Key takeaways
- Ownership comes first: your company must own the website, domain, ad accounts, tracking numbers and profiles.
- Ask for reports in booked jobs and revenue by channel, not impressions and rankings alone.
- Read the exit terms before the start terms: notice period, data hand-over and what happens to the website.
- Rule out any agency that writes, buys or incentivizes reviews; the FTC bans fake reviews, including AI-generated ones[1].
Why this decision matters
A marketing agency can be the best hire a plumbing company makes or the most expensive mistake. The difference rarely shows in the sales meeting. It shows a year later, when you want to know which spend produced jobs, or when you want to leave and discover the website, the phone numbers and the ad history belong to someone else.
Most plumbing businesses are small. About 63% of plumbing, heating and air-conditioning firms had annual receipts under $1 million in 2022[2]. For a company that size, a monthly retainer plus ad spend is one of the largest overheads after payroll and trucks, and it deserves the same scrutiny you would give a new van.
Know who you are competing with
The industry is splitting between many small firms and a few very large ones. In 2022, the 96,222 firms with fewer than 20 employees earned about 29% of industry receipts, while just 215 firms with 500 or more employees earned about 22%[3]. Large companies and consolidators often have in-house marketing teams, big ad budgets and their own call centers.
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2022[3]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| 96,222 firms with fewer than 20 employees | 29% |
| 215 firms with 500 or more employees | 22% |
That shapes what you need from an agency. You will rarely outspend the largest competitors, so the agency must help you win on local relevance, reviews, speed and conversion, and it must not also be working for the shop down the road. Ask directly about exclusivity in your service area.
Questions about ownership
- Will the domain be registered in our company's name, with us as the account owner?
- Will the website files and content be ours if we leave, and in what format will you hand them over?
- Are the Google Ads, Meta ads and other ad accounts created in our name, with us as an administrator?
- Are the call tracking numbers in an account we own, and can we keep the numbers if we part ways?
- Who is the primary owner of our Google Business Profile, and which access level will you have?
- Where are analytics, Search Console and tag manager accounts held, and do we have admin access?
For business profiles, the access level matters. Google's help pages explain that a profile can have several owners but only one primary owner, and that managers have mostly the same access as owners except that they cannot add or remove users or remove the profile[4]. Keep primary ownership yourself and give the agency manager access.
Questions about the work
- What exactly will you do each month, and how many hours does that represent?
- Who will do the work: in-house staff, freelancers or an overseas team?
- How do you write service and area pages, and will a licensed plumber on our team review them?
- Do you use AI tools to write content, and how is it checked for accuracy before publishing?
- How do you handle reviews and review requests?
- Which other plumbing or drain companies do you serve in our area?
AI use is now normal in small business: the U.S. Chamber of Commerce reported that 58% of small businesses used generative AI in 2025, up from 40% in 2024 and 23% in 2023[5]. That is fine if a person checks every fact. It is not fine if the agency publishes bulk-generated pages with your name on them and nobody reads them.
Questions about paid ads
- Which campaigns will you run first, and why those services and towns?
- How will you exclude areas, hours and job types we do not want?
- Do you add negative keywords to block searches such as plumber jobs or DIY questions?
- Will ads send people to dedicated landing pages, and who builds them?
- How will you handle hours when our phones are not answered?
- How quickly will you pause spend if lead quality drops?
Good agencies answer these with specifics about your market. Weak ones answer with general promises about optimization and algorithms.
Questions about the website
Ask where the website will be hosted and who pays the hosting bill, which platform it is built on, and whether another developer could take it over without rebuilding. Ask how fast pages load on phones, how they will handle your existing pages and links if they rebuild, and who updates prices, photos and hours. A website built on a proprietary platform that only the agency can edit makes you dependent on them for every small change, and often means starting from scratch if you leave.
Questions about reporting
- Will your reports show calls, booked jobs and revenue by channel, using our scheduling or invoice data?
- How will you separate repeat customers and referrals from new customers won by ads?
- Will we get call recordings or call logs to check lead quality?
- How often do we meet, and who attends from your side?
- What would make you recommend cutting a channel you manage?
An agency that only reports impressions, clicks and rankings is reporting its activity, not your results. Insist on numbers that tie to booked jobs, as described in tracking which marketing books jobs.
Contract terms to read twice
| Term | Good answer | Red flag |
|---|---|---|
| Length | Month to month after a short initial period | Long lock-in with automatic renewal |
| Notice period | Short, stated in days | Long notice plus early termination fees |
| Website ownership | Ours, with files handed over on exit | Leased site that disappears when you leave |
| Ad spend | Paid directly by us to the platform | Agency marks up spend without showing invoices |
| Tracking numbers | Ported or transferred to us | Numbers stay with the agency |
| Exclusivity | No direct competitor in our area | No answer, or a fee for exclusivity |
| Data on exit | All reports, logins and content within days | Data released only after a fee |
Red flags in the sales meeting
- Guaranteed rankings, guaranteed lead numbers or guaranteed placement in AI answers.
- A discount that expires today if you sign now.
- Vague answers about who owns accounts and the website.
- Case studies with no company names or contactable references.
- Reluctance to let you speak with current plumbing clients.
What a fair trial looks like
Even a good agency needs time. Search and content work often takes months to show results, while ads can show early signals within weeks. Agree on a trial of about one quarter with clear goals: for example, call tracking working on every channel, reporting tied to booked jobs, and a stated target for cost per booked job on paid ads. At the end of the trial, decide based on those goals. If the agency would not agree to measurable goals for a trial, it is unlikely to be accountable later.
Reviews: a hard line
Some agencies still offer review packages. The FTC's 2024 rule bans creating or selling fake reviews and testimonials, including AI-generated fake reviews[1], and it also bans using unfounded legal threats or intimidation to suppress negative reviews[1]. If an agency offers to post reviews, buy them, or gate requests so only happy customers are asked on public sites, walk away. Your company carries the risk, not the agency.
Example: comparing two proposals
Example (fictional): Agency A offers a low monthly fee, a new website in two weeks and guaranteed first-page rankings, with a 24-month contract. The website is hosted on its platform and stays with it if you cancel. Agency B charges more, quotes a month-to-month agreement after three months, builds the site on your own hosting and domain, and promises monthly reports on calls, booked jobs and revenue by channel using your field service data. Agency B is more expensive on paper and cheaper in every way that matters.
Onboarding the right way
List every account
Write down every marketing account and who owns it before the agency starts.
Grant access, not ownership
Invite the agency as a user or manager on accounts you own.
Agree the baseline
Record last year's calls, booked jobs and revenue by channel so progress can be measured.
Set the reporting format
Agree on one monthly report and the data it will use.
Book a 90-day review
Put a decision meeting in the calendar with clear success criteria.
Signs it is time to part ways
- Reports change format whenever results are poor.
- You cannot get admin access to your own accounts.
- Booked jobs from managed channels fall while spend rises, with no clear explanation.
- The agency resists call tracking or sharing call recordings.
- Your account manager changes every few months.
Frequently asked questions
What should I ask a plumbing marketing agency?
Ask who owns the website, domain, ad accounts and tracking numbers; what work is done each month; how results are reported in booked jobs; and what the exit terms are.
Should a marketing agency own my Google Business Profile?
No. Keep primary ownership in your company and give the agency manager access, which lets it work on the profile without adding or removing users.
Are long marketing contracts normal?
Some agencies use them, but month-to-month terms after a short start period protect you far better.
Can an agency post reviews for my plumbing company?
No. Fake or bought reviews are banned by the FTC, and incentives tied to positive reviews are banned too.
References
Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Census Bureau (2022). Statistics of U.S. Businesses 2022: Firms by industry and enterprise receipts size (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Census Bureau (2022). Statistics of U.S. Businesses 2022: U.S. and states, 6-digit NAICS (opens in a new tab) โ
Google Business Profile Help (2026). Manage your Business Profile owners & managers (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Chamber of Commerce Technology Engagement Center (2025). Empowering Small Business: The Impact of Technology on U.S. Small Business (2025) (opens in a new tab) โ