Dispatch scheduling

A dispatch priority matrix for plumbing calls

A written dispatch priority matrix for plumbing calls: four severity tiers, modifiers for customer type and vulnerability, scoring steps and examples.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing6 min read

On this page
  1. Why write the matrix down
  2. Severity tiers
  3. Why active water sits at the top
  4. Modifiers that reorder calls within a tier
  5. How to score a call
  6. Worked examples
  7. What the CSR says for each tier
  8. Common mistakes
  9. Overrides that are not about plumbing
  10. The after-hours version
  11. Teach it and test it
  12. Frequently asked questions
  13. References
Dispatch scheduling: A dispatch priority matrix for plumbing callsArticle coverDISPATCH SCHEDULINGA dispatch prioritymatrix for plumbingcallsAva for PlumbersInsightsDispatch scheduling: A dispatch priority matrix for plumbing callsArticle coverDISPATCH SCHEDULINGA dispatch prioritymatrix for plumbingcallsAva for Plumbers

Key takeaways

  • Severity comes first: active water, sewage, no water and safety risks outrank everything else.
  • Customer type and job value adjust the order within a tier; they never lift a routine job above an emergency.
  • Vulnerable occupants and freezing weather raise a call's priority.
  • Water damage and freezing caused 22.6% of homeowners insurance losses in 2023[1]; speed on active leaks protects customers' homes.

Why write the matrix down

Every dispatcher already has a priority system. It lives in their head, it changes with their mood and the loudest caller, and it leaves with them when they take a day off. A written matrix makes the order predictable. CSRs know what to promise, techs know why their afternoon changed and owners can review decisions after the fact.

The matrix below uses three inputs: how severe the problem is, who the customer is and what the job is worth. Severity sets the tier. The other two only reorder calls inside a tier.

Severity tiers

Example: severity tiers for a residential plumbing board
TierDefinitionExamplesTarget response
P1 EmergencyActive damage or a health or safety risk nowBurst pipe, water through a ceiling, sewage backing up into an occupied home, no water at allNext available tech, same day, including after hours
P2 UrgentDamage likely within hours or a key fixture outWater heater leaking from the tank, only toilet not working, main drain slow and getting worseSame day if capacity allows, otherwise first slot tomorrow
P3 SoonProblem is contained but needs fixingRunning toilet, dripping faucet, slow sink, small leak into a bucketWithin a few business days
P4 PlannedNo active problemFixture upgrades, estimates, maintenance visitsBooked to the customer's preference

Write your own examples into each tier using calls your CSRs actually get. The examples teach the matrix far better than the definitions.

Why active water sits at the top

Water does its damage quickly and expensively. The Insurance Information Institute reports the average homeowners claim for water damage and freezing was $15,400 (weighted average, 2019 to 2023)[1], and that water damage and freezing caused 22.6% of homeowners insurance losses in 2023, down from 28.7% in 2019[1]. Minutes matter more on a P1 leak than on any other call on the board.

Water damage and freezing as a share of homeowners lossesInsurance Information Institute.
Water damage and freezing as a share of homeowners lossesComparison. 2019: 28.7%; 2023: 22.6%.28.7%20192019: 28.7%22.6%20232023: 22.6%Water damage and freezing as a share of homeowners lossesComparison. 2019: 28.7%; 2023: 22.6%.28.7%20192019: 28.7%22.6%20232023: 22.6%

Source: Insurance Information Institute, 2019-2023[1]

Show the data
YearShare of losses incurred (%)
201928.7%
202322.6%

Slow leaks are a different tier, but they are not trivial. EPA says 9% of US homes have leaks that waste 50 gallons or more a day[2]. Those belong in P3 unless water is reaching building materials, in which case they move up.

Modifiers that reorder calls within a tier

  • Vulnerable occupants: elderly residents, infants, someone with a medical need for water or a toilet. Move to the top of the tier; a P2 with no working toilet for an elderly resident living alone can be treated as P1.
  • Weather: in freezing conditions, no heat combined with water lines in unheated spaces raises the risk. The American Red Cross notes pipes freeze most often when exposed to severe cold or in unheated interior areas such as basements, crawl spaces, attics and garages[3].
  • Commercial accounts with agreed response terms: honor the agreement within the tier.
  • Plan members: priority within the tier, as your membership terms state.
  • Callbacks on your own recent work: priority within the tier, because the customer already trusted you once.
  • Job value: use only as a final tie-break between otherwise equal calls.

Rule: modifiers move a call up or down inside its tier. Only severity, or a vulnerable occupant in a P2, can move a call to a higher tier.

How to score a call

  1. Set the tier

    Use the intake answers: is water active, is sewage involved, is there any water, is there a safety risk? The tier is decided before anything else.

  2. Apply vulnerability and weather

    If either applies, move the call to the top of its tier, or to P1 for a P2 with a vulnerable occupant.

