Call handling

Customers who call again and again: handling repeats

Why plumbing customers call the office three times about one job, the updates that stop it, scripts for each repeat call and a fair limit for abuse.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing10 min read

On this page
  1. The third call about the same water heater
  2. Why the same customer calls back
  3. Count the repeats before you change anything
  4. Updates that answer the next call before it comes
  5. What to say on the second, third and fourth call
  6. When repeat calls cross a line
  7. Nights, weekends and lunch: where repeats pile up
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. References
Call handling: Customers who call again and again: handling repeats19%: of US adults generally answer cellphone calls from unknown numbersCALL HANDLINGCustomers who call again andagain: handling repeats19%of US adults generally answer cellphone calls from unknownnumbersAva for PlumbersInsightsCall handling: Customers who call again and again: handling repeats19%: of US adults generally answer cellphone calls from unknown numbersCALL HANDLINGCustomers who callagain and again:handling repeats19%of US adults generally answercellphone calls from unknown numbersAva for Plumbers
Figure source: Pew Research Center, 2020[1]

Key takeaways

  • Most repeat callers are missing one fact, usually a time. Uncertain and unexplained waits feel longer[2], so give a time and say when the next update comes.
  • Call back from the main business number and leave the answer in the voicemail: only 19% of adults generally answer unknown numbers[1].
  • Tally repeat calls for two weeks with a reason code and the last promise made. The pattern points at the fix.
  • Raise the effort on each repeat: CSR, then dispatcher, then someone who can offer the customer a choice.
  • Frequency is not abuse. For the rare caller who harasses staff, use a written warn-then-end limit[3][4].

The third call about the same water heater

The third call about the same water heater tends to arrive mid-afternoon. The customer was told “sometime after lunch,” nobody has said a word since, and the CSR who booked the job is on another line. A second CSR picks up, the customer tells the story again from the top, and asks for a time that nobody in the office actually has.

Most repeat callers are not difficult people. They are missing one piece of information, and the phone is the only way they know to get it. David Maister's work on waiting lines explains why the gap hurts so much: uncertain waits feel longer than known, finite waits, unexplained waits feel longer than explained ones, and anxiety makes every wait seem longer[2]. A homeowner who has shut off the water to the house and has no hot water is anxious before the first call has ended.

So the fix is rarely a nicer phone manner. It is a schedule of information that reaches the customer before the next call would, plus a CSR team that treats every repeat call as a small failure to trace back to its cause.

Why the same customer calls back

Common repeat-call reasons in a plumbing office and the change that removes each one.
What the caller saysWhat they are missingWhat stops the next call
“Is anyone still coming?”An arrival time, or news that the time changedAn update at fixed points, each one naming when the next will come
“I never heard back.”A callback that actually reached themCallbacks from the number they know, and a voicemail that contains the answer
“The last person told me something different.”One consistent answerOne named owner per open job and a job note every CSR reads first
“When are the parts coming?”A date for the next stepA date, even a provisional one, plus the day you will confirm it
“Why is my bill higher than the quote?”Someone who can explain the invoiceA same-day call from the person who can answer, not a message passed around

The second row deserves its own paragraph, because offices often cause it themselves. In Pew's survey, 19% of adults said they generally answer calls from unknown numbers, 67% let them ring and check voicemail, and 14% ignore both the call and any voicemail[1]. iPhone owners can also choose to have calls from unsaved numbers silenced and sent straight to voicemail[5]. A CSR who rings back from a direct line or her own mobile, hears voicemail and hangs up has, from the customer's side, never called. Twenty minutes later the customer rings the main line again, a little angrier.

What US adults say they do when an unknown number callsPew Research Center survey of 10,211 adults, July 2020.
What US adults say they do when an unknown number callsDonut chart. Generally answer: 19%; Don't answer, check voicemail: 67%; Don't answer, ignore voicemail: 14%.Generally answer: 19%Don't answer, check voicemail: 67%Don't answer, ignore voicemail: 14%19% answer
  • Generally answer 19%
  • Don't answer, check voicemail 67%
  • Don't answer, ignore voicemail 14%

Source: Pew Research Center, 2020[1]

Show the data
ResponseShare of adults
Generally answer19%
Don't answer, check voicemail67%
Don't answer, ignore voicemail14%

Two habits close that gap. Call back from the main business number the customer dialed, so the caller ID matches what they expect. And when the call goes to voicemail, leave the answer, not a request to call back. Example: “Hi Ms. Patel, it's Dana at Millrace Plumbing. Luis is finishing a job in Oakdale and should reach you between 3:15 and 3:45. I'll call again at 3:00 if that changes.” That message ends the loop even if she never picks up.

Count the repeats before you change anything

Two weeks of tallying tells you which of those rows is your real problem. It costs one extra column in the call log and about ten seconds per call.

  1. Define a repeat

    Any inbound call from a customer with an open job, or from a number that called in the previous 72 hours, about the same issue. Callbacks you asked the customer to make do not count.

  2. Give every repeat a reason code

    Use five codes: arrival time, unreturned call, conflicting answer, next step or parts, billing. Add “other” and read those by hand at the end of each week.

  3. Write down what the customer was last told, and when

    This column finds the cause. “Told after lunch at 8:10, no update since” points straight at the fix.

  4. Total by reason and by shift

    A cluster on one shift is a handoff problem between people. A cluster on one reason is a process problem that every shift shares.

  5. Pick one fix per reason, then tally again

    Run another two weeks and compare. Repeats that do not fall are telling you the fix never reached the customer.

Example: a six-truck shop logs 410 inbound calls over two weeks. 58 are repeats from 29 customers: 24 about arrival time, 15 about unreturned calls, 8 about parts dates, 7 about billing and 4 other. Two thirds of them trace back to two habits: wide arrival windows with no update, and callbacks made from a mobile number that the customer never answered. Those become the first two fixes.

ExampleExample: CSR time spent on repeat status calls
Example: worked figures
InputExample
Repeat calls a day6
Minutes per repeat, including the dispatch check5
Share prevented by proactive updates60%
CSR hourly wage$22.22
Calls a month130
Staff hours on these calls11
Hours handed off6.5
Monthly value of that staff time$145

How it is worked out: Calls a day × 21.7 working days × minutes per call ÷ 60 × share handled = hours; hours × hourly cost.

Assumptions

  • Median hourly wage for customer service representatives at plumbing, heating and air-conditioning contractors, May 2025.[6]
  • Wage only. Total compensation for private-industry office and administrative support workers averaged $36.73 an hour in June 2026, so the true cost per hour is higher.[7]
  • Six repeats a day matches the tally example above. Five minutes covers the call plus checking with dispatch; 60% prevented is an assumption for this example, not a measured rate.

Example. The minutes are the smaller cost. The bigger one is a dispatcher pulled off the board to chase an arrival time while other jobs wait.

Updates that answer the next call before it comes

The rule that does most of the work is simple: every conversation with a customer who has an open job ends with a time they will hear from you next, and someone owns keeping it. “We'll call when he's on the way” is a promise with no clock. “You'll hear from us by 1:30 either way” is one the office can be held to, and a customer who has it rarely calls at 1:15.

  • At booking: the window, the technician's name if you know it, and “we'll confirm the time by 10 tomorrow.”
  • When the tech is assigned: who is coming and a first realistic arrival estimate.
  • When the tech leaves the previous job: a 20 to 40 minute heads-up, the update customers value most. On-my-way texts cover the wording.
  • When the plan slips past your delay threshold: a new time and a choice, before the customer notices. See what to tell customers when the plumber is running late.
  • After diagnosis on a job that needs another visit: the next step, its date and the day you will confirm it.

Text suits most of these: 91% of US adults own a smartphone[8]. Call instead when the customer has a decision to make, and use the channel each customer asked for (how plumbing customers want to be contacted). For jobs that run over several days, the milestone plan in keeping customers updated during long plumbing jobs heads off most of the anxious calls.

Inside the office, put the promise where the next CSR will see it. A job note that reads “Promised update by 1:30, Dana” turns a cold second call into a thirty-second one. A caller ID lookup that opens the job record as the phone rings helps even more; recognizing repeat customers the moment they call explains how to set one up.

What to say on the second, third and fourth call

Each repeat call should get more effort than the last, and the customer should be able to hear that it is getting more.

  • Second call: give what you know, then a new promise. “You're right, you should have heard from us. Luis is at a job two miles away and you're his next stop. I'm calling him now and I'll ring you back by 2:15 with a time.” Then do it, from the main line.
  • Third call: change who is handling it. The dispatcher speaks to the tech directly and calls the customer with a real time, instead of a CSR relaying a guess. Log the call as a repeat so the tally catches it.
  • Fourth call on the same day: a supervisor or the office manager calls back with a choice. Keep the slot with a firm time, take the first slot tomorrow, or send a different tech if one is free. By now the customer needs a decision, not another update.

Phrases that guarantee another call: “He's on his way” when nobody has spoken to him, “soon,” “I just answer the phones” and “You've already called three times.” Replace each with a fact and a time.

Example: turning a repeat call into the last call
  • Caller
  • System
  • Your team
  1. 01Caller

    Customer calls again

    Second call today about the same open job.

  2. 02System

    Job and last promise appear

    The CSR sees what was promised, when and by whom before saying hello.

  3. 03Your team

    CSR checks with dispatch

    The dispatcher confirms with the tech. No relayed guesses.

  4. 04Your team

    Customer gets a time

    Called back from the main number, with the next update promised.

  5. 05System

    Promise logged on the job

    The next CSR sees it, and the repeat is tallied by reason.

Example sequence for a CSR team. The logged promise matters more than the software it lives in.

When repeat calls cross a line

Frequency alone is not abuse. A customer who calls six times because nobody gave her a time is a process failure, and she is owed an apology. A different and much rarer caller uses the phone to threaten, insult or wear staff down. Federal law makes it an offense to make someone's phone ring repeatedly with intent to harass, or to make repeated calls solely to harass a specific person[3]. OSHA counts threats and verbal abuse as workplace violence[4]. CSRs need a limit they can use without asking permission first.

  1. Warn once, plainly: “I want to help, and I can't do that while you're speaking to me this way. If it continues I'll end the call and a manager will call you.”
  2. End the call if it continues. Log the time, what was said and the job number.
  3. A manager calls back the next business day, from the main number, and sets one route forward: a named contact, email only, or a scheduled call.
  4. Never cut off an emergency. If water is spreading or the caller mentions gas, the safety path comes first, whoever is calling.

Write the limit down and train on it. When a CSR may end an abusive call sets out a full warning-then-end policy, and de-escalating angry callers covers the far more common caller who is upset but not abusive.

Nights, weekends and lunch: where repeats pile up

Repeat calls multiply when nobody answers. A customer who reaches voicemail at 7:40 in the evening about tomorrow's appointment often tries again at 7:55 and again at 8:20, because nothing in the greeting suggested anyone would hear the message tonight. Each attempt becomes another voicemail for the morning CSR to sort, and the customer starts the day already annoyed.

Forwarding those hours to an SI Employee changes what the customer gets on the second call: an answer in your business name, the question taken down and read back, and a plain statement of when the office will be in touch. It answers only from the information you approve, so it will not invent an arrival time it cannot see. The summary reaches your inbox by email, with the recording and transcript in your account and urgent calls marked urgent (see what it does). In the 8-truck example scenario, messages like these are handed to the dispatcher at 7 am, before the first customer has time to call back and ask.

Whoever answers after hours, the morning routine is the same: read every overnight message about an open job first, and call those customers before 8:30 with a time. A customer who hears from you first does not call at 8:31.

Frequently asked questions

How many calls from one customer is too many?

There is no fair number, because the count usually measures your updates rather than the customer. Treat a second call about the same open job as a reason to change who is handling it, and a third as a reason for a supervisor to call back with a choice. Only what is said, never how often someone calls, makes a call abusive.

Should we give customers the technician's mobile number?

Usually not. Calls to a tech who is driving or under a sink go unanswered or distract, and the customer then calls the office anyway. Keep the office number as the single contact and make sure every update comes from it.

What should a CSR say when she doesn't know the arrival time?

Say so, give the time she will know by, and call back by then from the main line. “I don't know yet; I'll have a time for you by 2:15” prevents more calls than a guess that turns out wrong.

Do text updates replace calls?

For simple status news, mostly yes: 91% of US adults own a smartphone[8]. Call when the customer has to choose something, when the news is bad, or when they have asked you to call.

Can we block a number that keeps calling?

Blocking a customer with an open job usually makes things worse. For a caller who is harassing staff, follow your written policy, have a manager set one contact route in writing and keep the logs. Repeated calls made solely to harass can be a federal offense[3], and threats of violence are a matter for the police.

References

  1. Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. David Maister (in The Service Encounter, Lexington Books) (1985). The Psychology of Waiting Lines (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (U.S. Code) (2026). 47 U.S. Code § 223 - Obscene or harassing telephone calls (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Occupational Safety and Health Administration (2026). Workplace Violence (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Apple (2026). Manage unknown callers on iPhone (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, May 2025: Customer Service Representatives, hourly median wage, plumbing, heating and air-conditioning contractors (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employer Costs for Employee Compensation, Table 4 (June 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  8. Pew Research Center (2026). Mobile Fact Sheet (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo