Call handling

Answering service vs call center for a plumbing shop

Answering services relay messages; call centers can run scripted booking calls. How the work, the contracts and the volume where each pays off differ.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing8 min read

On this page
  1. Message desk or booking desk
  2. Two industries of very different size
  3. What the agent does on your call
  4. Contract shape: plans versus seats
  5. The volume where each one makes sense
  6. What a booking desk needs from you
  7. Price the in-house hours first
  8. Where an SI Employee fits between them
  9. Questions for either one
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References
Call handling: Answering service vs call center for a plumbing shop385,860: people worked at US contact centers in 2022, against 50,782 at telephone answering servicesCALL HANDLINGAnswering service vs callcenter for a plumbing shop385,860people worked at US contact centers in 2022,against 50,782 at telephone answering servicesAva for PlumbersInsightsCall handling: Answering service vs call center for a plumbing shop385,860: people worked at US contact centers in 2022, against 50,782 at telephone answering servicesCALL HANDLINGAnswering service vscall center for aplumbing shop385,860people worked at US contact centers in2022, against 50,782 at telephoneanswering servicesAva for Plumbers
Figure source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2022[1]

Key takeaways

  • The Census Bureau separates the two: answering services answer calls and relay messages, while contact centers take orders and give information on a client's behalf[2].
  • Contact centers are the far bigger industry, and 85.7% of their jobs sit in firms with 500 or more staff, against 66.8% at answering services[1].
  • A call center earns its fee when it is scripted to book. Used as a message desk, it is an answering service with a longer contract.
  • Work out agent hours from your own call log before taking a quote: a few hours of booking work a day, spread thin, rarely justifies dedicated agents.

Message desk or booking desk

The Census Bureau files answering services and call centers under separate industry codes, and the line it draws is the one that matters to a plumbing shop. Telephone answering services answer calls and relay messages on behalf of clients. Contact centers, filed with telemarketing bureaus, receive or make calls to promote products, take orders, and provide information or assistance, again for clients[2].

Translate that to your phones. An answering service is built to write down what the caller needs and get it to you fast. A call center is built to finish a piece of business on your behalf, which for a plumber means booking the job, quoting the trip fee you approved, or ringing maintenance members to set their annual visit. Either can be set up to do less than that. Asking an answering service to do more usually means extra scripting, schedule access and fees, so ask before you assume.

Two industries of very different size

Answering services and contact centers in 2022
  • 975

    telephone answering service firms[1]

  • 50,782

    people employed at answering services[1]

  • 2,299

    contact center and telemarketing firms[1]

  • 385,860

    people employed at contact centers[1]

Census Bureau, Statistics of U.S. Businesses 2022. Contact centers are counted together with telemarketing bureaus.

Contact centers employ more than seven times as many people as answering services, and the work is concentrated in big operations. In 2022, 85.7% of contact-center employment was in firms with 500 or more staff, against 66.8% at answering services, which also keep a longer tail of small local firms[1].

Share of employment by firm size, 2022Each industry adds to 100%. Firm size is the number of employees across the whole firm.
Share of employment by firm size, 2022Bar chart. Under 20 employees: Telephone answering services 8.7%, Contact centers and telemarketing 1.5%; 20 to 99: Telephone answering services 14.9%, Contact centers and telemarketing 4.5%; 100 to 499: Telephone answering services 9.7%, Contact centers and telemarketing 8.4%; 500 or more: Telephone answering services 66.8%, Contact centers and telemarketing 85.7%.Under 20 employeesUnder 20 employees · Telephone answering services: 8.7%8.7%Under 20 employees · Contact centers and telemarketing: 1.5%1.5%20 to 9920 to 99 · Telephone answering services: 14.9%14.9%20 to 99 · Contact centers and telemarketing: 4.5%4.5%100 to 499100 to 499 · Telephone answering services: 9.7%9.7%100 to 499 · Contact centers and telemarketing: 8.4%8.4%500 or more500 or more · Telephone answering services: 66.8%66.8%500 or more · Contact centers and telemarketing: 85.7%85.7%Share of employment by firm size, 2022Bar chart. Under 20 employees: Telephone answering services 8.7%, Contact centers and telemarketing 1.5%; 20 to 99: Telephone answering services 14.9%, Contact centers and telemarketing 4.5%; 100 to 499: Telephone answering services 9.7%, Contact centers and telemarketing 8.4%; 500 or more: Telephone answering services 66.8%, Contact centers and telemarketing 85.7%.Under 20 employeesUnder 20 employees · Telephone answering services: 8.7%8.7%Under 20 employees · Contact centers and telemarketing: 1.5%1.5%20 to 9920 to 99 · Telephone answering services: 14.9%14.9%20 to 99 · Contact centers and telemarketing: 4.5%4.5%100 to 499100 to 499 · Telephone answering services: 9.7%9.7%100 to 499 · Contact centers and telemarketing: 8.4%8.4%500 or more500 or more · Telephone answering services: 66.8%66.8%500 or more · Contact centers and telemarketing: 85.7%85.7%
  • Telephone answering services
  • Contact centers and telemarketing

