Key takeaways
- Most unhappy customers never tell you; they tell the internet or nobody. Only about one in ten Americans nearly always post reviews, so a complaint you hear is a chance to fix it before it is public[1].
- Use six steps: receive, acknowledge, investigate, decide, resolve, and close and learn.
- Set authority levels so the person on the phone knows what they can offer without asking.
- Log every complaint with a category and root cause. Patterns are the point.
- Damage complaints go to your insurer early. Water damage and freezing claims average $15,400[2].
Why a written process
Without a process, complaints are handled by whoever picks up the phone, in whatever mood they are in. Some customers get a refund for a minor issue; others with a real problem get a promise of a callback that never happens. Both outcomes cost money, and the second often ends in a public review. 54% of review readers pay more attention to extremely negative reviews[3].
A written process does three things. It gives every complaint the same basic treatment, it lets office staff resolve routine problems without hunting for the owner, and it produces a log you can learn from. For a small shop it fits on two pages.
What counts as a complaint
Define a complaint broadly: any time a customer says they are unhappy with the work, the price, the timing, the behavior of a team member or the state of their home, whether by phone, text, email, review or in person. If you define it narrowly, the log will miss exactly the issues that matter.
| Category | Examples | Default owner | Target first response |
|---|---|---|---|
| Workmanship | Leak returned, drain blocked again | Service manager | Same day |
| Price and billing | Bill higher than expected, unclear charges | Office manager | Same day |
| Timing | Late arrival, missed appointment, no call | Dispatcher | Same day |
| Conduct | Rude, careless or unsafe behavior | Owner or service manager | Within hours |
| Property damage | Water damage, broken tile, wall damage | Owner | Within hours |
| Safety | Gas smell after work, scald risk, electrical concern | On-call tech and owner | Immediately |
The six steps
Receive
Let the customer explain without interruption. Take notes in their words. Get name, address, job date and the best way to reach them.
Acknowledge
Thank them for telling you, say you are sorry they are dealing with this, and tell them exactly what happens next and when.
Investigate
Pull the job record, photos and notes. Talk to the tech the same day. Visit if needed.
Decide
Choose a remedy within the authority levels below, or escalate. Decide fast; delay is itself a second complaint.
Resolve
Call the customer with the decision, do what was promised, and confirm in writing by text or email.
Close and learn
Log the outcome and root cause. Check that the customer is satisfied with the resolution, not just that the ticket is closed.
The customer should never have to chase you. If you promised a call by 3 pm, call at 2:45, even if the only news is that you are still investigating.
What to say when the call comes in
- Open: “I’m sorry you’re having this problem. I want to make sure we get it right, so let me take down what happened.”
- Clarify: “Can you tell me when you first noticed it, and what it’s doing now?”
- Avoid blame: never say “the tech said you were told” or “that’s not our fault” on the first call.
- Commit: “I’m going to talk to the technician and the service manager this afternoon, and I’ll call you back by 4 pm with what we’ll do.”
- Urgent issues: if water is leaking now or there is a safety concern, dispatch first and investigate later.
Complaints do not keep office hours. A leak that returns at 9 pm needs the same first two steps, receive and acknowledge, even if investigation waits until morning. If your after-hours line is covered by an answering service or an SI Employee such as Ava, make sure it can take down the complaint in full and reach the on-call person for anything urgent.
Authority levels
| Level | Who | Can approve without asking | Escalate when |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Customer service or dispatcher | Free return visit for workmanship, rescheduling, apology call from manager | Customer asks for money back or damage is mentioned |
| 2 | Service or office manager | Partial refund or credit up to a set limit (Example: one service-call fee) | Request exceeds the limit or a pattern is involved |
| 3 | Owner | Full refund, larger credits, third-party repairs, damage settlements | Insurance, legal or safety issues |
Write the limits down and tell the team. A dispatcher who knows they can book a free return visit without permission will resolve most workmanship complaints in one call. A manager who knows their credit limit will not promise what the owner then has to refuse. Remedies for common problems are covered in service recovery offers.
Keep a complaint log
- Date received and channel (phone, text, email, review, in person).
- Customer and job reference.
- Category from the table above.
- Summary in the customer’s words.
- Technician and crew on the original job.
- Remedy offered and cost.
- Date resolved and whether the customer confirmed satisfaction.
- Root cause, chosen from a short list: training, process, parts, scheduling, communication, customer expectation.
If you record complaint calls, follow the consent rules. Federal law allows a call to be recorded when one party consents, but some states require every party’s consent[4]. The simplest approach is a short notice at the start of recorded calls and a written policy on who can listen to recordings.
Damage and safety complaints
Property damage complaints need extra care because the stakes are high. Water damage and freezing claims average $15,400 per homeowners insurance claim[2], and water damage or freezing losses hit about 1.6% of insured homes each year, second only to wind and hail[5].
Source: Insurance Information Institute, 2018-2022[5]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Wind and hail | 2.8% |
| Water damage and freezing | 1.6% |
- Make the home safe first: stop any active leak, ventilate if needed.
- Photograph everything before any cleanup, with time stamps.
- Tell your insurer or agent promptly, following your policy’s notice terms.
- Do not admit fault or promise to pay for damage in the first conversation; say you are taking it seriously and will follow up.
- Keep one point of contact, usually the owner, until the claim is settled.
$15,400
average homeowners insurance claim for water damage and freezing, 2019–2023[2]
When the complaint arrives as a review
Some customers skip the phone and go straight to a review. Treat that as a complaint received, not a marketing problem: log it, assign it an owner and run the same six steps. Try to reach the customer privately first, using the job record, then post a short public reply that acknowledges the issue and names a contact. The public reply and the private fix should say the same thing.
Once the problem is resolved, do not ask for the review to be removed as part of the deal. A customer who feels genuinely looked after often updates it unprompted; one who feels bargained with rarely does. Reply guidance is in responding to negative reviews.
Lines not to cross
- Do not threaten customers who post or plan to post a negative review. The FTC rule bans unfounded legal threats and intimidation used to suppress reviews[6].
- Do not offer a refund or credit on the condition that the customer removes or changes a review.
- Do not add clauses to your standard terms that restrict reviews; form-contract terms like that are barred by the Consumer Review Fairness Act.
- Do not discipline a technician on the basis of the customer’s account alone; investigate first.
Review the log monthly
The value of the log is in the patterns. Once a month, sort complaints by category and root cause and ask three questions. Which category grew? Which root cause appears most? Which single change would remove the most complaints next month? Typical answers are small: an on-the-way text rule, a fee explanation script, a parts-quality check, a ride-along for one tech.
Share a short summary with the team, without naming individuals. Complaints handled well are worth celebrating too: a customer who calls in angry and ends by booking their next job is a team win.
Example: one complaint, start to finish
Example (fictional): at 8 am a customer calls to say the toilet a tech replaced two days earlier is rocking and leaking at the base. The dispatcher apologizes, confirms no active flooding, books a free return visit for 11 am and logs it as workmanship. The tech finds the floor flange was cracked and not replaced. It is fixed by noon.
In this example the service manager calls the customer that afternoon to confirm all is well, notes the root cause as process (flange not checked) and adds “inspect and photograph the flange” to the toilet install checklist. No refund was needed, the customer posts a four-star review mentioning the quick return, and that particular complaint stops recurring. See explaining repairs in plain language and workmanship warranty terms.
Frequently asked questions
How should a plumbing company handle a customer complaint?
Receive it fully, acknowledge it, investigate the same day, decide on a remedy within set authority levels, resolve it and confirm in writing, then log the root cause.
Who should handle complaints in a small plumbing shop?
Routine complaints can be handled by the office or service manager within written limits. Damage, safety and conduct complaints go to the owner.
Should we record complaint calls?
It can help, but follow consent rules. Some states require all parties to consent, so give a notice at the start of recorded calls.
What if a complaint involves water damage to the home?
Make the home safe, photograph everything, notify your insurer promptly and avoid admitting fault in the first conversation.
References
Pew Research Center (2016). Online Reviews (Online Shopping and E-Commerce) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Insurance Information Institute (2019-2023). Facts + Statistics: Homeowners and renters insurance (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2016). Online Reviews (Online Shopping and E-Commerce) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (U.S. Code) (2026). 18 U.S. Code § 2511 - Interception and disclosure of wire, oral, or electronic communications prohibited (opens in a new tab) ↑
Insurance Information Institute (2018-2022). Facts + Statistics: Homeowners and renters insurance (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) ↑