Key takeaways
- BBB accreditation means meeting eight standards for trust, including licensing, at least six months in business and responding to complaints[1].
- 82% of US adults at least sometimes read reviews before a first purchase, so the badge works best alongside strong reviews, not instead of them[2].
- It tends to matter more for older customers, larger jobs and commercial clients who check BBB directly.
- Answer every BBB complaint quickly, factually and with evidence; readers judge you by the response.
What accreditation actually is
The Better Business Bureau is a nonprofit that keeps public profiles of businesses, takes consumer complaints and accredits businesses that agree to meet its standards. Accreditation is voluntary and involves a fee set by your local BBB. A plumbing company can have a BBB profile and receive complaints there whether or not it is accredited; accreditation is the badge that says you have committed to the standards.
The BBB lists eight standards for trust: build trust, advertise honestly, tell the truth, be transparent, honor promises, be responsive, safeguard privacy and embody integrity[1]. Under “build trust” the BBB requires businesses to fulfill all competency and trade licensing requirements and to have been actively selling products or services for at least six months before applying[1]. Under “be responsive,” businesses must address disputes forwarded by BBB quickly and in good faith[1].
How customers really decide
Most customers form their view of a plumber from reviews and word of mouth. In Pew Research Center’s survey, 82% of US adults said they at least sometimes read online ratings or reviews before buying something for the first time, and 40% said they nearly always rely on them[2][3]. 46% said the availability of reviews helps a lot in making them feel confident about a purchase[4].
Only around one in ten Americans nearly always post their own reviews[5], which is why a steady flow of reviews takes deliberate effort. BBB accreditation is one more trust signal in this mix. It rarely wins a job on its own, but for certain customers it is the deciding check, and a poorly handled BBB complaint can undo a page of good reviews.
Pros and cons for a plumbing company
| Factor | With accreditation | Without accreditation |
|---|---|---|
| Trust badge | Can display BBB seal on website, vans, quotes | No seal; profile may still exist |
| Customers who check BBB | Profile shows accredited status | Profile shows not accredited |
| Complaint handling | Committed to respond and take part in dispute resolution | Complaints still forwarded; response is voluntary but visible |
| Cost | Annual fee set by local BBB | None |
| Standards | Must follow BBB advertising and conduct standards | Your own standards |
| Commercial and older clients | Often reassured by the seal | May ask for other proof |
The fee is the obvious cost. The less obvious one is the commitment: once accredited, you have agreed to standards that a slow complaint response or a misleading ad could breach. That commitment is also the value; it tells customers you have something to lose.
When it is worth it
- A large share of your customers are older homeowners, who are more likely to check BBB before letting someone in.
- You do larger jobs, such as repipes, sewer replacements and water heater installs, where customers research more.
- You bid commercial, property management or institutional work where procurement teams check BBB status.
- Your market has had well-publicized contractor fraud, so customers look for extra reassurance.
- You already handle complaints well and want that visible.
It is less likely to pay back if your work is mostly quick emergency calls from customers who pick the first company that answers, or if your reviews are already strong and you have no older or commercial customer base. In that case, put the effort into reviews and response time first.
Before you apply: a checklist
- Look up your existing BBB profile and correct the name, address, phone, service area and license details.
- Read any past complaints and make sure each has a factual response.
- Check your advertising against “advertise honestly”: coupon terms, “lowest price” claims and service fee promises.
- Confirm your trade licenses and insurance are current and match the business name customers see.
- Decide who will own BBB complaints and the response deadline you will hold yourselves to.
- Ask your local BBB for the fee and what is included before you commit.
If any of these steps turns up problems, fix them first. Applying with stale complaints or misleading ads on file wastes the fee and can draw attention to the issues you meant to leave behind.
Handling a BBB complaint
The BBB expects responses to be professional, to address the complainant’s significant issues, to include supporting evidence and to explain why requested relief cannot or should not be granted when that is the case[1]. Accredited businesses must also participate in dispute resolution when the BBB requests it and honor any resulting settlement[1]. That is a good standard to follow whether or not you are accredited.
