Key takeaways
- A franchisor must give you its Franchise Disclosure Document at least 14 days before you sign or pay, and it has 23 numbered Items[1].
- Any earnings claims must appear in Item 19; if a salesperson shows numbers that are not there, treat that as a warning[1].
- Talking to current and former franchisees may be the most reliable way to check the franchisor's claims[1].
- Construction businesses face real survival risk either way: of establishments opened in March 2015, 57.5% were still operating five years later[2].
- Choose a franchise for systems and brand speed; stay independent for control over pricing, territory, culture and exit.
The real question behind franchise vs independent
Plumbing franchises sell a promise: a known brand, a proven playbook for marketing, pricing and hiring, software that already works, and people who have solved your next problem before. Independence offers a different promise: every dollar of margin and every decision is yours, and the company you build is entirely yours to sell. Neither is right for everyone, and the choice is mostly about what you are missing today.
Be honest about the risk you are trying to reduce. Construction businesses do fail. Of construction establishments opened in March 2015, 83.3% survived one year, 57.5% survived five years and 42.5% were still operating after ten[2]. A franchise does not remove that risk, but a good one can shorten the learning curve on the things that sink new shops: pricing, cash flow, call handling and hiring.
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2015-2025[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| After 1 year | 83.3% |
| After 5 years | 57.5% |
| After 10 years | 42.5% |
How the federal disclosure rules protect you
Under the FTC's Franchise Rule, the franchisor must give you its Franchise Disclosure Document (FDD) at least 14 days before you are asked to sign any contract or pay any money[1]. The FDD contains 23 numbered Items, and any claims the franchisor makes about sales, income or profits must be in Item 19[1]. Some states add their own registration and disclosure rules on top of the federal ones.
Use the 14 days well. Read the whole document, list your questions, have a franchise attorney and an accountant review it, and call franchisees before you sign anything. If a salesperson pushes you to sign faster, or shows you earnings numbers that are not in Item 19, slow down.
The FDD items that matter most for a plumbing buyer
| Item | What it tells you | What to look for |
|---|---|---|
| Item 3 and 4 | Litigation and bankruptcy history | Lawsuits by franchisees, regulators or customers; patterns rather than one-offs |
| Item 5 and 6 | Initial and ongoing fees | Royalty basis, marketing fund, technology and call center fees, minimums |
| Item 7 | Estimated initial investment | Trucks, tools, inventory, working capital; compare with your own budget |
| Item 8 | Required suppliers | Whether you must buy parts, trucks or software from approved sources |
| Item 11 | Training and support | Length of training, field support, software, call handling |
| Item 12 | Territory | Exclusive or not, how it is defined, what happens with national accounts |
| Item 17 | Renewal, termination, transfer | Term length, renewal costs, non-compete after leaving, transfer approval |
| Item 19 | Financial performance representations | Whether earnings data is given at all, and for which units |
| Item 20 | Outlet data | Openings, closures, transfers and terminations over three years; franchisee contact list |
| Item 21 | Financial statements | Whether the franchisor itself is financially healthy |
Item 20 is the most underrated. A high number of closures, terminations or transfers relative to the system size tells you more about franchisee experience than any brochure.
Questions to ask current and former franchisees
The FTC's consumer guide says talking to current and former franchisees may be the most reliable way to verify the franchisor's claims[1]. Item 20 lists their contacts. Call at least five, including at least two who have left the system, and ask the same questions to each.
- 'How long did it take you to reach break-even, and what did you have to put in beyond the Item 7 estimate?'
- 'Which parts of the support are worth the royalty, and which are not?'
- 'How are leads from the national website and call center handled, and how good are they?'
- 'Can you set your own prices, or does the system set them?'
- 'What happens when a national account customer is in your territory?'
- 'If you left, why, and what did the non-compete and exit cost you?'
- 'Knowing what you know now, would you buy again?'
Listen for agreement across conversations. One unhappy former owner may just be one story; four saying the same thing about lead quality or fees is a pattern.
Model the fees over ten years, not one
Franchise fees look different depending on the time frame. The initial fee in Item 5 is a one-time cost, but royalties, marketing fund contributions and technology fees in Item 6 run for the whole term, and they usually scale with revenue. A fee that feels small in year one can be the largest line in your budget by year eight, when the business is mature and needs less help.
- List every recurring fee in Item 6 and how it is calculated: a percentage of gross revenue, a flat monthly amount, a per-truck charge or a minimum.
- Model your expected revenue for each year of the term, then apply the fees year by year, including any minimum royalty in slow years.
- Add the costs the system requires but does not call fees: approved software, branded truck wraps, uniforms, required conferences and remodels of your shop or trucks.
- Compare the total with what you would spend as an independent to get similar results: marketing, software, a business coach or peer group, and your own time building systems.
- Check Item 17 for renewal fees and conditions, and what you must upgrade to renew.
The comparison usually shows a crossover point. In the early years the franchise support may be worth more than it costs, because you would otherwise pay for mistakes. Later, as the business runs on its own systems, the fees become a tax on a business you built. Know where your crossover point is before you sign, and whether the agreement lets you leave or sell at that point without losing the value you created.
Also ask how the marketing fund is spent and reported. Franchisees often pay into a national or regional fund; find out what share of it reaches your territory, whether leads from national campaigns are routed to you, and whether franchisees have any say in the spending.
Decision matrix: franchise or independent
| Factor | Franchise tends to win when | Independent tends to win when |
|---|---|---|
| Experience running a business | You are a strong plumber but new to pricing, hiring and marketing | You have managed a shop or office before |
| Speed to a trusted brand | Your market already knows the franchise brand | Your own name already has local reviews and referrals |
| Pricing control | You want a tested price book and are happy to follow it | Your market rewards local pricing you set yourself |
| Ongoing fees | The support clearly earns its royalty and fees | Margins are thin and fees would erase your profit |
| Territory | An exclusive territory protects you from other franchisees | You want to grow into any area without permission |
| Exit | A franchise resale market exists and transfers are approved | You want to sell to anyone, including a competitor or an employee |
Example: a fictional journeyman plumber with a strong network but no management experience compares two franchises and an independent start. The franchise with lower closures in Item 20 and franchisees who praise the training wins on her decision matrix, but only after her attorney negotiates a clearer definition of her territory. A second fictional owner, who already runs a five-truck shop with hundreds of local reviews, decides the royalty would buy him little he does not already have and stays independent.
What independents can borrow from franchises
If you stay independent, you can still build the systems that make franchises work. Most of them are not secret; they are just written down and followed.
- A written price book with clear options, reviewed twice a year against costs.
- A call script and booking rules every CSR follows, with calls answered every time.
- A hiring and onboarding checklist for techs and office staff.
- Weekly numbers: calls, booked jobs, average ticket, callbacks, cash on hand.
- Peer groups and trade associations for benchmarking; see trade associations for plumbing contractors.
Consolidation is also changing the independent path. Census data show that 338 plumbing, heating and air-conditioning contractor firms with receipts of $100 million or more earned 27% of industry receipts in 2022[3]. An independent with clean books and strong systems may later have options to sell to a larger platform, or to grow by acquiring smaller plumbing shops.
Before you sign anything
Get the FDD and wait
Use at least the 14 days the rule gives you, and do not pay deposits before you have read it.
Build your own pro forma
Model revenue, costs, fees and cash needs from franchisee conversations and your own market, not only from Item 19.
Get professional review
Have a franchise attorney review the agreement and an accountant review Items 5 to 7, 19 and 21.
Check licensing
Confirm who will hold the plumbing license and qualify the business, since most states and some localities license plumbers[4].
Negotiate what you can
Territory definitions, opening timelines and some fees can sometimes be negotiated, especially for conversion franchisees with existing businesses.
Ask yourself three personal questions as well. Will you be comfortable following someone else's price book and marketing rules for ten years or more? Do you have the cash to cover the Item 7 investment plus several months of slow revenue without borrowing against your home? And who will run the business day to day if you are on the truck? Franchisors look for operators who will follow the system; independents need owners who will build one. Be clear which of those you are before the sales process starts, and write down the answers so you can check them against what franchisees tell you.
If you are thinking about expansion rather than a first business, compare a franchise with opening a second location under your own brand; the market analysis is similar either way.
Frequently asked questions
How long do I get to review a plumbing franchise disclosure document?
At least 14 days before you sign any contract or pay any money, under the FTC's Franchise Rule[1].
Where do I find a franchise's earnings claims?
In Item 19 of the FDD. The FTC says any claims about sales, income or profits must be there[1]. Some franchisors give no earnings data at all.
Is a plumbing franchise less risky than starting independently?
Not automatically. A good franchise can shorten the learning curve, but fees, territory limits and franchisor quality add their own risks. Check Item 20 closures and talk to former franchisees.
Can an existing plumbing company join a franchise?
Many systems offer conversion franchises for existing businesses. Review the terms carefully, especially territory, fees on existing revenue and what happens to your brand and customer list if you leave.
References
Federal Trade Commission (2026). A Consumer's Guide to Buying a Franchise (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2015-2025). Business Employment Dynamics: Establishment survival, Construction (Table 7) (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Census Bureau (2022). Statistics of U.S. Businesses 2022: Firms by industry and enterprise receipts size (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) โ