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2022[1]

Show the data
Firm sizeTelephone answering servicesContact centers and telemarketing
Under 20 employees8.7%1.5%
20 to 9914.9%4.5%
100 to 4999.7%8.4%
500 or more66.8%85.7%

For a five-truck shop that has a practical meaning. At a large center, agents work across many clients and are scheduled to forecasts, so a small account gets the attention its script and its volume earn. A small answering service may know your name and your on-call tech's voice, and may also have a single operator covering every client at 2 a.m. Ask both how many people answer overnight and how many clients they cover between them.

What the agent does on your call

Typical setups. Plenty of providers blur the line, so judge the contract and the script rather than the label.
AreaAnswering serviceCall center set up to book
Agent's jobAnswer, capture details, relay the message, patch urgent callsFollow a booking script and finish the transaction on the call
Script depthGreeting, message fields, escalation rulesJob types, qualifying questions, booking rules, answers to common objections
Your scheduleUsually none; the office books on callbackAccess to your schedule or a booking portal, often with rules by job type
Training on your tradeShort; mostly your instruction sheetLonger onboarding, sometimes dedicated agents
Outbound callsRarely offeredOften offered: maintenance reminders, unsold estimates, past customers
After the callA message by email or textA booked job with notes, or a disposition code
Best fitNights, weekends and modest overflowSteady volume that needs booking at scale

The outbound row matters more than owners expect. Ringing maintenance members to book a visit, or chasing estimates that never closed, is classic call-center work, and it carries its own consent and do-not-call obligations. Settle in writing who is responsible for those before anyone dials, and keep inbound and outbound results in separate reports so you can judge each one.

Contract shape: plans versus seats

The two industries sell differently, and the shape of the contract tells you which one you are buying. Answering services usually sell plans with an allowance of minutes or calls and an overage rate; how answering services charge walks through those models. Call centers more often sell agent time: shared agents billed by the minute or hour, or dedicated agents billed as seats, with an onboarding period, a minimum term and a volume forecast you are asked to stand behind.

  • Volume forecasts. You estimate calls by hour and day, staffing is built on that estimate, and repeated misses in either direction can trigger re-pricing.
  • Onboarding and training time, billed or bundled, plus retraining whenever your offer, prices or service area change.
  • Service levels, usually a share of calls answered within a set number of seconds, measured monthly.
  • Quality monitoring: who scores calls, how often, and whether you see the scores and the recordings behind them.
  • Ownership of scripts, recordings and customer data, and how each comes back to you when the contract ends.

Read those clauses with the same care as the rate. Answering service contract terms goes through them one by one, and most apply to call-center agreements too.

The volume where each one makes sense

The deciding number is agent time, not call count. Example: a plumbing booking call that runs five minutes, plus a minute of notes, uses six minutes of an agent. Forty-five of those on a weekday come to 270 minutes, four and a half hours of work spread across a ten-hour day. That keeps no dedicated agent busy, which is why small shops end up on shared desks, whether an answering service or a call center's shared pool.

  1. Pull four weeks of calls

    Use the phone system's report, not memory, and split business hours, evenings and weekends. Call answer rate benchmarks show how to read it.

  2. Sort by what the caller needed

    New booking, existing job, emergency, vendor or spam. Only the first three need an agent who knows your business.

  3. Multiply by handle time

    Time ten real booking calls, notes included. Most offices underestimate the work after the caller hangs up.

  4. Find the peak hour

    Monday mornings and the first freeze night drive staffing, not the weekly average.

  5. Match the shape

    A few hours of agent time a day suits a shared desk. Full days of booking work at steady volume start to justify dedicated agents.

The commercial contractor example sits near the middle: about 85 calls a weekday plus 30 to 40 a week after hours, with most of the risk in routing and paperwork rather than raw volume. A shop that size could justify booking agents by day, yet still needs message-and-escalate cover at night.

What a booking desk needs from you

A call center can only book as well as the material you hand it. Treat onboarding like training a new CSR, because that is what it is; hiring and training plumbing CSRs covers the same ground for your own staff. Before go-live, the desk needs at least this much in writing:

  • Jobs you take and jobs you decline, with the words to use when declining.
  • Your service area by ZIP code, and what to say to callers just outside it.
  • Booking windows by job type: which work may be booked directly, which needs an office callback, and which goes straight to the on-call tech.
  • Fee wording you approve, word for word, and the questions agents must never price.
  • The on-call rota with primary and backup numbers, kept current every week.
  • Answers to the questions callers always ask: hours, weekend work, licensing, warranty, how soon a tech can arrive.

