Key takeaways
- Write one page in the order a call happens: greeting, service area, jobs, emergency test, wake ladder, price lines, fields to collect and where messages go.
- Turn “emergency” into yes-or-no questions. Water claims run at 1.50 per 100 insured homes a year and averaged $15,400[1].
- Script every price sentence word for word and quote the full amount; California's SB 478 bans advertised prices that leave out required fees[2].
- Prove the service follows the sheet with five test calls before the first night, then every quarter.
Why one page beats a binder
An answering service starts every account knowing nothing about your company except what you put in writing. The agent who takes a burst-pipe call at 2 am has your instructions on one screen, a frightened homeowner in one ear and a few seconds to find the right line. A three-page welcome letter about your history and values doesn't help them. One page, laid out in the order the call happens, does.
The service covers the hours your office doesn't. On an average weekday in 2025, 80.5% of employed people worked; on an average Saturday, Sunday or holiday, 30.3% did[3]. Plumbing doesn't take those days off: BLS notes that plumbers are often on call for emergencies, so evening and weekend work is common[4]. The instruction sheet is what lets someone outside your company make your decisions while you sleep.
This guide is the onboarding document itself: what goes on the sheet, exact wording for prices and emergencies, a finished Example, and the test calls that prove the service is following it. If you are still choosing a provider, start with the questions to ask an answering service.
The eight blocks, in call order
Write the sheet in the order an agent needs it during a call. Each block should fit in a few lines; if it doesn't, the rule is too complicated to follow at speed, and an agent under pressure will skip it.
| Block | What to write | Keep it to |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Greeting and disclosure | The exact opening line, the company name as callers know it, and any recording notice | One sentence |
| 2. Service area | ZIP codes or towns you cover, the edge cases, and what to tell callers outside them | A ZIP list plus one rule |
| 3. Jobs you take and don't | Services to book, work you refuse, and work you only do in daytime | Two short lists |
| 4. Emergency test | Yes-or-no questions that decide whether a call is urgent tonight | Four or five questions |
| 5. Who to wake | Names, numbers, order, how long to wait at each step, and the last resort | A ladder with timers |
| 6. Price wording | The exact fee sentences and what never to quote | Two or three scripted lines |
| 7. What to collect | The fields every message needs, with the number and address read back | Seven fields |
| 8. Where it goes | Who gets routine messages, by what time, and how urgent ones are flagged | Names and deadlines |
Block 2 needs a decision before it needs words. How far you will drive at night is often shorter than how far you drive by day, and the sheet should say so plainly; limiting after-hours service areas covers how to draw that line. Block 3 is the one owners skip, and it is the one that stops a service from booking a septic pump-out for a company that doesn't own a pump truck.
Write the emergency test as yes-or-no questions
Agents can't judge plumbing, but they can record a yes or a no. Water is where most of the judgment calls come from: across 2019 to 2023, insured homes filed 1.50 water damage and freezing claims per 100 homes a year, second only to wind and hail[1].
Those claims are expensive, averaging $15,400[1], which is why a cautious service costs you less than a careless one. Give the agent questions, not adjectives like “serious” or “major”:
- Is water coming out right now that the caller cannot stop at the fixture or the main shutoff?
- Is sewage or wastewater coming up into the home or business?
- Does the whole property have no water at all?
- Is a water heater leaking where the water could reach wiring, or can the caller not shut it off?
- Does the caller smell gas? If yes, the agent reads the gas line below and nothing else.
Gas line, word for word: “Please leave the building now. Don't switch lights on or off, and don't use your phone inside. Once you're outside and away from the smell, call 911 and your gas company.” This follows the public advice from Pennsylvania's utility regulator[5]; check your own state's or gas utility's wording and match it.
Then say what a yes means. A simple rule works for most small shops: one yes wakes the on-call tech; all no means a message for the morning, plus the shutoff advice from walking callers through a water shutoff if water is involved. The longer version, with different thresholds for evening and the middle of the night, is in when to wake the on-call tech.
Who to wake, and what happens when nobody answers
The wake ladder fails when the sheet says “call Mike” and nothing about what to do when Mike doesn't pick up. Write it as steps with minutes attached.
01Your team
A yes on the test
The agent records a yes on one of the written emergency questions.
02Your team
Call the on-call tech
Two tries over five minutes; leave a voicemail with the address.
03Your team
Call the backup
The second name on this week's rota, same five minutes.
04Your team
Call the owner
Last resort, any hour, for sewage or water that can't be stopped.
05Your team
Tell the caller plainly
Who was tried, when someone will call, and shutoff steps meanwhile.
Example ladder. Set your own waits, and write them as minutes, never “a while”.
Two details prevent most bad nights. Give the service the numbers in the order you want them used, either with the week's rota attached or as a single on-call number that you redirect yourself. And tell the service what to say when the ladder runs out: a specific time someone will call, not “someone will get back to you.” The no-answer backup plan has timer settings that suit a small bench.
Price wording, word for word
Never let an agent improvise a price. Give them the sentences, and tell them that anything else becomes a message for the office. Most shops need three lines. Example wording, with placeholder figures to replace with your own:
- Example, after-hours visit: “Our after-hours visit fee is $189. That covers the trip and the first 30 minutes, and the technician gives you a price for the repair before starting any work.”
- Example, daytime service call: “Our service call is $89, and the technician quotes the repair before doing it.”
- Example, anything else: “I can't quote that job, but someone from the office will call you with a price by 10 tomorrow morning.”
Quote the full amount the customer pays to get someone out. Since July 2024, California's SB 478 has made it illegal for most businesses to advertise a price that leaves out required fees, and the state Attorney General says a business may not advertise one price and add a service fee later[2]. Even where that law doesn't apply, “$89 plus a trip charge” sounds like a trick to a customer at midnight. For setting the number itself, see setting an after-hours emergency fee.
The recording and disclosure line
If the service records calls, put the notice in the greeting and keep a copy of the wording on the sheet. Federal law allows a call to be recorded when one party consents, but some states require consent from everyone on the call[6]. For a shop near a state line, the simple habit is to tell every caller. Call recording consent rules covers the state differences.
Example: a finished instruction sheet
This is the whole sheet for a fictional four-truck company. Printed, it fits on one page, and every line answers a question an agent would otherwise have to guess.
| Section | Instruction |
|---|---|
| Header | Example: Northfield Plumbing & Drain. Version 7, updated Monday. Office manager: 555-010-4471. |
| Greeting | “Thanks for calling Northfield Plumbing. This call is recorded. How can I help?” |
| Service area | The 14 ZIP codes on the attached list. Outside them: “We don't cover that area, but I can take your number for the office.” No referrals. |
| We do | Leaks, clogs, water heaters, sump pumps, sewer backups, fixture repairs, estimates for repipes. |
| We don't | Wells, septic pumping, gas line work, new construction, irrigation. |
| Emergency test | Water that can't be stopped; sewage coming up; no water at all; water heater leaking near wiring. Gas smell: read the gas line, then end the call. |
| Wake ladder | On-call tech (rota attached), two tries over five minutes; backup, five minutes; owner for sewage or uncontrolled water only. |
| Prices | Read the after-hours and service call lines only. Never quote repairs, replacements or estimates. |
| Collect | Name, mobile number read back, service address and ZIP, what happened in the caller's words, urgency, best time to call, new or existing customer. |
| Delivery | Routine messages by email to the office before 7:30 am. Urgent: phone the on-call tech first, then email with URGENT in the subject. |
| Never | Promise an arrival time, diagnose, give repair advice beyond the shutoff, or discuss invoices. |
Notice what is missing: no company history, no mission statement, no list of every service you have ever done. The “Never” row matters as much as the rest, because the most damaging thing an agent can say at night is a promise you didn't make, such as “someone will be there within the hour.”
Test the sheet before the first night
A sheet is only as good as the habit of reading it. Before real calls go to the service, make five test calls from phones it doesn't recognize, at different hours, and listen to the recordings.
A burst pipe at 1 am
Water you can't stop. Pass: the agent asks the emergency questions, gives shutoff advice and starts the wake ladder within the minutes you set.
An out-of-area caller
A ZIP you don't cover. Pass: your exact out-of-area line, and no promised callback you won't make.
A price shopper
“How much to replace a water heater?” Pass: no figure beyond your scripted fees, and a callback time.
A gas smell
Pass: the gas line is read word for word and nothing else is attempted.
An existing customer with a billing question
Pass: a message for the office, with no discussion of the invoice.
Score each call against the sheet, not against how pleasant the agent sounded, and send the service the exact line that was missed. Repeat the five calls after any change to the sheet and once a quarter after that. An answering service quality audit sets out a fuller monthly review.
The same sheet sets up an SI Employee
If unanswered calls go to an SI Employee instead of a human service, the sheet barely changes. Setup covers the same ground: the jobs you take and don't, the ZIP codes you cover, your hours, the fees you choose to share and the questions to ask, then who gets urgent calls, who backs them up and what callers hear when nobody picks up. Before any real call is forwarded, a burst pipe, an out-of-area caller and a routine booking are run through it as tests.
Two things work differently. The wake ladder becomes a transfer path: on-call tech first, then the backup, then a clear no-answer step, and if nobody answers, the caller is told plainly and an urgent message is saved. And each message arrives as a summary with the recording and transcript, by email and in the account, with urgent jobs marked urgent. The plumbing after-hours example walks through a full setup, and the 8-truck company example applies written wake rules to a modelled week of night calls.
Keep it current
Send a new version whenever something on the sheet changes: a ZIP added, a fee raised, a tech joining or leaving the rota, holiday cover. Ask the service to confirm which version they are working from. Old sheets cause the strangest failures, like a former employee woken at 3 am because their number was still at the top of the ladder, or a fee quoted that you dropped last spring.
Keep the old versions too. When a customer disputes what they were told on a night call, the recording plus the sheet that was live that night settles it quickly.
Frequently asked questions
How long should the instruction sheet be?
One printed page for the live call, with attachments for anything that changes weekly, such as the on-call rota or a long ZIP list. If an agent has to scroll to find the emergency test, it is too long.
Should the answering service quote prices?
Only the fee sentences you script word for word, such as the after-hours visit fee. Repairs and replacements should become a message with a callback time. Quote the full amount the customer will pay; California's honest pricing law bans advertised prices that leave out required fees[2].
What should the service do if nobody on the ladder answers?
Tell the caller exactly who was tried and when someone will call, repeat the shutoff advice, and mark the message urgent for the first person in the next morning. The agent should never promise an arrival time.
Can I just send the service my call script?
Send both if you like, but the sheet comes first. A script tells an agent what to say; the sheet tells them what to decide, and the decisions are where night calls go wrong.
How often should the sheet be updated?
Whenever a fee, ZIP, job type or rota number changes, with a new version number each time, plus a quarterly review with the five test calls.
References
Insurance Information Institute (2019-2023). Facts + Statistics: Homeowners and renters insurance (opens in a new tab) ↑
California Department of Justice, Office of the Attorney General (2024). SB 478 - Hidden Fees (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). American Time Use Survey, Table 4: Employed persons working and time spent working on days worked, 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission (2026). Gas Emergencies (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (U.S. Code) (2026). 18 U.S. Code § 2511 - Interception and disclosure of wire, oral, or electronic communications prohibited (opens in a new tab) ↑