |
| Best fit | Side work and very early stage | New solo business wanting liability separation | Steady profit well above a reasonable salary |
To be an S corporation the business must be a domestic corporation or eligible entity, have only allowable shareholders, have no more than 100 shareholders and have only one class of stock[5]. The election is made on Form 2553, which must be signed by all the shareholders[5]. Once elected, the company has payroll duties, including Social Security, Medicare and income tax withholding, and federal unemployment tax[5].
Worked example
Example: a solo plumber with one apprentice expects about $160,000 of profit before paying herself. As a single-member LLC with default tax treatment, self-employment tax would apply to most of that profit. If she elects S corporation status and pays herself a reasonable salary of $90,000, payroll taxes apply to the $90,000, and the remaining $70,000 she takes as distributions is not subject to Social Security and Medicare tax. At the 15.3% rate, that is roughly $10,700 a year less in those taxes before adjustments.
Example, continued: the real saving is smaller. She now pays a payroll service, a separate business tax return and possibly a state fee or tax on S corporations, and the Social Security wage cap and other adjustments change the math at higher incomes. Her CPA estimates the net benefit after those costs and confirms that $90,000 is defensible for her duties in her market. If her profit were $60,000 instead, a reasonable salary might absorb most of it, and the election would cost more than it saves.
What changes day to day after an S election
The election changes how the owner gets paid more than how the business runs. Instead of drawing money whenever the account allows, the owner receives a regular paycheck with withholding, and takes distributions on top when profit allows. Payroll filings become quarterly and annual obligations, and the company files its own federal return each year, with the owner's share of profit flowing to their personal return.
- Set up payroll for the owner from the first month the election applies, not at year end.
- Pay distributions in proportion to ownership if there is more than one shareholder, because the one-class-of-stock rule does not allow different economic rights.
- Keep a simple record of how the owner's salary was set, such as local job postings or wage data for similar roles.
- Review the salary each year as the business and the owner's role change.
Questions to bring to your adviser
- Based on my last two years, what is my likely steady profit, and what salary would be reasonable for my role?
- What would the election save after payroll, filing and state costs?
- Does my state tax S corporations or charge extra fees?
- How does my plumbing license need to be held if I form an entity?
- How will this affect my retirement plan options and health insurance?
- What deadlines apply if I want the election to start next year?
Decision criteria
Start with liability
If you have employees, commercial clients or significant contracts, form an LLC or corporation early and run it properly.
Check your license rules
Some states license the business entity separately from the individual plumber, or require a qualifying licensee on record. Form the entity in a way that keeps the license valid.
Estimate steady profit
Look at profit after a realistic salary for your role. If the remainder is small or unpredictable, the S election may not pay.
Price the extra costs
Add payroll processing, return preparation and state fees and taxes to compare honestly.
Plan the timing
Elections have deadlines and can affect a whole tax year. Decide with your adviser well before the year you want it to start.
Revisit as you grow
Adding partners, investors or a second location can change the best structure.
Mistakes to avoid
- Electing S status and never running payroll for the owner.
- Paying an owner salary far below what the role would cost to hire.
- Forming an LLC but signing contracts and bank loans in your own name.
- Forgetting state annual reports and fees, which can lead to the entity being dissolved.
- Assuming the entity protects you from your own workmanship claims and skimping on insurance.
- Choosing a structure on tax alone without considering how you might sell the business or bring in a partner.
Your structure also shapes deductions, payroll and retirement planning. See our guides to tax deductions plumbing owners miss and sales tax on plumbing services.
Frequently asked questions
Is an S corp better than an LLC for a plumber?
They are not alternatives. An LLC is a legal entity, and S corporation status is a tax election an LLC can make. The election tends to help when steady profit is well above a reasonable salary for the owner's role.
How much is self-employment tax?
The self-employment tax rate is 15.3%, made up of 12.4% for Social Security and 2.9% for Medicare, and applies once net earnings from self-employment reach $400.
What salary must an S corp owner take?
Reasonable compensation for the services provided, paid before non-wage distributions. The IRS looks at factors such as duties, experience, time devoted and what comparable businesses pay for similar services.
Does an LLC protect me if my work causes a flood?
Not fully. An LLC generally protects personal assets from business debts, but owners usually remain responsible for their own negligent work. Liability insurance is still essential.
References
U.S. Census Bureau (2023). County Business Patterns 2023, U.S. national file (cbp23us) (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) โ
Internal Revenue Service (2026). Self-employment tax (Social Security and Medicare taxes) (opens in a new tab) โ
Internal Revenue Service (2026). S corporation compensation and medical insurance issues (opens in a new tab) โ
Internal Revenue Service (2026). S corporations (opens in a new tab) โ