An answering service needs a shorter version of the same pack, because it is mostly capturing and routing. The longer the pack, the more the provider's onboarding time matters, and the more it costs you when they rotate agents and the new ones learn your trade on live callers.

Price the in-house hours first

Before comparing quotes, price the same work done by your own staff. Customer service representatives earned a median $21.53 an hour nationally in 2025[3]; at plumbing, heating and air-conditioning contractors the median was $22.22[4]. Benefits add to that: they make up 30% of what private employers spend on pay and benefits combined[5]. Switchboard and answering-service operators earned a median $18.57[6]. Whoever picks up your line, the trade knowledge comes from the script you write.

ExampleExample: in-house hours an outside booking desk would take on
Example: worked figures
InputExample
Inbound calls on a weekday45
Minutes per call, including notes6
Share you would hand to the outside desk40%
CSR cost per hour with benefits$31.74
Calls a month977
Staff hours on these calls98
Hours handed off39
Monthly value of that staff time$1,240

How it is worked out: Calls a day × 21.7 working days × minutes per call ÷ 60 × share handled = hours; hours × hourly cost.

Assumptions

  • $31.74 an hour is the $22.22 median CSR wage at plumbing, heating and air-conditioning contractors divided by 0.70, since wages are about 70% of private-industry compensation.[4]
  • Benefits average 30% of private employer compensation costs.[5]
  • The 40% share stands for evening, lunch and overflow calls in this Example; use your own split from the call log.

Example. Compare the monthly figure with an outside quote for the same calls, minimums and fees included.

In this Example about 39 hours of booking work a month would move off your staff, roughly $1,240 of CSR time. If a call center's quote for that work, minimums included, sits well above that, keep booking in house and buy message cover for nights. If it is close and the center books well, the outside desk also covers sick days and turnover. BLS notes that CSRs often need to work evenings, weekends and holidays during busy times[3], which is hard to staff with one person; in-house CSR vs answering service sets out that trade-off.

Where an SI Employee fits between them

An SI Employee sits between the two in the work it does. Like a booking desk, it takes the job details, reads them back and books routine work such as service calls, drain cleanings and estimate visits into one tested schedule, or leaves a request for your office to confirm. Like an answering service, it covers nights, weekends and busy lines on a forwarded number, and sends urgent calls along the on-call path you approve: primary tech, then backup, then a plain message to the caller and an urgent note to you if nobody picks up. Texting callers and creating jobs in field-service software are planned, not live. See how it works and run it through the same test calls you would give a call center.

Questions for either one

  • How many agents answer overnight, and how many clients do they cover?
  • Will my calls go to named agents or a shared pool?
  • Can the agent book into my schedule, and which job types are allowed?
  • What does the agent tell the caller when my on-call tech does not answer?
  • Which service level is in the contract, how is it measured, and what happens when it is missed?
  • What comes back to me at the end: recordings, call data and scripts?

Then test with your own calls. Virtual receptionist vs answering service compares the front-desk version of this choice, and running a remote CSR team covers keeping the work in house but off site.

Frequently asked questions

Is a call center more expensive than an answering service?

Per call it can be, because a booking agent spends longer on each call than a message taker. The fair comparison is cost per booked job, not cost per minute; cost per lead vs cost per booked job shows the arithmetic.

Can a call center handle plumbing emergencies?

It can if the script defines an emergency and the escalation path is tested at night. A booking script does not replace your on-call rules, so attach them to the contract.

What volume justifies a dedicated agent?

Enough booking work to fill most of an agent's paid hours at steady volume. Work it out from call counts and handle times; a few hours of work spread across a ten-hour day suits a shared desk.

Should outbound calling go to the same provider?

Only if they can show how they handle consent and do-not-call requests, and you keep ownership of the call lists and recordings. Report inbound and outbound separately so you can judge each one.

Do both record calls?

Ask. Where calls are recorded, the contract should say who owns the recordings, how long they are kept, how you export them and who plays the recording notice.

References

  1. U.S. Census Bureau (2022). Statistics of U.S. Businesses 2022: U.S. and states, 6-digit NAICS (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. U.S. Census Bureau (2022). 2022 NAICS Descriptions (561421 Telephone Answering Services; 561422 Telemarketing Bureaus and Other Contact Centers) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Customer Service Representatives (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (Public Data API) (2025). Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, May 2025: Customer Service Representatives (43-4051), hourly median wage, NAICS 238220 plumbing, heating and air-conditioning contractors (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employer Costs for Employee Compensation - June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. O*NET OnLine (U.S. Department of Labor, Employment and Training Administration) (2025). 43-2011.00 - Switchboard Operators, Including Answering Service (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo