Key takeaways
- The Justice Department says the ADA's rules for businesses open to the public apply to their websites, with flexibility in how they comply.
- 95.9% of the top million home pages had detectable WCAG failures in 2026, averaging 56.1 errors per page.
- Low-contrast text, missing image descriptions and unlabeled form fields are the most common failures, and all are cheap to fix.
- More than 1 in 4 US adults have a disability, so an accessible booking page is also a better booking page.
Does the ADA apply to a plumber's website?
Title III of the Americans with Disabilities Act prohibits discrimination against people with disabilities by businesses open to the public[1]. A plumbing company that serves homeowners is one of those businesses. The Justice Department has consistently taken the position that the ADA's requirements apply to all the goods and services such businesses offer, including those offered on the web[1].
The department's March 2022 guidance also says businesses have flexibility in how they comply, as long as they comply, and that existing technical standards such as the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) and the federal Section 508 standards provide helpful guidance[1]. There is no separate federal regulation setting a technical standard for private business websites, but WCAG at level AA is the benchmark most auditors, developers and courts look to. In April 2024 the department published separate web requirements for state and local governments; those apply to public entities rather than to private contractors[1].
The ADA itself lets private plaintiffs ask a court to order fixes and recover attorney's fees, and some state laws add money damages. Fixing common errors before anyone complains is far cheaper than responding to a demand letter.
How common the problems are
WebAIM's annual scan of the top one million home pages found detectable WCAG 2 failures on 95.9% of them in 2026, with an average of 56.1 errors per page[2]. Automated tools catch only part of what a person would find, so the real picture is worse. Contractor websites, often built from templates and updated by whoever has the login, are rarely the exception.
The good news is in the list. The six most common failures are simple, and several are one-line fixes in a website builder: low-contrast text on 83.9% of pages, missing alternative text for images on 53.1%, missing form input labels on 51%, empty links on 46.3%, empty buttons on 30.6% and a missing document language on 13.5%[2].
Who you lose when the site is hard to use
More than 1 in 4 US adults have some type of disability, according to the CDC[3]. The most common types are cognition at 13.9% and mobility at 12.2%, followed by independent living at 7.7%, hearing at 6.2%, vision at 5.5% and self-care at 3.6%[3]. Many of those people own homes, manage rentals or arrange repairs for relatives, and they need a plumber as often as anyone.
Most visitors also arrive on a phone. 91% of US adults own a smartphone[4], and a site that is hard to use with a screen reader or a magnifier on a small screen is hard for everyone in a hurry. An emergency caller with water on the floor and wet hands benefits from large buttons, clear labels and a phone number that is a real link, not a picture of text.
1 in 4
US adults with some type of disability, according to the CDC[3]
The barriers DOJ names, translated for contractor sites
| Barrier named in DOJ guidance | Where it shows up on plumbing sites | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Poor color contrast | Light gray text on white, white text on a bright brand color in the 'Book now' button | Darken text or button colors until they pass a contrast checker |
| No text alternatives on images | Project photos, logos, badges and coupons with no alt text | Describe what each meaningful image shows; mark decorative images as decorative |
| No captions on videos | Owner introduction videos, how-to-shut-off-water videos | Add accurate captions, not only auto-generated ones |
| Inaccessible online forms | Booking and estimate forms with placeholder text instead of labels, error messages in red only | Give every field a visible label and explain errors in words |
| Mouse-only navigation | Menus that open only on hover, date pickers that need a mouse | Make every control reachable and usable with a keyboard |
These five barriers come straight from the Justice Department's guidance[1]. If you fix nothing else, fix these on your home page, your service pages and your booking form.
A 30-minute check you can run today
Run a free automated scan
Use a browser accessibility checker on your home page and booking page. Write down every error it lists.
Tab through the booking form
Put the mouse aside and use only the Tab, Shift-Tab, Enter and arrow keys. Can you reach every field, choose a date and submit? Can you see where you are on the page?
Check the phone number
Make sure your phone number is text, works as a tap-to-call link on mobile, and appears near the top of every page.
Zoom to 200%
Zoom the browser and check that nothing overlaps or disappears and the booking button is still easy to find.