Respond fast
Acknowledge the complaint within one business day, even if only to say you are reviewing the job file.
Pull the record
Gather the work order, signed quote, photos, invoice, call notes and technician’s account.
Call the customer
A conversation often resolves what a written exchange cannot. Listen first.
Write the response for the next reader
Stick to facts: what was agreed, what was done, what you offered. Avoid emotion and never reveal private details beyond what is needed.
Offer a fair remedy where warranted
A revisit, a partial refund or a credit, stated clearly. Do not offer anything conditional on removing the complaint.
Close the loop
Record the outcome and what you will change, and check that the BBB marks the complaint correctly.
What never to do
Federal rules now cover how businesses treat reviews and complaints. The FTC’s rule on consumer reviews bans using unfounded legal threats, physical threats or intimidation to suppress negative reviews, and lets the FTC seek civil penalties for knowing violations[6]. It also bans creating or selling fake reviews[7]. Threatening a customer with a lawsuit over a BBB complaint, or posting fake praise to bury it, is both a legal risk and the kind of behavior that turns a single complaint into a story.
- Do not argue with the customer’s character in a public response.
- Do not post fake reviews or ask staff to review the company.
- Do not tie refunds or discounts to withdrawing a complaint or changing a review.
- Do not ignore complaints because the customer “isn’t a real customer”; respond and say so factually if that is the case.
Using accreditation well
If you accredit, make it visible where customers decide: the website header or footer, quote templates, the booking confirmation and the van. Link the seal to your BBB profile so customers can check it. Keep the profile accurate: license numbers, service area, hours and photos. Most importantly, treat complaint response time as an operating metric. Negative experiences draw extra attention; 54% of review readers pay more attention to extremely negative reviews[8].
BBB alongside your other trust signals
Think of BBB as one layer among several. Your Google reviews do most of the work for search and first impressions. Your license number and insurance answer the “are they legitimate?” question. Named technicians and confirmation texts answer “who is coming to my door?” BBB accreditation adds an independent “they have agreed to standards and answer complaints” signal that matters most to cautious buyers.
Whatever you decide, track it. Ask new customers how they found and chose you, and note when BBB comes up. Watch whether commercial bids or larger residential jobs mention it. After a year, you will know whether the badge earns its fee in your market or whether the money is better spent on response time and reviews.
Example: one complaint, two responses
Example (fictional): A customer files a BBB complaint saying a water heater install was overpriced and the tech left a mess. Response A, written the same evening in anger, accuses the customer of lying. Response B, written the next morning by the owner, thanks the customer, summarizes the signed quote, attaches after photos, apologizes for the cleanup and offers a free cleaning visit and a check of the install. The customer accepts. Future readers see a company that owned a mistake and stood by its price, which is exactly what the badge is supposed to signal.
Related reading: customer education to prevent repeat problems, handling credit card chargebacks, small touches after the job and review signals and local ranking.
Frequently asked questions
Is BBB accreditation worth it for a small plumbing company?
It depends on your customers. It tends to help with older homeowners, larger jobs and commercial clients; for quick emergency work, strong reviews and fast answering matter more.
Can customers file BBB complaints if we are not accredited?
Yes. Complaints can be filed about many businesses whether or not they are accredited, and your response, or lack of one, is visible to others.
What does the BBB require to become accredited?
Meeting its eight standards for trust, including fulfilling licensing requirements, at least six months of active trading and responding to complaints in good faith[1].
Should we offer a refund to get a BBB complaint removed?
Offer a fair remedy if one is warranted, but never make it conditional on withdrawing a complaint or changing a review.
References
Better Business Bureau (2026). BBB Accreditation Standards (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2016). Online Reviews (Online Shopping and E-Commerce) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2016). Online Reviews (Online Shopping and E-Commerce) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2016). Online Reviews (Online Shopping and E-Commerce) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2016). Online Reviews (Online Shopping and E-Commerce) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2016). Online Reviews (Online Shopping and E-Commerce) (opens in a new tab) ↑