Key takeaways
- The FTC’s final rule on reviews and testimonials, announced in August 2024, bans fake reviews, including AI-generated ones[1].
- Incentives tied to a review expressing a particular sentiment are banned; asking all customers for reviews is not[2][3].
- Threats, intimidation and unfounded legal threats to remove negative reviews are banned, and the FTC can seek civil penalties against knowing violators[4].
- The adjusted maximum civil penalty under the relevant FTC Act provision is $53,088 per violation[5].
- Form contracts cannot stop customers from posting honest reviews, under the separate Consumer Review Fairness Act[6].
Why the rule exists
Reviews carry real weight in how people choose a service. Pew found that 40% of Americans nearly always rely on online reviews when deciding what to buy[7]. For a plumbing company that weight is even heavier, because the customer is choosing someone to work inside their home, often in a hurry.
- Nearly always rely on reviews 40%
Source: Pew Research Center, 2016[7]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Nearly always rely on reviews | 40% |
On August 14, 2024 the Federal Trade Commission announced a final rule, adopted by a 5-0 vote, that bans the creation and sale of fake reviews and testimonials, explicitly including AI-generated fake reviews[1]. It applies to businesses of every size, including small local contractors, and to marketing agencies that act on their behalf.
Where the rule reaches in a plumbing business
Owners tend to think only of Google, but the rule is about consumer reviews and testimonials wherever you use them to promote the business. For a plumbing company that usually means several places at once, and the same standards apply to each.
- Review platforms: Google, Yelp, Facebook, Nextdoor, Angi, the Better Business Bureau and any trade directory.
- Your own website: a testimonials page, quotes on service pages, star widgets and case studies.
- Social media: posts quoting customers, before-and-after photos with a customer comment, videos of satisfied homeowners.
- Print and vehicles: mailers, door hangers and truck wraps that quote a customer or show a rating.
- Sales material: proposal packs for commercial clients and property managers that include references.
Testimonials on your own site need the same honesty as platform reviews. Use real customers’ words with their permission, do not edit a lukewarm comment into a glowing one, and do not present a staff member or relative as an ordinary customer. If a testimonial came from a customer who received something of value, such as a free inspection in return for being filmed, say so clearly next to it.
The key prohibitions
| Practice | What the rule says | Plumbing example to avoid |
|---|---|---|
| Fake reviews and testimonials | Banned, including AI-generated reviews and reviews by people who were not real customers | An agency posts “customer” reviews written by its staff |
| Buying or selling reviews | Banned when the reviews are fake or misrepresent the reviewer | Paying a review farm for 50 five-star reviews |
| Incentives tied to sentiment | Banned when conditioned on a positive or negative review | “$25 off if you leave us five stars” |
| Undisclosed insider reviews | Reviews by officers, managers, staff or relatives need clear disclosure | The owner’s brother reviewing the company without saying so |
| Company-controlled “independent” review sites | Cannot misrepresent a site you control as independent | A “Best Plumbers in Town” site that only ranks you first |
| Review suppression | No unfounded legal threats, physical threats, intimidation or knowingly false accusations to remove reviews | Threatening to sue a customer over an honest one-star review |
The FTC’s published questions and answers fill in detail. Family members can review your business if they clearly disclose their relationship. Officers and managers are not expected to read every review, but red flags should make them look closer. A business can decline to publish a review that is about the wrong business, and organizing reviews, such as sorting them by date, is not suppression[3].
What the rule does not ban
Plenty of normal review practice is fine. The FTC says its rule exempts generalized solicitations to purchasers, such as emailing all recent customers to ask for reviews[3]. It also says the rule itself does not prohibit giving incentives for reviews, as long as there is no requirement, stated or implied, that the review express a particular sentiment[3].
That second point is where many contractors go wrong, because Google’s own policy is stricter than the FTC rule. Google treats discounts, free services or payment for posting any review as fake engagement, so a small discount for any honest review, an offer that might survive the FTC rule, can still break Google’s terms. The practical rule for a plumbing company: no rewards for reviews at all.
Review gating, sending review links only to customers who said they were happy, is not specifically banned by the FTC rule. The FTC says it could still raise concerns under the FTC Act[3], and Google’s policy prohibits it outright. Do not do it.
Penalties
The rule matters because it gives the FTC a direct path to money penalties. The FTC said the rule lets it seek civil penalties against knowing violators[4], and its guidance says the rule authorizes courts to impose civil penalties for knowing violations[3]. The adjusted maximum under Section 5(m)(1)(A) of the FTC Act, the provision for rule violations, is listed in the federal regulations as $53,088 per violation[5].
$53,088
maximum civil penalty per violation under FTC Act Section 5(m)(1)(A), as adjusted[5]
Because penalties are set per violation, a batch of purchased reviews could multiply the exposure. That is not a small risk for a small company, quite apart from what Google may do to the profile.
The Consumer Review Fairness Act
A separate federal law covers contracts. The Consumer Review Fairness Act makes it illegal to use form-contract terms that bar or restrict a customer’s ability to review you, impose a penalty or fee for a review, or require customers to give up intellectual property rights in their reviews[6]. The FTC notes it is still acceptable to prohibit or remove reviews that contain confidential or private information, such as someone’s financial or medical details[6].
- Read your service agreement, estimate terms and work orders for any “non-disparagement” or “no negative reviews” wording, and remove it.
- Remove any fee or penalty linked to reviews.
- Keep clauses about confidentiality of customer data; those protect customers, not your rating.
Scenarios: allowed or not?
| Scenario | Verdict | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Texting every completed job a review link | Allowed | A generalized request to purchasers |
| Offering $10 off for any review | Avoid | Not sentiment-tied, but breaks Google policy |
| $25 off for a five-star review | Not allowed | Incentive conditioned on sentiment |
| Office manager reviewing the company | Not allowed without disclosure | Insider review |
| Asking an unhappy customer to remove a review in exchange for a refund | Avoid | Google bans incentives to remove reviews; FTC says it could be unfair |
| Replying publicly with the facts of a disputed job | Allowed, with care | Keep private details out; no threats |
| A lawyer’s letter over an honest but harsh review | High risk | Unfounded legal threats to suppress reviews are banned |
Vendors and agencies
Many violations start with a marketing vendor, not the owner. Packages promising a fixed number of new reviews per month, “review generation” that does not involve your real customers, or AI tools that write reviews for customers to post are all warning signs. You remain responsible for what is published to promote your business.
- Ask any vendor in writing how reviews are generated and from whom.
- Require that requests go only to your real customers, with the same message to all.
- Prohibit written-for-you reviews and any incentive for reviews in the contract.
- Keep the right to see every request template and every list it was sent to.
If something is already wrong
Some owners read the rule and realize a past practice does not fit. Perhaps an earlier agency posted reviews, a relative left one without saying so, or the website quotes testimonials nobody can trace. Deal with it rather than waiting for a complaint.
- Stop the practice immediately and tell any vendor involved, in writing.
- Ask relatives or staff who posted reviews to add a clear disclosure or remove them.
- Remove website testimonials you cannot connect to a real customer.
- Keep a dated note of what you found and what you changed.
- If you suspect a vendor posted fake reviews for you, take legal advice on next steps.
Going forward, the simplest protection is a process that only ever involves real customers, the same request for everyone and no rewards.
A compliance routine
Write a one-page review policy
Who asks, what they say, what is never offered, and who replies to reviews.
Brief the team
Cover the rule in a short meeting: no fake reviews, no rewards, disclose relationships, no threats.
Check contracts
Remove any wording that restricts or penalizes reviews.
Audit vendors
Confirm how any agency or software collects reviews.
Review quarterly
Scan new reviews for insider or suspicious patterns and fix the cause.
For practical templates that stay within these limits, see review request texts and emails and how to get more plumbing reviews. This article is general information, not legal advice; ask your attorney about specific situations.
Example: an offer to say no to
Example (fictional): a marketing agency pitches a three-truck shop a “reputation boost” package: 40 new five-star reviews in 60 days, written by the agency’s team from job details and posted from a pool of accounts. The owner is told it is standard practice.
In this example every element is a problem. The reviews would be fake, they would come from people who were not customers, and the pool of accounts is the kind of activity Google removes. The owner declines and instead asks every customer with a completed job, which produces fewer reviews in the first month but builds a profile that holds up.
Frequently asked questions
Does the FTC review rule apply to small plumbing companies?
Yes. It applies to businesses of any size, and to agencies or vendors acting for them.
Can I still ask customers for reviews?
Yes. Asking all customers is a generalized request and is fine. Do not tie anything of value to a positive review.
Can my employees review the company?
Only with a clear disclosure of their relationship. Better still, ask them not to; customer reviews carry more weight.
Can I threaten legal action over a fake review?
Unfounded legal threats to remove reviews are banned. Use the platform’s reporting process for fake reviews and get legal advice before any legal step.
References
Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2024). The Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule: Questions and Answers (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (e-CFR) (2025). 16 CFR 1.98: Adjustment of civil monetary penalty amounts (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2017). Consumer Review Fairness Act: What Businesses Need to Know (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2016). Online Reviews (Online Shopping and E-Commerce) (opens in a new tab) ↑