Turn on a screen reader
Use the one built into your phone or computer for five minutes on the home page. Listen for buttons announced as 'button' with no name, and images with no description.
Check your videos and PDFs
Confirm videos have captions and that any downloadable documents, such as maintenance checklists, can be read by a screen reader.
Give the list to whoever maintains your site and set a date to fix it. Most template-based sites can fix contrast, alt text and labels in an afternoon.
Make accessibility part of how you run the site
- Ask any web designer to build to WCAG 2.1 or 2.2 level AA, and put that in the contract.
- Test third-party widgets, such as chat bubbles, review carousels and booking embeds, because errors inside them are still on your site.
- Publish a short accessibility statement with a phone number and email for anyone who has trouble using the site, and answer those contacts quickly.
- Offer other ways to book, such as phone and text, and make sure staff can take calls through relay services. See our guide to accessible relay calls.
- Re-check the site after every redesign or new page template.
Be wary of products that promise instant compliance by adding a script to your site. An overlay can help some users, but it does not fix errors in your underlying pages and forms, and it does not stop people from finding them.
Assign one person to own the site the way someone owns your van inspections. That person checks new pages before they go live, keeps the list of open issues, and books a full review once a year. A website changes every time someone adds a coupon, a photo gallery or a new service area page, and each change is a chance to add a new barrier without noticing.
If a demand letter arrives
Some small businesses first hear about web accessibility from a lawyer's letter. Do not ignore it, and do not panic. Treat it as a legal matter and a website problem at the same time.
- Send the letter to your business attorney and your insurance agent the day it arrives; some liability or cyber policies may respond, and deadlines matter.
- Do not reply to the sender yourself or post about it online.
- Have your web designer run a full scan and a manual check of the pages the letter names, and save the results with the date.
- Start fixing the errors right away and keep a record of what was fixed and when.
- Publish or update your accessibility statement with a working contact method.
- Let your attorney handle any negotiation, using your documented fixes as part of the response.
The best defense is the routine in this guide: regular checks, fixes on a schedule and a clear way for customers to reach you if anything still does not work for them.
Example: fixing a booking page
Example: a plumbing company's site scan shows 41 errors on its booking page. The 'Schedule service' button is white text on a light orange background, the form uses placeholder text instead of labels, the date picker cannot be used with a keyboard, and the 'Call now' graphic is an image with no alternative text.
The web designer darkens the orange, adds visible labels to every field, swaps the date picker for a simple dropdown of available days, and replaces the graphic with a real tap-to-call link. A second scan shows four errors, all in a third-party review widget, which the company replaces. The page now works with a keyboard and a screen reader, loads faster on phones, and is easier for everyone to use. Privacy notices on the same forms are covered in our guide to state privacy laws, and outbound follow-up rules in TCPA rules for calls and texts.
Frequently asked questions
Does the ADA require my plumbing website to be accessible?
The Justice Department's position is that the ADA's requirements for businesses open to the public apply to their websites. Businesses have flexibility in how they comply, and WCAG is the most widely used technical benchmark.
Which WCAG level should a contractor site meet?
WCAG 2.1 or 2.2 at level AA is the common target for private business websites. Start with the most frequent failures: contrast, image descriptions, form labels and keyboard access.
Will an accessibility overlay make my site compliant?
Not on its own. Overlays do not fix errors in your pages and forms. Fixing the underlying code and content is the reliable route.
How many people does an inaccessible site affect?
The CDC says more than 1 in 4 US adults have some type of disability, from cognition and mobility to hearing and vision, so accessibility problems affect a large share of potential customers.
References
U.S. Department of Justice, Civil Rights Division (ADA.gov) (2022). Guidance on Web Accessibility and the ADA (opens in a new tab) โ
WebAIM, Institute for Disability Research, Policy, and Practice, Utah State University (2026). The WebAIM Million: The 2026 report on the accessibility of the top 1,000,000 home pages (opens in a new tab) โ
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2024). Disability Impacts All of Us (infographic) (opens in a new tab) โ
Pew Research Center (2026). Mobile Fact Sheet (opens in a new tab) โ