  3. Apply customer type

    Commercial terms, members and recent callbacks go ahead of other calls in the same tier.

  4. Break ties by time and distance

    Equal calls are served first come, first served, unless one is far closer to an available tech.

  5. Use value last

    If two calls are still equal, the higher-value job goes first.

Dispatchers should be able to explain any decision in one sentence using these steps. If they cannot, the matrix needs another example.

Worked examples

Example (fictional): at 10:15 a.m., three calls are waiting and one tech is about to free up.

  1. Example call A: a homeowner with a running toilet who is a plan member. Tier P3, member modifier. Waits.
  2. Example call B: a tenant reporting water dripping through the kitchen ceiling from the unit above. Tier P1. Goes first.
  3. Example call C: an 80-year-old caller living alone whose only toilet will not flush. Tier P2, vulnerable occupant, treated as P1. Goes second, and the CSR calls to set expectations.

Example, continued: an hour later a commercial account with a contract calls about a slow floor drain in its kitchen. Tier P2, contract terms move it to the top of P2 but not above call C, which is already treated as P1. Call A, the member, gets the first P3 slot that afternoon and a text explaining the time.

What the CSR says for each tier

The matrix also tells the CSR what to promise. Each tier gets a standard line, so callers hear a consistent answer and nobody over-promises to end a difficult call.

  • P1: 'This is an emergency, so I'm sending the next available plumber now. While you wait, can you find the main shut-off? I'll stay on the line and walk you through it.'
  • P2: 'We'll get someone out today if we can. I'll call you by 2 p.m. with a time, and if today fills up you'll be first on tomorrow's list.'
  • P3: 'This can wait a day or two without causing damage. I have Thursday morning or Friday afternoon. Which suits you?'
  • P4: 'Let's find a time that works for you. Mornings or afternoons?'
  • Any tier, if the caller pushes back: 'I understand it's frustrating. We send the most urgent problems first, like water coming through ceilings. If anything changes, call me straight back and I'll look at it again.'

Common mistakes

  • Letting job value jump tiers. A big install estimate never outranks a sewage backup.
  • Treating every caller who says 'emergency' as P1 without asking the intake questions.
  • Forgetting to re-tier. A P3 drip that starts running down a wall is now P2 or P1.
  • Hiding the matrix from techs, who then see every schedule change as favoritism.
  • Writing so many modifiers that nobody can apply them on a busy morning. Five is plenty.

Overrides that are not about plumbing

  • A caller reporting a gas smell is told to leave the building and call the gas utility or 911 from outside. Dispatch does not send a plumber into a possible gas leak first.
  • A caller with water near electrical panels or outlets is told to stay clear and, if safe, shut off the main water valve. Mention the electrical risk before anything else.
  • Sewage in an occupied home with children or anyone unwell is P1 regardless of the volume.
  • Any call where the CSR is unsure goes to the dispatcher immediately rather than waiting in the queue.

The after-hours version

After hours the matrix gets simpler: P1 calls go to the on-call tech, P2 calls go to the on-call tech if they agree or are booked first thing in the morning, and P3 and P4 are booked for business hours. BLS notes plumbers are often on call for emergencies, so evening and weekend work is common[4]; the matrix protects the on-call tech from being sent out for a dripping faucet at midnight.

The person or system answering the after-hours line needs the same intake questions and the same tier rules. If you use an SI Employee such as Ava for those calls, the urgency it records should map onto your P1 to P4 tiers, so the on-call tech is reached for the right calls and routine requests wait for the office.

Teach it and test it

Train CSRs with real calls. Play a recording, have each person assign a tier and modifiers, then compare. Disagreements show where the definitions are vague. Add the disputed call as a new example in the matrix.

Each month, review a sample of dispatched calls: was the tier right, were modifiers applied, did any P1 wait too long? Track P1 response time from call to arrival as the headline measure. If P1 times slip, the problem is usually capacity, so look at the floating truck and the same-day promise before blaming the matrix.

Members deserve their own rules within each tier; giving members priority without wrecking the board covers that in detail.

Frequently asked questions

What is a dispatch priority matrix?

A written rule set that decides the order of service calls. It ranks calls by severity first, then adjusts within each tier for vulnerable occupants, weather, customer type and, last of all, job value.

Should members always go first?

Members should go first within their tier, not ahead of emergencies. A member's running toilet waits behind a stranger's burst pipe.

How do I handle a gas smell on a plumbing call?

Tell the caller to leave the building and call the gas utility or 911 from outside. Do not send a plumber in first.

How often should the matrix be updated?

Review a sample of decisions monthly and add any disputed call as a new example. Update tiers when your services or agreements change.

References

  1. Insurance Information Institute (2019-2023). Facts + Statistics: Homeowners and renters insurance (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, WaterSense (2026). Fix a Leak Week (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. American Red Cross (2026). Frozen Pipes (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo