Call handling

Should a plumbing company use a phone menu?

When a phone menu helps or hurts a plumbing company, how many options to offer, why emergencies come first and how to test whether callers abandon it.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing6 min read

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. Options compared
  3. When a menu helps
  4. When a menu hurts
  5. Design rules if you use one
  6. Sample menus
  7. Language options
  8. Emergencies deserve their own path
  9. Measure whether the menu works
  10. Menus after hours
  11. Example: removing a menu
  12. A quick decision checklist
  13. Frequently asked questions
  14. References
Call handling: Should a plumbing company use a phone menu?Article coverCALL HANDLINGShould a plumbingcompany use a phonemenu?Ava for PlumbersInsightsCall handling: Should a plumbing company use a phone menu?Article coverCALL HANDLINGShould a plumbingcompany use a phonemenu?Ava for Plumbers

Key takeaways

  • Most small plumbing shops do better without a phone menu: a person answering on the first ring beats any menu for speed and trust.
  • A menu helps when calls genuinely need different teams, such as residential service, commercial work, billing or several locations.
  • If you use one, keep it to three options or fewer, put emergencies first and let callers reach a person without pressing anything.
  • Language options deserve care: 39% of people who speak Spanish at home speak English less than very well[1], so a bilingual answer may serve them better than "press 2".

The short answer

For most plumbing companies, the best phone menu is no phone menu. Callers ring a plumber because something is wrong, often urgently. Every second spent listening to options is a second they are not explaining the problem, and a second in which they might hang up and call the next company.

That changes as a company grows. A shop with separate residential, commercial and billing teams, or several branches, may route calls faster with a short menu than with a single receptionist passing calls around. The decision comes down to whether the menu saves the caller time or only saves the office effort.

Options compared

Phone answering options for plumbing companies
OptionBest forStrengthRisk
Live answer, no menuMost shops under about 20 staffFastest, most personalNeeds enough people or overflow cover
Live answer, then transferShops with a few specialist staffCaller talks to a person firstTransfers can drop or wait
One-option menu: press 1 for emergencyShops with a separate on-call lineGets emergencies out of the queueAdds a few seconds for everyone else
Short menu: up to three optionsLarger shops with distinct teamsRoutes to the right teamAbandonment if options are unclear
Deep menu with sub-levelsRarely suitableDetailed routingHigh abandonment and frustration

In the US, about 58% of plumbing, heating and AC establishments have fewer than five employees[2]. In a shop that size, every menu option usually rings the same one or two people anyway. A menu just adds delay before they answer.

When a menu helps

  • You have separate teams that cannot handle each other's calls, such as commercial project managers and residential CSRs.
  • A large share of calls are not new work: billing questions, supplier calls, job applicants. Routing them away keeps CSRs free for customers.
  • You run several branches and callers need to reach the right one.
  • You want a fast lane for emergencies that skips any queue and goes straight to the on-call path.
  • Your phone reports show that transfers by a receptionist are causing long waits or dropped calls.

When a menu hurts

  • Emergency callers must listen to several options before finding the right one.
  • Options overlap, so callers do not know whether "service" or "repairs" is the right choice.
  • The menu plays a long greeting or promotion before the options.
  • Every option rings the same group, so the menu does nothing but add time.
  • There is no way to reach a person without choosing.
  • Older callers or callers on a poor mobile connection struggle to hear or press the options. Most older adults do have mobile phones, with 96% of those aged 65 and older owning a cellphone[3], but a menu designed around fast keypad use still trips many callers up.

Design rules if you use one

  1. Emergencies first. "If you have a plumbing emergency, such as an active leak or sewage backup, press 1." The urgent caller should not wait for any other option.
  2. Three options at most, plus "stay on the line to speak with someone".
  3. No sub-menus. If you need more routing, have the person who answers transfer the call.
  4. Keep the whole menu under about fifteen seconds.
  5. Put the most common option early, after emergencies.
  6. Never end in voicemail without a final attempt to reach a person.
  7. If callers do nothing, send them to a person, not back to the start of the menu.
  8. Say the company name before the menu so callers know they reached the right place.

Sample menus

A one-option emergency menu:

"Thanks for calling Westbrook Plumbing. If water is leaking right now or sewage is backing up, press 1 to reach our emergency team. Otherwise, stay on the line and we'll be right with you."

A three-option menu for a larger shop:

"Thanks for calling Westbrook Plumbing. For an emergency, press 1. To book service or an estimate, press 2. For billing or an existing job, press 3. Or stay on the line to speak with our team."

What to avoid:

"Thank you for calling Westbrook Plumbing, serving the region with pride. Please listen carefully, as our menu options have changed. For new service, press 1. For maintenance plans, press 2. For commercial, press 3. For billing, press 4. For careers, press 5. For all other inquiries, press 6..."

That last version takes over twenty seconds before the caller hears a useful choice, buries emergencies and invites hang-ups.

Language options

In 2019, 67.8 million people in the US spoke a language other than English at home, and 62% of them spoke Spanish[1]. Many speak English well, but a significant share do not, and for some languages more than half of speakers say they speak English less than very well[1].

Many callers at home in another language need help in itShare of people who spoke each language at home and spoke English less than very well, 2019.
Many callers at home in another language need help in itBar chart. Vietnamese: 57%; Chinese: 52%; Spanish: 39%; Arabic: 35%; Tagalog: 30%.VietnameseVietnamese: 57%57%ChineseChinese: 52%52%SpanishSpanish: 39%39%ArabicArabic: 35%35%TagalogTagalog: 30%30%Many callers at home in another language need help in itBar chart. Vietnamese: 57%; Chinese: 52%; Spanish: 39%; Arabic: 35%; Tagalog: 30%.VietnameseVietnamese: 57%57%ChineseChinese: 52%52%SpanishSpanish: 39%39%ArabicArabic: 35%35%TagalogTagalog: 30%30%

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2022[1]

Show the data
Language spoken at homeSpeak English less than very well (%)
Vietnamese57%
Chinese52%
Spanish39%
Arabic35%
Tagalog30%

"Para espaΓ±ol, oprima 2" is better than nothing, but it only works if a Spanish speaker answers when the caller presses it. If nobody does, the option sends Spanish-speaking callers to voicemail. Better options are a bilingual CSR in the primary group, a separate Spanish-language line advertised in Spanish, or an answering option that follows the caller's language from the first words.

Emergencies deserve their own path

Water damage and freezing claims averaged about $15,400 over 2019 to 2023[4]. Whatever your menu design, a caller with an active leak must reach a person or your on-call path within seconds. Options:

  • Make "press 1 for emergency" the first thing callers hear, and route it to the on-call group with no queue.
  • Advertise a separate emergency number that skips the menu entirely.
  • Answer every call live and triage in the first question, with no menu at all.

Whichever you choose, test it after hours as well as during the day.

Measure whether the menu works

Your phone system can usually report what happens inside the menu. Look at:

  • Menu abandonment: callers who hang up before choosing or reaching a person.
  • Option split: how many callers choose each option. An option nobody uses should go.
  • Zero-outs: callers who press 0 or wait for a person. A high share means the options do not match why people call.
  • Time to answer from the start of the call, not from when the call reached a ring group.

Callers who hang up in a menu rarely wait for a callback. Eight in ten Americans say they generally do not answer calls from unknown numbers[5], so a lost caller is usually gone for good.

A menu that works in the daytime can fail at night. If option 2 rings the office ring group and the office is closed, callers who choose it may reach a closed-office message or voicemail while the on-call technician's phone never rings. Check every option against your after-hours schedule.

At night, most shops are better off switching to a single path: one short greeting, an immediate emergency route and a clear option to book for the next day. Some phone systems let you load a different menu for each schedule. If yours does, write the night version separately rather than reusing the day one, and keep it shorter, because the people calling at 2 am are almost always calling about a problem that cannot wait.

Example: removing a menu

Example: the fictional Westbrook Plumbing had a four-option menu that all rang the same three CSRs. Their phone report showed that 11% of callers hung up inside the menu, and the "maintenance plans" option was chosen by almost nobody.

They replaced it with a live answer plus a one-line emergency option. Example: over the next month, menu abandonment fell to 3%, average time to a person dropped by about fifteen seconds, and CSRs said callers were calmer because they no longer had to choose an option before being heard.

A quick decision checklist

  1. Count your teams

    If every call rings the same group, skip the menu.

  2. Check your reports

    Look at transfer times, abandonment and why people call.

  3. Decide on emergencies

    Choose between a first-option emergency route, a separate emergency number or live triage.

  4. Draft the menu

    Three options or fewer, emergencies first, a way to reach a person.

  5. Time it

    Read it aloud; cut anything that takes it over about fifteen seconds.

  6. Test and review

    Call it yourself at different times, then check abandonment after a month.

Frequently asked questions

Do small plumbing companies need a phone menu?

Usually not. If every option would ring the same people, a menu only adds delay. Answer live and use overflow rules to cover busy periods.

How many options should a phone menu have?

Three at most, plus a way to reach a person by staying on the line. Avoid sub-menus; they increase hang-ups.

Should "press 1 for emergencies" be the first option?

Yes. Emergency callers have the least patience and the most at stake, so their option should come first and skip any queue.

Is a "press 2 for Spanish" option a good idea?

Only if a Spanish speaker reliably answers that option. Otherwise it sends callers to voicemail. A bilingual answer in the primary group is usually better.

References

  1. U.S. Census Bureau (2022). Nearly 68 Million People Spoke a Language Other Than English at Home in 2019 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. U.S. Census Bureau (2023). County Business Patterns 2023, U.S. national file (cbp23us) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Pew Research Center (2026). Mobile Fact Sheet (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Insurance Information Institute (2019-2023). Facts + Statistics: Homeowners and renters insurance (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo