Call handling

How to run a one-week call audit at your plumbing shop

A seven-day call audit for plumbing offices: what to export, four outcome buckets, a daily routine and a one-page report that shows where jobs leak.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. What a call audit tells you that a dashboard does not
  2. Choose the right week
  3. Before day one: what to export
  4. The four outcome buckets
  5. The daily routine
  6. How to classify the hard cases
  7. Build the one-page report
  8. Example: a first audit
  9. Turning findings into decisions
  10. Mistakes that spoil an audit
  11. Keep the audit fair to the team
  12. Frequently asked questions
  13. References
Call handling: How to run a one-week call audit at your plumbing shopArticle coverCALL HANDLINGHow to run a one-weekcall audit at yourplumbing shopAva for PlumbersInsightsCall handling: How to run a one-week call audit at your plumbing shopArticle coverCALL HANDLINGHow to run a one-weekcall audit at yourplumbing shopAva for Plumbers

Key takeaways

  • Seven consecutive days, every inbound call, four outcome buckets: booked, lost, unqualified and unanswered. That is the whole method.
  • Pick a normal week. Industry employment swings between winter and summer, and your call volume does too, so note the season on the report[1].
  • Include nights and weekends. Plumbers routinely work them, and that is where many shops have no one answering[2][3].
  • The output is one page: totals by bucket, the lost and unanswered calls by hour, and the three fixes with the biggest dollar value.

What a call audit tells you that a dashboard does not

Your phone system can tell you how many calls came in. It cannot tell you how many of them were jobs, how many your team turned away without meaning to, or which hour of the week loses the most work. A call audit answers those questions by putting a human label on every inbound call for a short, defined period.

One week is enough to find the big leaks. It covers each weekday, a weekend and at least one evening rush. It is also short enough that the office manager can finish it without the audit becoming a second job. Run a second week later to confirm a fix worked.

Choose the right week

Pick a week that looks like most of your year. Avoid the week of a cold snap, a holiday or a big marketing push unless that is exactly what you want to study. Employment at plumbing, heating and air-conditioning contractors rises from winter into summer and eases off again by December[1], and call volume moves with the same seasons.

Plumbing, heating and AC contractor jobs swing with the seasonsAll employees, not seasonally adjusted, selected months. September 2026 is preliminary.
Plumbing, heating and AC contractor jobs swing with the seasonsLine chart. Sep 2024: 1,315 thousand; Jan 2025: 1,294 thousand; Jul 2025: 1,335 thousand; Sep 2025: 1,325 thousand; Dec 2025: 1,318 thousand; Jan 2026: 1,306 thousand; Aug 2026: 1,358 thousand; Sep 2026: 1,347 thousand.1,280 thousand1,300 thousand1,320 thousand1,340 thousand1,360 thousandSep 2024Jul 2025Dec 2025Sep 2026Sep 2024: 1,315 thousandJan 2025: 1,294 thousandJul 2025: 1,335 thousandSep 2025: 1,325 thousandDec 2025: 1,318 thousandJan 2026: 1,306 thousandAug 2026: 1,358 thousandSep 2026: 1,347 thousand1,347 thousand1,315 thousandPlumbing, heating and AC contractor jobs swing with the seasonsLine chart. Sep 2024: 1,315 thousand; Jan 2025: 1,294 thousand; Jul 2025: 1,335 thousand; Sep 2025: 1,325 thousand; Dec 2025: 1,318 thousand; Jan 2026: 1,306 thousand; Aug 2026: 1,358 thousand; Sep 2026: 1,347 thousand.1,280 thousand1,300 thousand1,320 thousand1,340 thousand1,360 thousandSep 2024Sep 2026Sep 2024: 1,315 thousandJan 2025: 1,294 thousandJul 2025: 1,335 thousandSep 2025: 1,325 thousandDec 2025: 1,318 thousandJan 2026: 1,306 thousandAug 2026: 1,358 thousandSep 2026: 1,347 thousand1,347 thousand1,315 thousand

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics, 2025[1]

Show the data
MonthEmployees (thousands)
Sep 20241,315 thousand
Jan 20251,294 thousand
Jul 20251,335 thousand
Sep 20251,325 thousand
Dec 20251,318 thousand
Jan 20261,306 thousand
Aug 20261,358 thousand
Sep 20261,347 thousand

Write the season and any unusual events at the top of the report. A January audit and a July audit are both valid, but they should not be compared without that context.

Before day one: what to export

  • The full inbound call log for the seven days: date, time, caller number, line or tracking number called, ring duration, talk time and final disposition.
  • Voicemail list with timestamps, and the recordings if your system keeps them.
  • Call recordings, if you record calls and have the required consent in place.
  • Jobs created in your field-service software during the same seven days, with the phone number on each job.
  • Web form, chat and text requests for the same period, so you can see the requests that never became calls.

Put everything in one spreadsheet with a row per inbound call. Add four columns: bucket, reason, who handled it and dollar value if booked.

The four outcome buckets

Every call goes into exactly one bucket. Decide the rules before you start and write them at the top of the sheet so two people would classify the same call the same way.

The four buckets and how to apply them
BucketDefinitionTypical examplesWhat to record
BookedA new or returning customer request that became a scheduled visit or estimateDrain clog booked for tomorrow; water heater estimate setJob number and expected ticket
LostA real job request that was answered but not bookedCaller wanted a price only and hung up; no slot offered; out-of-area caller with no referralOne-line reason for the loss
UnqualifiedAnswered calls that were never a jobVendors, spam, job seekers, existing customers asking for an arrival timeCall type only
UnansweredCalls that reached no personRang out, hung up on hold, voicemail, full mailbox, menu abandonmentWhether a callback happened and its result

The daily routine

  1. Morning, 15 minutes

    Pull yesterday's calls into the sheet. Mark each one with a first-pass bucket from the disposition and the job list. Highlight anything you cannot place.

  2. Listen to the unclear ones

    Play the recordings or voicemails for the highlighted rows only. Most days that is a handful of calls. Fill in the bucket and a short reason.

  3. Check the unanswered rows

    For every unanswered call from a number that is not spam, note whether anyone called back, how long it took and what happened.

  4. Tag the hour

    Add the hour of the day and day of the week to each row so you can sort lost and unanswered calls by time later.

  5. Flag fixes as you see them

    If a call was lost for a reason that is easy to fix, such as a wrong service area answer, write it on a separate notes tab the same day.

  6. Weekend calls on Monday

    Do Saturday and Sunday on Monday morning, and give them extra attention. Only 30.3% of employed people work on an average weekend day or holiday, against 80.5% on a weekday[2], so your coverage is thinnest exactly when emergencies still happen.

  7. Day eight

    Lock the sheet. No more edits, only analysis.

How to classify the hard cases

  • A customer who calls three times before reaching someone counts once, in the bucket of the final outcome. Note the two failed attempts separately; they still tell you about coverage.
  • An existing customer asking about an open job is unqualified for booking purposes, but a long hold or unanswered call for them still belongs in your service-quality notes.
  • A caller who asks for a price, gets one and says they will call back is lost unless they rebook within the week.
  • A call answered by a tech in the field and booked from the truck is booked. Record that the tech took it; it shows how often the office misses calls.
  • A callback that reaches voicemail is not a recovery. Most people do not pick up calls from numbers they do not know[4], so log the attempt and the outcome honestly.

Build the one-page report

Keep it to one page so the owner reads it. Use this order:

  1. Week, season and anything unusual, such as a storm or a staff absence.
  2. Total inbound calls and unique callers.
  3. Count and share in each bucket.
  4. Lost calls by reason, largest first.
  5. Unanswered calls by hour block and day, with how many were called back and how many of those were won back.
  6. Estimated value of lost and unanswered jobs, using your average first-visit ticket. The missed call cost calculator shows the method.
  7. Three fixes, each with an owner and a date.

Example: a first audit

Example: the fictional Lakeshore Plumbing, an eight-person shop, ran its first audit in a quiet October week. It logged 186 inbound calls from 164 unique callers. Of those callers, 71 were booked, 19 were lost, 42 were unqualified and 32 were unanswered.

The detail was more useful than the totals. Example: 14 of the 32 unanswered calls arrived between 12 and 1 pm, when the single office person took lunch and calls rolled to a voicemail box. Another 9 came after 6 pm on weekdays. Seven of the lost calls were price shoppers who were quoted a repair price without a visit and never booked.

The three fixes chose themselves: a lunch cover rule, an evening answering plan and a new answer for price questions. Lakeshore is a typical size for the trade; about 77% of plumbing, heating and AC establishments have fewer than ten employees[5], and one-person office cover is common at that size.

Turning findings into decisions

Use simple criteria so the audit leads to action rather than debate:

  • If unanswered calls cluster in one or two hour blocks, fix coverage for those blocks first. That is usually cheaper than adding a full shift.
  • If lost calls are mainly one reason, fix the script for that reason and coach it in the next team meeting.
  • If unanswered calls are spread evenly across nights and weekends, you need an after-hours plan, not a rota tweak. Plumbers are often on call for emergencies[3], so decide who answers when the on-call tech is on a job.
  • If unqualified calls take a large share of the CSR's day, look at spam filtering and at a self-service way for existing customers to check arrival times.

Run the audit again four to six weeks after the fixes. Compare like with like: same length, same buckets and, ideally, a similar season.

Mistakes that spoil an audit

  • Changing the rules halfway. If you decide on day four that price shoppers are unqualified rather than lost, go back and reclassify days one to three, or the totals mean nothing.
  • Auditing only office hours. The calls you most need to see are the ones nobody was there to take.
  • Letting the person being measured classify their own calls without a second look. Have the manager or owner spot-check a sample each day.
  • Skipping the dollar estimate. Without it, the report becomes a list of complaints instead of a ranked set of fixes.
  • Announcing fixes before the week ends. Changes made mid-audit blur the baseline you are trying to measure.

Keep the audit fair to the team

An audit can feel like surveillance. Say at the start that it measures the system, not individual people. Share the one-page report with the CSRs, ask them which lost calls frustrated them most, and let them suggest one of the three fixes. They hear the calls every day and usually know where the problems are before the spreadsheet does.

Frequently asked questions

How many calls do I need for an audit to be useful?

There is no minimum, but a full seven days is the important part. Even a small shop with a few dozen calls a week will see patterns by hour and by reason that it cannot see from totals.

Do I need call recordings to run an audit?

No. Recordings make classification faster and more accurate, but you can audit from the call log, voicemails and your job list. If you do record, make sure your disclosure meets your state's consent rules.

Should existing customers be counted in the audit?

Yes. Put them in the unqualified bucket for booking purposes, but keep their unanswered calls visible. Long holds and missed calls from existing customers still cost you reviews and repeat work.

How often should a plumbing shop repeat the audit?

After every significant change to staffing or phone routing, and at least twice a year to catch seasonal differences between summer and winter.

References

  1. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics (2025). All employees, plumbing, heating, and air-conditioning contractors, not seasonally adjusted (CEU2023822001) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). American Time Use Survey, Table 4: Employed persons working and time spent working on days worked, 2025 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  5. U.S. Census Bureau (2023). County Business Patterns 2023, U.S. national file (cbp23us) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo